The Covered Call ETF Lie Nobody Is Talking About (JEPI, XYLD, SPYI, SPY)

Smart Money
8 followers
3 Video ViewsĀ·Apr 13, 2026
Comments are disabled for this video.
I want to start this video with something one of you wrote in my comments recently,
and I'm going to paraphrase, but it went something like this.
All these funds look great now when the market is on a rocket ship,
but what happens whenever it is not performing well?
In a major correction, will there be NAV erosion?
I'm worried that people who are entering retirement and depending on this income
do not have 10 years to wait for the market to recover.
And I want to be honest with you, this is a legitimate question.
And the person who wrote this deserves a real data-driven answer,
not a dismissal, and not cheerleading.
And here's what I also want to tell you,
that that comment is mixing up two very different things.
And that confusion is costing people real money,
either by avoiding funds that actually work,
or by owning the wrong ones for the wrong reasons.
And I'm Stephanie, an ex-tech leader, a serious data fan,
and an investor who has personally been generating over $4,000 a month
in cover call ETF distributions since 2023.
This isn't theory, this is my actual financial life.
And in this video, I'm going to walk you through the data,
the real performance, through bull markets,
and the one real bear market test that we have on record.
And I'm going to give you the framework that you need to tell
which cover call ETFs are built to last,
and which ones the critics are actually right about.
And stay with me to the end,
because the answer is more nuanced than the skeptics would want you to believe.
And it is more honest than the hype would have you think.
And before we continue, as always,
this content is for educational purposes only, and not financial advice.
All investments carry risk, including the potential loss of capital.
Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.
Please consult a qualified financial professional
before making any investment decisions.
And today we're looking at four funds,
and I want to be clear as to why I chose these four funds specifically.
Because the comparison only works if the starting point is right.
So first up, we have SPY, the SPDR's S&P 500 ETF.
This is our benchmark, the purest form of owning the U.S. stock market.
It is what everything else in this video gets measured against.
If a cover call ETF can't justify its existence relative to SPY
over a full market cycle, we need to know that.
Second, XYLD, the Global X S&P 500 cover call ETF.
Its inception date is June 2013,
over 12 years of monthly distributions without interruption,
$3 billion in assets.
This is what I call the original architecture of the cover call ETF world.
It buys the entire S&P 500,
then it sells at-the-money cover call options
on 100% of the portfolio every single month.
100%, that is the number that we need to sit with,
because that strategy is what generates the high income.
Currently around 10% to 13% annually,
but it is also what creates the trade-off that we need to talk about.
And third, JEPI, the J.P. Morgan Equity Premium Income ETF.
Launched in May 2020, over $40 billion in assets,
making it the largest actively managed ETF on the market.
JEPI is what I'm going to call the institutional grade,
steady-eddy approach.
It doesn't buy the entire index.
It actively selects lower volatility S&P 500 names,
and then it writes out-of-the-money calls,
not at-the-money,
usually using equity-linked notes rather than direct options.
And that distinction matters enormously,
because we're going to come back to that later in the video.
JEPI also has the most important data point
in this entire conversation.
It survived the 2022 bear market,
and the numbers are striking.
And fourth, SPYI, the NEOS S&P 500 High Income ETF.
Launched August 2022.
That's what I consider the new generation.
Tax-efficient by design.
It uses Section 1256 index options,
which receives 60-40 long-term,
short-term tax treatment under IRS rules.
And it writes out-of-the-money calls,
captures more upside than a full overwrite strategy,
and since it's launched, has outperformed JEPI on total return.
So for investors in higher tax brackets,
the structural difference really matters.
Now, here's the thing that I need you to understand
before we look at a single performance number,
because everything that we're about to look at,
all of it depends on whether you're measuring
the right thing.
I'm going to make a statement that sounds simple,
but it's a statement that the entire debate
about cover call ETFs hinges on.
Price return and total return are not the same thing.
And which one you look at
is going to completely change your conclusion.
So let me give you an example
that has nothing to do with cover call ETFs.
Imagine two people each put $100,000
into the stock market 10 years ago.
