Top Economist The Unthinkable is About to Happen to Oil Prices

Global Finance News
11 followers
#finance
#financement
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00 — Introduction: Why This Moment Is Economically Different
01:07 — Iran-Israel Escalation: What The Markets Are Actually Pricing In
02:13 — Oil Price Analysis: Historical Patterns & 2026 Outlook
03:06 — The Dollar: De-dollarization Facts vs. Hype
03:50 — Defense Spending & Who Profits From Conflict
06:05 — Supply Chain Risk: Gas, Fertilizers, Metals
09:11 — Recession Indicators: What Steve Keen Is Watching
13:13 — What You Should Actually Do With Your Money Right Now
15:00 — Closing: Honest Uncertainty vs. False Certainty
Trump is stupid enough to take on what Israel wanted to do, which was destroy Iran.
The Financial Times is reporting that traders placed 580 million dollars worth of oil bets.
Just 15 minutes later, President Trump posted on Truth Social
that he was halting planned strikes on Iranian power plants.
Meet Steve Keen, the man who predicted the 2008 crash.
As war disrupts global oil, something strange happens.
Markets move before the news. Millions were already on the line.
If someone is using this as a way of making profit,
then it's playing a game with the lives of people on this planet.
Trump is being pressured by Netanyahu, who always wanted to have an attack on Iran.
He underestimated the capacity of Iran to fight back.
I've been praying that there'd be some way to back out of this war.
Nobody can talk about anything other than what's happening in Iran,
and of course what's happening to the oil price, and the availability of oil,
and all the other resources coming out of the Strait of Hormuz
that are now being blocked by this conflict.
But there's something happening on stock markets and commodity markets as well
that's worth discussing.
And Ed Conway, who does the empirical research for Sky News,
has found something rather fascinating.
So let's have a look at it and see what Ed has found,
and then let's see what could possibly explain
these strange dynamics on the stock market.
It was a really massive moment when Donald Trump came out,
the social media post basically saying that talks were underway.
You'll probably remember at that point markets went crazy.
A lot of people selling off oil, buying shares,
because they saw a big opportunity to make money out of this.
And here's what's striking.
What we're looking at here is just the volumes,
how many people were doing the buying and selling at any given time.
If you look at when Donald Trump made that post, it was 1105 UK time,
there was a massive flurry of activity immediately afterwards.
Not surprising at all.
But here's what is surprising.
15 minutes before he made that post, a group of people made a massive trade.
One of the biggest trades that we'd seen in that market up until that announcement.
Did they actually know what the president was about to announce?
Because when you take that, that trade on this market and the other oil markets,
they have made hundreds of millions of dollars potentially.
That's the scary thing, because what's being implied there
is that this is insider trading in some sense.
Someone has information about what's going to happen.
Trump is going to make an announcement,
and 15 minutes before he is going to make that announcement,
somebody makes a large trade,
which will benefit out of the impact of that announcement on the market.
It is unthinkable, given the scale of damage to the global economy,
the number of people who could suffer because of this change
and going forward in this year.
We face potential famines in countries like India,
even famines in countries like Australia,
because suddenly they're going to run out of oil
to be able to transport food around.
If someone is using this as a way of making profit,
then it's playing a game with the lives of people on this planet
in a way which is beyond reprehensible.
Now, we don't know that it's actually happened.
It could be luck, as Ed is saying there,
but the possibility is that someone thinks this is a way to make a fortune
by gaming the market,
knowing the president is going to make an announcement
which is going to move the market dramatically
15 minutes after you make a position.
We saw the difference in the oil price there.
That was from $100 to $85.
It's a $15 drop.
If you can sell it $100 before it drops to $15
and make other positions to options trading as well
to benefit from that change, you make a fortune.
Is someone making money out of this war?
Is this war not just an ideological battle,
not even about security?
Is it about gaming the market and making a fortune?
And that is horrific that you can even consider
that this is what's going on.
Again, this is the sort of behaviour that comes out of people
who don't really care about other people in any sense whatsoever.
