Did Muhammad Exist? | The Historical Muhammad

Indian Ancestors
19 followers
6 Video Views·Apr 7, 2026
Hi, welcome to Al Muqaddimah, my name is Syawish.
In 1953, in his book Muhammad at Mecca, William Montgomery Watt says that Islam
was born in the full light of history.
Now, in 1953, that was a largely uncontroversial statement but since then, it has been challenged.
The earliest compiled biographical material for the Prophet's life
dates at least 100 years after his death and those 100 years have been rigorously questioned
by scholars in the decades since 1953.
There are all kinds of questions and hypotheses about him, ranging from disregarding the entire
compendium of Islamic tradition to questioning the very existence of Prophet Muhammad.
Now, questioning his existence is a bit of an extreme position and it's not one that's
taken by many mainstream scholars.
However, in this video, we will take a look at Prophet Muhammad as a historical subject
and answer two questions about him.
First, did Prophet Muhammad exist?
And second, was Muhammad just another name for Jesus?
Before we begin, I'd like to tell everyone that my merchandise store is now up on AlMuqaddimah.com
where you can find really cool wall posters like the Timeline of Islamic History which
condenses 1400 plus years of Islamic history into a beautiful timeline.
There are two versions of that chart, one with portraits of important figures and one
without.
So, you can pick whichever one you prefer.
We also have a map of the fall of Al-Andalus which shows, century by century, how Muslim
empires lost ground in Spain and Portugal until their eventual collapse on the Iberian
Peninsula.
So, be sure to check it out.
That's the best way to support AlMuqaddimah and show off some love for Islamic history.
Alternatively, if you want to support AlMuqaddimah financially, you can join these awesome patrons
over on Patreon.com.
The links to everything are in the description.
Back to the video.
This video is a part of my series called The Historical Muhammad which takes a look at
Prophet Muhammad as a historical subject.
I have other videos about him as well so be sure to check those out if you're interested
in the topic and subscribe for more.
Now, how do we know if a character actually existed?
There are four questions to answer for determining the historiosity of any given figure.
First, contemporary written accounts.
Has this person been mentioned in sources from around the time that they are supposed
to have lived?
Second, archaeological evidence.
Do we have any physical remains from this person?
Maybe inscriptions or coins or even a tomb, although tombs can be faked.
In the modern era, we sometimes use DNA and other scientific methods to determine if a
person's remains are actually authentic.
Third, multiple independent sources.
Is this person mentioned, even in passing, by multiple sources that are disconnected
from each other?
Fourth, consistency across accounts.
Do we generally get the same sketch of this person from the various sources that mention
them?
Fifth, can be the biases of the sources, but if we're just trying to establish a person's
existence, the other four can work just as well by themselves.
Let's apply this to a few historical figures and see how it works out.
Let's take Odysseus, for example.
The first mention of Odysseus comes around 8th century BCE, when he's supposed to have
lived, around the 13th century BCE, so that's some 500 years already after he's supposed
to have lived.
Then, we don't have any archaeological evidence for him.
There are no coins with his name on them, no pieces of pottery, or anything physical
from his time that can be connected to him.
He's supposed to have lived on the island of Ithaca, and while remains have been found
there, nothing there can be connected to Odysseus.
Then, we don't have multiple sources for him.
He's mentioned by Homer, and all subsequent mentions of him come from the legend that
Homer created.
So, they are all connected, and they do paint a consistent and roughly the same picture
of the king.
Hence, all historians believe him to be a legendary, if not mythological figure, meaning
that maybe he's based on some real king or local chief, but we have no evidence to say
that anything that he did or any of his attributes were found in the same person or that he ever
went to Troy, which, by the way, was a real place.
At this point, he's likely entirely fictional.
Let's consider King David from the Bible.
We don't know when the parts of the Bible that mention King David were actually written,
but it's likely from around the 7th century BCE.
David is supposed to have lived around the 11th century BCE.
However, when it comes to David, we do have a mention of him from outside the Bible.
On this stele, called the Tel Dan Stele, a king named Ahaziah is mentioned, who comes
from the house of David.
This stele is from around 870 to 750 BCE, so it's quite a bit after David is supposed
to have lived, but at least it mentions David.
When it comes to archaeological evidence, it doesn't support the kingdom that the Bible
mentions.
Around the time that David is supposed to have lived and ruled a great kingdom, from
his capital at Jerusalem, which likewise is supposed to have been a great city, Jerusalem
was likely just a village, according to archaeological evidence.
However, this stele doesn't tell us anything about who David was, just that a man named
David was remembered as the ancestor of this king, Ahaziah.
So, this leads historians to believe that David was likely a real person, perhaps a
local chief, who founded the dynasty that eventually took his name.
However, nothing else from the Bible about David can be confirmed, so he's likely a
legendary figure.
Let's take one final example, Moses.
We have no contemporary sources for Moses, no archaeological evidence, and no independent
sources.
But here's the interesting wrinkle.
The whole story that revolves around Moses, that of the exodus of the Jews from Egypt,
isn't plausible either.
It simply couldn't have happened.
According to Exodus 1237, there were at least 600,000 men who left.
Those are just men, not counting women or children.
If we assume the same number of women and some random number of children, we get around
1.5 million Jews who left Egypt.
The entire population of Egypt around the time that the exodus is supposed to have happened,
around 1200 BCE, was 3-4 million.
Imagine a country 40% of whose population leaves overnight.