Person A is going to buy a growth stock.
In over 10 years, the price triples.
Now they have $300,000.
They never received a dividend or a distribution.
All of the return is in the price.
Person B buys a dividend-paying fund.
The price barely moves.
Maybe it went from $100,000 to $110,000,
but every year they received a 10% cash distribution.
That is $10,000 a year for 10 years,
$100,000 in total income sitting in their bank account.
Now, if you only look at the price
of person B's investment,
you would think that they're barely breaking even.
But if you add the income back in,
the actual total return,
you see that they doubled their money.
And this is the error being made
in most cover call ETF criticism.
People look at the price chart.
They look at XYLD, hasn't grown much since 2013,
and they conclude that it's a bad investment.
But they're only looking at half the picture.
Now, I want to be precise here.
Does total return close the gap between XYLD and SPY?
No, it doesn't.
Over the last 10 years,
SPY has outperformed XYLD on total return.
That is a fact,
and I'm going to address it later in the video.
But the question isn't whether the cover call ETF
beats the S&P 500 over a 10-year bull market.
The question is whether it's the right tool
for a specific job,
generating reliable monthly income
with lower volatility
for someone who is approaching retirement
or in retirement.
Those are two completely different questions.
And that brings me to the second concept
that I need you to understand,
the difference between true NAV erosion
and a fund simply tracking its benchmark downward.
True NAV erosion is when a fund's price
declines structurally,
not because the underlying market is declined,
but it's because the fund's own strategy
is giving back more capital
than it can actually sustain.
The fund's price drifts down
even when the market is flat or rising.
Income is essentially being paid out
out of your own principle.
This is a real risk of certain funds,
and I want to show you exactly how to identify it.
Then there's market correlated decline,
and it's something completely different.
When the S&P 500 drops 25%
and your cover call ETF drops 15%,
that's not NAV erosion,
it's the market going down
and your fund holding up better
because of the option premiums that it collected,
and they acted as a partial cushion.
So when the market recovers,
your fund recovers.
The comment that I read at the start of the video
was conflating these two things.
The commenter was right to be concerned,
but the risk that they were describing
if they were holding JEPI or SPY
is market risk, not structural fund failure.
And there is a massive difference.
So let me show you how to spot the difference
of any fund in about 60 seconds.
Pull up the total return chart
on stockanalysis.com
and look at two periods.
First, a bull market period,
say 2023 and 2024.
Second, a down market period, 2022.
If a fund's price is declining
in 2023 and 2024
when the S&P 500 is up 30%,
then you have a structural issue.
And if the fund is down in 2022
and then recovers in 2023,
that is a market cycle.
That is normal.
And I want to show you two real world examples
of NAV erosion so that it's not abstract.
And I chose these specifically
because they're funds
that are actively being marketed
to retirement income investors right now.
Yulti is the yield max ultra option
income strategy ETF,
and it launched in February 28th,
2024.
And here's the number
that I want you to sit with.
The S&P 500 returned approximately 25%
in 2024,
one of the best bull market years
in recent history.
From its launch through February 2025,
Yulti's price dropped over 60%.
At the same time,
it was advertising distribution rates
of 80, 90, even over 100% annually.
So what is happening?
The fund was not generating enough income
from its option strategy
to cover those massive distributions.
So it was paying investors
back their own capital.
Every distribution reduced its asset base.
A smaller asset base
means smaller option premiums
the next month.
Smaller premiums means
smaller distributions,
which then meant that
the price falls further,
which means the base is smaller again.
And the spiral is what happens
when true NAV erosion is created.
And here's the part
that should make anyone
paying attention uncomfortable.
Yulti was paying investors
a dollar per share per week at launch.
But by mid 2025,
that had dropped down to 10 cents per share,
not because the market collapsed,
but because the fund's own asset base
had been eroded to a point
where it couldn't generate the same income.
The yield percentage
may look similar on screen,
but the dollar amount
hitting your bank account
was shrinking every single month.
And this is what the commentator
was actually worried about.
