NEBBIOLO vs SANGIOVESE Blind Tasting!!!

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
2 Video Views·Apr 13, 2026
That's good
Even though it's a little oakier. That's a hell of a wine. I'm Matthew Horky for the last seven years
I've traveled around the world tasting thousands of wines annually in search of the most unique
exciting and expensive bottles on the planet
The two greatest red grapes in Italy we have San Gervese and Nebbiolo
We're gonna have a little bit of a taste off. I wish I had that boxing guy here
San Gervese is planted throughout Italy. It's the most planted red grape in Italy. I think the last census I read it's about
77,000 hectares whereas Nebbiolo. There's only about 5,000 hectares planted most of that is in Piemonte
Although you'll find it neighboring Lombardy as well. San Gervese's real spiritual home though is central Italy
especially Emilia-Romagna, Umbria and of course
Tuscany. The greatest San Gervese's are thought to come from the areas of Brunella de Montalcino, Chianti
Classico, Vino Nobile de Montepulciano
Although there are other Appalachians that do great examples as well
And there's a lesser known one here
You're gonna see when it comes to Nebbiolo the most sought-after the most coveted Appalachian is Barolo in Piemonte
Also, you have Barbaresco and across the river you have Rero. You go up north in Piemonte really geeky
Appalachians like Gattinata, Bocca come to mind and then you go over to the neighboring Lombardia
Valtellina as well. A lot of times people confuse these grapes and blind tastings especially with age because they have these haunting aromas of
Rose petal, tar, perfume, more red fruit driven and both lighter in color
Also the fruit flavors in Nebbiolo I get more dried cranberry type flavors whereas in San Gervese
I usually get more sour cherry. That's the thing or black cherry. That's really the identifier for me
These are grapes that are high in acid high in tannin
However, I find that Nebbiolo tannins bite a little bit more and San Gervese tannins tend to be a little bit less drying
They really just have this beautiful interplay between sweet and sour fruit go awesome with pizza
Pasta any tomato based dishes braised meats, especially in Piemonte. They create everything from simple table wines
Serious age-worthy and expensive red wines
These are not cheap wines by any stretch all the wines here go from 30 to about a hundred and twenty-five dollars
Nebbiolo Barolo especially has kind of taken a seat right next to Burgundy in terms of terroir driven wines
What makes San Gervese Nebbiolo unique as well is really the best examples are in its native homeland in Italy
There are producers have tried to plant it all around the world but with varying results
And yes, I've tasted a lot of San Gervese Nebbiolos from around the world, California, Australia
I'm sorry, they do not stack up to the greatest examples from Italy. These are all great wines and to prep my palate
I even had a burgundy tasting right before this
So my bar is already set high all of these wines here are either a hundred percent San Gervese or a hundred percent Nebbiolo
I have been so excited about doing this episode for a long time
I've been waiting for two months to get the last sample to complete the set
We're gonna get these Coravin blinded and we're gonna taste them. You ready?
As always I'm tasting with my Gabrielle glass standard editions. I absolutely love these glasses
Universal glasses they work really well with San Gervese and Nebbiolo
I'm gonna put a link in the description box below if you want to check them out
It really helps the channel out a lot
Thank you for being here with me. Really. I appreciate it had somebody mix them up for me
Let's taste them. One of these bottles was a lot taller than the rest of them
So I had to put like a dummy bottle in but I put like a Lebanese bottle in so when I pull it out
I'll know exactly what wine it is
Wine a comes out of the gate swinging now
Typical first of all small call Nebbiolo because I smell dried cranberry tar rose petal
It's a little more subdued the top and this is this has got to be Nebbiolo. I hope I'm four for four in this, please
for me
Dried cranberry and then the tannins the tans
These are a little bit more biting especially in the bottom gum
I think wine a is Nebbiolo wine B is a lot more denser lot like talk
It's got more black cherry fruit flavors something
I usually associate with San Gervese or richer San Gervese
Although I have been fooled with Barolo's in the past. I'm this shows more wood than this one. Obviously San Gervese
I feel I can take more wood most of the time the Nebbiolo can although I prefer my San Gervese to have less wood
Black cherry mocha earth. This is a richer San Gervese. I think it's San Gervese. Oh, that's good
Even though it's a little oakier. That's a hell of a wine. It's good. It's structured
It's got length a lot of casual people are gonna kind of go towards that style of wine because it does have a lot of
Oak, but I think that I think it has the fruit where the oak is going to integrate with time again
I tried to get the same vintage of all these wines and at first I thought I was winning
But as producers started sending wine, I realized oh not gonna be able to keep to the same vintage wine
C and D, you know, I cut and I edit these to make them a little quicker
So you don't sit there and think through everything
