---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Remember, in filmmaking there's no problems, just a lack of solutions!
My name is Tom Antos. I am a film director and cinematographer with over 25 years experience in VFX & animation.
--------------------------------------------- DISCLAIMERS: Some of my links have an affiliate code, allowing me to make a small commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Thanks!
The opinions expressed in this video were not influenced by or paid for by any outside individual or company. I use and test lots of products that are sent to me or that I buy myself. In the end, I only talk about the products that I find interesting. ----------------------------------------------------------- In this video, I compare three different gimbals from DJI, including the latest new dji gimbal, the RS5, alongside the dji rs 4 pro and dji rs 3 pro. The main difference between these camera gimbal models is their size, as the RS4 Pro and RS3 Pro are the "pro" versions. I discuss how to use a gimbal effectively and express my interest in comparing an RS5 Pro if it becomes available, but for now, DJI we're looking at the current dji gimbal lineup.
Hi guys, in this video I'm going to be comparing three different gimbals I got from DJI.
I've got here in the middle of course the RS5, the latest one.
I also got the RS4, this is the pro version, and another RS3 pro version.
Probably the biggest difference between these gimbals is actually the size,
and the reason is because these are the pro versions.
This one is the standard one of DJI releases, an RS5 pro.
I'm definitely going to be getting that so I can kind of compare it.
But yeah, the size is the biggest thing because these can technically take a bigger payload,
but usually for that means you're going to have a bigger camera or maybe bigger lenses,
so the handle basically here, like the main arm here,
needs to be longer and kind of extend more to be able to accommodate for that.
Now when it comes to the bottom of these gimbals here,
what I mean is the tripods and then the batteries,
they all look pretty much identical, but they are actually not identical.
The biggest difference is obviously the battery capacities,
and also the rate at which they can charge.
So out of those ones, I mean, you know, when it comes to like the charge rate,
the RS5 is the best, so that's something you care about.
That's probably, you know, what you're going to choose.
And also they do have different capacities,
but anyways I'm going to put all that info up on the screen or on my website tomantosfilms.com,
so if you guys are interested in all those little specs,
go check that out, follow the links in the description.
Another thing is the tripods.
The tripods actually look identical,
and if you look at it, like this version for example compared to here,
this is the RS3, RS4, they all are pretty much identical, I don't see a difference.
But the RS5 looks identical, but it's not,
and the reason is because when you open or close the tripod legs,
it doesn't matter basically which one you grab,
but they all actually, you know, the three of them do it basically in sync.
But that's really the only difference between it.
And it is a nice sort of added new sort of feature or upgrade.
Not that there's anything wrong with the other older tripods,
because they are very stable,
but they just, you know, again, if you want to fold it,
you have to kind of go through the trouble of doing that or this.
Another thing maybe when it comes to the build I'll talk about are the handles.
So all of them do come with handles,
or it depends, you know, which versions you get and stuff.
But yeah, the handles on the RS3 and RS4 are identical,
meaning, you know, you have the sort of adjustment for this angle,
and, you know, you can lock it here.
You have a cold shoe mount here on the top,
and then you have a quarter 20 mount,
so you can, for example, attach a monitor here in the back of these,
or on the top of these handles.
Now these handles, at first glance at least,
they look the same, but they're actually not.
What I mean by that is that both the RS3 and the RS4 are kind of the same size.
The sort of a side arm that attaches to the gimbal is the same,
but the biggest difference is that on the RS5,
you have the actual contacts here, electronic contacts.
So that means that when you put it in there,
it'll actually connect electronically to your gimbal.
Another little thing also is this little safety latch that you have.
So now as you put this in, it kind of locks it in there,
and even before, you know, you had a chance to really tighten this,
it's already kind of holding the gimbal.
Or, for example, if you're using this and if this ever gets loose,
well, it's not going to fall down like, for example, it will on the previous gimbals.
This will just fall out.
There's nothing to really kind of hold it in place.
