The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
UK Constitutional Law refers to the body of law and principles that govern the structure, functioning, and organization of the United Kingdom's political system and government. Unlike some countries with written constitutions, the UK's constitution is not found in a single written document but rather is a combination of various sources, including statutes, conventions, common law, and historical documents.
A. Bradley, K. Ewing & C.J.S. Knight, Constitutional & Administrative Law (18th edn, Pearson, 2022). R. Masterman & C. Murray, Constitutional & Administrative Law (Cambridge University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In this lesson we're going to talk about the next of our major principles of the UK constitution,
arguably the most important principle, and as a result of which the one that we're going to
spend a lot of time examining. This is the idea of parliamentary sovereignty. So we'll talk about
parliamentary sovereignty in a number of different ways in the next few lessons. We'll talk about a
sort of general principle in this lesson, as well as talking about the history in the next lesson,
looking at some of the ideas enrolled within the idea of parliamentary sovereignty,
so things like the doctrine of implied repeal for example, and then talk about challenges to
parliamentary sovereignty, at least challenges on paper to the idea of parliamentary sovereignty.
We'll do that towards the end. Arguably, and in my opinion probably, the doctrine of parliamentary
sovereignty, the principle of parliamentary sovereignty, is the most fundamental and
important of all of the principles that exist within the UK constitution. We're going to be
spending a lot of time talking about this principle. We'll talk about the original position
of parliamentary sovereignty, take an introduction to parliamentary sovereignty in this lesson.
We will talk about the historical development of the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty,
so talking about the pre versus the post 1688 approach to parliamentary sovereignty,
where you have in the pre stages, the preliminary stages of the idea of parliamentary sovereignty,
there is a lot of judgment that suggests that the common law may actually be supreme,
that parliament may be subordinate to the common law, and then you have the 1688 Glorious Revolution
and the subsequent 1689 Bill of Rights, which enshrines this principle of parliamentary
sovereignty as being the most foundational of the UK constitution. We'll talk about parliamentary
sovereignty today, talk about the idea of the enrolled bill rule, talk about the idea of
implied repeal, talk about the theory of constitutional, of the constitution
relating to parliamentary sovereignty, and then finally we will talk about challenges to
parliamentary sovereignty, and we can explain challenges to parliamentary sovereignty by
reference to a number of different institutions, different principles, and different laws,
which may be said to present something of a challenge to the idea. So our previously existing
membership to the European Union is something of a considered to be challenge to parliamentary
sovereignty. The idea of devolution is considered to be a challenge to parliamentary sovereignty.
So too is the Human Rights Act from 1998. So we've actually already talked about parliamentary
sovereignty quite a lot in this series of lessons already, so I'm going to be quite brief in
explaining what parliamentary sovereignty is in its general form, because ultimately what this
tells us, what the principle of parliamentary sovereignty tells us, is that the Westminster
Parliament, the parliament that we can see just above the screen here with Big Ben in the
picture, is the supreme law-making authority in the United Kingdom. That is all parliamentary
sovereignty tells us, okay. Now there are various other elements that are attached to it, which we'll
get to in a second, but fundamentally the concept of parliamentary sovereignty is that the Westminster
Parliament, the parliament that is situated in Westminster, is the supreme law-making authority
in the UK. So it also means that Parliament has the complete authority to make and unmake
any law it so chooses, and this represents the cornerstone, in my opinion at least, the cornerstone
of the UK's constitutional framework, because it establishes the highest authority of law-making
in the United Kingdom. So rather than there being some codified constitution, where you have an
entrenched principles of law that are difficult to amend with a single constitutional document,
like you have in the US for example, where the highest law and the highest law-making authority
is represented and enshrined by the US constitution, what we have is a principle, and this is the
principle of parliamentary sovereignty. This represents the highest establishment of law
and legal authority in the United Kingdom, rather than the idea of a single codified document,
and it ties into a little bit what A. V. Dicey says about the rule of law, the idea that the
ordinary law is supreme. The idea here is that the law that is passed here by Parliament
is supreme, it is the highest authority in the United Kingdom. According to A. V. Dicey specifically,
in fact, who talks a lot about parliamentary sovereignty, neither more nor less than this,
namely, the Parliament thus defined has, under the English constitution, the right to make and
unmake any law whatsoever, and further, that no person or body is recognized by the law of England
as having a right to override or set aside the legislation of Parliament. This is essentially
the enshrining of the principle of parliamentary sovereignty by A. V. Dicey specifically, and what,
in fact, A. V. Dicey is doing is outlining two elements to the principle of parliamentary
sovereignty, and it is true that these elements exist. The elements are that parliamentary
sovereignty can exist in a positive sense, in a positive legal sense, but it can also exist in a
negative legal sense. There are two elements attached. The positive element is the fact that
Parliament has the power to make and unmake any law they so choose. They have the active authority
to go, and they can pass a law that says whatever they want, okay, but they can also take laws away
if they so choose to, if they think, you know what, tomorrow we don't want the Companies Act
2006, we're going to get rid of it. They can, they absolutely can. Can they say, tomorrow you,
we're going to pass a law tomorrow that says that it is now legally acceptable and legally
permissible for you to punch your neighbour? Absolutely. There is nothing legally, shall we say,
legally there is nothing that suggests that Parliament does not have that power to do so,
because there's no other higher authority that limits Parliament in that way, at least theoretically,
at least on paper. The negative element relates to other institutions which relate to Parliament. So
no other person or body is recognised by the law of England as having the right to override or set
aside the legislation of Parliament. So not only does Parliament have the positive right to make
any law they so choose, but they also have the right to be supreme. They have the right to be
supreme in relation to any other institution, such that no other person or no other institution
can override and set aside legislation that is passed by Parliament. Now from a historical
perspective, we will get to this in the future, in the next lesson should I say specifically,
but the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty develops mainly out of the civil wars and
revolutions in England, with the execution, the regicide of Charles I, the restoration of the
monarchy, as well as the invitation of William of Orange with the Glorious Revolution of 1688.
We'll get to more of this in the next lesson, but ultimately, while these are the sort of impetus
catalysts for the formal enshrining of the principle of parliamentary sovereignty,
the idea and the relationship between Parliament and the monarchy had been straining very
slowly for many years prior to the events which takes place under the early period of
the Stuart dynasty. We'll get to all of this though in the next lesson.