They're simply trying to profit out of the situation.
This just looks like people treating a monumental shock
to the global economy as a way of making a profit.
One thing which this also makes me think about
is Trump trying to understand Trump's behaviour.
As I've said before, I think a lot of it comes out of sheer narcissism.
He's also cunning.
One of the explanations for the war which makes eminent sense,
Trump was being pressured by Netanyahu,
always wanted to have an attack on Iran,
and for whatever reason,
the political relationship between Trump and Netanyahu,
Trump has done it,
whereas all the other American leaders before Trump
did not want to go into Iran.
We know that the Pentagon wanted to invade Iran,
but I think also the research the Pentagon did said,
it's a really bad idea.
We might want to be one of the countries
you knock over or we knocked over Iraq,
we knocked over Afghanistan, et cetera, et cetera.
The Pentagon had that intention,
but they would have potentially done the research
to say,
what capabilities does Iran have to fight back and say no?
Now, this time it's gone ahead.
America, in particular, Donald Trump and Pete Hegseth,
and I prefer to call Pete Hogsbreath, by the way,
the so-called Secretary of War,
maybe they just massively underestimated
the capacity of Iran to fight back.
And so that's the explanation,
and they got themselves into this terrible trap,
and now they've got to find a way to extricate themselves.
But if it's also being used as a way of making a fortune
by pumping and dumping on the market,
then it's even harder to reverse the war
because Americans who don't want to see a war happen,
we're thinking, oh, we've got to find a way
to extricate ourselves from this.
But if it's being used as a game to increase the profit,
increase the money of people who Trump knows
or who know Trump or whatever else you can imply here,
it's horrific.
And it means that no matter what we say,
this war is going to continue
because people are making money out of it.
Well, if that's where there's your appetite
to have a realistic approach to economics,
then join me and learn realistic economics
through stevekane.com.
You can use my Ravel software
that you've seen me using in this video.
You can talk to me and ask me questions.
It's a free book bundle that's available just this week.
To apply, go to stevekane.com or scan the QR code.
Not just in terms of being able to sell Texas oil
for more than they could
before the supply of oil from Saudi Arabia was cut off,
but actually gaming the market in a pump and dump scam.
One thing which makes me think
this is what's actually happening
is one of the crazy things you've seen
come out of Trump.
You would have probably noticed him
when he said that he's got a very nice gift from Iran
and was toying around with it as,
you know, I got a present from Iran.
The present was letting eight ships
get through the Straits of Hormuz.
Now those eight ships weren't American ships.
They were ships which were with the countries
which had agreed to buy the oil
using the Chinese currency, not the American dollar.
And the oil was going to countries
which are not allied with America,
certainly not involved in the potential invasion of Iran.
So it wasn't a gift given directly to Trump.
So in what sense could it be a gift?
Well, one way it could be a gift is
that because there's eight tankerfuls of oil
end up in the market,
that's going to depress the oil price to some extent,
which could potentially accentuate the gain
if you do something else,
which is going to panic people
and make people worried about the oil
being not available again.
There's a, it means that this,
what looks like a crazy comment,
you know, he did presents for Trump.
He didn't receive the oil directly.
It wasn't sent to America even.
It was sent to other countries.
It makes no sense to say he got a gift.
But if this falls into something
which can be exploited in a pump and dump scheme,
then that's where the gift comes into Trump.
And that is even scarier.
I've been praying that there'd be some way
to back out of this war.
But if this war is being used as a way of profiting,
whether it's Trump or whether it's associates of Trump
or heaven knows what,
then the war's not going to stop
while people who are profiting from it
on the markets on a 15 minute interval
between when Trump makes an announcement
and before the rest of the world finds out.
It means this war is unstoppable.
The damage it's doing is just going to continue.
This is a war that should never have happened.
There was no justification
for attacking Iran at this time.
Took out the nuclear power.
All the normal interpretation would say
he wants a way to back out.
