Why China is America's Greatest Threat - Forgotten History

Artifact Archives
9 followers
3 Video Views·Apr 13, 2026
This video is sponsored by Private Internet Access VPN. China has had a long and tortured
history of conflict, rival warlords, external invaders, and internal civil wars, but the
rivalry between the Nationalist Kuomintang and the Chinese Communists lasted longer than all of
World War II and eventually tore the country apart. During World War II both political paradigms
spent almost as much time fighting each other as they did the Japanese, and the Allied nations
were on a quandary as to which side needed the most support and to which group to allocate
military resources. Who was Chiang Kai-shek? How did he become the Nationalist leader of China?
What was his effectiveness in World War II? What did the Allies think of him?
How did he lose China to the Communists?
Hello, I'm Colin Heaton, former history professor, Army and Marine Corps veteran,
and welcome to this episode of Forgotten History.
Chiang Kai-shek was born on October 31st, 1887 in Fenghua, Zhejiang Province, China,
into a wealthy merchant and farming family. He was well-educated and attended the Baoding
Military Academy in North China and also military school in Tokyo, Japan.
He served in the Japanese Army from 1909 to 1911, whose Spartan ideals he admired and adopted.
Chiang was never enamored with the Manchu dynasty ruling the country,
and he easily adopted a revolutionary mindset.
Once the tremors of revolution erupted against the emperor, Chiang returned and joined in the
fighting, and he also fought in the revolution of 1913 to 1916, once the emperor was replaced
by the would-be replacement, Yuan Shikai. Let me tell you of a way to hide your IP
address from hackers. I use Private Internet Access, the world's most transparent VPN provider,
with over 30 million downloads. Private Internet Access hides your IP address and encrypts your
internet connection. This way, it shields your digital life from the eyes of hackers,
internet service providers, network administrators, and government censors. Streaming services such as
Netflix, Amazon Prime, Disney Plus, and more, have different library options based on where
you are located, and some shows cannot be accessed if you are not located in the region.
Private Internet Access VPN helps you overcome these restrictions by giving you the option of
changing your IP, allowing you to gain access to websites and services that are only available
in these locations, such as the submarine TV series Dust Boat, only available in Germany and
Switzerland. Well, not anymore. Just click on Germany or Switzerland on PIA, and you're good
to go. That's why I use Private Internet Access. Private Internet Access is available for all
platforms, Windows, macOS, Android, and many more, and you can use one Private Internet Access
subscription to protect an unlimited number of devices at the same time. So, click on this now
and get 83% off on Private Internet Access. That's just two dollars and three cents a month. And you
also get four extra months completely free, giving you access to content worldwide and unlimited
bandwidth. You also get a 30-day money-back guarantee. Following a temporary peace,
Cheng left public life and lived quietly in Shanghai until 1917, during which time he joined
the Qingbang, or Green Gang, which was involved in black marketeering and currency and commodities
manipulation. With the Kuomintang, the Chinese Nationalist Party, coming into prominence,
Cheng joined its leader Sun Yat-sen in 1918. Cheng liked Sun's idea of unifying China,
which had devolved into many rival warlords who wielded a lot of local power. Sun Yat-sen began
shaping the Nationalist Party into a Soviet Bolshevik-style organization, and Cheng visited
the Soviet Union in 1923 to study Soviet institutions, especially the Red Army.
Upon his return to China, Cheng became the commandant of a Soviet-styled military academy
in Wampoa near Guangzhou. Soviet advisors arrived to aid and indoctrinate the peasants,
during which time Chinese Communists were admitted into the Kuomintang. When Sun died in 1925,
the Communists became more prominent and tried to dominate the Nationalist Party,
led by Mao Zedong. But Cheng still had the power with the army behind him.
Cheng tried to handle the Communists to maintain Stalin's support, but that plan fell apart.
Cheng finally launched a violent coup, expelling the Communists as well as breaking up their labor
unions, which saw support from Moscow fade away. Stalin now backed the Communists and would
continue to do so. Cheng then led his army north to combat the warlords, ending with his taking of
Beijing, with the Nationalist central government established in Nanjing. Around this time,
Cheng married Sung Mai-ling, later known as Madame Cheng, whose family were Catholic,
and he converted in 1930. Turmoil still existed as the warlords and Communists,
who sometimes fought each other, until the Japanese invaded Manchuria in 1931. Perhaps
Cheng had his reasons, but he decided to ignore the Japanese threat to deal with the Communists,
who had recruited many of the former warlords. In December 1936, Cheng faced a coup of his own,
when one of his generals arrested him, called the Xi'an Incident, and supported by many of his
They believed that the military should be focusing upon fighting the Japanese instead
of the Communists. Most of the Nationalists believed that they could convince the Communists
to set aside their differences and join them in the fight against the common enemy. Cheng
agreed to their demands and united with Mao's Communists in 1937, starting the Sino-Japanese
War, which would last for over four years, as China fought alone until the Allies, primarily
the Americans and British, began to assist. One of the main methods of support was in the form of
the American Volunteer Group, a unit of American pilots, mechanics, ground support personnel,
who Cheng hired to fight the Japanese. Led by General Claire Chennault, they were effective
in supporting the Chinese to slow down and even halt Japanese expansion to include flying missions
out of Rangoon, Burma. But Cheng was not exactly respected among his paid mercenaries, nor the
Allies, especially among some of the pilots who came to know him. One was legendary Marine Corps
fighter pilot Gregory Boynton, who said I was also a little less than pleased with Chiang Kai-shek.