And they were right to worry
because they were describing Yulti,
not JEPI.
Fund selection is everything.
QYLD is a different flavor
of the same problem.
Slower, more subtle,
and more dangerous
precisely because it's subtle.
QYLD launched in December 2013.
It owns the NASDAQ 100
and sells at the money cover calls
on 100% of its portfolio
every single month.
The same as the S&P 500 version of XYLD.
And it's been paying monthly income
consistently for 11 years.
On paper, it looks like
a reliable income machine.
But if you pull up the price chart
since 2013,
while the NASDAQ 100
has gone from roughly $3,000
to over $20,000 over that period
and roughly 600% gain,
QYLD's price has gone
mostly sideways to down.
And the fund systematically
sells away the upside
every single month.
And in a decade-long bull market,
that compounds into a serious gap.
Now, this is where I want to be precise
because at the same time,
it's a trap that I warned you about earlier.
That's the price chart.
So what about total return?
If you reinvested every distribution
in a tax-free account
over that same period of time,
QYLD's annual total return
was approximately 7%, not zero.
But the fund's NAB declined
at approximately 3.7% annually
during the same stretch.
Meaning for every dollar
that you put in,
the underlying asset base
was quietly shrinking,
even as the fund paid out
its distributions.
And if you were actually spending
the income rather than investing it,
which is the entire point
for most retirement investors,
you experienced that NAB erosion in full.
Your income base shrank,
your dollar distributions got smaller
year after year.
So let me give you
the original CoverCall ETF structure
it's honest due.
Because I do think that understanding
XYLD, even QYLD,
is what allows you to fully appreciate
what Jeffy and SPYI have improved upon.
XYLD launched in June 2013,
and it's over 12 years old.
It's paid monthly distributions
every single month since inception,
12 years running.
And that isn't nothing.
It does so by doing
a very simple and systematic thing.
It buys all 500 stocks in the S&P 500
and every single month
it sells at the money
CoverCall options
on 100% of that portfolio.
At the money means that
the strike price is set
at or very near
the current market price.
So if the S&P 500 is at $5,000 today
and you sell an at the money call,
if the market closes above $5,000 by expiry,
you effectively surrender
almost all of that upside
and the option buyer gets it.
And in exchange,
you're going to collect the option premium.
In a volatile market,
that premium is rich.
In a calm and grinding bull market,
that premium is thin,
but it pays every single month regardless.
And here's what it looks like in practice.
In a year like 2023,
when the S&P 500 was up 26%,
XYLD's total return
was approximately 11%.
You left roughly 15 percentage points
of upside on the table
because you sold calls
that capped your participation
above the strike price.
Now, here's where I want to give
the skeptics their due.
If you're a pure accumulator,
someone who had 30 years
to let the market compound
with no need for the income
from this portfolio right now,
then yes, over a long bull market,
a 100% overwrite strategy
will underperform a pure index fund
on total return.
The math is real.
But I do want to ask you
a different question.
What if you're 61 years old
or you're two years from retirement
and you need a strategy
that generates $4,000 to $5,000
a month in income
so you don't have to sell your shares
at the worst possible time?
Suddenly, XYLD looks completely different,
not because the fund changed,
but because your question changed.
The right tool depends entirely
on the job that you're trying to do.
And here's one major data point
that rarely gets discussed.
In 2022, the worst year
for both stocks and bonds in decades,
XYLD's total return
was approximately negative 12%.
The S&P 500 total return
that year was approximately negative 18%.
So XYLD outperformed the index
in a bear market
precisely because the option premiums
had been collecting
acted as a cushion on the way down.
And that's not nothing.
For someone in a drawdown mode,
the difference between 12% loss
and 18% loss is real money.
And the difference between
temporary disruption
and a sequence of returns problem
is really hard to recover from.
So where does XYLD fall short?
The honest answer is
in an extended bull market.
You're systematically
leaving upside on the table.
And over a long time horizon,
that compounding gap is meaningful.
So for someone who needs growth
and income for over 15 to 20 years,
a partial overwrite strategy
like JPY or SPYI
gives you a better structural outcome.