But if this is being used to make a profit,
then he doesn't want to back out.
He wants to continue seeing the market going up and down,
accentuate the ups and downs
and make as much money as profitable.
Not saying it's Trump that's doing that,
but it's the associates potentially,
people who get to know what he's going to do.
They're exploiting it.
And the war could go on
even if there's a potential resolution.
One point which we speculation about
is what's going to be the impact on the global economy
of shutting off this oil.
Mainstream economists would argue
that it wouldn't have much impact at all
because the way that they analyze production
is they argue that you have these inputs
of labor and capital and energy,
and you can substitute.
If you don't have energy,
you can substitute more labor and more capital.
So that type of argument comes out of the way
that conventional economists model production.
That's called the Cobb-Douglas production function.
It's the dominant model used by mainstream economists.
And a group of German economists
back when the Ukraine war began
did an estimate using neoclassical theory of saying
what would be the impact
if the energy supply to Germany fell by 10%
because that was speculation
about the impact of losing access to Russian oil
that much energy would drop.
Well, they fed that into
this Cobb-Douglas production function.
And the answer was that a 10% fall
in the level of energy into the German economy
would reduce German GDP by 0.4%.
In other words, 10% fall in energy,
trivial fall in GDP.
Now, why do they get that answer?
It's because what's called a production function
that they use in their models
says that the impact of a change in one of the inputs,
the inputs would be technology,
labor, capital, and then energy.
The impact depends upon the fraction
that labor and capital and technology
make up of total GDP.
So labor, according to
the Cobb-Douglas production function,
contributes 70% of output.
Capital contributes 26% of output
and 4% comes out of the energy industries.
So therefore a 10% fall in energy
only causes 0.4% fall in GDP.
I'm taking a look at energy and GDP together.
This is gross world product,
which is the sum of the GDP
of all the economies on the planet,
the black line up here.
And then the red line is gross world product
measured in the American dollars in 2015.
And you can see that they're pretty much
parallel with each other.
Now that gives you an extremely high correlation,
but partly that correlation comes out of the fact
that they're both rising.
So the next chart down the bottom
takes a look at the change in energy
and the change in gross world product
and percentage terms,
and then graphs them against each other.
And this is from, just to zoom in,
this is from 1972 through to 2024.
So it's the last 50 years of economic data.
And not only do they move the same way,
the moves are the same scale.
So if you have a 6% increase in energy,
you have a 6% increase in GDP,
almost precisely the same.
If you have a huge falls we had back under COVID,
when it fell by about 8%,
you had an 8% fall in GDP.
So what it says is that the change in gross world product
is virtually identical to the change in energy.
And that means that if we have a 10% fall in energy,
we're gonna have a 10% fall in GDP,
not a 0.4%, but a 10% fall in GDP.
And this is empirically based.
There's no theory involved in this.
This is just the empirical data.
The empirical data tells you something that says
the impact of a loss of energy is 25 times larger
than the neoclassical economists will think it is.
That's how wrong they are.
And I think this is one reason
that I'm such a critic of mainstream economics,
because it's divorced from the physical world
in which we live.
It's ludicrous to say that energy,
a 10% fall in energy or a 10% increase for that matter,
would only change GDP by 0.4% either way.
That's completely trivializing
the role of energy in production.
When you take it seriously by looking at the data,
you see that the 10% fall in energy,
10% fall in GDP.
Now, most people I think would have some gut feeling
of that relationship would hold,
that people who've swallowed conventional economics
trivialize the impact of losing access
to critical inputs like oil.
And again, one of the crazy things
about conventional economic theory
is that it has absolutely no link to the physical world,
to the natural world.
So the model of production that the neoclassicals use
basically says you can produce output
by combining technology and labor and capital,
no inputs from the real world.
Now that's nonsense.
If you have no inputs from the real world,
you can produce absolutely nothing.
And my little shorthand saying on that front
relates to energy.
And it is that labor without energy is a corpse.
Capital without energy is a sculpture.
Without energy, you can do nothing.