Cheng was a legalized bandit, a crook big time, and everyone knew it. He got real rich off the war,
and I know he was profiteering from all the Allied aid coming in. He kept bitching about
needing more aid before he could commit more troops to help Stilwell. But Stilwell apparently
had the ledgers showing that Cheng was getting better and more numerous supply shipments than he
was, and he was the damned commander. Cheng had been stockpiling his weapons and ammunition,
saving them for the final fight against the Communists once the Japanese were defeated.
Cheng also was very reluctant to support the Allies under American General Joseph Stilwell
and British Field Marshal William Joseph Slim in the Burma campaign. The AVG was disbanded
in July 1942 following war being declared by the USA against the Axis powers. Now the full weight
of the Allies would come to bear against Japan. Cheng also had problems with his own people,
and his relationship with the British had deteriorated. The British Commonwealth
leadership were tired of trying to get him into the fight. The U.S. had brought a shipload of
munitions and weapons into Rangoon Harbor aboard the USS Tulsa with instructions that the cargo
was to be moved to the British, but Cheng had his men confiscate the shipment, and the controversy
became known as the Tulsa incident. Then in an act of reprisal, some British soldiers decided
to steal the weapons and ammunition back, really angering Cheng. This was just one of the final
straws that caused the British to simply abandon Cheng and focus upon the Burma campaign as a
singular focus in their own interests. China could rot. President Roosevelt decided that to entice
Cheng to get more involved, he requested that Prime Minister Winston Churchill appoint Cheng
as Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces in China and Burma, or any title that he thought
Cheng would agree to. Churchill agreed, but using Cheng only as a figurehead, not as the field
commander of British forces, but someone was needed to keep Cheng in line. As a result, the decision
was made to send General Stilwell, who was fluent in Mandarin and many dialects with many years of
China experience. Franklin Roosevelt needed someone who could kick ass and get Cheng in the
fight. General George C. Marshall agreed. Marshall wrote a personal letter to Lieutenant General
Joseph Stilwell on April 29, 1942, stating, your leadership, especially under the peculiar
conditions and difficulties of your authority and in a desperately critical situation, is a model
for the army. In essence, he was buttering him up to get him back into China.
The assignment would give Stilwell three jobs, Chief of Staff to Nationalist Leader Chiang Kai-shek,
Commanding Officer of American Forces in China, and Lend-Lease Administrator. His title was
Commanding General of the United States Forces in the Chinese Theater of Operations, Burma and
India. The orders did not address the specific duties implicit in these positions, especially his
relationship with British theater commands. But Chiang knew that the British did not trust him,
and that went both ways. So Chiang then requested that Stilwell take the role of overall commander
of all forces in China and Burma, and if the British tried to alter that fact, he threatened
to remove all Chinese soldiers from Burma proper. The British were rather upset at this proposal
since they relied upon Chinese manpower to support their forces. To make matters worse for Stilwell,
the China-Burma-India Theater of Operations was the least important theater in Roosevelt's or
Churchill's eyes, so Stilwell was the last in receiving logistics and supplies. So Stilwell
was in effect the gatekeeper in dispensing Lend-Lease supplies to Chiang, but he was very
reluctant to do so after the British had supplied him for a year with no positive activity against
the Japanese. The British saw Burma very important as a buffer into India saving that colony,
while Stilwell saw Burma as the gateway into China that could break Japanese control,
if he had the support. Chiang offered Chinese troops to get the supplies. Field Marshal Sir
Archibald P. Webble, British commander-in-chief in India, personally believed that the Japanese
offensive in Burma was overextended and would only end in failure. Chinese forces were not
required for victory, but he did accept one division from Chiang in a conciliatory gesture,
although he doubted their sincerity and he was not alone. Chiang's timid response to the Japanese,
while focusing upon Mao's kindness, was not helping the allied cause. In fact, the British,
under Slim and the overall command of Lord Louis Mountbatten, seemed to have little interest in
supporting the Americans if Chiang was involved. Stilwell was well aware of the problems between
Mao and Chiang, and Chiang's unreliability in stealing supplies from both the US and British
without any result. Stilwell made it clear that Chiang would get nothing on his watch.
