This Putnam Integral Looks Impossible

"Physics & Astronomy"
21 followers
Okay, this is Putnam math competition integral. So we have integral from 0 to 1 ln of 1 plus x
over 1 plus x square dx. So we have this logarithm on your numerator. So looks like we should be
using some clever substitution that turns this logarithm into something complementary.
So there's a classic sub between 0 and 1 saying we can just say x as 1 minus t over 1 plus t.
Just a classic sub between 0 and 1. Then we should be changing this lower bound at the
upper bound, right? So for example, when x is going to 0, then obviously your t is going to 1.
And when x is going to 1, your t is obviously going to 0. So we need to switch this lower
bound to the upper bound using t, right? And then since we have dx, let's just get derivative.
So since x is 1 minus t over 1 plus t, let's get derivative on the left and right hand side. So we
have dx. So dx is going to be then quotient rule. We should be squaring the denominator.
Okay, then on the numerator, we should have negative of 1 plus t. And then minus parenthesis
1 minus t. So working this out, it has to be the same as negative 2 over 1 plus t squared.
We have dt of course. Okay, let's talk about this 1 plus x using t, right? So 1 plus x is
then going to be the same as 1 plus 1 minus t over 1 plus t. So that is why this is going to be then
2 over 1 plus t. So ln of 1 plus x is going to be ln of 2 over 1 plus t, right? So ln of 1 plus x
is the same as ln of 2 over 1 plus t. Then we have 1 plus x squared on your denominator. So
let's just talk about 1 plus x squared. So 1 plus x squared is the same as then 1 plus parenthesis
1 minus t over 1 plus t squared. Okay, then if you're working this out, then it has to be the
same as then parenthesis 1 plus t squared over 1 plus now t entire thing squared. Now that minus
1 minus t squared over 1 plus t squared. Okay, so that's why if you work this out,
then it has to be 2 parenthesis 2 parenthesis 1 plus t squared that over 1 plus t entire thing
squared. Okay, then I'll be calling this integral as just the i, right? And since we're switching
the lower bound and the upper bound, right? So your integral i is then going to be the same as
integral from 1 to 0. Okay, then we should have ln of 2 over 1 plus t and that divided by this
whole thing, right? 2 parenthesis 1 plus t squared over 1 plus t entire thing squared. And then dx
was negative 2 over 1 plus t squared dt, right? So that of negative 2 over 1 plus t entire thing
squared, then we have dt. And if you work this out, then it's still integral from 1 to 0. And
then we have ln of 2 over 1 plus t, the times reciprocal of this denominator, right? So that
times 1 plus t squared over 2 times 1 plus t squared. That times is everything, negative 2
over 1 plus t squared of dt. So it looks like some terms got cancelled out, right?
So we can cancel this 2s out, and then we can cancel 1 plus t squared out. And about this
negative sign, we have integral from 1 to 0 of everything, right? So we can just switch this
lower bound and the upper bound by pulling negative sign out. So this negative sign and that negative
comes positive. So this integral has to be then the same as integral from 0 to 1 of everything,
right? So it is going to be then ln of 2 over 1 plus t. And then that times we have 1 over 1 plus
t squared. And we have dt. Since we have 1 plus t squared in your denominator, it looks like this
is going to be related to our tangent, right? So writing this nicely, it is integral from 0 to 1
of ln of 2 over 1 plus t. That over 1 plus t squared. Then we have dt. And about the numerator, ln of
2 over 1 plus t. We can rewrite this as ln of 2 minus ln of 1 plus t. So that is why this integral
i, we can rewrite this. Integral i has to be then the same as integral from 0 to 1 of ln 2 minus
ln of 1 plus t. That divided by your denominator was 1 plus t squared dt. So that we can separate
this integral into two integrals. So this is then the same as, let me just pull this ln of 2 out
first. That times integral from 0 to 1 of just the dt over 1 plus t squared. Then minus integral from
0 to 1 of ln of 1 plus t over 1 plus t squared dt. This is your integral i. But then again looking
at the second integral. The second integral is exactly this integral i that we're looking for,
right? So this integral is just the same as integral i. So that is why if you add i to both
then 2 times i. 2 times integral i that we're looking for is just going to be the same as ln
2 times integral from 0 to 1 of dt over 1 plus t squared. So this integral is typical r tangent,
right? So about this integral, it is just going to be the same as just r tangent of 1. That's it.
And r tangent of 1 is equal to pi over 4. So that is why 2 times integral i is the same as
pi over 4 times ln 2. So integral i that we are looking for. So i integral i is the same as pi
over 8 that times ln of 2. This is the answer to the question. Okay so pretty interesting integral
that we use clever substitution to turn this logarithm into something complementary. How amazing!
