World Saola Day with Dr. George Schaller, Bill deBuys and Bill Robichaud

World Saola Day
14 followers
Well, welcome everybody. This is Bill Robichaud.
I'm one of the co-founders and directors of the Salwa Foundation,
and I'm really happy to be in conversation today with two people
very important to the whole Salwa story and history of its conservation.
The first one is George Schaller.
We're doing this conversation, this chat today,
basically in honor of George's recent 90th birthday.
That's just incredible to me.
George has been doing field work for 70 years,
and for more than 60 years,
he's been defining his place as the preeminent field biologist of our time
by being the first one or the first Westerner to study charismatic
or important, ecologically important, large mammals in the field for the first time.
He's the author of numerous books on his work,
and he's an inspiration to thousands, if not millions, of conservationists around the world.
So welcome, George.
Well, thank you very much.
All right. And our second guest is Dr. Bill DeBruys,
another outstanding, eloquent writer on topics of conservation and the environment.
I spent time in Laos with George looking for Salwa and other things in the 90s,
and then Bill DeBruys came out,
and we had quite some adventures in the Annamite Mountains of Laos in, I think, 2011.
And out of that research, Netherland research,
Bill wrote the wonderful book about Salwa and its conservation, The Last Unicorn.
And Bill's with us from his home in the mountains of New Mexico today.
Welcome, Bill.
Good to be with you, Bill. Thank you.
Yeah. And Bill DeBruys and George Schauer also worked together for several years
with a major supporter of Salwa conservation, the Liz Kleber and Art Hortenberg Foundation,
and we're very grateful to them.
So they know each other and have stolen a few horses themselves.
So, George, most of your career in the field, you've done some incredible fieldwork.
Most of it's been in Asia.
You know, looking back on a career of, you know, 60-plus years doing conservation work in Asia,
any thoughts, any reflections around hopes for the future of conservation in Asia?
Well, that's a rather general question.
Conservation depends in part on political stability in the country.
And it depends on the economics of the country.
If it's reasonably well off, they can afford to have conservation.
But it's also extremely important to get the local communities involved in conservation
so they benefit at present and for the future
and help protect the wildlife and habitats.
So there's still a lot of environment left to protect,
but a lot of it is being carelessly destroyed.
Right. And I think that's where we're lucky with Salwa.
Because, as you know, there's a lot of animals in Asia that have a very high price on their heads.
And it's, you know, an economic opportunity lost for people to conserve these animals.
Or maybe they're in competition with their livestock or whatever, or killing their livestock.
We found quite good traction with getting community support for Salwa conservation
because there's no cost to villagers, really, to not killing a Salwa.
Just being caught up as bycatch, you know, in the commercial wildlife trade and poachers.
Bill Louise, do you have any thoughts on reflecting on what you saw in Laos
when things weren't quite as good for conservation in Laos when you were there?
I think they've gotten better since then.
Any thoughts on hopes for Salwa and conservation in Southeast Asia?
Well, two things.
One is that the toll of snaring in the Annamite Mountains was really,
it was a defauntation of the entire ecosystem.
As Rob Kidd said, you know, there's large sections of forest
where you cannot encounter an animal larger than a copper spaniel.
They're just all gone.
But that said, the second big thing is just the fecundity of that environment.
The potential, if areas are reasonably protected for livestock to come back,
the fertility and the reproduction possibilities are simply enormous.
One of the things that struck me about Salwa is that their habitat,
where they occur, is in areas so remote that Salwa never even showed up
in the otherwise encyclopedic pharmacopoeia of traditional Asian medicine.
So as you said, there was no particular price on their head.
They weren't lusted after for one purpose or another.
So golly, if they're still there and if their habitat can be protected,
the prospects are really, really good.
Yeah.
And, George, if I may, I'm going to quote you from your wonderful book,
Tibet Wild, that's one of my favorite books of yours,
about your experiences in this huge area of the Tibetan steppe, the Chong Kang.
And you spent a lot of time there searching for the calving ground
of the endangered Tibetan antelope or churu.
And you wrote in Tibet Wild, quote,
Whenever I do research in an area, I select a totem animal in which my heart can rest,
an animal of beauty and interest and in need of conservation,
and also one that can contribute to conservation of a large area.
And I think you did that with Tibetan antelope in the Chong Kang.
And as Bill said, we have these amazing anemite mountains,
and we're trying to use Salwa in the same way.
Well, I've made only two trips to Vietnam in the late 80s and four trips to Laos in the 90s.
