Therapist Reacts to CRAZY, STUPID, LOVE

Love Arcana - Where Love Finds Depth.
4 followers
How do you make a relationship work or… how do you have a healthy breakup?
Licensed therapist Jonathan Decker and filmmaker Alan Seawright react to Crazy, Stupid, Love and all of the messy, ridiculous, and wonderful relationships throughout the film.
Cinema Therapy breaks down the relationship dynamics in Crazy, Stupid, Love. Filmmaker Alan Cight and licensed therapist Jonathan Decker analyze the realistic portrayals of love, infidelity, and emotional growth displayed by the characters.
#sponsored
This is the pathway to a healthy, happy life.
I don't know how we're going to make it work, but we both want it, so we're going to find a way.
I'm so glad you bought me that ice cream.
There are plenty of couples who, post-divorce,
have a healthy friendship, and it comes from moments like this.
Me too.
They acknowledge, I should have fought for you,
and I stopped treating you with the attention and affection that you deserve.
Being kind, being accountable.
Nine!
The healthiest, happiest,
wholest, most healed outcome, whatever form it takes, comes through this sort of thing.
And that level of determination and resilience is what keeps the marriage together.
Oh, he's so hot and so miserable.
West Coast, we're coming to California, baby!
Live shows.
18th in Los Angeles.
20th in the Bay Area.
A Q&A.
Live meet and greet.
March!
Link is in the description below.
It will be fun.
Hello, and welcome to Cinema Therapy.
I'm Alan Seawright, a professional filmmaker who needs therapy.
I'm joined by my co-host...
Jonathan Decker, licensed therapist who loves movies.
What do we got going on today?
So you're going to react to a movie called Crazy Stupid Love.
Ooh, I love this movie.
I love this movie.
There's great relationship stuff.
There's terrible relationship stuff.
Right.
But it's all well-written.
It's all spectacularly acted.
I'm going to ask for permission right now
to just refer to the characters by the names of the actors.
They don't have character names.
It's Julianne Moore.
It's Ryan Gosling.
Emma Stone, Steve Carell.
Yeah, here we go.
Yeah.
Okay.
Just learned that she's had an affair.
I've seen this twice.
You should, you know, because maybe I'll just say it.
Maybe I'll just tell you.
He hasn't.
I slept with someone.
Oh, just there.
He just there learns that she had an affair.
But she asked for a divorce, and he doesn't know why.
And now she just said why.
And so he's going to do...
Listen, for those who've been there, this is actually a very relatable feeling.
The last person in the world that I want to hurt is your couch.
If you keep talking, I'm going to get out of the car.
But I think if I did it, it just shows how broken we are.
Okay.
And how much I really need your couch.
My bias as a couple's therapist is always,
okay, we're going to start with trying to save the relationship.
Like, that's why you're in therapy.
That's why I became a therapist, is to try and help couples stay together.
But the simple fact is sometimes they don't.
And sometimes that's the best play for everyone involved.
Yeah, how do we both, like, soft landing, right?
Exactly.
The plane's going down, but it can, like, glide on its belly across the grass.
Or it can explode and kill everyone.
Right.
Another happy landing.
Sometimes couples therapy transitions into divorce mediation.
And something I see a lot in session is just sometimes people really want to be heard.
They want their feelings justified or validated.
Or they at least want their partner to understand what's going on and why this is happening.
And their partner's just like, I can't stand to listen to another word of this.
It's too painful.
It's too much.
To the point where this scene is so brilliant because it's realistic.
And here's why it's realistic.
No, it's a bit of comedy.
And it seems extreme, except for they're in a residential neighborhood.
They're not on the freeway.
If they're on the freeway, suddenly it's like a Zucker Brothers, like, way over the top.
They're going, like, 15, 20 in a residential.
And he accurately gauges this is going to hurt, but it's going to hurt less than this conversation.
With everything going on in Cal's life with his marriage, his kids, his work,
he's probably feeling pretty overwhelmed.
Definitely.
But he's resistant to asking for help.