However, I do think when you're tasting especially blind you go with your first instinct, you know
I've been sure you've seen me tripped up on the channel before because it didn't go with my first instinct
Let's check out wine C here. It's very
Traditional like get me excited here. Like it's a little bit of that balsamic vinaigrette type flavor. This has like a lot
It's very floral and usually with Nebbiolo
San Gervese, I think rose petal. This is more violets. This is just like a pretty nose grape dried cranberry a little bit tart
I think this is Nebbiolo
Wow, that's in between that's a good wine not gonna be to everyone's palate, but man
Nebbiolo can be round and silky up front like Pinot and then the tannins can come and hit you on the back end almost like
A boxer that also does ballet dancing, you know all elegantly and nicely and then boom hits you with hard tannins
That's a good wine. That's really good wine D more raspberry more sour cherry
I'm think right away go San Gervase on this earth pepper. I mean to me this quintessential San Gervase and good one at that
I don't know here man to me. It tastes San Gervase
It's like a really good one, whatever this is, but the tannins hit pretty hard on the back end
This is a hell of a wine like raspberry
Tobacco this to me is kind of like quintessential what I think of when I think about Brunello good Brunello de Montalcino
Langtier
Extraordinary just to let you know in that first set of four wines. My lowest score is 90 92 plus wine E and F
I think that it's a little bit more difficult to tell these wines apart with age
That's why I tried to get all 2017 vintage some with bottle age because it's a little bit easier
I think when they're young, but I couldn't get all the same vintage this one right here. I think I think isn't that yellow?
It's a little more stare a little more closed off the rose petal again cranberry
Oh, and as you shake it out the floral notes really start to come out
I didn't have yellow is such a weird grape because your mouth waters like crazy
But then it dries out because there's so much acidity and there's so much tannin to dry up your palate
this is a
Super pretty wine, but lots of acid a lot of tannin, but super pretty wine. It's more of a lighter style
This is wine. I think it's gonna age really nice
Wine F has got a lot of tar notes this one
Pinot Noir heads gonna absolutely love it got a lot of fall leaves type character on the back end something identified with Pinot Noir
Good wine so far good
Wines G&H wine H is considerably darker or more. I'm gonna think that's that's Sangiovese
It's a tip-off, but we'll see let's see wine G here. This is wine that I'm confused right away
I don't know if it's it's right in between got raspberry got some cranberry got some sour cherry type flavors
Put rose petals start to come out a little bit again
I think the tan gives us away this wine up front from the front the start to the mid palate just impeccably balanced
I think some people are gonna have like young Nebbiolo can be hard
I think this is Nebbiolo at first the tannins can really start to get to yuck unless you have food
Do you really need food with these wines or you need them to have age?
This is good. This is really good
That's really good super good wine H has got leather black cherry. It's dark
I think this is Sangiovese, but and it's so funny. I like my Sangiovese a little more delicate. This is
Extraordinary like it like for a bigger Sangiovese really well done
Just it's dark blackberry mulberry type flavors like wine B
This is oaky, but you know what you cannot deny the quality the quality is very good. It's so funny
That's why in wine you never make I think it in life too with people you may never make
Definitive statements although you know I have before I know if I'm guilty
But this right here is not the style that I usually like I think it's Sangiovese
It's dark. It's rich and dense put the finish and the length on this okay
I can handle the oak up front if there's enough fruit, but I think it's gonna melt well
That's a good wine you ready for the reveal. You're ready. You're ready. I'm ready
No losers here my lowest score 92 plus all the way up to 95
Plus so there's um some serious wines here. This is all preference because these wines they're so different
It's you know all about the style listen to tasting notes
And that's like that's how I think that you should go for what the kind of wine that you want to have
Tied for 92 plus I thought it was Sangiovese
It is rich black cherry has some oak, but could not deny the quality on the back end
Let's see if it's Sangiovese wine B. I'm a little bit nervous. Please let it have please be Sangiovese. Let's see here
This is a wine in this is I thought was gonna be the best wine in the past
It's a bit young the Boscarelli. You'll know chill
2017 this is not a cheap wine goes for about 125 bucks
I have to say this is young last year at this time
I had the 1991 the first vintage ever and it was one of the most mind-blowing wines. I've had in my life
Beautiful wine made with Brunello clones like I said oak up front, but at the end. I could not deny the quality
I thought this would be the highest scoring wine so Wow
Blind tasting man, okay wine II
This is pretty acidic lighter gentle like I said, it's just a lighter floral pretty
Nebbiolo, that's what I think it is. I think it's nebbiolo. I'm one for one. Let's see here wine II
92 plus okay
