HSK 1–2 - 为什么学了很久还是不会说中文?- Why You Still Can’t Speak Chinese.

Zhongwen Zone
31 followers
Why have you been studying Chinese for so long but still can't communicate? In this video, we'll discuss the three biggest reasons why learners struggle with speaking—and how to address them. Learn simple, practical tips like talking to yourself, finding a language partner, and starting small. Don't aim for perfection—start speaking today!
#LearnChinese #PracticeSpeakingChinese #HSK1 #HSK2 #CommunicatinginChinese #SelfStudyChinese #ChineseLearningTips
Hello everyone, welcome to Daily Chinese. I'm your friend, Wang Yu.
Hello everyone, I'm Li Ming, nice to see you all again.
Wang Yu, today I'd like to ask you a question first.
Okay, what's the problem? Go ahead and tell me.
The thing is, I have many friends who are currently learning Chinese,
They often send me messages, writing Chinese characters very well.
They often listen to our podcast, and they say they can understand it.
Yes, that's great; it shows they are studying very hard.
Yes, but they have a big problem.
They don't speak Chinese, or perhaps they're afraid to speak Chinese.
They often ask me, Wang Yu, why I've studied for so long,
You know so many Chinese characters, yet you can't speak them?
Oh, I see. This is a very, very good question.
I imagine many of our podcast listeners right now,
There might be the same issue.
Yes, so today we'd like to talk to everyone about this topic,
Why, after studying for so long, can't you speak Chinese?
Alright, I hope today's chat can help everyone.
Li Ming, I think the first and biggest reason is,
It's just fear, fear of saying the wrong thing.
I agree; many people aren't unable to speak, but rather afraid to speak.
Yes, it's exactly that—what I'm afraid of.
I remember when I first started learning English,
I know many words; I can understand everything in books.
But when the teacher called on me to stand up and answer the question,
My goodness, my heart is beating very fast.
Are you afraid?
Yeah, there are so many thoughts in my mind,
But my mouth just won't listen; I can't say a single word.
I'm afraid my pronunciation is wrong, afraid my sentences are incorrect,
I'm afraid the classmates will laugh at me.
I fully understand; this feeling is what we call a psychological barrier.
I really want to say it in my heart, but it's as if a wall is blocking your mouth.
Yes, yes, yes, it's just a wall—your description is perfect.
Have you ever felt this way when learning a foreign language before?
Of course there is, I'm someone who tends to pursue perfection.
That's why when I first started learning,
I always want to say every single thing I utter perfectly correctly.
The grammar must be correct, the vocabulary must be appropriate, and the pronunciation must also be accurate.
So what's the result?
The result is that I overthink too much and say too little.
I have to think for five minutes in my mind before I say a single word.
By the time I've thought it through, others have already moved on to the next topic.
Me too, exactly the same. So how did you change later?
Later, one of my Chinese teachers said a sentence to me,
He said language is meant to be used for communication.
It's not for exams, you're wrong, but that's okay.
I can understand your meaning, and that's what matters most.
You're absolutely right; I can understand what you mean, and that's what matters most.
A friend of mine from the United States also told me the same thing.
At that time, I wanted to tell him in English that I had gone to see a movie yesterday.
I said yesterday I saw a movie.
Yes, this grammar is incorrect.
Yes, it's entirely Chinese grammar.
After I finished speaking, my face turned very red; I felt so embarrassed.
But my friend immediately said,
Oh, a movie? Which one was it? Was it good?
He fully understood what I meant.
He doesn't feel my grammar is strange at all.
Yes, what he cares about is what movie you watched.
Not whether your sentence is right or wrong.
Yes, ever since then I've begun to become brave.
I was wrong, and that's fine; what matters is that I spoke up.
I have expressed my meaning.
So, friends listening to our podcast right now,
I want to tell you, please don't be afraid; it's really okay to make mistakes.
Your Chinese friend, your Chinese teacher—they will surely understand you.
Yes, boldly open your mouth,
This is the first step to learning to speak Chinese, and also the most important one.
Wang Yu, besides fear,
I think there is another very important reason.
What is it?
It's just that many friends only take in and never give out.
Input? Output? What do these terms mean? They sound a bit like computer-related words.
Haha, let me explain it, it's very simple.
Input is the process of your learning.
For example, when you read a book, recognize Chinese characters, or listen to our podcast,
All this knowledge has entered your brain—this is input.
Oh, I see. Then I'm typing every day.
However, language learning requires not only input but also output.
Output is the process of using language.
For example, writing Chinese characters, or even more importantly, speaking Chinese.
