The Barbarian General E11 - Rome: Rise And Fall Of An Empire

The Roman Legacy - The Strength of Rome Endures.
17 followers
27 Video Views·Apr 11, 2026
Inheriting an empire ravaged by barbarians and torn apart by rival emperors, one man
rises victorious. His name is Constantine. Fighting under the banner of a new god,
he brings unity to a divided Roman Empire. As its armies are defeated and emperors slain by
barbarians, Rome is on the brink of disaster. In this chaos, two mighty leaders emerge.
One from within the empire, the other from the ranks of its enemy.
Their struggle will reveal an empire at war with itself.
On the edges of the empire, Roman soldiers march off to defend the frontier villages from attack.
A young boy named Stilicho proudly watches his father among them.
Stilicho was the child of a mixed marriage as it were. He had a Vandal father but a Roman
mother and this meant that he grew up in a sort of context that was half barbarian and half Roman.
This was not atypical of people in this period and above all of people who were associated with
the army. Stilicho dreams of becoming a soldier like his barbarian father,
fighting to protect the great empire. By this time a sizable percentage of the officer corps was of
what you might call barbarian ancestry. These are men who were recruited,
worked their way up the ranks. The next generation they become the generals.
As ever fiercer tribes invade the empire, Rome's dependence on barbarian mercenaries grows by the
Under pressure to protect its expansive frontiers, the empire divides in two. The
west is defended by Emperor Valentinian in Rome while Emperor Valens defends the east in Constantinople.
But Valens is challenged in 378 AD when a savage enemy attacks the city of Adrianople.
They are the Goths and what they want is Roman land. They intend to destroy the Roman forces
with muscle, steel and fire. Knowing the heavily armored Romans will quickly feel the heat as the
battlefield burns. The Goths were far more numerous and they had a lot to fight for.
They'd been badly treated by the Romans, they'd been sold into slavery, they really had nothing to lose.
During the Battle of Adrianople, Emperor Valens' soldiers are no match for the savage and
relentless barbarian warriors. They attack and everybody is pushed to the right. The Romans always
edge to the right anyway because you want to keep that right shoulder under the shield of the guy
next to you. Now this is accelerated, everybody compacts around the emperor because he's on the
far right, the point of honor, and his men won't move. So we have this acceleration, this compactor
process. The Goths come out of this circular deployment and surround the Romans and cut them
down. The Emperor Valens himself falls on the battlefield, forced to fight for his life.
It is a fight he quickly loses, sending his shocked soldiers into panicked retreat.
When an ancient army breaks, mass slaughter always ensues. What made Adrianople even worse
was that the Roman army was partly surrounded and not everybody could run, so that in their haste
to get away, the Roman soldiers ended up killing one another, trampling on one another, and
suffocating to death simply in the vast confusion. Two-thirds of the Roman army is lost. The late
Roman historian Hermianus Marcellinus describes the carnage. Arrows whirling death from every side,
always found their mark with fatal effect, since they could not be seen beforehand or guarded
against. The battle of Adrianople is a turning point in Roman history. It's a turning point
from which the empire cannot return. The army is largely gone and there's no way of getting it back
except to use the barbarians themselves. The new Eastern Emperor Theodosius does just that.
He invites the Goths to a banquet, offering them land in exchange for military service.
At his side is Stilicho, now a Roman general in his early 20s. Stilicho was half a barbarian,
as it were. He was half Vandal, half Roman, and as is typical for so many of these kinds of guys,
he worked his way up through the army. Emperor Theodosius relies on Stilicho to
handle negotiations with the Goths, whom he plans to use as mercenaries.
The conditions that the Goths achieve from Theodosius are highly unusual because it puts
them in a stronger position than they might have expected. The most important thing is that
they're not broken up. The Goths who have been fighting Theodosius are all settled in one place,
and they're settled in one place without being put under Roman control.
Stilicho brokers the deal. In exchange for this land, the entire Gothic force agrees to fight his
soldiers in Theodosius' army. Though Stilicho is himself a half-barbarian, Theodosius trusts him
like a son and has no doubts. Stilicho was very good at what he did. He distinguished himself. He
came to the attention of the Emperor, and so as he worked his way through, he got higher and higher,
and was in command of a large contingent of Theodosius' army. But Stilicho's position does
not make him next in line to rule. That honor falls on the Emperor's biological sons, Arcadius
and Honorius, who is born in Constantinople in 384 AD. Yet Stilicho enjoys a royal connection as well.
