Mar 7, 2022 Get your SPECIAL OFFER for MagellanTV here: https://try.magellantv.com/baumgartne... It's an exclusive offer for my viewers! Start your free trial today. MagellanTV is a new kind of streaming service run by filmmakers with 3,000+ documentaries! -- There are some types of damage that push a painting to the brink and challenge the conservator to find a way of saving the piece. Among the most impactful and catastrophic forces is fire. It takes no quarter and spares no painting. But for a piece that has not been thoroughly consumed by fire there is hope... and that is the survivor. - Support me on Patreon / baumgartnerrestoration
Follow me on Instagram - / baumgartnerrestoration Facebook - / baumgartnerfineartrestoration Key moments
View all Transcript Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
Baumgartner Restoration 1.94M subscribers Videos About
Patreon
Instagram
Facebook 1,320 Comments
This video is brought to you by MagellanTV, a new documentary streaming service founded
by filmmakers whose mission is to tell great stories that have defined the human experience.
For as long as I've been doing this, there's one question that just seems to smolder on,
and that's, when is the damage too much? When is a painting too far gone and beyond the ability
of the conservator to, well, conserve it? And while not universal, it really comes down to one
word. Fire. That most humbling of elements that can turn just about anything into base carbon
takes no quarter. It spares no painting, regardless of how beautiful, important, or
valuable it may be. But all hope is not lost. You see, most paintings aren't thoroughly consumed
and destroyed by fire. Rather, they're just damaged by the byproducts of fire, smoke, and heat.
And for those paintings, even though the window is small, if we can thread that needle, well,
there is hope. Fire is an impressive and awesome force. It can do amazing things,
none of which are good for paintings. Case in point, this small painting of a western
mountain landscape by Albert Bierstadt was profoundly damaged by fire. The surface of the
work no longer resembles that of a painting, but more a lunar landscape. It is so pocked and
blistered. The heat has caused the surface to bubble, and in places, those bubbles have popped
off and are now losses. Yes, the painting is dirty with a discolored varnish, and it was glued to a
sheet of masonite, but those are hardly the most problematic features. It is the perilous nature
of the paint layer, and the fact that we can hardly see through these blisters to enjoy the
image that is of most concern. Now, this painting was dismissed as a complete loss by an auction house,
by an appraiser, and by the owner's insurance company. But they have belief, and who am I to
begrudge their belief that Baumgartner can bring a Bierstadt back from the brink?
Well, I owe it to my client and this painting. After all, it's the survivor. A German-born
American painter, Albert Bierstadt began his career as a member of the Hudson River School,
but after seeing the landscapes of the American West, he found his inspiration. And those grand,
extravagant paintings of the landscape helped create support for the conservation movement,
and ultimately the establishment of America's first national park, Yellowstone. MagellanTV's
Yellowstone is a virtual tour of this natural showcase that exceeds any other film that has
attempted to capture the splendor of this patch of heaven. Head over to try.magellantv.com
slash Baumgartner Restoration, or click the link in the description below to take advantage of this
offer and try something different. This painting is uniquely difficult, but to understand why,
we have to understand how a painting flakes. So we start with canvas, brown, and then a ground
layer. And then, on top of that ground layer is the paint layer, here in blue. Now, when paintings
flake, we have the canvas. We have the ground layer, which has separated from that canvas.
And when it has cracked and lifted, it takes the paint layer with it. This is the first type of
flaking, and the easiest to resolve, because we can take adhesive and through the back, porous
canvas, saturate the painting and fill those voids with adhesive. And then, using heat and pressure,
we can bond the lifting paint back down. But there's another type of flaking. In this case,
we have the canvas, and we have the ground layer. But here, instead of the ground layer detaching,
just the paint layer has detached, while the ground is still bonded to the canvas.
Now, in this case, we must go from the front and inject an adhesive through the openings. And then,
using heat and pressure, we can bond the lifting paint back down. And then the painting will be
stable. But our painting is a little different. First, we have a layer of masonite, then canvas.
Then we have the ground layer, which is well bonded to the canvas.
And then we have the paint layer. And here, we have areas where there are losses,
areas where there are bubbles and losses, and areas where there are bubbles but no losses.
So we can inject adhesive into the areas we have access to, but what do we do about the rest of
the painting? And that's where this painting will get interesting. But before we get there,
we're going to take a moment to do some stabilization so that no more paint is lost
during handling. So I've heated up and thinned out the adhesive, and I'm drawing it into a needle.