And I was wonderfully impressed with the cooperation and the helpfulness
that the government and the local people extended to me in America,
considering the horrible war America fought in that region.
So I think the people are open to helping others and themselves
to have a good environment for the future for the Salwa and other animals.
Yeah, yeah. And certainly our experience at the Salwa Foundation,
the supportive environment of the Lao government is fantastic now.
It's, you know, the best any of us have ever seen since we've been working in Laos for 30 years.
The government is really committed to working with us to save Salwa,
and they recognize also the importance of the anemite mountains,
and they're really taking serious steps to protect it now.
That's wonderful news.
Bill Robichaud, what's your perspective looking forward?
You spent more time on that region than either of the other two of us in recent years.
Yeah, you know, to be honest, I mean, the way I look at it is
certainly all of us in the Salwa Foundation,
we are absolutely convinced that there is time to save Salwa.
And both of you know our technical director, Rob Timmons.
He's just brilliant at finding rare wildlife in Southeast Asia.
He's been doing this for years.
And Rob's also a very pragmatic skeptic.
And he's the last person in the world who would go on like a wild goose chase
or an extinct animal chase.
And he's convinced that there are Salwa still to be found.
So I'm very hopeful.
That said, what we're doing through the Salwa Foundation,
the way I look at it, Bill, is, you know, Laos is a Buddhist country.
You both worked in Buddhist countries a fair bit.
Both of you in Nepal, you know, and Laos.
You know, the Buddha said no effort is wasted.
And even if we're not in time to find Salwa and save it,
we're doing so much good along the way by developing,
especially something that was so important to George,
or is important to George for his entire career,
is developing and encouraging and mentoring young conservation talent.
And we're doing that in Laos.
And whether or not this team is going to be in time to find Salwa,
as we believe it will be,
this team is going to be together working on the next animals, you know,
that need help in the Andamite Mountains.
Things like the large antlered muntjac.
George and I, in one of our surveys, we rediscovered a muntjac,
Roosevelt's muntjac, that hadn't been heard of for like 60 or 80 years.
So there's a lot of other species in line.
So yeah, at the Salwa Foundation and myself,
I just get up every morning and I put one foot in front of the other
and do the next right thing in front of me.
You know, I don't have control over the outcome.
But we do have control over, you know, what good action we take.
So yeah, I'm very hopeful.
If that sounds hopeful.
So there's this one species that has been discovered
and never found.
The reed worm, which is this goat-like animal
with this spiral horn.
Oh yeah.
And the horn's like this,
like, was found in the woods.
And just like you did the Salwa,
this reed worm,
that's never been found as a body.
And where is it?
Is it exterminated?
You gotta keep looking.
George, are you talking about the Khating Vore
from northern Cambodia, southern Laos area?
Yeah.
Yeah, actually I did some searches for that in southern Laos.
And as you said, some people are...
It's known that some of the horns
of what were believed to be this animal
were faked out of cow horns.
But others also believe that some of the horns
that are in collections now are the real thing.
So yeah, it just, you know, it's...
It also, you know, that's another window on,
you know, we just still live in this incredible world,
you know, with still amazing things
and a lot yet to be discovered.
And if I may on that note,
I'm going to quote from Bill DeBuise's book.
I'm pretty sure this is from...
Actually, this is from The Last Unicorn.
I love this passage.
Bill wrote, quote,
Uncounted species, and not just charismatic animals
like tigers, gorillas, rhinos, and Salwa,
but even a larger number of obscure rodents,
amphibians, birds, and reptiles
have been pressed to the brink.
We hardly know them,
and yet within the vastness of the universe,
they and the rest of the Earth's biota
are our only known companions.
Without them, our loneliness would stretch to infinity.
And that really, that's so beautifully said,
and that sums up for me, you know,
while I'm still involved in Salwa conservation,
because, you know, the world's a better place
with Salwa in it than without it,
and that's really the only reason I need it.
I'm sure that is something that you and I discussed
when we were on the trail together, Bill,
that the conservation movement
has often justified its goals
only in terms of utilitarian values,
you know, what wildlife can do for people.
And we haven't, in a way, emphasized enough
just the beauty of the wild world
and the creatures that live in it.
So I think that's the message,
that the Salwa Foundation is doing a good job
of getting out there.
Well, thanks.
And again, and this is something
that's been central to George and his career.
Here's another quote from, by George,
from, I think, Tibet Wild,
which I think really aligns with you and me, Bill.
George wrote,
you can do the best science in the world,
but unless emotion is involved,
it's not really very relevant.
Conservation is based on emotion.
It comes from the heart,
and one should never forget that.
