Who does PINOT NOIR better??? Australia vs New Zealand

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
1 Video View·Apr 11, 2026
Pinot Noir is a beloved wine grape all around the world and while its origins lie in France,
there are substantial plantings in California, Germany, and these two oceanic countries,
Australia and New Zealand. Pinot Noir was introduced to Australia in the early 1800s.
The first plantings were around 1830. There are just under 5,000 hectares of vineyards,
so if my math serves me right, 12,500 acres. In Australia, it's the fourth leading red grape
planted. In New Zealand, there are 5,800 hectares of vineyards. It's the number one
planted red variety. If you add together those total plantings between New Zealand and Australia,
that's less than a third of the entire Pinot Noir plantings in France. Both countries make
fascinating Pinot Noirs. When I used to live in Asia, I used to drink them often. In fact,
I miss drinking them. Even though people think of Australia as a hot place, you got to remember,
the entire country of Australia is bigger than continental Europe. There are a lot of cool
regions. Regions that really stand out for Pinot Noir include Mornington Peninsula, Tasmania,
Yarra Valley, the Adelaide Hills, and more. In New Zealand, central Otago is really the showstopper,
although there are great Pinot Noirs being made in Canterbury, Martinborough, and even Marlborough,
a region that's famous for Sauvignon Blanc. In general, I prefer the quality of Australian
Pinot Noirs for my palate personally. However, the most impressive oceanic Pinot Noirs I have
tasted have been from New Zealand, namely the region of Martinborough. I'm generalizing here.
There are a lot of good producers, but I find Australian Pinot Noirs to be more fruity, more
on the red fruit spectrum, a little bit softer. Where New Zealand, it can be quite different.
In places like central Otago and Martinborough, they can be darker. They can be more concentrated,
even a little bit tannic. I'm ready to go to work. I even have my wannabe winemaker vest on.
I remember once a very esteemed, well-renowned winemaker told me,
tasting Pinot Noirs work. It's actually not a lot of fun because you have to think.
A lot of us wine geeks love Pinot Noir for its haunting aromas, can be perfumed, can be floral
even, really can express a sense of place, can have some earthy mineral-type notes, usually has
a silky mouthfeel, and depending on the style, can be pretty structured, pretty tannic, especially
in the case of Burgundy. Although New World Pinot Noirs are usually made to be a little softer.
That means they're not as astringent. I've got three Australian Pinot Noirs and three New Zealand
Pinot Noirs from all different regions. These were all available in the USA. I know that some
of these wines might be harder to find in Europe. Sorry about that. I'm ready to get tasting.
Tasting out of Burgundy glasses. These are the Rovesia Burgundy glasses. These are the best
inexpensive red wine glasses I've ever used. A lot of people have thanked me for recommending
them. I have a link in the description box if you want to check them out. I appreciate it.
These are all screw caps because they're Australian and New Zealand Pinot Noirs,
so I poured them out and then I had somebody mix them up for me. I've usually preferred
Australian Pinot Noir over New Zealand Pinot Noir in its totality in the past. Let's see
how that shows up here today. It's wintertime when I'm shooting this. I wanted to get a little
colder so there weren't any flies coming around and landing in the glasses. I wanted to give Pinot
Noir ample time to breathe, to express itself. Usually when it comes to wine glasses, I like
universal glasses. If you're ever going to use a varietal specific glass, Pinot Noir is the grape
to use it for. I find with a lot of universal glasses, Pinot Noir doesn't express its best.
You need a big, bold glass. Let's give number one a go here. Very, very, very nice right off the bat.
Red, red raspberry, strawberry. Almost like a little bit of a cool ocean breeze type flavor.
Now, here's the thing. Stylistically, smelling this right away, I would probably guess that we
are in New Zealand or Australia. They just have that distinctive flavor profile. I like that cool
air type flavor. I took a seven-week road trip across New Zealand back in the day when I traveled
around the world for the first time. I just remember on the South Island, driving along the
coastal roads on both sides of the South Island, had the mountains in the middle and then the ocean
on the side. I thought, wow, this is just incredible. That's what I smell here. Maybe
it's kiwi. We'll see. Some of these wines I haven't tasted before. Only a couple of them
I've tasted previous vintages. I'm looking for length here. Pinot Noir is really hard to taste
because it's quite delicate. Here, the tannins are soft. It's not super structured. They are
more fine-grained. All these wines are pretty expensive. We're talking the 40 to 70 US dollar
range. They're going to be higher-end stuff. It's got this nice burst of flavor. It's just nice,
well-balanced oceanic Pinot Noir. Really quite good. Let's move on to number two here. Two has
much more slatey, flinty notes. One was a little bit more fruity, while two, the flint, the crushed
rocks jump right out at me, but you still have the red raspberry flavor. Number one had a mix
of strawberry and red raspberry. This is full-on mineral red raspberry. Smells really distinctive.