And that is the evolution
that this cover call ETF category has made.
And this is the section
that the commenter
was really talking about.
And it's the most important
data point that we have
because it's the only genuine
bear market test
that these funds have faced.
So let me set the context.
2022 was historically brutal.
The Federal Reserve
raised interest rates
at the fastest pace in 40 years.
The S&P 500 fell approximately
18% for the year.
Bonds, which are supposed to soften
the stock market loss
in a traditional 60-40 portfolio,
they also fell sharply.
And then the Bloomberg
aggregate bond index
lost around 13% that year.
So in other words,
the traditional defensive playbook failed.
Both legs of the portfolio
went down simultaneously.
So what happened to cover call ETFs?
Let me say the JEPI number
out loud one more time.
In a year when the S&P lost 18%,
JEPI's total return,
including every single
monthly distribution it paid out,
was approximately negative 3.5%.
So how?
Two reasons working together.
First, JEPI focuses on lower volatility
stocks within the S&P 500.
It's actively managed,
so it's not the pure index.
That selection process
meant that its underlying portfolio
held up better during the sell-off.
Second, the out-of-the-money
cover call strategy that it uses
meant that it hadn't surrendered
as much upside during
the preceding rally,
so it had some more room to fall
before hitting bottom.
XYLD also outperformed
the index in 2022,
down 12% as we discussed earlier.
The option premiums collected
over that year cushioned the blow.
And this is the cover call mechanism
working exactly as it's designed.
You give up upside in good times
and return, you get a partial buffer
in bad times.
Now here's the direct answer
to the math question from the comment.
The commenter said 10% of $500,000
is more than 10% of $375,000.
And they're completely correct.
If your fund drops 25%,
your income dollars
are going to drop 25% too.
But let me put real numbers
around what actually happened
in 2022 for someone holding JEPI.
So if you had $500,000 in JEPI,
on January 1st, 2022,
by the end of the year,
your position was worth
approximately $482,000.
That's the negative 3.5% return.
And at the same time,
you collected approximately
8% to 9% in distribution.
So roughly $40,000 to $45,000 of income.
The fund paid you that entire time
while the market was down.
Compare that with someone holding
pure SPY with no income strategy.
They started with $500,000.
They ended the year with $409,000,
a loss of about $91,000.
And to cover living expenses that year,
they may have had to sell shares
at depressed prices.
That's the sequence
of return, risk, and action.
You're selling low,
permanently reducing your base,
and that's going to compound
for you going forward.
This is the core argument
for income generating strategies
in retirement.
Not that they're perfect,
not that they're going to outperform
in bull markets,
but that when the market goes down,
you have income arriving
without having to sell shares
down at the bottom.
And this scenario isn't hypothetical.
It's what these funds
are designed to do.
One of the most compelling things
happening in this category right now
is that fund managers
are getting smarter.
And SPYI is the clearest example
of that evolution.
SPYI was launched in August, 2022,
right into the beginning
of the recovery.
It uses fundamentally
different mechanisms
in either XYLD or JEPI.
Instead of equity-linked notes
or a direct index tracking
approach like XYLD,
SPYI trades options
directly on the S&P 500 index.
Why does that matter?
Two reasons.
First, tax efficiency.
Because SPYI uses
Section 1256 contracts,
which is what the IRS calls
exchange-traded index options,
60% of those gains are automatically
treated as long-term capital gains
and 40% as short-term.
For investors in the 24% bracket
or higher,
that can meaningfully change
the after-tax yield
compared to JEPI or XYLD,
both of which generate
primarily ordinary income.
Second, upside capture.
SPYI uses an active
out-of-the-money override approach.
It doesn't sell calls
on 100% of the portfolio like XYLD,
and it writes calls
above the current market price.
So the S&P 500 has to rally
a certain amount
before your upside gets capped.
And that means in strong bull markets,
SPYI participates more
than a full override strategy would.
What SPYI's performance data tells us
is that the narrative
that cover call ETFs can't keep up
with the rising market
is getting outdated.