I see. Many friends spend a lot of time every day reading books and attending classes—this is input.
But they never speak Chinese, so they have no output.
Exactly correct. Wang Yu, let me give you an analogy.
What do you think learning to speak Chinese is like?
Hmm, like learning to sing?
It's a bit like, I have a better analogy,
I think learning Chinese is like learning to swim.
Swimming lessons? That sounds interesting. Go ahead and tell me about it.
You know, if a person wants to learn swimming,
He bought many books about swimming and reads them at home every day.
The book told him how to move his hands and how to move his feet.
He also watches many videos online to see how world champions swim.
He has mastered all the theories.
Yes, he studies very diligently.
Then, I took him to the edge of a swimming pool,
Alright, you can go swimming now.
Do you think he can swim?
He definitely won't; he'll sink.
Why is that? He has already learned so much knowledge.
Because he's never been in the water before.
He didn't know what it felt like to be in the water.
Reading about something and actually doing it yourself are two different things.
Exactly correct; the Chinese language expression is identical as well.
You understand all the Chinese characters and have listened to all our podcasts.
It's like that person who read every book about swimming,
You have acquired a great deal of knowledge in your mind.
But if you never open your mouth to speak,
Your mouth and the back of your tongue will never learn how to produce Chinese sounds.
Your body doesn't have the habit of speaking Chinese.
You're absolutely right; speaking Chinese is a bodily habit.
Just like swimming, it requires physical practice.
Seeing with the eyes alone and hearing with the ears alone is not enough,
The mouth also needs practice.
Yes, so friends, please check your study methods.
Are you someone who only watches without speaking, only listens without speaking every day?
If that's the case, then you might have found the reason why you can't speak Chinese.
What you need is to get into the water right away and start practicing speaking immediately.
Li Ming, just now we talked about being afraid of making mistakes and only inputting without outputting.
I recall one of my students, her name is Mary.
He has a particularly typical problem.
Oh, do tell me about it.
Mary is a very hardworking student; she has been studying Chinese for two years.
I might know more Chinese characters than you do.
She can understand the general meaning of Chinese news articles.
She must be really talented; her Chinese proficiency should be very high.
Yes, theoretically that's correct, but she hardly ever speaks.
When we had class, whenever I asked her a question, she always had to think for a very long time.
Sometimes she wouldn't answer at all, just smile at me.
Is she afraid of saying the wrong thing too?
It's a bit, but more importantly, she wants to say it too perfectly.
Once during class, I asked her, Mary, why don't you speak during class?
Your Chinese is very good.
What did she say?
She told me, "Teacher Wang, I just wanted to say,"
But when I want to say a word,
I have many questions running through my mind; is this word usage correct?
Would a native Chinese speaker say it this way?
Are my four tones correct?
I thought and thought, and then I didn't know how to say it.
Ah, that's exactly what I just mentioned—my previous issue was striving for perfection.
Yes, she wants to speak a sentence just like a real Chinese person—perfect, with no mistakes.
The more she thought that way, the less she could bring herself to say it.
I completely understand this feeling—it's like when you want to walk,
But every time you take a step, you have to think—where should my left foot go?
My right foot—should my body move forward? The more I think, the less I can walk.
That's exactly the feeling, so I told Mary not to overthink it.
Language is not mathematics; there are not so many things that are entirely right or entirely wrong.
You are now a learner; making mistakes is normal, and even expected.
Yes, making mistakes is part of learning. No baby ever learns to walk without falling down at first.
No one starts learning to speak without making mistakes.
Yes, so my advice to Mary is to forget about perfection and strive first for completion.
That's a great statement—finish first, then perfect it. What does it mean?
What I mean is, don't always keep thinking about crafting a perfect hundred-point sentence.
A sentence with sixty points is enough.
If the other person understands you, then you've succeeded.
For example, you want to tell someone that this afternoon I went to a café with a friend and had a latte.
This sentence is a bit long and a bit difficult.
Yes, for beginners, indeed.
You might be wondering whether the tone of the word "afternoon" is correct.
How do you say café? How do you say latte?
After thinking it over and over, I finally gave up and decided not to say anything.
It's very likely.
But if you're aiming for completion, you can say it more simply.
You could say, today my friend had coffee,
The grammar of this sentence is incorrect; it's very simple.
But can your friend understand?
Of course I can, I'll definitely understand.
That is enough; you have completed the communication.
When you speak better and better in the future,
You will naturally be able to utter that perfect hundred-point sentence.
But now, start from the sentence that scored sixty points.
Well said, so friends,
Don't let perfection be your enemy; the most important thing is to speak up first.