Another thing is that because this now electronically,
you know, connects to the gimbal itself,
it also means that on the back of the handle here,
you actually have your joystick,
you have the record button and the M button.
So just like you have on the back of these gimbals,
but, you know, you don't have it on these handles.
And that means that now when you're, for example,
in briefcase mode, holding the gimbal like this,
you can still control the position of the gimbal with this,
or this could be controlling your focus motors,
or start and stop the camera,
or whatever it is that you program these buttons to do.
So that's kind of a nice addition that you don't have to now,
you still, but like, for example, hold it here,
but still be, you know, the operator or just certain things
here on the back of the gimbal itself.
Another thing is just the way that the different axes sort of are connected.
It's like little things that are kind of different between these gimbals.
I'll tell you this, the RS3,
not that there was anything wrong with it.
I mean, I think it was a great gimbal.
But yeah, for example, when you want to adjust,
like, let's say this, you know, here,
the pan axis, you want to adjust that,
you basically just have like a latch, you loosen it,
and then you have to push this back and forth.
And what I find with this is that it's,
it has this carbon fiber design that it's kind of rubberized.
And it's a little bit hard sometimes,
especially once you have the weight of the camera on this,
like kind of like, it's hard to do this sort of fine kind of adjustments
because sometimes you want to move it just a little bit.
And then like this, this thing will kind of skip.
Sometimes it's like there's friction,
and sometimes it just seems to go.
So that's one thing.
And that's basically the same on all the axes.
I especially found it annoying here on the roll axis.
Like if you unlock this, and then, you know, especially again,
once you have your camera with a lens and everything up there with the weight,
and then it's pressing down on this,
then it's really hard sometimes to kind of smoothly adjust this.
Even right now without anything on it, it's kind of hard.
Well, with the RS4 at least,
they improved it slightly by adding sort of a,
like it feels almost like a little Teflon kind of nonstick coating.
It's a little bit better, but at least still have a similar kind of issue
where kind of those fine adjustments are not,
yeah, basically not all the way there.
Now, when it comes to the RS5,
the nice addition is that now they added an even better coating.
I guess it's like really smooth.
That really doesn't stick at all.
Plus they added these fine sort of adjustment knobs.
So when you loosen, like for example, the roll axis here,
you don't have to push it.
Like if you want to, you could do it,
but you actually just have a knob and it allows you just by,
you know, turning it to adjust it.
And, you know, you have your marks there,
so you can adjust it like a tiny little bit left or right,
you know, and really dial it into the setting.
And this works really well, even when there's weight here from a camera,
you can really fine tune and get that position perfectly.
And then kind of lock it in there.
So that again, it just means that you can dial in
and balance your gimbal a lot quicker
than you can with the other two gimbals.
And that's actually probably the biggest sort of,
I would say, improvement on this gimbal for me, at least.
When I first got my hands on this and I started using it,
you know, when you're using the gimbal itself,
like once it's balanced,
then I find that they're all very similar.
Like they'll all produce smooth shots.
They all have pretty simple, you know,
user interface and like calibration and settings that you can do,
the controls of the gimbal.
But this alone, I would say is like, you know,
if you're willing to spend the extra money
and upgrade for the latest gimbal,
then I would say that's a nice new feature.
Now, another big upgrade on the RS5
is that it now comes with a tracking module camera.
It's nice, black and matches the color of the gimbal itself.
And just like on the RS Mini, for example, gimbal,
this now comes included.
And you can use it essentially to track an object.
So it doesn't matter what your camera sees or doesn't see.
This actually has its own camera
and you'll actually be able to see it here
on the back of the screen,
whatever objects it recognizes.
So it actually now recognizes animals, cars, or people.
And then you just tap on, you know,
let's say the object that you want to follow
and it's going to start following it.
You can also use the hand gestures
just like you could on the RS Mini or the RS4, for example.
So you can put your hand up, for example,
to start and stop,
we'll be getting sort of a selfie shot.