Which honestly feels all too relatable.
As a therapist, a father, and a business partner, I have to be a lot of things to a lot of people.
A lot of people are counting on me to meet their needs.
And honestly, it's a lot of pressure.
Adulting is hard.
But the new year can be a chance for a fresh start.
I help other people, but I also need help.
Getting therapy has been a source of support and strength for me.
It can help you feel lighter and start this new year with clarity and self-compassion.
Today's sponsor, BetterHelp, can help you start therapy with confidence.
They'll help you find a therapist that matches your goals, preferences, and needs.
And if the match isn't quite right,
you can switch therapists anytime for any reason at no additional cost.
And 72% of BetterHelp clients report a reduction in symptoms within just 12 weeks.
Showing that professional support truly can make a difference.
That's much better than relying on some random pickup artist to help you put the pieces of
your life back together after you've shattered them into a million pieces.
Click the link in the description or go to betterhelp.com slash cinematherapy
to get 10% off your first month.
And let BetterHelp support you in feeling lighter in 2026.
I mean, there's lots of beautiful women in this bar.
Your friend included.
Hi.
I love you.
But I can't take my eyes off of you.
That's a fact.
It's not a lie.
I find you very attractive.
Do you find me attractive?
She does.
Okay, Ryan Gosling and Eva Stodd, obviously.
Absolute thunderstorm of electricity between them, right?
There's a reason we've seen them in multiple movies together.
They're great.
The best friend is so funny.
Yeah, very, very funny.
Just come on.
Let me do my closing argument.
When I talk about him doing like the full Ryan Gosling charming,
but it's a facade.
It's a veneer and we see that later,
which is why Ryan Gosling gets to eat as an actor in this movie.
Yes.
That guy from the bar that one time,
that was a total Tomcat in the sack,
but I can't guarantee you won't not regret it.
That's a double negative.
You're a double negative.
Okay, Hannah, can I buy you a drink?
Okay.
You know what?
It's time to go home.
Really?
It's forward of you, but okay.
This is a womanizing character and we later see that
he's like a lot of at least cinematic womanizers.
Cinematic womanizers and real life womanizers
are not cut from the same cloth, generally speaking.
I'm a loving uncle.
Who's trying to get her into bed.
That's the loving part.
In movies, pickup artists go after women because yes,
they seem shallow,
but inside they have a deep longing for connection, right?
And they're just too scared to be vulnerable and to be real.
And they always meet a charming, intelligent woman
who doesn't fall for their bullshit,
doesn't fall into bed with them.
And that intrigues them.
To be fair, I've seen that happen in real life,
but it far more often takes the...
It's happened to me in real life.
That's how I met my wife.
I was significantly less handsome and 3% as charming as Ryan Gosling.
But you still kind of played this game a bit.
I did that same thing and the response was, okay.
The biggest difference is that most real life pickup artists
are not longing for something deeper.
And this is not just a mask that they wear to hide a deeper self.
There is no deeper self.
That's why they're pickup artists.
If they hit rock bottom.
Eventually there will come a time.
There could be a deeper self and therapy can help with that.
And the warning to you ladies out there,
who there might be a charming pickup artist
who's charming at you and pick uping at you.
You're not going to be the one who fixes him.
No.
And this is my issue with the film as a relationship counselor,
not as a film fan.
Because as a film fan, no notes.
Brilliant.
I do have some notes on the messaging of the film,
but we'll get to that.
Okay.
There's a, a turnoff foul for the sprinklers over there.
Last week, you know, when I told you that I had to work late,
I really went to see the new toilet.
She's, she's opening up to him.
Like they're still spouses.
Yeah.
And he can't because he wants to be a spouse to her.
And she like they're divorced.
She broke it.
Yeah.
We haven't been us not for a long time.
And I don't know when you and I stopped being us.
I mean, do you?
Maybe it's when you screwed David Lenhagen.
Okay.
Nice people are no longer nice when at a certain point.
Yep.
When the pain is too much, the betrayal is too much.