And then I'm going to try to inject it everywhere where I can. In some spots, I can find openings
where the paint has flaked off, and just kind of saturate the area, and hope that the adhesive
penetrates underneath the existing layer of paint. This is not all that difficult. But in some areas
where I don't have complete loss, the use of a needle will help, because I will be able to go
into or under those areas where there is a void, and inject the adhesive. I don't have to worry
about being too careful here, because the excess will be removed. And really, my main function is
to get as much into the voids as possible. So a little spillover isn't going to hurt anyone,
let alone this painting. Now this is a slow process. There's just no way to do it fast,
unless of course you speed up the video. But trying to get every little spot is really
critically important, because I want to make sure that as much of this paint remains on the painting.
Once that adhesive has been allowed to dry, I can begin the cleaning process.
Now I made some tests, and I found that there surprisingly was not a lot of surface grime.
In fact, almost none. Maybe it had been wiped off, or maybe the painting wasn't high enough
up to be exposed to the smoke. In any event, I need to get rid of this old varnish.
But because the paint layer is so delicate, I can't go over it with a swab and a stick.
So I'm using a poultice. And in this case, I'm using a piece of felt,
saturated with a solvent mixture that I've tested that removes the varnish,
but is safe against the painting. I can leave this felt on the surface, and it will soften
and remove that varnish layer. The felt will absorb it as the solvent evaporates,
and I'll be left with a completely clean painting. Now I am going over it with a cotton ball,
and I'm just delicately rolling this cotton ball, because I don't want to break any of that paint
layer. And this is just to ensure that I have picked up any residues that may be left behind
from the poultice. The method of using a poultice is one that allows the conservator to apply
solvents to a painting that can't stand surface friction. Imagine if I were to try to clean this
painting with a swab and a stick. How much paint would come off? And of course, that's not what we
want. But here, I can simply lift off the varnish. When I did my initial tests on this painting,
I expected it to be much dirtier than it actually was. I thought I would find a very thick layer of
soot on top of a very discolored yellow varnish. But ultimately, there really wasn't any surface
grime on it at all. And this may be because the painting was just subject to heat. If it was
much lower, and the smoke didn't get to the painting, it wouldn't be covered in smoke.
The painting also might have been wiped off before, and all of the smoke and soot removed.
But the old varnish remained, and removing it is critical. Now, we can see that it is yellowed, but
it's not horribly, horribly discolored. But even still, the areas where the varnish has been removed
are much clearer, not only in color, but in content. We can actually see the mountains.
Now, the paint layer itself is still a problem, and that will have to get solved. But at least
removing the varnish starts to give us, well, an idea of why Bierstadt was such a great painter.
We can start to see his actual work. Leaving the signature for last is a time-tested and
mother-approved way of going about conservation. It's also fairly smart, which is why we do it.
It allows us to gather as much information as possible about the paint layer and how it responds
to the solvents and our techniques before we go about removing the varnish from this very
important area. Removing a signature, and you've basically removed the provenance and the value
of a painting. Now, sometimes artists will thin out their paint to make it flow better on a very
small brush and enable them to sign their name more effectively. And the problem with this is
that when you thin out oil paint, the binder, the oil, is diluted. And that means that the paint
itself just isn't as durable. It's more fugitive. So we have to go a little bit more slowly,
a little bit more carefully, and just be cautious of what we find. But if we do it right,
we can clean off the signature without doing any damage. And in this case, you can see that making
multiple passes with the poultice and the cotton ball has removed all of that old varnish, and
guess what? None of the signature. With the painting clean, I can start to think about the surface and
how I'm going to try to remedy all of these pockmarks and blisters. And it comes down to one
word. Heat. If heat caused them, maybe heat can un-cause them. Well, not really. You can't
un-cause damage to a painting. You can't make it as if it never happened. If paint cracks,
you cannot un-crack it. If canvas is torn, you cannot un-tear it. You may be able to repair it
and retouch it or conserve it such that it doesn't appear to have been damaged,
but once damaged, always damaged. And so here, I'm applying a little bit of heat with my hot air pen
in an attempt to soften up this thin paint layer. And then I'm using a silicone spatula to press it
down. And my theory was that if heat was able to soften this paint and cause it to blister,
then maybe heat would be able to soften the paint enough that I could press it back down
and secure it back to the painting. And lo and behold, it works. But it is slow.
I thought about trying to do this in one fell swoop on the hot table,
but ultimately, I decided against it. This painting is too delicate and there's nothing
to be gained by rushing or risking a mistake that would otherwise damage the painting further.
And with one little section done, my gosh, look at the difference. That little strip on the edge
compared to the rest of the painting. This section I'm working on compared to the left
and below, well, I think it's clear that this is the solution. Now it takes a lot of time,
and you can see that I'm going very slowly. I'm modulating the heat by the temperature control
on the device and by how close I hold the hot air pen to the paint surface. But it's working.