Well, you look at the Salwa,
just a photograph,
it is a beautiful animal
with a wide page of markings,
the white of the hoof, and so forth.
So, for adults, I believe that it's beauty.
Wild world is ethnic.
Yeah, exactly.
You know, George, people often ask us,
me or you,
why are you saving Salwa?
What's the point?
Well, one of my responses I noticed,
nobody ever asks the guards at the Van Gogh Museum
or the curators there,
why are you saving Van Gogh's paintings?
Why are you doing all this work?
Well, it's obvious.
You don't have to ask people why they're doing that.
It's this incredible thing of beauty,
the world's better for it being in it.
And I agree with you guys.
That's really all the answer I need for Salwa.
And Bill, I think you're right.
In fact, the utilitarian arguments for conservation,
they can be a bit risky
because they can lack credibility
or just sound a little bit ungenuine
because, you know,
if you go to a conservation conference
and you have all these dedicated conservationists there,
you know, people like you and me and Schaller,
and you look out on that sea of faces,
not one of them got into animals and conservation
as a young person for utilitarian benefit.
They got into it because they love it,
and they got into it with their heart.
And I think we need to be confident enough to just say,
look, I'm just doing this because I love it
and I think it's worthwhile.
You know, we always kind of feel the need to make us,
yeah, this utilitarian excuse for conservation.
And I don't know if that's particularly helpful
because that's not why any of us got into it.
So we should just, you know, speak from the heart
and speak honestly,
and I think people can respond to that better in some ways.
How do you convince local people?
Is that the reasoning?
They can make so much money.
In Vietnam, they wiped out the last rhinos.
Right.
They can make thousands of dollars.
Thailand can bring several thousand dollars in products
selling body parts to China.
Yeah.
Yeah, this is true.
And you're also, yeah, you're not going to worry
about the utilitarian arguments.
But who knows?
Maybe somebody, you know,
typically some of the best kinds of local conservation
in Laos is for reasons like,
there's areas in Laos, you know,
where the local people protect gibbons,
you know, the small ape,
because they say they're a lot like people.
They look like people.
They live in small family groups like people,
and we just like them so we don't kill them.
So again, it's the reasons we see local conservation.
They can be for economic benefit.
Local people may do it.
But as you said, it's such a challenge
when the prices are so high
and these animals are killing them.
But in our cases, yeah,
local people will conserve animals
for more heart-centered reasons
or spiritual reasons like taboos
on killing rhinos or wild cattle.
George, another thing you said along the lines,
and I think it's, you said,
although conservation must be scientifically grounded,
it is actually a moral issue of beauty, ethics,
and spiritual values.
And that's something very much
that I very much resonate with.
Getting back to the animites,
which both of you got,
well, all of us have spent a fair bit of time
in the animites.
One of the things, George,
that you recognized is in one advantage
of focusing on conservation of large animals,
which you've done for your whole career,
is you pointed out that a large animal
needs a large area.
So by definition, to conserve a large animal
like a sawa or a Tibetan antelope
or, you know, tiger or Serengeti lion,
you need a large area.
And then by doing that,
by protecting that large area
to protect that animal,
you get a lot of smaller animals
in the package in the whole ecosystem.
So is it fair to say
that's been part of your approach and career?
Well, that's very true.
That's one reason.
But if you're a field biologist,
unless you have independent wealth,
you depend on research grants.
So if you pick a large animal
that gets some interest,
you're more likely to raise the money to do it
than if you study the striped rabbit in Vietnam,
even though it's unique and local.
Yeah, so the practicalities of economics
raise their head again in that respect.
Yeah, indeed.
George, I understand that you're planning
to go back to Nepal and Brazil
in the coming months or in the next year.
Is that right?
The government has been very cooperative
and they've asked me to come back.
So even at age 90,
retirement does not seem to be on your radar or agenda.
What do you mean by retirement?
That reminds me of...
I was in Switzerland recently.
I saw Bruce Springsteen in Kassel in Zurich,
and it was fantastic.
And I saw an interview with him several years ago
when he was in his 60s, about 10 years ago,
and they said,
Oh, Bruce, are you still going to be touring
when you're in your 70s?
And without hesitation, he said,
Of course I will.
This is what I love to do.
It's what I've always loved to do.
So why should I stop?
And I hear George Schaller and field work
for large wildlife in that answer as well.
And it is something useful.
George, what are you going to be doing in Nepal?
Are you going back to Dalta?
Yeah.
The whole economy in that area is changing,
or has changed, rapidly.
And I want to see what's been going on.
