The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
UK Constitutional Law refers to the body of law and principles that govern the structure, functioning, and organization of the United Kingdom's political system and government. Unlike some countries with written constitutions, the UK's constitution is not found in a single written document but rather is a combination of various sources, including statutes, conventions, common law, and historical documents.
A. Bradley, K. Ewing & C.J.S. Knight, Constitutional & Administrative Law (18th edn, Pearson, 2022). R. Masterman & C. Murray, Constitutional & Administrative Law (Cambridge University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In the previous lesson we outlined the rule of law as a basic principle of the UK constitution
and the UK's constitutional framework. This lesson is going to examine a very very famous
interpretation of the rule of law coming from arguably one of the greatest constitutionalists
and constitutional theorists that we've ever had in the UK, this obviously being A.V. Dicey.
We're going to talk about what A.V. Dicey interprets the rule of law to be and to mean
and will explain the importance of this interpretation. So the last lesson looked
at the rule of law in a more general framework, talking about the difficulty getting some kind
of definition, talking about Joseph Raza's perception of the rule of law and a number
of the different characteristics, talking about the fact that when we come to define the rule of
law we actually spend more time looking at different things that the rule of law could be
and some of the elements of the rule of law rather than trying to come up with a specific
and a coherent and contingent definition itself that is perfectly self-sustaining.
Well in the same way that we looked at Joseph Raza's theories of the rule of law in the previous
lesson, this lesson is going to look at A.V. Dicey's theory of the rule of law. It's a little
bit more simple, there's a few less characteristics that Dicey associates with the concept of the
and ultimately in his part two of his introduction to the study of the law of the constitution from
1885, one of the all-mentioned cited works of constitutional theory in the United Kingdom,
in fact arguably one of the major sources of the UK's constitution which we'll get to in the future,
what A.V. Dicey does is elucidate what he believes to be just three major principles which
essentially codify and enshrine the rule of law and these three main principles are as follows,
we will get to them in a second, but ultimately he himself understood the rule of law to be one
of if not the most important and one of the most fundamental principles of the UK constitution.
Now there's sometimes a bit of back and forth, a bit of debate about what comes before the other
between the rule of law and the principle of parliamentary sovereignty and there are lots
of different arguments for why the rule of law is more important than parliamentary sovereignty,
there are lots of arguments why parliamentary sovereignty is more important than the rule of
law, but suffice it to say that sovereignty of parliament and the rule of law are the two most
important principles arguably of the UK constitution. The three fundamental principles of the
rule of law then are elucidated as follows by A.V. Dicey, he argues that firstly no one should be
punished except for a violation of the law, part two is that nobody is above the law, the law is
equal and then part three relates to the supremacy of the ordinary law. Okay those are the three
principles, so better than Joseph Raz's seven, eight, nine or ten principles that sort of
encompass ideas relating to the rule of law, we only have to deal with three principles and have
to talk about them in a little bit more detail. So principle one is that no one should be punished
except for a violation of the law, this is the view essentially that the law should not be imposing
arbitrary restrictions, arbitrary power over the citizenry without the due process of law,
it's very very simple. Arbitrary power is subordinate to the authority of the law,
this elucidated some basic principles that we see in not only the glorious revolution of 1688
when parliament invites William of Orange to essentially rule over and reign replacing
James the second, it also is elucidated in the first two articles of the 1689
bill of rights and it makes complete sense, you shouldn't be subjected to the force of the law
without the due process of the law. Okay there is a sort of yin and yang that exists within the
concept of law itself that tells us that a violation of the law is the only condition
for the enforcement of arbitrary power, at least over the law, because otherwise it would be
arbitrary. Law cannot be arbitrary therefore there has to be this due process of law that exists.
In addition to the due process of law and the lack of arbitrarity of law we also have the idea
of the equality of law, okay, the law means, sorry, the law ought to be applied equally to
every person, that's what the law is equal refers to, the idea of the equality of law,
very very simple, okay. Not only does this entail that no person is above the law but it also
entails that there is no bias or arbitrary discrimination of individuals who are under
the law itself. So not only is there no such thing as a person who exists outside of the law
but also for everybody who exists inside of the law there is no discrimination on the basis of
arbitrary bias, okay. Now there's a little bit of debate about this one because ultimately and
theoretically you could make the argument that the monarch is above the law because the monarch
is the person to which all of legal authority and sovereignty comes from, they are the sovereign,
but the extent to which the monarch can actually break the law is debatable because even though
theoretically the sovereign exists as above the law you have the fact that the power of the
sovereign is where law enforcement comes from, you have things like the Crown Prosecution Service,
when you have a criminal case it is the Crown versus the defendant.
If the monarch was to actually break the law it would spark quite an interesting constitutional
debate and the question of whether or not the law is actually something that the monarch is
subjected to is one that is sort of a a grey area in terms of the constitution, it's a murky ground
that ultimately we may have to just wait and see if the monarch ever does break the law as to
whether or not it actually applies equally. The final principle then is the idea of supremacy of
ordinary law. This is the view that the general principles of the constitution are derived from
the ordinary law. At the time this represented the law of judicial decisions, the judge-made
law of the common law essentially and essentially what A. V. Dicey does is note that this is
particularly true regardless of whether or not the particular law is actually good or bad.
So the argument here goes that Dicey is rejecting the notion that there exists some higher authority
within the UK constitution and so he is rejecting the idea that there is some kind of higher
entrenched legal system that would exist in for example a codified document like the US constitution.
So in recognising that there is no codified constitution in the UK and therefore there is
no higher constitutional law that exists similar to that of the provisions of the US constitution
that means therefore that the ordinary law that is non-constitutional is supreme, that is where
the highest source of authority begins and ends. At the time this is representative of the
common law because legislation wasn't as pertinent at the time but it could also be representative as
the idea and the principle of parliamentary sovereignty. Sort of elucidating parliamentary
sovereignty in this principle but also making it very clear that the point of this principle
is that there is no delineation between ordinary law and higher law. Ordinary law
is the supremacy, is the supreme kind of law that exists.