Because economists have this naive model
that doesn't involve any inputs from the natural world at all,
let alone energy,
it's made us all complacent about the impact
of losing something like access to oil in the Persian Gulf.
Also, economic theory in general blinds you
to the importance of understanding
the production system.
If you go back 40 years in economics,
you'll actually find their models were better
on this front, not worse.
So 40 years ago, or 50 years ago,
conventional neoclassical economists
use what they call computable general equilibrium models.
Now what those models did was describe
the production system for the economy
as an input-output system.
Let's say there's a hundred different
major classifications of commodities.
Then each line is like a recipe saying
how many elements of this, that, and the other
do you need to make iron, for example?
And how many of those do you need to make plastics?
And how many of those do you need to make cars?
And so on and so forth.
So with those tables, they could actually say,
well, if we see there's going to be a 10% fall in oil,
then looking at the input-output dynamics,
this means there's going to be a 10% fall in GDP.
It was actually much more realistic 50 years ago.
Now what they've done is they think
they've improved their modeling
because they think the important thing
is to derive their macroeconomic models
from what they call sound microeconomic foundations.
But to get those so-called sound microeconomic foundations,
they've completely forgotten about the production system.
So to a large extent, as to why we're being so surprised
by the impact of the closure of the Strait of Hormuz
is because we've had an economic theory
that most people absorb.
Most people learn whether they go
into an economics degree or not.
They see supply and demand diagrams.
That's how they think about the economy.
They think price adjustments
can handle virtually everything.
In the real world, that's simply not true.
So we're finding out the hard way,
and economic theory has got in the way of us understanding
how important it is not to have things happen
like the closure of the Straits of Hormuz.
Then that comes back to the fact
that there's no justification in the real world
for this war taking place.
The one thing I can say in favor of this war happening now
is that we're going to see the impact
of losing access to energy and access to fertilizer
and all the critical elements
that come out of the Strait of Hormuz,
including helium and the supply of the sulfur dioxide,
which is the supply of hydrogen sulfide,
which is part of producing sulfuric acid,
which is a vital input to so many production processes.
So we're suddenly going to find
what it's like to have those cut off.
And in that sense, this is forewarning
of what global warming itself will do at some point.
So if I have to find any positive spin
on this horrible experience for the world,
it's waking us up to how important it is
to be free of fossil fuels.
It's turbocharging the really lackadaisical way
in which the Western world has approached
the issues of global warming.
All these words are spoken about,
let's get off fossil fuels,
but really most countries
aren't doing anything serious about it.
This is now going to make so many countries think,
holy hell, we can't rely upon that oil arriving anymore.
We can at least rely upon the sun coming up in the morning
and the wind blowing.
And we can also rely upon nuclear power for that matter.
This is a real wake-up call to the world
ahead of what global warming is going to do
to give us a wake-up call
we should have taken notice of 50 years ago.
This is a pre-global warming wake-up call for the planet.
You have to get off fossil fuels
to have a sustainable civilization.
So we all went through the COVID lockdown
and we remember being unable to leave our homes
because of the attempt to stop the spread of the disease,
which was extremely badly handled,
just like virtually anything modern politics
touch, they handle it badly.
We're going to get the same thing out of this approach
because if we're going to have 20% less energy,
then we're going to have a 20% fall in GDP,
which is horrifying,
but that'll mean we're going to have rationing.
Energy is going to be rationed.
Food maybe have to be rationed
and that'll make what happened during the COVID lockdown
seem like a picnic
because at least during the COVID lockdown,
you still got food, you still got energy.
In this process, people are going to be being told now,
don't go to work from home as much as you can.
But after all the pressure
to get people back into the office again,
now we're being told we have to work from home,
not to stop a disease spreading,
but to stop us running out of energy.
And in that situation,
if we don't stop ourselves running out of energy,
then at a certain point,
commerce comes to a complete and absolute halt
and we can't move anything.
So the COVID lockdown will look like a picnic
compared to what this will do to us.