I haven't been back since 2016.
So is Dhopo the area that you traveled with Peter Matheson
when he did the book, The Snow Leopard,
and the area Bill DeVries traveled
for his recent book, The Trail to Kondoroba?
Is that Dhopo?
Yes.
Yeah, in both cases.
Okay.
Bill, do you want to just say a little bit about,
I mean, you were in Dhopo just in the last several years,
and certainly you had in mind,
and I think you were sort of tracing some of the trails
that George Schaller had been on with Peter Matheson
in the early 70s.
Any reflections on changes that you saw
in the intervening decades there?
Well, like every place, it's a complex situation.
The recent years, recent decades,
especially since the Civil War
and through the Civil War in Nepal,
many, many people left the rural areas
and went to Kathmandu and other urban centers.
And so the village world in Dhopo
and other remote regions of Nepal
was substantially depopulated
as people sought livelihoods in the cities.
But COVID reversed that migration
because life in the city was intolerable
and people moved back to where they could raise food
because the tourist economy of Nepal absolutely crashed.
So where does it stand with that push and pull right now?
I certainly couldn't say.
I'll be really interested to hear
what George learned from his trip
because nothing stays the same
and the ecological changes with climate change
in that region are also part of the push and pull
and are very powerful.
Yeah.
And we're seeing the same thing in the Andamike Mountains
where a lot of the villages that you and George went to,
I've been to,
there is this sort of depopulation
of the young people moving down to the cities
to accept jobs, working in restaurants or whatever.
There's also the risk of some of them
getting caught up in the human trafficking
that goes across the border to Thailand.
One thing that we found as a consequence of this,
it's harder to find local people in the villages,
younger people who know as much about wildlife
and the forest and the local ecologies
as they did 10, 20 years ago
because they seem less interested in going in the forest now.
You know, they want to go down
where they have cell phone connection in the villages.
One thing I'm proud of in the Sao Laos Foundation
is we put together this Lao team
to help us do the intensive Sao Laos search.
We've got a team of about 30 Lao field workers.
They're going to be detection dog handlers
and wildlife trackers and logistical support.
And a lot of them are recruited from villages in the Sao Laos range.
So we're finding a way for them to find employment
but to stay in the forest.
And in our view, that's a good thing.
The issue for Sao Laos and local people up in the forest
killing it for food,
it's these organized commercial poaching gangs
who are often based in the cities coming in and poaching.
And actually having local people in the forest
can be a bit of a deterrent to that.
Plus they can also be the eyes and ears
for both Sao Laos and for threats.
That makes me think about some of the people we were with
when we went to the Nam Yang in 2011, Bill.
Have you been back to Ben Lomoy, for instance, and Gong Chan?
I have been back, but actually not in,
God, it's been a few years because COVID shut everything down.
So like you, I haven't been back to Laos now since COVID
but only to the city about six months ago.
So I've been wondering about Gong Chan
and his liver is given out yet for his fondness for the drink.
But I really am planning to get back up there
and see if Gong Chan is there and Mr. Tsai,
who was the great tracker and Sao Lai expert.
I did run into Vieng Tsai, who was kind of,
he was the guy, he's great at a drinking party in the village,
but he was a pain in the ass in the forest.
He found a job down in town.
I ran into him working as like a security guard
at a hotel or something down in the town of Macay afterwards.
That's mind-blowing.
He was really a persistent difficulty for a three-day long trip.
Yeah, and I read about, you know, reading like Tibet Wild
and George's challenges with like just some of his,
you know, the drivers, the truck drivers,
trying to get across the Tibetan steppe
who just decided they weren't going to drive the truck anymore.
They had enough and, you know, what can you do?
And certainly, George had a lot of experience with that and his adventures.
So one thing that I'm wondering,
how do you solve the poaching problem in Annamarie
or anywhere else?
Because as you mentioned,
you can walk for hours, days, and you don't see an animal,
not even a monkey in these areas.
And you have snare lines, fences built several hundred yards long
with a snare each, and animals can't fly that.
If you send in a guard to destroy it,
will the local people tolerate it?
That's a really interesting question
and something we've been, you know, looking at
and well working on for decades now.
So one answer is the local people do tolerate it.
In fact, they're quite happy because,
at least on the Laos side of the border, to be honest,
most of the snaring is done by Vietnamese
coming across the border from Vietnam.
Because, you know, in Vietnam,
the population is 100 million people.
With all these trade connections to China,
you know, in Laos, the population is only 6 million people,
mostly farmers.