Stilicho was actually closely related to the Emperor Theodosius. He had clearly been selected
from among the many barbarian or semi-barbarian generals as a future leader, so much so that the
Emperor Theodosius had married Stilicho to his own niece, and this marriage was a strong point
in cementing Stilicho's relationship with the imperial house throughout the course of his life.
Though chosen by the Emperor to lead, Stilicho's power will always be limited.
As a barbarian or a half-barbarian, there was no way he was going to be Emperor, but that was it.
Nonetheless, Emperor Theodosius knows he can rely on his most trusted general to help manage the
empire's biggest problem, the Goths. To solidify Emperor Theodosius' new treaty,
Gothic boys are sent to training camps to be instructed in Roman military ways.
What is clear is that they weren't fully Roman subjects, but that they were obliged to
serve the Roman army when the Roman Emperor called on them to do so.
As Theodosius' right-hand man, Stilicho ensures the young Goths are well-trained and loyal.
There is one whose natural talent catches Stilicho's attention, the boy Alaric.
Alaric had probably been born inside the empire, and he'd probably been raised inside the empire
with full awareness of what a Roman military career was like.
Taking Alaric under his wing, Stilicho cannot begin to imagine how their fates will be intertwined.
Over the next decade, the Eastern Empire grows stronger under the combined rule of Stilicho
and Emperor Theodosius. But their authority is jeopardized when a betrayal in Wien Gaul
rocks the Western Empire in 392 AD. While sleeping in his palace, the Western Emperor
Valentinian II is murdered by his barbarian guardian, Arbogast, who then disguises the
death as a suicide. The Emperor was the symbol of Rome's empire itself, and so the death of
around whom the state was structured, symbolically structured, is a tremendous psychological blow.
Worse still, the Western Empire and its army fall under the control of the ambitious barbarian
Arbogast. The usurper is now a threat to the Eastern Empire as well. Without delay,
the Eastern Emperor Theodosius leads his army westward to confront the usurper.
He calls upon his trusted general Stilicho to prepare the troops for battle.
Stilicho was the master of the soldiers in Thrace and was in command of a large contingent
of Theodosius's army at the time. Stilicho recruits the young Alaric, now a full-grown
Gothic chieftain, and his tribesmen to fight alongside the Romans. By now, about a quarter
of the Roman army is made up of barbarian mercenaries. The Romans had become extremely
reliant on non-Roman manpower with non-Roman leadership in a way that could potentially
become very dangerous for the empire. Emperor Theodosius recognizes this danger, but he has
devised a plan to destroy the usurper Arbogast and weaken the Goths in one powerful blow.
In 394 AD, Theodosius leads his eastern army, including Alaric's Gothic troops,
against the forces of the Western Roman Empire, now led by the power-hungry traitor Arbogast.
The battle takes place in 394 AD at the River Frigidus in modern-day Slovenia.
Confronted with Arbogast's army, Emperor Theodosius orders Alaric and his Goths into battle
first, preserving his Roman troops. He almost certainly deliberately put them on the front
lines for the very first engagement, knowing that that was the most dangerous position for them.
He probably hoped that as many of them would die as possible and yet still achieve victory.
The Goths fight for their lives, but Arbogast's forces, hungry for blood and booty, cut them down.
Just as defeat seems imminent, a fluke of the weather changes everything.
It just so happened that the way that the troops were lined up, the winds were blowing
very much against the forces of Arbogast and for the forces of Theodosius,
so that the projectiles that were shot and thrown on the part of Arbogast's army
failed to reach or have any effect on Theodosius's army.
With this advantage, Emperor Theodosius defeats Arbogast soundly, but in the process,
he has made a dangerous new enemy. As Alaric searches the bodies of the fallen Goths for
survivors, Theodosius's betrayal cuts deep. When the Goths were put on the front lines and used as
cannon fodder or missile fodder for the troops of Arbogast, Alaric must have been furious.