Alright, Wang Yu, we've analyzed the three main reasons.
First, fear of saying the wrong thing.
Second, input only, no output.
Third, an excessive pursuit of perfection.
Why have we said all this?
Now we should give our friends some practical ones,
A simple solution—tell them what to do.
Alright, this is the most important part.
First, tell me what good solutions you have.
I have a very simple one,
And the method that everyone can accomplish,
It's just talking to oneself.
Talking to oneself, speaking to oneself?
Yes, many people say I don't have Chinese friends.
I don't live in China, and I don't have the environmental opportunity to practice Chinese.
These are not problems; you can create your own Chinese environment.
How to create?
Using the method of talking to oneself,
For example, when you wake up in the morning,
You can look out the window and say in Chinese,
Good morning, the weather is nice today.
While you're having breakfast,
You can look at your bread and say, "This is bread."
I like to eat bread.
Haha, this method is so interesting.
Say whatever you see.
Using the simplest Chinese words and sentences you have already learned,
Describe the world around you.
For example, if you see a red cup on the table,
Just say it's a cup.
It is red; I drink water using a cup.
I see, there are several benefits to doing it this way.
First, you don't need anyone else,
One person can practice.
Second, you will not be afraid,
Since no one is listening, it doesn't matter if you say it wrong.
Yes, and most importantly,
This exercise can help establish a connection between your brain and your mouth.
Get used to thinking in Chinese and expressing yourself in Chinese.
This exercise is very simple.
But if you persist in doing it for just ten minutes every day,
One month later,
You will surely find that you have made great progress.
This method is excellent and very suitable for shy friends.
I have a solution as well.
My approach is to find a Language Pokémon.
Language Partner, this is also very popular.
Yes, the internet is very convenient now.
You can find many Chinese people online who want to learn your native language.
You can become friends, become language treasures.
And then, how do you practice?
You can agree to call or have a video chat once a week.
For example, chat for thirty minutes,
For the first fifteen minutes you spoke in Chinese,
In fifteen minutes, speak in your native language.
This is beneficial for both parties.
This method is also good.
Because you now have a real conversational partner,
You can practice listening, or you can practice speaking.
Yes, and when chatting with real people,
You'll learn many very natural expressions that aren't found in textbooks.
If you can't find the Language Treasure, there's still another way.
What is it?
Go talk to people in the real world,
For example, if there's a fruit shop downstairs from your home,
You can go talk to the boss.
This might be a bit difficult for beginners.
It's not difficult; you can start with the simplest question.
In China, we often refer to older, friendly women as
Auntie.
You can walk up to the fruit shop and say to the shopkeeper with a smile,
Hello, auntie.
Yes, this is a good beginning.
Then, you can point at the Apple and ask,
How much is it per catty?
The jin is a commonly used unit of weight in China.
One jin equals 500 grams.
The boss will tell you the price.
You might not understand, that's okay.
You can ask him to write it on paper.
You only said two or three sentences in this process.
But this was a genuine, successful communication.
You will feel a great sense of accomplishment.
I agree.
Such small successes will give you great confidence.
Helping you feel more confident speaking Chinese.
Yes, so my suggestion is to go out and talk to people.
Even just a simple "hello" or "thank you,"
They are all remarkable beginnings.
Alright, today we've talked a lot about the topic of how to start speaking Chinese.
The time is about right.
Wang Yu, we're the same as usual,
Let me summarize today's content for everyone.
Alright, today we talked about why, despite studying for a long time, you still can't speak Chinese.
We believe there are three main reasons.
First, and most importantly,
It's just fear.
Please don't ever be afraid of making mistakes.
The second reason is,
Many people only input,
Do not output.
Please remember our metaphor about swimming,
Learning a language is not just about using your eyes and ears,
You must also practice with your mouth.
Yes, go swimming in the water.
The third reason is,
Don't strive for perfection too much.
Please remember,
Done is better than perfect.
A sentence that scores 60 is a hundred times better than a sentence that scores 0.
It feels really great.
We also provide some simple methods,
for example, talking to oneself,
Or find a language partner,
Or bravely say a few words to the aunt at the fruit shop,
I hope these methods are helpful to everyone.
Well, then, dear listeners of our podcast,
Now it's your turn.
We would like to ask you a question,
To practice speaking Chinese,
What was the first Chinese sentence you said?
Dare you speak Chinese aloud?
What are some good ways to practice speaking?
Please leave us a message in the comments section below.
We are truly looking forward to your sharing and your story.
Alright, then let's end here for today.
Thank you all for listening to Daily Chinese.
See you next time.
Goodbye.