So the villagers are actually happy to have,
you know, they're afraid of these organized poacher gangs,
and they're actually happy to have patrols go up
and kind of take care of it
so they don't have to run into and confront them.
On the wider issue, and we actually,
we had programs where villagers were earning money
by collecting snares.
They would go out and we would pay them,
like I think there was a while
we were paying like 25 cents a snare.
And if they collected hundreds of snares,
they could make actually quite a lot of money.
On the other question of how, you know,
what you guys have talked about is, you know,
at the end of the day, you know,
conservation, you know, does need to come from the heart.
People have to want to do it.
They'll always find a way around the rules and regulations.
And I think what's essential is the work of groups
like WildAid that are working on the demand side
with these like publicity campaigns in China
using like Jackie Chang and Yao Min, the basketball player.
Because I think my experience of human nature is
you have to get the demand countries
and the people in the urban centers
to just stop wanting to buy wildlife.
But that takes a generation,
I think for those attitudes to change.
So the way I look at what we're doing is
you got these great organizations like WildAid
working on reducing the demand for wildlife
in source countries like China and urban centers in Vietnam.
But at the same time,
you need other conservation organizations on the ground
like WCS or WWF or the Salwa Foundation
trying to keep some of these animals alive long enough
until that demand can go away, you know, in 20 years.
And WildAid is having quite a lot of success
in reducing demand for things like shark fin and other wildlife.
And our hope with the Salwa Foundation
is keep some of the beautiful Salwas alive
until areas of the forest
aren't under such pressure from the poaching.
Because as you've seen, George and Bill, both of us,
you know, we did a lot of snare collection.
We collected hundreds of thousands of snares.
But you get in this economic bind where
as these animals get rarer, the price goes up.
So the motivation for the poachers to go into the forest
and keep setting more snares increases.
So we finally concluded, well, not just us,
the International Union for the Conservation of Nature,
IUCN and the IUCN Salwa Working Group,
everybody finally recognized that
we couldn't save Salwa in the forest.
And I think Bill Dubuis, you saw that, you know,
in the kind of tone when we were there together.
The snaring, despite all the efforts of the increased patrolling,
the snaring was outpacing it.
And so the only hope for Salwa now
is to get some of them into safe captivity
and then work on, you know, getting these landscapes protected
to where you can eventually release them someday.
So I think the short answer, George,
is you have to have long-term vision
and people working at both sides of the issue.
Both the immediate killing of the animals in the forest,
trying to limit that as much as possible
and doing what you can for the animals
while you reduce the human desire to do these things.
It certainly is a risk.
I mean, as you know,
Salwa has never been kept in captivity successfully, you know.
But also Salwa has never been kept by anybody
with professional expertise in the keeping of hoofed animals.
All the Salwa that have been in captivity in Laos and Vietnam
have just been kept in an ad hoc fashion
by Department of Forestry guys or, you know, villagers.
And certainly a captive breeding program for an animal
which there are none in captivity now is very risky.
But our belief is that leaving Salwa in the forest
with all the snares is riskier.
So we don't have a risk-free option to save Salwa
and we're just going for what
basically the global conservation community has agreed
is the least risky option that we have.
And Bill, the captive breeding of Okapi
has been sort of an inspiration along this line, hasn't it?
Yeah, it has.
And in fact, on the advisory council of the Salwa Foundation
is Steve Schurter.
And Steve Schurter is one of the guys
who figured out how to find Okapi,
which is another large, rare tropical ungulate, rarely seen.
I mean, most people know Okapi,
but it's this giraffe relative of Central African forests
that, like Salwa, was discovered very late.
I think it wasn't discovered until, like, 1901 or 1910.
And Steve Schurter is one of the guys
who figured out how to find Okapi, capture them,
and how to keep them successfully in captivity.
So that's exactly why we brought his expertise
into the Salwa Foundation.
Can I... I want to share a little story
about George is very famous for snow leopards.
I think, George, weren't you the first one
to photograph a snow leopard in the wild?
Do I have that fact correct?
I don't know if I was the first one,
but people claim it.
Okay, well, we'll claim it for you.
So, when you and I were doing a survey together
in Laos in... it was probably about 1995,
and we were out in this forest area,
and we passed a big...
We were headed towards a campsite,
and we passed a big fig tree and fruit,
which often tracks a lot of animals.
Then we went another hour or so, and we made camp.
And we were with our pal, Mr. Kam Koon.
And then our destination...
We were going to a village.
We were trekking towards a village
for our next stop that night.
There are no roads in this area.
We were just on hiking trails.
And what I asked for...