And, you know, it is a nice feature to have.
And that's actually something that I added
because it did not come with the RS4 Pro,
but you can buy this as an addition.
It's just like a little here.
Basically, you buy the camera itself
and then with this little adapter.
And so then that actually attaches here
to the back of the gimbal here.
And then once it's there, just lock it.
And now it also works and allows you to use the tracking.
And I find that, you know, to be a great feature,
especially when I'm getting sort of
behind the scenes shots of myself.
Now, if you want to simply get the best deal, you could say,
then you can definitely find the RS3.
This gimbal is basically really good at stabilizing,
just like the other ones are.
It just doesn't have some of these latest features
like the tracking module.
Now, again, how useful is that going to be?
I'll tell you this, in my professional work,
like for films and stuff,
I never actually used this, you know,
on any of these gimbals
because it's still not 100% reliable
and it might improve over time with the software,
but so far it isn't.
When an object is moving too fast,
even like, for example, on the RS5,
it can now track, like I said, cars, animals,
but like my dog running too fast,
it loses it each time.
If a car even passes by, you know, it loses it.
Or for example, if you have more than one subject,
so like two people in the shot,
or let's say two cars,
and especially if they get close to each other
or one passes over the other,
then it just gets messed up pretty much every time
and it loses the tracking.
So it's not something I would really rely on.
For me, what these things are great for is like,
again, if I'm getting a selfie shot of me
for these YouTube videos, like behind the scenes,
and I just want to like be able to talk to the camera
and I don't have anybody operating it for me,
then it's great.
Like I did actually a video about this sort of a robot,
you know, camera system that I created using DGI.
It was actually the RS4 gimbal with that tracking module
and also the Edochrome Dolly 1.
So when you combine it with that,
you essentially can have like a robot
that moves around in your space
and can also follow you in real time,
which is really cool.
And so for those kinds of things,
you know, like I said, it's great.
So maybe for doing like YouTube videos,
that kind of content.
But if you want to be using this
for actual film production or video production
or let's even like, I don't know,
if you're doing live events or weddings,
yeah, forget about it.
You do not want to rely on it because it's not 100%.
And so that's why it's like,
you got to kind of consider,
is it worth spending the extra money for this?
Well, it's really, you know, for you.
With this one, like I said,
you can buy the RS4
and if you don't care about it,
you know, you still have all the other nice features
that the RS4 gives you,
but you don't need to spend money on that.
And not that it's expensive.
I think it was $60 or $80,
but yeah, but then if you want to,
you can always add it in there.
So now when it comes to the actual performance
of this tracking,
supposedly the RS5 has more advanced logarithm.
I don't know why they wouldn't be able to add that
via software update to the RS4,
but supposedly, yeah, supposedly it's better.
But again, in my test,
I have not really seen much of a difference.
But anyways, here's that little test
so you guys can compare it for yourself.
So in this test, you can see up there,
it says what speed setting I had the active track on.
And as you notice here in the slow setting,
it barely basically keeps up.
Now what, you know,
the advantage of being in a slow setting
is that if you're not moving much in front of a camera,
if you're kind of doing more like a talking head
and then you're slightly moving,
then the camera stays pretty steady.
Now this is in medium setting.
And again, you'll notice it's a bit more responsive,
but still I feel like it looks natural, the motion.
Now again, though, if you're really moving quickly,
it's not going to be able to keep up.
And this doesn't matter whether you're tracking a person,
an animal or a car.
Now in the fast setting, it is a little bit better.
You'll notice like if I'm walking around,
but for example here,
when I'm going, see, ducking up and down,
it still, in some cases, will not keep up.
And like in here, see, it kind of got,
was kind of a little jerky there
because sometimes it just completely loses track of you.
And this is especially visible
when you're tracking, for example, cars.
Now I actually got a question from one of my viewers
on my review of the RS5 gimbal
and asking if this tracking module now can do,
for example, follow an object while,
like let's say if you're shooting,
I guess like a talking head,
kind of a tabletop review of a product,
and you want to set this up
so that it's actually following the object
while it's being kind of moved around
by the person in the video.