please
This is the Alba the GD Vajra Barolo, this is the Alba
2018 young so I picked up that this is young cool thing about this one. This is 45 bucks
This is the wine that made me fall in love with Barolo years ago. I bought this wine
I think it was a 2005
You know, but way before I was in the wine industry that blew me away with the tar the perfume notes
This is consistently one of the best values in Barolo
If you want to check it out because Barolo wines can't be really pricey 45 bucks
It's a steal like I said 92 plus super good wine
Okay, two for two wine F fall leaves for those that like Pinot Noir
I think this is nebbiolo because of the development the tannins at the back end. I gave it
93 points, let's see. Aha
It's the Lebanese I put the Lebanese so because it's a taller bottle
This is the this is the Marquesa de Barolo Sarmasa Barolo single vineyard
2017 or the legend is modern Barolo as we know it was developed in the cellars of Marquesa de Barolo because in the past Barolo
Was actually a sweet wine
This is a very very well pedigreed wine 85 fall leaves, which I really like
I think it's gonna show really really nice with time. Nice job. Okay
I am so far three for three coming up next wine a I thought it was nebbiolo
I thought the tans were really drying, but it's really good 93 plus the cranberry the tar stuck it out a lot
Let's see if I'm
Yeah
This is the other Nana chicken Barbaresco the server Rambone
2017 a lot of people go to Barolo the prices are extraordinary. I think Barbaresco is a region
You can still find a lot of values
This is a very good producer before I was in the wine industry. I stayed at this producer
They have an agriturismo an amazing breath breakfast on at least a 45 bucks
Super high quality 93 plus points. I've had this wine age 2 and I say it ages extraordinary
This is a wine highly seek out you got kind of search for it, but you can find it good wine
Okay, I got two wines here tied for
94 points wine see I thought it was nebbiolo head traditional like flavors
Violet type flavors. I thought it was really really pretty
Remember I said Barolo's, you know nebbiolo based wines usually gonna get a rose petal. But however, this was more violet. Okay
Let's see traditional
94 points. I thought it was nebbiolo. Please let it be never so I got one back
This is the Feltzina
Fantoloro Toscana
2018
Legendary producer in the south of Chianti Classico. This is an IGT a super Tuscan wine Fantoloro
It's because it's named after the Golden Fountain that it's on the estate
50 bucks
94 I thought it was nebbiolo really good wine
It's so funny because a lot of times I think they're Chianti Classico or deserve is better than this wine
This showed extraordinarily today Wow Wow tied
Also wine G here. I thought it was balanced all the way to the end. That's when the tannins start to hit hard
94 points. I thought that it was nebbiolo, but I've seen I've got one wrong so far
I'm excited to see what this is. Okay, let's see what it is 94 foot
Wow
So it is nebbiolo I got that right, this is the Adriano Marconi Vittorio Bassett in Barbaresco
2019 Michele great job this wine speaking of value is 30 bucks 30 bucks. I met this producer in
Singapore they came out and visited because their importer was in Singapore
Then I went to visit them when I started traveling all around the world
And then I had mutual friends somehow of the daughter that runs this estate
It's 30 bucks and they have a buster in reserva that often really outperforms other wines 30 bucks
This is the cheapest wine in a bunch
94 points
That's all you need to know blind tasting excellent. Seek it out the two top wines
I thought they were both San Gervasi, but I think obviously I got one of them wrong
Okay, let's start our hill here and I'm gonna be surprised so
Wine H
It was super oaky, but I could not deny the quality in the back and oak mulberry black cherry
94 plus points
There's oaky Wow
This is the Terra
Margarita telly this is a torsion or Rosa
Reserva torsion Oh is an appellation in Umbria dedicated to San Gervasio
You can also blend Cagliolo Mamolo colorino in it. This is a hundred percent San Gervasi organic
Here's the thing 125 bucks. This is the picture. It just can only get this at the estate, but oaky
But man, you cannot deny the quality here 125 bucks
I'm surprised not the typical type of wine that I'm gonna enjoy
But it was awesome. And before we get to the top wine, make sure you subscribe to the YouTube channel
There's a lot of good stuff coming out and let me know. Do you prefer San Gervasi or do you prefer Nebbiolo wine D?
I thought it was San Gervasi. It was hard for me to tell if it was San Gervasi Nebbiolo tart raspberry
Cherry and the finish just separated this. I thought it was San Gervasi. Let's see
95 plus
Extraordinary wine
Okay, it is a San Gervasi. This is the Poliziano le Caglioli
Vino Nobile de Montepulciano
2017 here's the thing a hundred bucks. I've been a huge fan of this wine in the I've had past vintages
Wow, really surprised for it to show that well
Incredible what I mean this winery you can find all around the world their entry level Vino Nobile de Montepulciano
I think it's about 30 bucks. It's very very good. This is their top wine
Excellent. I just got one wrong. You know, that's how it is. So tell me have you ever done tastings like this?
Do you have a region that you prefer? Let me know in the comments below. Thanks a lot
I'll see you soon