Never again will Alaric allow his people to be mere casualties of Roman glory.
While Theodosius celebrates his victory at the Frigidus and becomes the sole emperor of Rome,
Alaric and the Goths take their vengeance, ravaging the Balkans for food and booty.
There, Roman farmers, unarmed and vulnerable, are completely unprepared for the wrath of the Goths.
Their harvest is exactly what Alaric needs.
Alaric has nothing now to draw upon to support his people. He does not have access to local taxes,
he does not have access to granaries, that means he can't feed his people.
Alaric is now determined to feed his people with Roman grain,
and the local Roman garrison can do little to stop him.
Emboldened by their success, the Goths now declare Alaric their king.
With Alaric, they become the first barbarian people to create a kingdom inside the empire.
Alaric is very important because what he does is really forge the Goths as a single
political unit and really create from a band of soldiers a people.
Alaric's Gothic kingdom is unchallenged for now, as the empire faces other more critical upheavals.
In 395 AD, when Emperor Theodosius falls ill and dies, the empire is divided once again.
His teenage son Arcadius is made Emperor of the East in Constantinople,
and his ten-year-old son Honorius becomes Emperor of the West in Rome.
Theodosius' loyal general Stilicho is not forgotten.
He becomes the boy emperor Honorius' protector and teacher.
After Theodosius fell ill, it was Stilicho that he turned to. For whatever reason, he says
to Stilicho, according to one version or the other, that he wants him to be the regent of Honorius.
Inexperienced in the tools of war, young Honorius relies on Stilicho for his expertise and guidance.
Stilicho had a sort of patronizing relationship,
a sort of godfather relationship with this child.
I think Stilicho always saw Honorius as his little kid.
But Honorius is an indifferent student.
Stilicho keeps a keen eye on him.
He knows that the future of the empire depends on his control of the boy.
In 397 AD, Stilicho secures his hold on Honorius by marrying the young emperor to his daughter.
What he was really interested in is having his grandson be emperor,
because he married his first daughter Maria to Honorius.
So clearly he wanted Honorius' son and his grandson to be emperor.
So that would be the only possible way
that he could have direct familial influence over the next emperor.
The wedding guests are scandalized at the joining of the royal bloodlines with a barbarian.
But Stilicho is oblivious to their anger,
seeing himself as Roman to the core.
But Stilicho's power in Rome does not extend to the other young emperor,
Arcadius in Constantinople.
There, the 19-year-old Arcadius enjoys the amusements of the imperial bedchamber,
leaving important matters of state to his advisors.
Well, the fact that Theodosius, had he been alive to see his sons
try to operate without his presence, would have been greatly disappointed.
Of that there can be no doubt.
Shockingly, Arcadius grants the honor of consulship to his chief of staff,
the eunuch Eutropius.
A eunuch as a consul is like having a porn star elected as president of the United States.
This is just so far beyond the pale that people just can't believe it.
A eunuch as consul is monstrous.
But what makes him truly hated in Constantinople
are Eutropius's plans to negotiate with the barbarian Goths.
For three long years, Alaric and the Goths have raided the Balkans,
pressuring Emperor Arcadius in Constantinople to give him the land that his people so badly need.
Finally, in 397 AD,
Emperor Arcadius invites Alaric to Constantinople at the urging of Eutropius.
Indifferent to politics, the emperor leads the negotiations to the eunuch.
Eutropius executed an agreement between the eastern court and Alaric.
And Alaric, this gothic leader, certainly saw in that a tremendous advantage,
particularly the advantage of being able to gain supplies
and potentially land from the eastern court.
In return, Alaric promises the Goths will once again fight for the eastern empire.
But this deal leaves the people outraged.
The Goths had regularly confronted the Romans in battle
and actually defeated the Romans in battle.
The Romans, therefore, had a huge amount of
not so carefully disguised distaste for the Goths.
Poisoned with hatred for their one-time enemies,
the angry people will not be satisfied until the streets of Constantinople flow with gothic blood.
In 397 AD, the eastern emperor Arcadius, at the urging of his closest advisor,
the eunuch Eutropius, makes a treaty with Alaric the Goth.