I said, early in the next morning,
I'm going to go hide before dawn
under this fig tree and just see
what animals come into it.
And why don't you and Kam Koon and the porters,
you keep going down the trail,
and I'll catch up to you in the village
later in the day.
So I did that, and I had a fantastic morning.
It was like this...
Gibbons came into this fig tree
and these great hornbills,
you know, these huge birds.
And it was full of birds.
And I was so excited.
And I just had to tell the great George Schaller
about all this.
Because I just want to say,
you've been very important to my family
for a long time, but you don't even know.
My late older brother has been calling you
Serengeti George for years.
And I think he gave me the Serengeti lion
as my high school graduation gift.
And then when he heard I was working
with you, he said, Oh God!
Say hi to Serengeti George for me!
And so forth and so on.
So anyway, I catch up with you in the village
later that day, and I just run
on and on about all the great things I saw.
And you got this little
mischievous,
shite-eating
grin on your face.
And then I finally said, Oh, did you and Kam Koon
see anything on the walk to the village?
And you say, Yeah.
Saw a clouded leopard
right in the middle of the day,
20 yards. First one I've ever seen.
God,
I couldn't believe it.
You were walking to the village, and like you always do,
you walked in front so you could see the wildlife.
And you came around a corner on a trail,
and there was a clouded leopard sitting on the trail.
The first clouded leopard ever seen
by George Schaller.
Are you still the only biologist
who's seen
all of the
big Asian cats
firsthand?
I have no idea.
I saw that reported about you
at some point.
I can't remember the source.
I can't keep track of that.
And you know, when you were in
Laos, so we were both working for the
Wildlife Conservation Society, and I remember
I started my career
sort of like you. We both started studying birds
in college and high school, and then
I was, you know, I'm not a mammologist,
and when you were in Laos in the mid
1990s, and you went
out with the late Alan Rabinowitz, who was my
boss at the time, as director of the Asia
program, you and Alan did
one of the first field surveys for
saula, and you published a paper on that
in the journal Oryx about all the stuff
you'd found about saula on the field in Laos.
And I remember I asked you,
I said, George, look,
you've defined your career.
And you were in your, I think,
mid-60s then. You were still very young.
And I said, you defined
your career as being the first
biologist to study some little
known large animal
in the wild. I mean, you started with
the mountain gorilla in 1959,
and then you went on to tigers and
Serengeti lion and jaguar,
you know, the first Westerner allowed into China
to study giant pandas.
And I said, why aren't you settling down in
Laos and making saula your
retirement project? I just thought
you and Kay were going to move
to Laos and you were going to start studying saula.
And you just said,
Well, it feels good, obviously.
Yeah, I guess so. Well, thank you
for leaving it to me.
But I remember what you said.
You said, well,
how do you study an animal you can't even
see? I'm going back to the Tibetan
Plateau where I can actually see
what I'm studying. That was your answer.
Well, that makes sense.
And I still haven't
seen a saula in the wild.
You know, I've seen Martha the captive,
but I've still not seen one in the wild that I know of.
Well, the fact of the matter
is, all these rare species
from the Annamites,
they're usually discovered
as horns and antlers
nailed to a girl's wall.
Yeah, that's what you and I,
you and Kham Khun, when we were in
another part of Laos, we were down in a
village in the province of
St. Kwan, which is one of the most
bombed areas of the
war. You know, U.S.
Air Force turned Laos into the
most bombed country in history, and part
of that was around this area where we
were. Yeah, we were down in the village,
and we found in the village
they had a pair of
very small mudjack
antlers. They had a little antler
trophy, but the antlers,
these barking deer antlers, were tiny.
And, you know,
it looked a bit strange, so we
paid a bit of money
for this, you know, a couple dollars for
this set of antlers.
And then
your colleague at WCS at the time,
George Amato, did a genetic analysis,
and it turns out that you'd rediscovered
Roosevelt's barking deer,
Roosevelt's mudjack, which
was known from one
specimen collected by the sons
of Teddy Roosevelt in northern Laos
in like the 1920s
and hadn't been seen since.
So, yeah, and Rob Timmons, our
technical director at the Saola Foundation,
he discovered that striped rabbit from
a specimen in a food market in Laos.
He discovered an entirely
new mammalian family,
this weird rodent, the Kanyu,
from a food market in Laos.
We discovered, you know,
first records of some birds
in Laos by going to the fresh food
markets, fortunately.
Good news is that's much less common.
I mean, the markets that are selling wildlife
for food that people shoot,
and that was really common in the 1990s.
And the government really has made
a lot of good progress in, you know,
making that more
difficult for people to do.