I once went to a three day, like 10 hours a day
training with the Gottmans at UC Berkeley
on treating affairs and betrayal trauma.
And it got certified in that.
And then that's been a major part of my practice ever since.
The first thing you have to acknowledge in situations like this,
because she's talking about what happened leading up to the affair.
She's talking about the distance between them.
She's talking about growing apart.
She's talking about not feeling seen, not feeling valued,
not feeling connected, feeling lonely.
Like all these things that led to a psychological state
where she was more vulnerable to the temptation of falling in with another man.
And he is focused on...
All he's feeling is the betrayal of the act.
The act.
And in this sort of situation in therapy, his needs need to come first.
She's talking about what happened before,
but the thing is, she didn't have to cheat.
What I always tell people is,
the things that were going wrong in the marriage, you created together.
And we need to explore what went wrong
and who needs to be accountable for what,
and what needs to change if there's going to be a marriage going forward,
or if there's going to be a co-parenting relationship or something healthy here.
But the affair itself, crossing that line was a moral choice.
Right?
To do it or not to do it.
And you can't say, I had an affair because I was lonely.
You can't say I had an affair because we'd grown apart.
The fact is, lots of people feel lonely.
Lots of people grow apart and they don't have affairs
because that's not the choice they made.
And if you're going to regain enough trust and credibility
to have a conversation about all the other stuff,
you have to start with,
I crossed this line and I devastated you.
And I know that was wrong.
And I know you didn't deserve it.
And that part is 100% on me.
Only when you do that, can we go and look at the other stuff.
Whoa, look at you.
I feel like I'm going skiing.
Did you sleep with him?
Jesus God.
Yeah, probably.
What?
You would?
So he's getting his makeover, his pretty woman makeover
from Ryan Gosling teaching him how to be.
You see what just happened, Cal?
As soon as you opened your mouth,
Tiffany started doubting whether she wanted to sleep with you or not.
That's probably the meanest thing anyone's ever said to me.
No, this is.
Your wife cheated on you because you lost sight of who you are as a man,
as a husband, and probably as a lover.
You're right, that's meaner.
He's a douchebag pickup artist.
There's probably some validity to what he's saying.
Yeah.
Like almost certainly, which is why it's the meanest thing anyone's ever said to me.
There is something to be said for understanding how to dress,
how to groom yourself, how to present yourself,
especially if you're dating or just in life.
And there's something to be said for having an innate confidence of knowing who you are.
Steve Carell had lost sight of who he was as a man, as a husband, as a father.
He spent so much time feeling sad and pathetic that what his family needed was a leader
and needed somebody who would be strong and somebody who would provide,
but also somebody who would give their love freely
and show confidence instead of just hanging back, feeling unsure.
I made an effort when we were younger, didn't I?
I mean, miniature golf and dancing.
You were such a great dancer.
I had to be.
You're such a good miniature golfer.
Again, witty.
I guess I got lazy.
I got, I got boring is what I got.
Witty and charming, but believable.
No.
And I'm so mad at you.
I'm really mad at you for what you did, but I'm mad at myself too.
This feels like a huge breakthrough, right?
I should not have jumped out of that car.
I should have fought for you.
Because you fight for your soulmates.
At least that's what my 13 year old son tells me.
He's a really strange kid.
I miss you.
A lot of things in therapy is kind of a wait and see.
You know, we're going week by week and we're seeing how this unspools.
What this conversation is, whether they get back together or not,
is a breakthrough, as you said, in vulnerability and in accountability.
Yeah.
There are plenty of couples who post-divorce,
they have a healthy friendship and it comes from moments like this.
Like they don't get back together, but they acknowledge,
Hey, I should have fought for you.
Or I got complacent and I stopped treating you with the attention
and affection that you deserve.
Like that sort of thing is how healing happens.
And healing sometimes means reconciliation.
Sometimes it means you get back together.
Sometimes it doesn't.
But this is what I really believe about therapy and about life.
Being kind, being accountable, engaging a perspective,
everything that we talk about on the show,
about what healthy relationships look like.