The fund that uses an intelligent,
partial override,
and tax-efficient structures,
they're generating strong total returns
and meaningful income.
Now, SPYI has only been around
since mid-2022.
That's less than three years of data.
And I want to be honest about that.
We don't know yet how it performs
through a true extended bear market period.
The 2022 data that we have is partial.
I believe that the structure is sound,
but intellectual honesty requires
acknowledging the data that we have
and the data that we don't.
And SPYI is not the only fund
in the new generation
that deserves your attention.
Two others that I track closely,
GPICS and TSPY,
did a full breakdown
on how they're structurally built
versus SPYI and JEPI.
You can find that linked
in the description below
or somewhere up here in the corner.
The bottom line
on this new generation of funds
is that cover call ETF space
has evolved enormously
in a short period of time.
The difference between a 100%
monthly overwrite like XYLD,
a partial monthly overwrite like JEPI,
and a tax-efficient index overwrite like SPYI,
they're not cosmetic.
They're really structural.
And they translate into
meaningful different outcomes,
depending on your tax situation,
your income timeline,
and your tolerance for complexity.
Getting the selection right is the work.
And I need to spend some time on risk,
not to scare you off from the strategy,
but because anyone who doesn't give you
an honest risk picture
isn't somebody that you should trust.
Risk one, income variability.
Cover call income is generated
from option premiums.
Option premiums go up
when the volatility is high,
which often happens
during market corrections.
And they compress
when the market is grinding higher
in a lower fear environment.
And that means your monthly distributions
will fluctuate.
Some months will be richer than others.
And if you're budgeting
on a fixed income number
from these funds,
you need a cash buffer
to smooth out the variability
or work with funds
that strategically work
to pay distributions out consistently
from an amount standpoint.
I personally maintain 12 months
of living expenses in cash
separate from my cover call ETF portfolio.
Risk two is dollar income declines
in a severe drawdown.
If you hold $500,000
in a cover call ETF
and it drops to 400,000
during a bear market,
your 10% yield now generates $40,000
versus the $50,000
you were originally expecting.
The percentage yield
may stay the same,
but the dollar amount
and the income is lower.
That's the commenter's point
and it's valid.
The mitigation is positioning size,
not putting your entire retirement
income need in cover call ETFs.
Building your income floor
across multiple sources,
social security,
cash distributions,
and a core growth portfolio
that compounds untouched.
Risk three, tax treatment.
And this is the one
that catches people off guard
and it shouldn't.
Most cover call ETF distributions,
XYLD, JEPI, most of them,
they're taxed as ordinary income,
not qualified dividends.
So that means if you're in the 22
or the 24% bracket,
your 10% yield becomes roughly
seven and a half to 8%
after federal tax.
SPYI is a partial exception
due to its section 1256 structure
and ROC distributions.
And the practical implication
is hold these funds
inside your IRA
or your Roth if possible.
If it's in a taxable brokerage account,
the tax drag can be real.
So if you're going to hold them
in a taxable account,
SPYI structure deserves
serious consideration.
Risk four, limited track record.
I'm going to say something
that I think is important
to acknowledge.
Most of the funds
that I'm discussing today
haven't been through
a prolonged multi-year bear market.
JEPI launched in 2020,
SPYI in 2022,
and we have one 12 month test.
2022, they both performed well,
but 2022 was not 2008.
A sustained two
to three year bear market
with a 50% drawdown
would be a harder test.
I believe these funds
are structurally designed to hold up,
but I can't show you the data
because it doesn't exist yet.
Any advisor or creator
who tells you they know
exactly how these funds perform
in 2008 scale conditions is speculating.
I'd rather be honest with you
than confident.
Risk five, you can own the wrong fund
for the wrong reason.
XYLD in a taxable account
when you don't need
the income right now
is probably not optimal.
JEPI in a Roth IRA
that should be growing for 20 years
is also not optimal.
These are tools,
and like any tool,
the right question is,
what job am I trying to do?
And is this the right instrument
for that specific job?