So we're not discovering as many new species
anymore because we can't find them in the food markets.
So I guess we have to get out in the forest.
The wonderful thing is
you now have this technology
by George Amato uses the DNA
to separate the different
you know, to make sure
Right, and that's one thing
we're really grateful to
WCS, the Wildlife Conservation Society,
for. We partnered with their
molecular genetics laboratory.
And in the last year, they've developed
for us this Salwa-specific
rapid DNA test kit.
So if we find
some Salwa sign, like, you know,
some droppings that we think are Salwa,
thanks to this WCS test kit,
we can test it and get an answer
within an hour in the field.
And that's a potential game changer
for finding and protecting
Salwa. Excellent.
Bill DeVries, I want to read another quote
from, I think
from The Last Unicorn,
your wonderfully eloquent book.
And again, I think it's,
you know, Salwa
is a different kind of animal to conserve
because it's, you know,
it's never been seen in the wild by a biologist.
And so we're always just kind of
out there with hope.
And we often get asked, God,
how do you keep up your enthusiasm?
How do you do this? And for me,
I think you said it succinctly.
You wrote, quote,
put a horse in an empty meadow
and the meadow becomes animate.
Put a Salwa,
even a Salwa you cannot see
in a forest, and the forest
as though it held a unicorn
acquires an energy that cannot
be named. It becomes
numinous. It gains the pull of
gravity, the weight of water, the
float of a feather.
And that's so beautifully said.
And I don't know about you, Bill and George,
but, you know, when we're, when we walk
around the animites,
just knowing there are Salwa
probably there and you could meet one
if you come around a corner like George met
a clouded leopard. I mean, that's
enough juice to keep me going when I'm there.
I don't know if you guys feel the same way.
Well, Bill, one thing I should
say about
The Last Unicorn, if that book
has any merit, it's not
least because your spirit
runs all the way through it.
You are
so eloquent yourself
that it made it
so much easier for me
to write about those
challenges and that
landscape, thanks to your
narration of it as we
travel through it.
Oh, well, thank you very
much. Thank you. You know, it's
an incredibly inspiring
place. And I think, again,
I'm always, I've taken a lot
of pages out of George Schaller.
One thing that George
did, you know, with the Tibetan Antelope
and the Changthang is he just stuck with it.
He kept going back to
Changthang and searching for the
calving ground of Tibetan Antelope.
You know, George, it took you, what,
like 20 years to find those calving
grounds, but you stuck with it.
You made a tremendous
contribution by
picking that place
and becoming committed to it.
And that's something that, you know, all of us at the
Selva Foundation have picked up with the Antelope
Mountains now. Well, I think
the Tibetan Antelope now are
increasing again because China
gives it better protection.
Yeah, and I think
we're seeing the same thing play out with
Selva and Laos. The Lao government
has really gotten, you know, serious about
saving it. You know, whether we're in time or not,
you know, with the support
of the world, because we can't do this alone,
we're going to find out very soon,
within the next two years. So it's
quite an exciting time.
You know, like you searched for Tibetan Antelope
for years. We're
searching for Selva.
I have a better vision now.
I can see for miles across
the plains.
Yeah, I
read Tibetan Wild, I envy you.
Oh, we saw like 2,000
Tibetan Antelope today. I said,
God, lucky son of a gun. That would be nice,
you know. But, you know, they're
similarly beautiful animals. I mean,
the Churu, the Tibetan Antelope,
is so freaking beautiful.
But it really wasn't that well
known, like, until you put it on the radar.
But I see a lot of kinship
with Selva.
Well, yeah, it was too well known to the
people buying the scars, for sure.
You just got to keep at it.
And you and Tibetan Antelope
I think had something stacked against you
that Selva doesn't have. It's people actually
trying to kill it. You know, for those
who don't know the story, in the 1990s
these scars
shot toosh made from
the incredible fine underwool
of a Tibetan Antelope
that they would sell for thousands of dollars.
The only way you could get this was
to kill these Tibetan Antelopes.
And they were being wiped out for this trade.
And George was a significant
player in bringing attention to this
to the world. But you really had,
you know, people were out trying to
search for those Tibetan Antelope
and kill them. And you were kind of racing
the poachers of the last Tibetan Antelopes.
That's something, you know,
we're not having to deal with
Selva. Nobody's out trying to find the last
Selva. So hopefully that will give us
a little bit of hope and edge
in saving from extinction.
It's very similar.
You're out there connecting
these possible poachers.