It's not outcome-based if the outcome is,
Well, I want it to look exactly like this.
Because you're always dealing with,
Well, what does the other person want as well?
But the healthiest, happiest,
holiest, most healed outcome, whatever form it takes,
comes through this sort of thing.
This is the pathway to a healthy, happy life.
It might not be the one you planned on.
Right.
It will not be the one you planned on.
Good catch.
There is no chance of it being the one you planned on.
However, you'll be happy.
Nine?
He followed Ryan Gosling's advice and hooked up with a lot of women.
It worked.
You showed me.
She assumes it was to hurt her.
Yeah.
I wasn't trying to show you.
He was reeling himself.
Let's try and move on.
One thing this film shows really, really well
is their hurtful, stupid things we do
are all based in understandable motives and human emotions.
Yeah.
Tell her she's the perfect combination of sexy and cute.
That's what he used to say to his wife.
Why did he sleep with nine women?
He was trying to move on.
And he had a role model.
He had this guy he really looked up to.
And who wouldn't?
It's Ryan Gosling.
Yeah, this guy that he really looked up to
that he thought really had it figured out
and had his act together.
Fact is, that guy didn't really.
No.
The things that we do that cause harm to ourselves and to others,
generally speaking, don't come from a place of malice.
With some people, they do.
And with those people, give them a wide berth.
Like, I don't think any of us need malicious people in our life.
But there's a difference between malice and when he says,
wasn't trying to show you.
I was trying to move on.
Like, he never intended for her to find this out.
He had a mentor who was like,
the best way to get over somebody is to get under somebody else.
And he took that literally, you know?
Sleeping with a lot of younger women that you meet at a bar
seems like the dream.
He's miserable.
He's empty.
It did nothing for him.
Yeah.
When we consider each other,
there's a difference between letting someone off the hook
for their bad behavior
and understanding with compassion and empathy
where the bad behavior came from.
Yeah.
And there are two different things.
Well, I'm not going to blame Julianne Moore in this scene.
She just found out.
She got a frigging bomb dropped on her.
Yeah.
She's going to be reeling from the explosion for a minute.
Yeah.
You can't expect her to just be like,
oh, well, I can see that you were hurting
and maybe we should talk about this some more.
She's going to say,
NINE?!
I am here to bang the hot guy that hit on me at the bar.
Jacob.
Are people still saying bang?
Oh, I do.
We are going to bang.
This is happening.
This is probably what would happen
if I picked up somebody in a bar
because I have no idea how that scene works.
What do we do?
Yeah.
What are we doing?
All right.
He gads.
Oh, he's so hot and so miserable.
It's like you're photoshopped.
I love it.
You get one F word in a PG-13 and they deployed it.
Can I?
Perfectly.
You have gold hands.
Now you take off your dress.
No.
Yes.
No way.
It's so real.
Just so believable.
I love it.
Yeah, these are electric together.
Could you do me a favor?
What?
Will you do me a kindness?
Will you ask me something personal about myself?
Okay, fine.
One of his rules, never get personal.
Yes.
What's your mother like?
My mom is very beautiful, very vain, very smart, cold.
So we've skipped a bunch of stuff.
Like this scene is really long.
Like the dirty dancing.
The dirty dancing.
What's your move?
I do the dirty dancing.
He was such a sweet guy.
He was probably too sweet, very successful in business.
So this is where it's important to distinguish films from reality.
Because the film is showing you that the pickup artist you meet at the bar is secretly very tender.
Yeah.
And very sweet and very respectful.
Couldn't really handle my mother.
And a very deep person.
Which don't get me wrong.
Statistically, there's probably bound to be a few pickup artists who are actually like that.
Sure.
This is a one in a million shot.
Except it's one in 50 million because that guy happens to also be Ryan Gosling.
I generally hate the bad boy changes for the right woman trope.
I like it here because it just goes to show if you write it well enough
and you cast it well enough, you can even win me over.
If you're going to have a bad boy with a secret heart of gold
fall for someone and get changed, it's going to be Emma Stone.
