The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
UK Constitutional Law refers to the body of law and principles that govern the structure, functioning, and organization of the United Kingdom's political system and government. Unlike some countries with written constitutions, the UK's constitution is not found in a single written document but rather is a combination of various sources, including statutes, conventions, common law, and historical documents.
A. Bradley, K. Ewing & C.J.S. Knight, Constitutional & Administrative Law (18th edn, Pearson, 2022). R. Masterman & C. Murray, Constitutional & Administrative Law (Cambridge University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In the previous lesson what we did was introduce the concept of parliamentary sovereignty.
This lesson I want to essentially talk about the history of this principle
and explain how it develops out of the period of the Stuart dynasty within Britain,
and then talk about how modern conceptualizations of the principle exist to this day.
So, like I said, the previous lesson introduced the subject of parliamentary sovereignty,
we outlined its meaning, and then also we outlined a number of the implications that
exist therein. So, for example, the concept of parliamentary sovereignty being both a positive
and negative set of obligations on the part of the fact that parliament from a positive sense
can make and unmake any law they so choose, but they also have this fact that we have a negative
element of sovereignty which suggests that other institutions and organizations have to always
regard parliamentary legislation and they can never disregard and ever set it aside.
This lesson, like I've said, is going to explore the historical development of this principle
and examine how it applies to this day. Now, beginning first then with the early history of
the principle, in the earliest of history of England we see that the concept of parliamentary
sovereignty, or at least the concept of sovereignty where power lies, was something which was exercised
by the sovereign him or herself, this being the authority of the royal council, and that this is
really where we see the authority of lawmaking beginning in the history of England. The council,
the royal council, or the cura regis, would develop into the creation of the first parliaments,
and that these first parliaments would lead to the establishment of a formal legislature
throughout time. The understanding of how parliament is structured today, in fact,
comes out of what is known as the model parliament in 1295 under Edward I. This was where we see
firstly the division of parliament into two branches, so you have the idea of bicameralism
actually beginning in 1295 under Edward I. You have bishops, abbots, and barons forming the
house of lords, and then you have two knights from each shire forming the house of commons.
This is the model parliament of 1295. In 1539, parliament passes the statute of proclamations,
so we see a significant period of time where we see parliaments essentially being
subordinate to that of the crown, being called by the crown to pass legislation, often for all
financial purposes. 1539 is a year where the monarch in England was Henry VIII. Henry VIII
would rule England from 1509 to 1547, and in 1539 parliament passes the statute of proclamations.
This gave the king at the time, as I mentioned, Henry VIII, the broad powers and the broader
authority to essentially legislate without reference or consent from parliament.
One of the historical traditions that existed with monarchies even before Henry VIII
was this idea that you would call parliament to legislate, and you would require the consent
of parliament to legislate. In fact, this was one of the most significant influences
that Henry VII attributed to his consolidation of authority and royal authority.
His claim to the throne was very, very weak in comparison,
and so to end the Wars of the Roses in 1485, what Henry VII did was call parliament to ensure
his royal authority. And so ultimately this is a tradition that becomes a little bit skewered
with his son Henry VIII, because in 1539 we see the passage of the statute of proclamations,
differing, like I said, from his father Henry VII, who believed and regarded the requirement
that parliament be required for the passage of legislation. In 1610 then, when we see a transfer
in dynasties away from the Stuart period, with the death of Elizabeth I in 1603, and we see James
I becoming the first Stuart monarch, we see the case of Dr Bonham's, the Dr Bonham's case.
In this case, the Lord Justice Coke would ultimately establish the rule which seemed
to contradict any idea of parliamentary sovereignty. So remember, this is before
parliamentary sovereignty becomes an established and enshrined principle, because in this case,
what Coke essentially does is suggest that the common law is sovereign, and it is parliament
that is subordinate to the common law. Coke noted that the common law may be able to control the
power of parliament, and even declare provisions were void if they were against common right and
reason, or repugnant, or impossible to be performed. What this is doing is essentially enshrining the
idea that it is the rule of law which is the authoritative principle of the UK
constitution, or at least the British constitution, and that this idea of parliamentary sovereignty
is subordinate to the rule of law, owing to the fact that the rule of law essentially allows for
parliamentary decisions or parliamentary legislation to be set aside
if it is repugnant or impossible to be performed. The ultimate conclusion that we see here is that
the English Civil War changes all of these processes quite significantly. This is one of the
most fundamental power struggles that existed, and really it was a question of where we
see power lie. The supporters of Charles I, the royalists, argued that
sovereignty laid in the hands of the king, and that sovereignty was delegated by the king,
with the expressed permission of the king, to parliament. The parliamentarians, the people who
supported parliament, as you can probably imagine, believed that sovereignty lied with parliament,
acting on behalf of the people. Ultimately this is what the English Civil War was about, about the
fact that Charles I would continually try to raise taxation, and try to raise finances from
parliament, and that then would ultimately cause a lot of division and disputes between the two
sides, between the royalists and the parliamentarians. Again, the main issue was where the power of
taxation lied. Charles I would often exert his right to issue new taxes, and would do so without
the consent of parliament, shall I say, even though the remit of parliament, and the
fact that taxation was a provision and a competence made by parliament, was something that had been
established all the way back in the 1200s with the reign of Edward I. Without divulging into
too much detail about the English Civil War, the regicide of Charles I, and the back and forth and
the restoration of the monarchy, we see that we get the restoration of the monarchy, but then we
get a new monarch who is invited in, because James II, who is ultimately
replaced by William of Orange, we see this with the 1688 Glorious Revolution.
So when the reign of James II, who was a Roman Catholic, would come to
clash with that of parliament, we see that parliament decides, very prominent politicians
would actually sign a letter inviting the son-in-law of James II, who was William of Orange,
who was a Protestant, to come and take the throne. And so William of Orange would do so, and
was met with very little resistance, and a convention parliament was called in regard to
this particular invitation. Ultimately, his invitation to reign came with a number of conditions,
one of which was an acceptance of the 1689 Bill of Rights, and the significance of this was the
fact that essentially what it asserted was that the rights of parliament
over the monarch and his wife Mary II, and ultimately we see in 1689 the Earl of
Shaftesbury state that the Parliament of England is the supreme and absolute power, which gives
life and motion to the English government, and this essentially is enshrining in 1689, the year of
the Bill of Rights, the year after the Glorious Revolution, a fundamental shift in where parliament
lies in the broader structure of authority. Parliament lies at the top, parliament is
sovereign as a result of these events that take place. So this is really where the history of
parliamentary sovereignty ultimately begins to take shape, and becomes the most prominent
principle of the UK constitution. In the next lesson we'll sort of do a little jump to the
more modern conceptions of parliamentary sovereignty, and talk about some of the
principles of parliamentary sovereignty.