Just this flavor profile has me kind of going to Martinborough. Just that flintiness. It just
almost smells quite intense. In Martinborough wines, I feel like you get a lot of the earthy
characteristics. This is structured, long. I think I have one, maybe I have two Martinboroughs
in here. This, I think, is a Martinborough. It's just got a lot of structure. Tannins are tight,
but when I said the tannins are a little bigger and structured, Pinot Noir tannins are going to
be different than big Cabernet Sauvignon or Borolo tannins. These are a little bit softer. It just
adds a little bit of astringency. Number two was great. Let's move on to three here. Very difficult
in terms of differences because they're all different in style. Three is the most floral.
We had fruity, we had flinty, and now we have floral. Rose petal even has a little bit of
thyme. You're still going to get some strawberry rhubarb-type flavors. This is extremely bright.
When I say bright, I'm saying it's got a lot of acid. You got to think if you've ever had
fresh pressed juice before, especially when it comes to orange or maybe grapefruit juice,
the seed comes and hits you hard. This one is extremely bright. I'm an acid guy. The acid's
higher. I think maybe most people would prefer number one in terms of fruitiness. Two is for
more connoisseurs. You have to think through it a little bit. Three is for more people that love
a city like me, Riesling nuts. It's brilliant stuff. Let's move on to number four here.
Four is also concentrated, darker. I think two and four, maybe Martin Burrell Centro Otago-y.
Red raspberry, black cherry. This really smells like if you have flint and you smack them together.
I used to do a lot of backpacking, camping, and trying to start fires when you don't have matches.
It's a game we used to play. That's what it smells like. You have the sparkiness in it.
Length here is perfect. This is structured. Man, when you have fantastic wine, you have this
beautiful interplay between the fruit, the acidity, the tannins. There's this little dance in your
mouth. And then really good red wines. I want just a touch of astringency. That's what I'm getting
here. In New Zealand, it's pretty southerly. You would think that the wines would be a little bit
lighter. They are the most southerly vineyards in the world. However, there's a partial hole
in the ozone layer there. So when you're there, the light is a little bit more intense. That's
why I do think Pinot Noir develops more color. I know when I was with some famous winemakers in
Santa Barbara County, where the Pinot Noirs tend to be a little bit darker, they were talking about
just because there's a lot of sun, they tend to be more darker. Doesn't make the Pinot Noir better
or worse. It's just what it is. Four was absolutely killer. It'd be funny if a Central Otago wins,
because I've always been poo-pooing on Central Otago. It gets so much hype and that's what
people know it for. I prefer Martinborough. Five is such a great balance between the flintiness,
the floralness, also a little bit of thyme flavors. What I like about these Oceanic Pinot Noirs is a
lot of times they're not trying to be burgundy. I think Martinborough is the closest in these two
countries that become burgundy, but they are a distinctive style on their own. This is also
brilliant. There is a little bit of structure here. Beautiful plant. I mean, these are some
really impressive wines. Let's move on to number six here. Six is the flintiest by far. I think I
had number two as slatey. I had number four as when you spark rocks together. Five was floral
and flinty. This is super, super flinty, which kind of reminds me sometimes of some Tasmanian
Pinot Noirs I've had before. Darker as well, more concentrated even than the color I can see. Out
of all these wines, this is the least fruity. It's the most tannic as well. It's entirely mineral
driven. It is Pinot Noir, so you're going to have those bright red fruit flavors, but if you want a
fruity, easy drinking Pinot Noir, this is not going to be it. Six is so funny because I'm scoring for
right now what I'm enjoying, but I think it might be one that lasts the longest because it's really
structured. The tannins are quite drying for Pinot Noir, that is. This is hard. That's difficult.
You ready for the reveal? Tight, tight scores here. Okay. I think if you're a Pinot head,
you're not going to go wrong with any of these. I think number one is the most friendly out of all
these. It's something that I would recommend to everybody. I think everybody's going to like it.
It has enough fruit to interest people that aren't really hardcore in the wine, but it has some of
those nuances. Nice balance. I gave it 92 points. 92 points. Let's see what number one is. I only
think that, well, I think this is Australian. Let's see. We'll see. Flavor profile, easy drinking.
I just think it was Australian. Let's take a look. It's not. It is New Zealand. This is the
Pyramid Valley Manata 2021. 50 bucks. Easy drinking Pyramid Valleys from Canterbury.
The capital of that region in the South Island is Christchurch. It's amazing there because the
mountains are so high. They come close to the sea. This is one of the Pinot Noir producers I've always
been impressed with. This is a brand new project. This is from their central Otago vineyards.
50 bucks, brand new wine, 2021, young. This is something you bring it to a dinner party.
Absolutely. Everybody's going to love it. Got one wrong already. Number three was the most floral.