Yeah, that's right.
You're going to meet Emma Stone and you're going to be like,
I will change literally everything about me.
The very definition of disarming.
He's a bad boy in vibe, not in actuality.
Bad boy asterisk.
He's very upfront about things.
None of these women are getting into a relationship with him
thinking it's going to really go somewhere.
They're thinking, I get to have a night in the sack with Tomcat.
Right.
Because genuinely bad guys are deceptive.
They use people.
They mistreat people.
They devalue people.
He's doing none of that.
He's always very upfront that this is just a casual night, right?
So he's not bad in that sense, but he is deep.
And I've heard it said that you can only know others
as well as you know yourself,
or you can't know others deeper than you know yourself.
And this is the first time he's actually exploring this space
and it makes him very uncomfortable and it throws him off his game,
which is really fun to watch.
The pilot lights out and I don't know how to relight it.
So I'm sorry to bother you.
No, no, it's fine.
That's fine.
Call me.
I'm glad you called about this.
I'll just walk you through it, okay?
He doesn't say call me anytime.
He doesn't say I'll be right there.
He's trying to play it cool.
You see the gray door?
Yeah.
Okay, just slide that down.
Okay.
There's a red button.
I love subtext and that's all this scene is.
It's great.
Yeah.
And it's not, you know,
some subtext is really, really subtle and it's hard to find
and you end up doing headcanon.
Yeah.
This is punching you in the face.
There it goes.
But it doesn't matter because it's good.
And sometimes a breakup or a divorce is the right call.
Sure.
And you still feel longing and you still miss the person
because there's a history there.
There's affection there.
It doesn't just go away.
And sometimes it's there because maybe reconciliation is the right play.
And this is what I mean when I say you see where it goes.
Yeah.
The movie's telling you what it needs to tell you about these people.
The intensity with which he's playing,
like just staring at her and like drinking her in,
like this is sustenance for his soul.
And the way he's playing it is so beautiful.
And it's so lovely to have a character get to have that moment of catharsis of like,
I get to be there for this person who does need me emotionally,
even though she can't say it and she certainly doesn't show it
and she hurt me really badly.
But like, this is what I need and I'm getting it,
even though I have to do it in the shadows while wearing aerating spike shoes.
Well, and the movie is telling you these crazy kids are destined to be together.
And I get swept up in the romance of it.
And again, in therapy and in life, it can go either way.
But what's really beautiful about this scene to me,
even though the movie is framing as he's there for her,
she's his soulmate and he's always going to be there for her.
You take a step back from the soulmate destined to be together rhetoric and just look at
they're no longer married and he's still showing kindness to her.
Yeah.
My actual son believes in grand romantic gestures.
He believes in the existence of one's soulmate.
And it's easy to just look at a 13 year old and say,
you don't know what you're talking about.
You are wrong.
But I'm not so sure.
I am.
I met my soulmate when I was 15 years old.
We went out for ice cream.
After my dad started teasing me.
A little baby Joey King.
Dads do.
Doing some good work there.
I told him, dad, it's no big deal.
Because the son believes his soulmate is his babysitter.
And the film kind of frames it like, yeah, once he grows up,
they're going to be together because they're soulmates.
Definitely.
And it's kind of like the zing in Hotel Transylvania.
Like it's a little too.
He imprinted a little bit.
Yeah.
He did a little Renesmee.
When I was 15 years old and I loved her.
Every minute of every day.
Since I first bought her that mint chocolate.
Okay, here's my concession.
I do believe in the soulmate concept,
but not in the sense of the universe.
Fates two people that must be together.
You can create a soulmate situation with somebody.
That I believe.
Even when I've hated her.
Only married couples will understand that one.
And I don't know if it's going to work out.
I don't know what's going to happen.
I'm sorry, Robbie.
I can't give you that.
But I can promise you this.
Such a realism.
Yeah.
I will never stop trying.
Because when you find the one, you never give up.
Just because I enjoy the performances doesn't mean I go along with all of it.
When you find that person, never give up is a great motto.