But anti-barbarian prejudice spreads like poison throughout the city.
After two years of public outcry, Eutropius is finally arrested,
swept away in the growing race hatred.
His rivals claim his disgrace will quickly appease the angry mob.
The problem that arose, of course, was that his power made him unpopular
and he had a great many rivals for control of the imperial court.
And one of the things they exploited was his willingness to negotiate
with barbarians and with the Goths.
Eutropius is sent into exile and later executed.
But his sacrifice does not quell the anti-barbarian fervor of the people
who rise up and massacre every last Goth in the city.
It's very difficult in any period to put your finger on the roots of ethnic tension.
It's clear enough that the Romans resented barbarians who were invading their territory,
but Roman feelings against barbarians went much deeper than that.
There was a sort of visceral dislike of anything that smacked of the barbarism.
Such violence against his people sends an undeniable message to Alaric
that a treaty with the East is impossible.
The hatred is too deep.
A desperate Alaric takes his people west to Italy,
hoping to gain a favorable treaty from General Stilicho instead.
But soon a terrible new force threatens both the Goths and Rome, the Huns.
Sweeping into the tribal villages at the margins of the empire,
the Huns attack and destroy everything before them.
Well, the Huns were moving west.
They were looking for greener pastures, as it were,
and they're forcing the various Germanic tribes, the nomadic tribes,
the settled tribes to move out of their way.
The Huns are nasty, they're ruthless, and no one wants to be near them.
But to all intents and purposes,
they're forcing the others ahead of them like a bow wave in front of a boat,
and people are trying to get out of the way.
Those who do not flee the savage horsemen are cut down with brutal precision,
for the Huns leave no survivors.
The Hunnic invasion forces other barbarian tribes deeper into Roman territory,
and while Emperor Honorius moves the seat of the Western Empire
to the better protected city of Ravenna,
the defenseless villages of northern Italy fall prey to the barbarians' devastation.
The dwindling Roman forces are overwhelmed.
In the Italian field hospitals,
General Stilicho watches the numbers of fallen soldiers grow daily,
depleting an already sparse army.
And I think that's one of the main problems that Stilicho faces.
He just doesn't have a proper standing army,
and it then becomes the major problem of the West.
Throughout the 5th century, there isn't a standing army.
Something happens, you've got to run around, pay guys,
gather sort of whatever mercenaries and whatnot you can,
and get off to the battlefield as quickly as you can.
With each soldier he loses, Stilicho grows more desperate.
In order to defend Italy, he needed more troops.
And in order to take back the rest of the empire, he needed more troops.
And he needed them because much of the Western Empire wasn't under his control.
Being half-barbarian himself, Stilicho feels his support in the army is waning.
Now he has no choice but to turn to the one person who can help him secure more troops.
The Gothic king, Alaric.
In 406 AD, Stilicho travels to Alaric's camp in Illyricum,
modern-day Serbia, offering a deal.
Alaric, eager for a treaty with Rome, welcomes Stilicho to his camp.
Stilicho brings his old friend Alaric a gift to warm the Goth to his request.
Stilicho desperately needed troops.
There simply weren't enough Roman troops in Italy to go around.
And the only reservoir of manpower was Alaric and his Goths.
Stilicho also offers Alaric the position he's always wanted.
In 404, he wants Alaric to be given a Roman command,
and he's given a Roman command so that Stilicho can then use him as an army
to capture Illyricum so that he can then use that as a launching pad.
Stilicho desperately needs Illyricum,
a recruiting ground for soldiers that now belongs to the Eastern Empire.
Alaric agrees to help him take it for the West,
offering Stilicho a Gothic sword as a symbol of their treaty.
From Alaric's point of view, this was a very good thing.
He needed some way to keep his followers occupied so that they didn't simply drift away.
He needed some way to keep them fed so that they didn't mutiny or depose him.
Stilicho promises Alaric that his Goths will be well paid
by the grateful Western Emperor Honorius.
The two men embrace as allies once more.
But years go by, and Honorius' court is unwilling to make good on Stilicho's promise to Alaric.
Stilicho finds he has lost influence over the young emperor.
By now, Honorius is a full adult, doesn't need a guardian anymore.