Much to Stilwell's surprise, the Chinese 200th division held at Tunggu for 12 days against
repeated Japanese assaults. Their stand represented the longest defensive action of any allied force
in the entire campaign. Even so, another major allied withdrawal was inevitable.
That was because when Stilwell ordered the Chinese 22nd division in the south to relieve
the 200th, exasperated and worn down from combat on the line, he received little response except
excuses from the division commander. Despite Chiang Kai-shek's assurances to the contrary,
Stilwell still had not been given the quangfang or the seal or chop as commander-in-chief in Burma.
He had only been named chief of staff. The Chinese commanders, therefore, refused to carry out orders
from Stilwell until they had been cleared with Chiang, who persisted in his habit of constantly
changing his mind. Another major problem was Brigadier General Ord Wingate, commanding the
77th Indian Infantry Brigade, Wing as a colonel, then later overall commander of the Chindit
Commandos. Wingate's successes throughout 1943 were hard won due to the failure of Chiang to
support him. Expecting support, Wingate's force, after months of heavy fighting without relief
and supplies, withdrew back into India, losing almost one-third of their force. Wingate was not
a fan of Chiang, but Chiang's forces also failed to support each other. When the 200th Chinese
Division withdrew without being replaced, it exposed the Burma Corps at Proma to Japanese
attack. Beginning in March, the Allies started their north march, with the British and Chinese
blaming each other for their repeated reverses. Due to Chiang's lack of support, Lashio fell on
April 29th, completing the Japanese blockade of China by closing the Burma Road. China was now
sealed off. Stilwell ordered an emergency evacuation. Part of the Chinese force managed
to withdraw east into China, but three divisions headed west into India. Determined to begin a
renewed defensive effort, Stilwell sent part of his staff ahead to prepare training bases in India,
and on May 26th, the campaign ended as the last of the Allied forces retreated into India, joining
Wingate's depleted forces. Stilwell was furious, as were Slim, Mountbatten, and even Churchill.
Then Chiang, seeing that Stilwell was not a man to be bullied, protested for two years to
Washington to have Stilwell removed as the American commander, which finally happened
in October 1944. Chiang was not distrusted by everyone. Some had faith in him that he would
come around, and the British push in 1945 from India and the amphibious landings on the coastal
islands would eventually see a link up with the Americans liberating Burma. But despite these
positive events, Chiang's fragile government was falling apart, which grew worse as the war
progressed, and once the war was over, the Nationalists resumed their fight against the
Communists. The start of the Civil War in 1946, which was bloody, but even worse, the new U.S.
President, Harry S. Truman, was not about to get involved, not with Chiang's history of bad
decisions and wavering loyalties. Chiang's gangster-like approach and dictatorial style,
as well as his rampant nepotism within his government and incompetence as a political
and military leader, saw many former Nationalists defect to Mao's Communists. Chiang's lukewarm
handling of the Japanese had lost him the prestige and support among the Chinese population that the
Communists ultimately gained by their fierce anti-Japanese resistance. Mao and the Communists
had fought a ruthless campaign against the Japanese, mostly without much Allied support,
with the exception from the Soviet Union. But their resistance impressed the Chinese people,
who saw the Communists as their saviors and the Nationalists under Chiang as thieves.
There was a good reason to feel that way. Chiang could also not account for millions in gold he had
been paid to recruit, train, and equip his army, which were largely forced to rely upon American
and British donations. Nationalist morale plummeted. The morale and effectiveness of his
armies had decayed during their enforced passivity in southwestern China, while the Communists had
built up a large battle-hardened army on the strength of their appeal to the Chinese Nationalist
sentiment. By 1949, Chiang had lost to the Communists and the People's Republic of China
was established. The Nationalists relocated to Formosa, which they renamed Taiwan, where he
established a mild dictatorship which was supported by the US and UK. Despite his well-known corruption
and incompetence, which was only salvaged by his intelligent and more competent wife,
Madame Chiang, he received Western aid and built up a growing economy over the next 20 years.
Under the Dwight D. Eisenhower administration, the United States signed the existing defense
agreement with the new government of Taiwan, but the warming of relations with China during
the Richard M. Nixon administration in 1972 endangered Taiwan's future. But time caught up
with Chiang, who died on April 5th, 1975, in Taipei, Taiwan, a very rich man, and he was succeeded
temporarily by Yin Chiang, who was replaced by Chiang's son, Chiang Ching-kuo, in 1978,
and the legacy continued. So, click on this now and get 83% off on private internet access.
That's just two dollars and three cents a month, and you also get four extra months completely free,
giving you access to content worldwide and unlimited bandwidth. You also get a 30-day
money-back guarantee. Thank you for watching this episode of Forgotten History. If you liked what
you saw, please click like, share, and subscribe, and if you would like to assist with the ever-increasing
cost of production, please consider becoming a channel member and joining our Patreon page.
Please check out our merchandise store, and thanks for watching.