Now, the obvious response is that I'm also deforming or changing the paint surface.
And the answer is yes, I am. But remember, this painting was written off as a complete
loss by an auction house, an appraiser, and the insurance company. In fact, the client didn't
even believe that there was any point in trying to conserve this. But when bringing in some other
paintings, they thought, we have to go see Baumgartner. We may as well bring this thing
anyways. So the measure of success here is not whether the painting appears as if there was no
damage. That's not going to be possible. There is no way to unblister this paint and to make it
as if it had never been altered by heat. But what I am able to do is remove the impediment
to enjoying the image, and secure this paint back down so that it's stable. Yes, some of the
nuance of the brushwork is lost when I heat it up and I press it down. But what is the alternative,
I ask? We leave it, and we leave it vulnerable to flaking at the mere handling, and that would
result in permanent loss of the paint. And that's no better. We leave it, and the image can't be
viewed through all of these pockmarks and blisters? Well, that's no better either, because the whole
function of this painting is to be viewed. So the measure is not whether what I'm doing now
is changing the painting, but whether it's changing it from an already altered state
to a better state. And I think the answer here is pretty clearly yes. Well, in fact, I know it's yes,
because I've seen the end result. This process took days. In fact, it was executed over almost
three weeks, working a little bit at a time each day. It was just too high stress to focus on for
a long period of time. But once it was all done, well, the paint layer was smooth. And now I could
start focusing on filling in those losses, a fairly rote procedure for painting conservation.
Remember, there were areas where the blisters burst, either during the fire or during handling,
and those are little divots. And if I don't fill them in, they're going to be just as problematic
when one views the painting as the blisters were. So using a little chalk-based fill,
I can overfill and then come back and remove it later. I want to make sure that I get as many of
these as possible, because this painting, by and large, is smooth. Not just because of the work
that I've done, but because Bierstadt painted really smoothly. I've conserved, oh, about a dozen
paintings, from small studies to grand, grand masterpieces. And he was very deliberate in his
use of impasto, the physical buildup of paint. Trees, foliage, rocks, thick clouds, all were
built up texturally. But areas of sky were often very, very smooth. Areas that he wanted to recede
into the background were very smooth. And so all of these areas where there are pockmarks,
they are smooth. And we need to make sure that they're smooth after varnishing.
So after filling in all of the little holes, I can let the fill in dry and come back and start
to remove it. You'll notice that there is quite a haze left over. And I can keep going back with
swabs, or I can come back with a little shop towel and slowly lift it off. There is only the slightest
bit of moisture on this shop towel, and I'm just gliding over the surface and picking up that
residue. It's very responsive, and this is a method that works really well and allows me to get a lot
of it off without having to spend as much time as if I were to use little swabs. At this point,
I've decided to put on a base varnish, and I've mixed up a different resin than I normally use.
And this one is highly plastic, meaning it's very, very flexible. And I've decided to do this
because if in the future somebody decides to remove this painting from the Masonite,
and I'll talk about that decision in a minute, they can leave this on the surface as a temporary,
transparent layer of washi kozo, if you will. Because it's flexible and plastic, it won't crack
or break apart or even change all that much when the painting is removed from this Masonite.
But it is reversible. So after the painting is removed, well, this could be removed too,
or not. It just depends what the next conservator wants to do. And that's one thing that I try to
keep in mind, that while I may be working on this painting now, I don't believe that I will be
working on it in 50 years. And so it's my responsibility to not only correct the mistakes
of the past and do everything I can to preserve and restore the painting, but to make the next
conservator's life a little bit easier. I'd like if when they flip this painting over and they see
my label, they chuckle and say, thanks Baumgartner, I really appreciate it. You didn't plant a land
mine that caused me to have a bad day. Now just like I do with other varnishes, I'm brushing this
out a little bit, because I want it to be thin and even. There is nothing worse than getting a
gloopy, gloppy, thick, gooey layer of varnish. It serves no purpose and it's a pain to deal with.
And now on to retouching. And I'm actually really excited and also kind of apprehensive about this
one. And it has nothing to do with it being a Bierstadt. I've restored many of them, as I
mentioned. And at this point in my career, the artist, the value, the client, none of those
things really faze me. What does get me shaking in my boots is the painting itself, and how the
mixed and painted it. In this case, Bierstadt painted wet on wet, meaning that this sky
was blended on the canvas. Multiple colors were laid down and feathered, blended into each other,
which makes for a beautiful effect. The sky transitions from this bright blue to an orange
and some yellows, and it's really gorgeous. It is also really difficult to color match.
On top of that, these colors change as they dry. They get a little bit darker.