Stilicho's position versus Honorius' court, the inner circle, that is a very difficult one.
Because as Honorius grew into adulthood,
his court distances him, Honorius, from Stilicho's influence.
Feeding the emperor anti-barbarian propaganda,
these advisors have delayed Stilicho's plan to work with the Goths for years.
The Goths now demand to be paid for their services promised.
Stilicho needs to come to the Roman Senate and he needs to ask that the senators themselves
produce 4,000 pounds of gold in order to pay off the Goths for this.
He has to do so in many ways over the protests of Honorius,
so it's very clear that the two of them are beginning to part ways at this point.
But Stilicho warns Honorius that if Alaric is not paid,
the Goths will revolt, an event the emperor may not survive.
Honorius at first agrees to this, but then his personnel official, who's named Olympius,
believes that Stilicho is trying to do this so that Stilicho himself
can set up his son, Eucarius, on the eastern throne.
Scared and confused, Honorius believes Olympius' claims.
Making a decision that will spell disaster for both Stilicho and the Western Empire.
Facing barbarian invasions on the frontier, the Roman general Stilicho
appeals to Alaric, king of the Goths, for troops.
But Emperor Honorius' advisor, the anti-barbarian Olympius, turns the emperor against Stilicho.
Olympius and his like-minded officers incite the army to revolt against the
half-barbarian general Stilicho.
And so Olympius then starts sowing all sorts of rumors amongst the troops as well.
The troops riot in August and they call for the death of Stilicho.
Swayed by Olympius' slander, Emperor Honorius responds by issuing a decree against Stilicho.
Honorius had many courtiers willing to play upon his fears to suggest to him that Stilicho
was seeking the throne for himself or for his son.
And the emperor's mind was really poisoned against Stilicho.
Stilicho is himself declared a public enemy.
And many of his supporters are massacred in cities throughout Italy.
Ethnic hatred explodes among the populace.
5th century chronicler Orosius.
Stilicho has sprung from the barbarian vandals, that cowardly, greedy, treacherous and crafty
The racially motivated violence is brutal and the victims are quickly overwhelmed.
Determined to cleanse the empire of all barbarians,
the Romans now hunt for the general himself.
The angry mob of Roman soldiers, eager for blood,
find Stilicho in a church in Ravenna where he has taken refuge.
Stilicho flees to a church and tries to escape the decree knowing full well it will mean his
death but he's given strong assurances that he's only to be arrested and not to be executed.
Despite his misgivings, Stilicho decides to give himself up willingly.
He was in a position to seize the state for himself had he wanted to.
But he remained a loyal servant of the ruling family his whole life.
Even at the end when he was betrayed by the master he had served his whole life,
he refused to rise up and resist and it certainly spared Italy a civil war.
Outside the church among the angry mob, Stilicho finds Olympias waiting for him.
Instantly a second decree arrives ordering Stilicho's death.
His attendants and bodyguards threaten that they will attack those who have been sent
to arrest Stilicho but Stilicho, in very noble fashion,
agrees to allow himself to be killed so as not to stir up further trouble.
Stilicho is stripped of the symbols that mark him as a Roman general.
Stilicho himself is something of a tragic figure.
He could quite easily have rebelled when he faced this hostility from his emperor
but instead he surrendered, left the church where he had taken sanctuary
and went quietly to execution.
Great Barbarian General is felled as those he sought to protect cheer on.
His death excites the crowd who are no longer satisfied by symbolic gestures.
Their hatred of the Goths soon spreads beyond Ravenna to cities throughout Italy.
Roman troops attacked any Gothic families immediately killing as many as 10,000
of them as a response to this anti-barbarian sentiment
that had arisen at the end of Stilicho's administration.
Sixth century historian Zosimus describes the massacre that occurs
in the Italian cities in 408 AD.
The soldiers fell upon the barbarian women and children in each city
and as if at a predetermined signal destroyed them and plundered their property.
Naturally those Goths who remained alive and who escaped this massacre
were no longer willing to associate themselves with the Romans
and they had an easy and quick place to turn, Alaric's army.
30,000 Goths instantly switched allegiance and joined Alaric.
But with Stilicho's death their treaty with Rome
and the money and land it promised them vanish.