I said that a bunch. Strawberry rhubarb flavors. The acidity is what made it popping. One and three
were quite similar to me. I think more people are going to enjoy one. Three just has more acidity,
and for people that love Riesling like me, that's what draws me to it. I think this is Australian.
92 plus points. 92 plus points. This is the Giant Steps Sexton Vineyard Pinot Noir from Yarra Valley
2021. This has got a weird pricing system. I was looking up anywhere from 50 bucks to 79 bucks.
Giant Steps actually has won tons of awards. I think this wine was in some of the top 100 wines
of the world list and different critic sites. This is a single vineyard. I used to buy their
basic Pinot Noir a lot in Singapore. It's a super dependable wine, and I remember once in my WCET 3
course being tricked by one of their Chardonnays, which I thought was burgundy. Very nice wine.
Australian, I called it. We got one Kiwi, one Aussie wine. Let's move on. Five and six,
tied for 93 points. Number five was that perfect balance between flinty floral, had some thyme,
some garig notes, along with the red fruit flavors. I think it was impressive. Had pretty
good structure. I don't know whether this lies in. I didn't know if it was Australian or New Zealand.
Let's take a look here. From Tasmania. I have to go back and see. I think that when I tasted this,
I said some of this flintiness reminds me of wines I've tasted from Tasmania before.
Number six here, which kind of reminds me sometimes of some Tasmanian Pinot Noirs I've
had before. Number five. This is the Dali Rimple Pipers River Tasmania Pinot Noir 2021. This comes
in at 40 bucks. Tasmania, really hot area for a Chardonnay Pinot Noir right now, especially for
sparkling wines. An island south of the main island of Australia. I have not been there yet.
I really want to make it there. In the past, I did a couple of big Tasmanian Pinot Noirs
Chardonnay tastings, and I came away disappointed with quite a few producers. However, I've done a
few videos in the recent months with Tasmanian Pinot Noirs, and they've both been impressive.
40 bucks, 93 points for a Pinot Noir. That's pretty good. I think Dali Rimple is owned by
the same family that owns Yalumba, even though it's a bigger company. It's still family owned,
so that's cool if that's important to you. Number six. I think a lot of people would think this is
the worst wine out of the bunch because it was more mineral driven. It was the least fruity out
of the bunch. It was really structured. I gave it 93 points because I see this wine has a big
time future. I don't know if it's Australian or New Zealand. I think it could be either way,
93 points. Mineral driven, buyer beware though. This is a wine that you probably want to store
for a little while. Let's take a look. This is the Craggy Range Temuna Road Vineyard from
Martinborough, 2021, 40 bucks. This is a single vineyard wine. They're even basic wine. It is
delicious, and they have a wine a step ahead called the Aroha, which is the top. It's one
of the best oceanic Pinot Noirs I've ever had. Shows up in an upcoming video. I actually thought
wine too was this. 93 points. This is outstanding wine. Craggy Range is a pretty well distributed
brand, so you'll be able to find these wines. I was through this area in New Zealand back when I
was traveling through the country, although I didn't know a ton about wine then. I was just
drinking it casually. I need to go back there, and I want to go visit them because I know they
have a hotel too. I think that just needs to be laid down for at least five more years. That's
just my opinion personally. Two Aussie and two New Zealand. Is that right? Yeah. The top two,
splitting hairs, 94 and 94 plus points. We're going to start out with wine number two,
Sladey Structured Long Tannic. I actually thought that this was the Temuna Road. I thought this was
the Martinborough wine. I gave it 94 points. I thought it was outstanding. It's a wine that
you're really going to enjoy now, but I think it has the ability to age very nicely. Let's take a
look. New Zealand, babe. This is the Smith and Chef Pinot Noir Cru Coiro from Central Otago as
well. The Gibson Valley, 42 bucks. It's 2019, so it has a touch of age on it. It still tasted young.
I don't know a ton about this producer, but the wine is good. That's all I have to say. Look at
me, poo-pooing on Central Otago and then came out with Central Otago. We have number one,
which I think is going to be an Australian wine. It was darker, had the fire rocks type
flavor. I was talking about camping. The length is what really separated here. I thought it was
Central Otago, Martinborough, but I guess I think Australia. That's all we have left.
The Sean Smith Pinot Noir from Adelaide Hills, 2021, 39, 40 bucks. This is absolutely outstanding
wine. I know that Michael Hill Smith is an MW. Adelaide Hills, right next to Adelaide, is a
little bit higher. Vineyards are, I think they go to 300, 400 meters, so we're talking about
1200, 1500 feet. This is a brand that's also widely available. This is excellent. Aussie, Aussie,
Aussie. I said overall, I like Australian Pinot Noirs, although in the past I felt like
the most impressive ones I tasted were New Zealand, but we have at the top,
94 plus Australia, 94 New Zealand. I had a ton of fun doing this tasting. Let me know if you did
too. Let me know if you like Australian or New Zealand Pinot Noirs. Any favorite producers?
Drop it in the comments below.