So when I'm applying this paint, I'm fully expecting that I'm going to have to come back
and change the colors a little bit. Trying to mix a color knowing that it is going to be 10%
darker when it dries, and then maybe only 5% darker after the varnish is applied and all of
the other colors get saturated and more dense is very, very confusing. And I have been doing this
for over two decades, and still my brain sometimes spazzes out, and I have to take a break because I
just forget how to mix colors. In those instances, there's plenty of scraping waiting for me.
Now, I also mentioned earlier on that I decided to leave this painting on the hardboard.
And I decided to do that with a heavy heart. I hate this hardboard. It is a product of sawdust
and glue. The mixtures are secret. The companies don't allow us to know what's in them. They're
full of acid, wood pulp, all sorts of unknown materials. And they shouldn't be anywhere near
a painting. So I want to get it off of this painting. But the adhesive used is a rabbit
skin glue adhesive. I tested that and confirmed it, which generally would be great, except for
the fact that it's soluble only with exposure to water. And when canvas is exposed to water,
it swells. When it swells, it puts tension on the paint layer. When it dries, it shrinks.
And when it shrinks, it puts more tension on the paint layer. And all of that tension on
the paint layer is something that I really want to avoid. Even though I was able to stabilize all
of this paint, I just don't know that the paint can handle it. And it's a risk that I'm not really
sure I want to take. In addition, the client didn't really want to take that risk either.
Keep in mind, this painting was written off as a complete loss by everybody that saw it.
And the client didn't even know if it was worth attempting to conserve.
I used my powers of persuasion to convince them to let me have a go at it. And luckily,
they listened. But they don't know that this painting is going to work out in the end.
They're hoping. They're wishing. They're praying. But they're not 100% certain.
And removing this hardboard from this painting, well, it could easily double or triple the cost
of conservation. And that is a big ask for a painting that may or may not be salvageable.
So I get it. It's heartbreaking for sure, but I think it's the prudent choice. And I'm pretty
sure my client agrees. Now, if it turns out that this painting is incredibly valuable or
highly desired, well, then we can revisit removing that hardboard. We can come up with
a solution that will work. We can investigate what we can do. And I've removed hardboard
from paintings. There are a number of ways. We can take precautions. But I think that from where
the painting came to where it will end up, spoiler alert, I've seen the completed painting,
there is no doubt that the transformation was a positive one. And yes, there is a little bit more
that can be done. But I'm okay leaving that on the table. Maybe for the next conservator,
maybe for myself. I don't think that I would be able to live with myself if I pushed the client
to do this just because I wanted to and the painting was damaged further. With all of my
retouching complete, I can now proceed with the final varnish. And this layer is going to protect
the painting from UV light and also allow me to adjust the sheen to something that I like.
I'm using a smaller brush because the painting is, well, smaller. And I'm removing a lot of
the varnish from this brush. Now, keep in mind, this brush is still saturated. There is plenty
of varnish to cover this painting. But it is always better to use less varnish than more.
I can always come back and add more varnish as I'm doing this if I feel that it's too thin or
there's a dry spot. But pulling it up, well, that's a real pain. So just as normal, I'm going
front to back, left to right, up, down, trying to distribute this varnish evenly. And then,
as the solvent starts evaporating, I'm going to start brushing the varnish out to create a really
beautiful velvety texture. Now, I noticed that some spots were a little bit shinier than others.
They were smoother, and so they reflected the light a little bit more. So I've taken my badger
hairbrush, and I'm just going over the surface, lightly tapping, to create another microtexture,
diffusing the light a little bit. And this is a way that I can make sure that this varnish layer
is even and that there are no distractions when we look at it. And with all my work complete,
here is the painting. Quite a stunning view, if I do say so myself.
The old varnish was removed, yes, that gave us all of these beautiful colors. But more importantly,
the paint layer was stabilized. And while I mentioned that you can't undo damage,
we can certainly try. And here, the delicate and precise application of the force that
caused the damage was able to remove it. And yes, the painting has been irrevocably changed,
by fire, by me. But I think it's a change for the better. Because before,
we couldn't see the image. All we could see was the surface, the blisters, the bubbles.
We were focused on the damage. And now, with a smooth paint layer, we can focus on the image.
And in fact, some of the impasto in the trees, the rocks, and the clouds remains. It was not damaged.
So there is a delicacy of brushwork that comes through now, that was invisible before.
And to all of those who wrote off this painting as a complete loss,
well, I would encourage them to revisit that assessment.
Because this painting isn't just surviving anymore, it's thriving.
Thanks for watching, and if you had any questions about this or any of my other projects,
join me over on Patreon, where in addition to ad and sponsor free videos,
I take questions and answer them in a follow-up epilogue video, exclusive only to Patreon.