Alaric and his now powerful army move towards Rome
to pressure Emperor Honorius to give them what they want.
Alaric and his tribesmen invade Italy and lay siege to Rome in 410 AD
but Emperor Honorius, safe in Ravenna, refuses to negotiate with the Goths.
Honorius and his advisor Olympias care little for the people of Rome.
So what little by little happens is Alaric's trying to do anything
to get Honorius' government to sit across the table from him and talk shop.
I mean, what's going on here?
We're destroying Italy.
All I want is a command, some place to take that command
and the court won't talk to him.
But the Roman senators insist that Alaric's demands must be met or the city will fall.
They're negotiating a ransom in essence for their city
and what they agree to pay seems like a lot.
It's many thousands of pounds of gold.
Humoring the senators, Honorius agrees
sending Alaric word of a possible treaty.
Come to Ravenna and we'll come to terms.
But the anti-barbarian emperor has his own plans for the Goths.
In the chaos following General Stilicho's death
the Goths lay siege to Rome.
To save the city, Emperor Honorius agrees to make a deal with the barbarian's king, Alaric.
Alaric and his troops begin their journey from Rome to Ravenna
to meet Honorius for negotiations in good faith.
But along the way, Alaric is ambushed by a group of mercenaries working for the emperor.
The fact is that over and over again the Romans display
that they're only barely going to tolerate these barbarians
and that whenever possible they're going to massacre them
or put them in harm's way so that they'll be killed.
As his men are cut down around him,
Alaric knows he has been deceived by the Roman empire once again.
That's a good story of betrayal of a lack of honor on the part of the court of Honorius.
Alaric is a very honorable man who's dishonored by both courts.
And one could go on.
Alaric is done with peaceful negotiations.
He orders his men back to Rome, bent on destruction.
The Goths break through the gates of Rome in 410 AD
and at long last enter the ancient Roman capital.
For the first time in 800 years, the great city is sacked.
It's important to realize that Alaric didn't want to sack Rome.
He did not want his army to sack the city.
It was a decision made out of frustration at the fact that
really two years worth of negotiation had failed to get him anything that he wanted.
And in the end, he saw no other way forward but to allow his army to sack Rome.
Unlike the Romans, who so recently slaughtered thousands of Goth women and children,
Alaric orders his soldiers to show restraint.
Alaric clearly did his best to stop his troops from indiscriminately
killing people or seizing captives.
Nonetheless, for three days, the Goths plunder the riches of Rome, taking all they can carry.
The sack of Rome would have been devastating in terms of the amount of
treasure and money that was taken away from the city.
And we can be sure that however mild it was,
there were still a great many atrocities perpetrated.
There's no question of that.
But the deepest effect of the sack of Rome is psychological.
A former citizen of Rome, Saint Jerome, writes mournfully about the devastated city.
My voice sticks in my throat.
And as I dictate, sobs choke my speech.
The city which had conquered the whole world was itself conquered.
In response to this attack on the very heart of the empire, Emperor Honorius does nothing.
It becomes clear that Stilicho's death has robbed the empire of its last great leader.
Honorius is, in a sense, a captive court figurehead,
alone in his palace, surrounded by courtiers with
no real sense of what's going on in the world or anything else, for that matter.
When confronted by refugees from Rome come to beg for aid,
the emperor shows only annoyance, ordering this reminder of his failure to be removed.
So not only is he distancing himself from the realities of government,
he's progressively losing the credibility of the office.
Many Romans lose faith in the emperor's ability to defend its people
from their barbarian enemies.
Their fears will be justified.
As the Goths continue to savage the dwindling Roman army,
the emperor is powerless to stop them.
The Goths are here to stay.
The Gothic kingdom that grows out of Valeric's following is the first
real successor to Rome in the West.
It's the first part of Roman territory to fall away.
And it's the first of many.
Over the next 40 years, barbarian tribes will continue to pour across
the vulnerable borders of the empire, taking large regions of Roman land.
These losses and the fading of the empire were foreseen by General Stilicho,
who tried desperately to stop them, only to earn his own execution.
Stilicho's tragic downfall foreshadows the terrible and irreversible fate
of the empire itself.