Bill, I've got a question
for you. And that is, can you
just guess for us a little bit
the timeline that you see
right now in the search
for Selva? I know
Rob and
the rest of the field team are
moving into the field now, are they not?
They are. Yeah, in fact, Rob
flew to Laos two days ago,
two to three days ago.
Our expert wildlife tracker
based in Wisconsin
like me, Matt Nelson, he's one of the best
wildlife trackers in the United States
and probably the world. He was
helping a neighbor shovel something
last week and the
handle of the shovel slipped and
knocked off the
meniscus on his kneecap
or something.
So his flight, his trip to Laos is delayed.
He's got to go in for an MRI
in the next few days, but I just texted
him. He thinks he's okay and he'll be able to travel
soon. So things are accelerating.
So Rob's going back to the field.
The field team has assembled
the dogs, the first detection dogs,
are due to arrive in the next couple months.
As you know,
our goal is to field this
entire innovative,
integrated team and keep them
fully supported for
24 months in the field. We think that's
the best chance for Salwa and
we're just about to start that.
And I'd just like to give a shout out. We just heard
in the last couple of days
Ocean Park
Zoo in Hong Kong
has joined our Salwa
Gold Circle and
they've just contributed $50,000
to the Salwa search and we're so
grateful because it's that kind of support
that's going to get this done. And it's so
cool to see an institution
in Asia because
Salwa is an Asian species
and now we have this institution in
Hong Kong supporting
the conservation of another Asian
species. So things are going
and the other good news, Bill, is
we're not
positive how to identify
Salwa tracks, at least not yet
because there's other animals,
hoofed animals in its range
are about the same size and
that's why we need these sign detection dogs
to verify. But in the
area where the team has
been starting to do some
preliminary searching based on
information from local people,
they've been finding a lot of ungulate
sign and ungulate droppings.
A lot of it is probably this
wild goat type thing
that's found there, the serow,
but certainly some of the tracks they're finding
are consistent with what could
be Salwa. In fact, one of them
took just a photo
video, a long video with this film
camera of a serow walking around
the forest. And
a serow is about the same size
as a Salwa and if they're still there
and like sort of semi-tame enough to
be filmed with a smartphone,
this gives us
hope that there still can be Salwas there
as well. So, so far the news is
all really good. We're finding
sign of ungulates
at a much higher rate than we expected
going into this area.
So this is an area that we found that hasn't been
wiped out yet by all the sneering and the poaching.
So the news is good.
News is quite good. That's really
wonderful. And I did
get to see the video of the serow
and it was amazing
in that the animal was plainly
aware of the humans
who were making the video
and yet
it stayed in the area.
So
it's even enchanting to
see that. Right.
Well, I just want to thank
both of you for your time.
And I want to wrap up again a couple
pages out of George's book.
One thing to remember is
George said, very
astute I think, he wrote,
there are never victories in conservation.
If you want to save a species
or a habit, it's a fight forevermore.
You can never turn your back.
Conservation isn't a destination.
It's a journey. It's something
you always have to do.
And George also reminded
us of a quote,
the Dalai Lama said,
ultimately the decision to
save the environment must come from
the human heart. And both
of you guys have contributed a lot to
that, just through George
and his example of working from the heart.
You know, for 70 years
George Chow has been doing field work from the heart.
And Bill, your
beautiful book, The Last Unicorn,
I mean, written with the heart.
You know, I've asked donors, you know, given us
big chunks of money, and they'll say,
how did you ever find us and find Sala?
And one of them said to me recently,
that book, The Last Unicorn,
that's what got me involved.
And both of you
just, you're always working from the heart.
That's so inspirational.
Because at the end of the day, that's what conservation needs
most, is inspiration. So I just
want to give thanks and a shout out to both
of you.
Thank you.
Alright, thanks George.
George, when are you
coming back to Laos?
Well, why don't
you come visit?
Yeah, we're fantastic.
Our Laos programs
director, Ole, who I've known
since he was a kid, he's
just brilliant. And he's put together
just a really fantastic team.
George, how about you come visit the
first Salas when we get them into the
captive breeding program?
Well, look at it.
It's one of the few large animals
in the world you haven't seen. So I think you
need to come to Laos. I'm going to give you a call
when we have some, and you can come to
cross that T in your career.
Oh, okay.
Well, that'd be fun.
Alright George, thank you very much.
And Bill Buis, we want you
to get back to
Salas habitat. You can do some
more eloquent writing about this search.
So I hope we can work that out.
I'd love to do it.
I'd love to get
back on the trail with you, Bill, one of
these days. Likewise. Thanks very much.