So let me bring this together
into a framework that I use
and that I walk my clients through.
Step one,
define your income need specifically.
Do not think about cover call ETFs
as a percentage of your portfolio.
Think of them as an income machine
with a specific job.
What is your income target
from your investments?
Separate from social security
and any pension.
How much of that do you want to have
come from cover call ETF distributions?
Size the position
to hit that income number
not just as a random allocation.
Step two,
match the fund with your goal.
If your priority is maximizing income
and you can accept
surrendering significant upside
in a bull market,
XYLD could be your choice.
If you want balance of reliable income,
lower volatility,
and upside participation
with ordinary income tax treatment,
JEPI.
If you want income,
upside capture,
better tax efficiency
for higher bracketed investors,
SPYI.
These are tools.
They're not interchangeable products.
Match the fund structure
to your specific goal,
the account type,
and your tax situation.
Step three,
put the fund in the right account.
Cover call ETFs belong in a Roth IRA
or a traditional IRA
wherever possible.
Roth means that the income is tax free.
Traditional IRA means
that the income is tax deferred.
Taxable brokerage account means
ordinary income tax
for every distribution.
If you have to hold these
in a taxable account,
SPYI section 1256 tax treatment
gives you the best structural advantage.
Map out the account type
and the fund type
before you think about anything else.
And step four,
build a buffer.
For retirees,
12 to 24 months of living expenses
in a cash
or short-term treasury bills
outside of the cover call ETF portfolio
is key.
This means if distributions compress
in a low volatility environment,
you're not forced to sell
in a down market.
You could draw from the buffer
while the portfolio recovers.
This is the simplest,
highest impact risk management move
in the strategy.
And step five,
track total return,
not just price.
Go to stockanalysis.com right now
or whatever you use
and pull up any cover call ETF you own.
Switch to the total return view.
That's the number that's going to tell you
how your investment is actually performing.
So if someone sends you an article
about how your cover call ETF
is quote unquote down since inception,
ask them to show you
the total return chart as well.
The conversation should change.
So let me come back to the comment
that started this video.
Will there be NAV erosion?
Are people entering retirement
who depend on this income
going to be okay
when the market corrects?
Here's my honest answer.
For a fund like XYLD,
the 100% overwrite structure,
you're making a deliberate trade-off.
You're giving up long-term growth potential
in the exchange for high,
consistent monthly income.
In a prolonged bear market,
you will experience drawdown
and your income in dollar terms will be lower.
You need to know that going in
and size accordingly.
For funds like JEPI and SPYI,
the partial overwrite
out of the money structures,
the 2022 data tells us a compelling story.
JEPI held up in one of the worst years
for traditional portfolios in modern history,
paid income every month throughout
and recovered.
That is not nothing.
Is this strategy for every person
in every situation?
No, there's no such strategy.
But is it a strategy
that deserves to be dismissed
based on risk reading
how NAV erosion actually works
or based on looking at only the price chart?
Absolutely not.
I built a real income engine
with these funds.
I did it carefully.
I sized positions intentionally.
I track everything.
And if you want help thinking through weather
and how this strategy could fit
into your specific retirement picture,
that's exactly the work that I do with clients.
If you're 55 to 65
and have built something real
and you're trying to figure out
how to turn that into an income plan
that doesn't require you just to hope
that the market cooperates every year,
let's talk.
The link to book time with me
is in the description below.
I work with a small number of clients.
I take this work seriously
and availability is limited.
So if you don't see time available
in the next 30 days,
please be sure to look further out.
And I'll also be announcing periodically
when more spots open up.
If this video gave you a clearer picture
of how to actually evaluate cover call ETFs,
hit the like button.
It's the single best way
to help more people find this type of content.
And it takes two seconds.
It really means a lot.
And subscribe if you haven't already.
I release new videos every week
and I go deep into these topics every time.
And check out my cover call ETF playlist here.
Every video builds on this framework.
And if you are newer to this space,
this is the best place to get started.
This is all about giving yourself
permission to be wealthy.
I'll see you in the next one.