As long as the feedback you're getting from them is yes, keep trying.
Yeah.
If that person feels the same way about you.
Right.
Yeah.
Never give up on each other.
I've helped hundreds of couples stay together with that same energy.
Sure.
And create something beautiful where they thrive and they're happy.
Based on I love you, you love me.
This is really hard.
I don't know how we're going to make it work.
But we both want it.
So we're going to find a way.
And that level of determination and resilience is what keeps the marriage together.
And helps it to blossom.
Absolutely.
Yep.
In real life, if a man proclaimed his undying love for a woman who cheated on him and divorced him.
At a public school, like a pep rally.
She's probably going to be like, what the hell are you doing?
This is my issue with this scene.
I actually like the speech.
I think it's a good speech.
I think it's a great speech.
I don't have a problem with it.
The only issue I have with it is it's happening at a graduation and no one stops it.
Right.
No.
If I'm a dad in there, I'm like, who is this guy?
Sit him down.
Hey, can we get control of this?
This is a middle school graduation ceremony.
This dude's kid is the valedictorian and he's giving the valedictorian speech,
which was going off the rails.
And now this guy's doing this.
We see why the kid was going off the rails.
Get both of them off the stand.
Principal, let's go.
A healthy real life version of this is if Steve Carell goes to Julianne Moore.
And he says, you know, through all of this, I've arrived at one inescapable conclusion.
Give speech.
I love you.
I choose you.
And if there is part of you that feels the same way and wants to explore that,
I will not give up until you tell me to.
If you're willing to fight for us, I'm willing to fight for us.
And to say that privately with her.
And then to say, but if what you want and need for your life is not this,
because I love you, I will also honor that.
And then see what she says.
This is the difference between movies and reality.
It's been a really hard year.
How so?
Again, sweet, funny people deal with problems.
With humor.
I guess I just, you know, really what I, what I want to say is that I'm,
I'm so glad you bought me that ice cream.
Gosh, these two are good.
They're so, so good.
Like they're so good that I'm tearing up.
Despite this twingly, twangly music that's driving me.
And then I love that this kid who has like fixed everything kind of sorta
gets the hero backlight shot and just like,
Movies.
If there's one thing Hollywood has taught me is that perverts can do anything.
Little perverted kid fixed his parents' marriage.
And one of the things that I love about this movie so much is that it does tie everything
up with a bow, right?
Like, I'm glad you bought me that ice cream.
Like the, the emotional release here is like, oh, they're going to get back together.
Yeah.
But they don't.
At least not on camera.
Not on camera.
We don't have to see them hug.
They don't kiss.
They don't whatever, right?
They're just laughing and smiling and having a good time together.
And they're free to be themselves together again.
And that is emotionally more satisfying, I think, than the big sweeping, rotating dolly
shot of them kissing in slow motion.
Like, we don't need it.
We need them to laugh and smile and be okay.
Yeah.
Like, I know any number of divorced couples who get to a place of, instead of it just
feels like a train wreck and it feels like the worst thing that could ever happen.
Like, I'm really glad you bought me that ice cream.
Like, I'm really glad we've experienced what we experienced.
I'm glad for this family that we created all of this.
Like, I don't regret it.
And that's beautiful and that's healing.
And it's hard because in divorces, it takes two to create that dynamic.
Like, just like it takes two to create a healthy marriage, it takes two to create a healthy
divorce.
Yep.
This is a fantastic film.
So until next time.
All right.
How about we say what we want on three?
Okay.
One, two, three.
Creme brulee.
I actually like that.
And watch movies.
He was supposed to say I want a divorce.
But I just want creme brulee, guys.
Hey, guess what?
This show is also brought to you by patrons who get access to director's cuts of episodes
that are longer.
This one's very long.
We recorded for over an hour because we have so much to say about this movie because we
loved it so much.
People with names like these names.
Holo Heartbreak.
And Snow.
The underscore spaced underscore man.
Fowlin.
And Meg.
Thank you.
We love you.
Thanks, guys.