So anyways, here's a quick little test I did of that feature.
You guys can see for yourself.
So in this test, it's, I right away show you basically
the setting that was done in medium
because tracking speed.
And the reason is because I tried this first
with the active track speed set to low and, or slow.
And essentially it did not work at all.
It was not able to keep up.
So this is on a 15 millimeter lens.
And you see here when I put the phone down too quickly,
it just loses track.
So the tighter the lens, obviously,
the harder it's going to be for the system
to kind of keep track.
Now here is in the fast setting.
And you notice it's a little bit better in keeping track,
but then at the same time, it looks a little jerky
because it's really kind of,
see like tries to sort of,
sometimes almost like it feels like
it wants to overcompensate.
And it moves the camera too far.
But you see, again, when I moved the object down,
then it did not keep up with it.
And then that's it.
At that point, it just loses track.
Now, as far as when it comes to the performance
of these gimbals,
basically how smooth of a shot you're going to get
with these, the ease of use also,
and then just sort of adjusting all your settings.
I find all of them to be pretty much,
you know, at the same level.
They all allow you very quickly
without the use of a phone
to kind of adjust each of these settings here
by using the touch screen,
or you have also these preset buttons
for like, let's say, pen follow,
you know, let's say POV shot,
like all these different modes that you can have.
They all have that nice trigger.
And then these roll,
basically adjustments here now
that you can program them
and make them do different things for you.
And the gimbals, they all have that.
And these all work great.
So, I mean, they're all basically great gimbals
when it comes to just the basic main thing
that they're supposed to do,
which is to produce smooth shots.
It's sort of, you could say,
like if you want a little bit advanced,
you know, or other features
like the vertical shooting
or the, you know, the tracking,
then you can do it with the RS4.
And then if you want to be able to track
more types of objects,
like, you know, cars or animals,
then you're probably going to go with the RS5.
Now, another thing though to consider is,
will you be, well, first of all,
what kind of a camera are you going to be flying?
Because they do have different payload limitations.
Like, for example,
if you're putting a small little DSLR
and you're not going to be putting,
let's say, follow focus
or, you know, video transmitters
and stuff like that,
then you probably don't care
because all of them will do that.
But if you want to put a bigger,
you know, package or bigger payload
with a nice big lens,
follow focus system, all that stuff,
then you're probably going to go
for one of the Pro gimbals.
And, you know, this one has,
I think the biggest payload right now
because there is no RS5 Pro yet
that has come out.
Also, another thing is, for example,
if you already invested
or maybe you're planning to buy
the Focus Pro from DJI,
which I think is a great unit.
It allows you a lot of cool things,
like literally turns your manual,
for example, even anamorphic lenses
into fully automatic lenses,
but also has gives you
some fine-tuned kind of control
if you want to be doing,
you know, remotely operating the focus
for you or for a focus puller.
Then, you know, I think that's one
of the better focus systems out there.
I still have mine and I still use it.
And if that's the case,
if you're going to buy it
or you already own it,
then pretty much that means
the RS5 is definitely not the gimbal for you
because it just doesn't work with that.
Like, yeah, you can put
one of the small motors,
but you cannot use the full RS,
basically, or yeah,
the DJI Focus Pro system
with some of the other advanced features
and stuff like that on that
because it just simply
doesn't communicate with that.
So that's when we probably want to go
with the RS4 Pro gimbal.
Anyways, that's it here
for this comparison of these three gimbals.
Hopefully it answered some questions
for you guys.
If you're kind of wondering
which one to get
and if you enjoyed this video,
I think you'll definitely enjoy my other video
where, like I said,
I created my personal camera assistant robot
using the RS4 Pro and that Edelkon Dolly.
So check that out.
The links for that,
as always, are in the description
or on my website at tomantosfilms.com.
Bye!