Imagine the economic wreck that would cause.
It would be like a real-life snap by Thanos from Avengers Infinity War.
Even in those movies, we can see the devastation brought by the disappearance of 50% of the
population.
Although they really should have made more movies about that.
They really screwed the pooch on that one.
There could have been a lot more interesting movies about that time period.
Egypt was a highly organized society that kept records.
We find nothing to suggest that 1.5 million people suddenly left Egypt.
Then we have these 1.5 million people wandering in the desert for 40 years and settling in
modern-day Palestine.
They must have left some impact.
1.5 million people.
That's an entire Philadelphia's worth of people.
What were they eating in the desert?
Where were they living?
Where were they pooping?
How did they leave no evidence?
How about when they arrived in Palestine?
Imagine any country taking in 1.5 million people overnight today.
Even the richest country in the world would struggle to house and feed 1.5 million people
in one night.
Canada's population grew by 3 million in 3 years and my stupid rent went through the
roof.
So it's simply not possible based on the evidence that we have.
Hence Moses is likely a mythological figure or at least a legendary figure.
And the exodus, if it even happened, was a very small event.
Some kind of emigration of Semitic people from Egypt which we do have some evidence
for but nothing even remotely on the scale that's mentioned in the Bible.
Now let's take Prophet Muhammad.
Do we have any contemporary sources for him?
Well, yeah.
Kinda.
The prophet is supposed to have passed away in 632 or 634 CE.
The discrepancy comes from the conversion of the Islamic Hijrah calendar to the Gregorian
calendar.
632 is usually the date that's accepted and it's the one that I stick to on my channel.
However, there's a non-Islamic source called the Dr. Rina Yokobi that mentions a prophet
who has appeared among the Saracens or the Arabs.
So this is a very near-contemporary if not contemporary source that mentions a prophet
among the Arabs.
For a man who lived on the periphery of civilization, this is as good as it could get.
Here, it also says that the prophet claims to have the keys to paradise.
We'll come back to that in a minute but keep that in the back of your mind.
Then we have a manuscript that mentions the prophet by name in 637 CE.
So that's just 5 years after the prophet is supposed to have passed away.
It mentions the Arabs of Muhammad.
We have another mention of the Arabs of Muhammad in 640 as well.
So this checks the first and third parts of the criteria.
So far, we know that there was a man named Muhammad who lived at some point around 634.
After all, he's being mentioned as a figure in 634 and who claimed to have the keys to
paradise and whose followers then invaded Syria and Palestine.
Now, do we have any archaeological evidence for the prophet Muhammad?
Not quite in the way that we have for some other figures.
For certain kings and leaders, we have inscriptions or rock carvings mentioning them and something
that they did.
Like, you know, some building could have a carving that goes,
this building was built by XYZ in the year ABC, right?
We don't have evidence like that for prophet Muhammad.
But we do have coins from 687 that mention him.
And then his name is on the dome of the rock in Jerusalem and then a gravestone in Egypt.
Both of these come around 692 CE.
At this point, we get an explosion of the prophet's name being written on all kinds
of things.
And we'll come back to that in a minute as well.
There's stuff that's attributed to the prophet for sure, like his letters to certain
kings and emperors around the Mediterranean, like the Persian and Roman emperors, along
with things that he used.
A lot of these things are currently in Istanbul.
But there's no real way to prove that they are authentic.
As far as the prophet's tomb goes, while I've never seen any credible hypothesis that
it's not the prophet's tomb, for now, let's dismiss it still, just for argument's sake.
Finally, are the sources about prophet Muhammad consistent?
Well, yeah.
Dr. Rina Yaqobi mentions the prophet claiming to have the keys to paradise, meaning that
he is a source of redemption for his followers.
And that's certainly what the Qur'an tells us.
His story is also very plausible.
It takes place in a very real place and a very real setting.
We find it to be consistent with what we know about his surroundings, such as Arabia in
late antiquity from other sources.
Additionally, the prophetic tradition was still quite alive in the Middle East during
late antiquity.
So, a prophet appearing among the Arabs wouldn't be implausible.
So, we can say with certainty that there was a man named Muhammad who claimed to be a prophet
and who claimed to hold redemption for his followers around 634 or so.
That is the view of most scholars.
Even the most critical scholars do believe that prophet Muhammad did indeed exist.
Now, there are those who claim that prophet Muhammad didn't exist and that Muhammad was
merely a title for Jesus.
Muhammad means the praised one.
And I guess Jesus can be called the praised one as well.
But that's pretty much where it ends.
Even then, the name Muhammad, if it was a title, would be accompanied by an article,
the or al in Arabic, but that's not used in any of the earliest sources.
Also, if it was indeed Jesus, where did the name Muhammad come from?
The root of Muhammad in Arabic is ha-meem-dhal and certainly that's found within both Arabic
and Hebrew as words relating to praise and for sure Jesus was praised.
But why did the Arabs pick up an obscure title for Jesus when there's many more common
ones that could have been used?
Why Muhammad?
Especially given that the people who would become Muslim had direct contact with the
Christians of greater Syria.
Arabs of Hejaz, the part of Arabia that Islam originated in, were going up to Syria to trade
and it just seems weird that they'd pick up Jesus but not his name.
It doesn't really make much sense.
Also, in 660CE, we have a source called the Khuzestan Chronicle that clearly mentions
the Prophet as being the leader of the sons of Ishmael.
There was a very clear idea among Christians at the time that the Arabs were Ishmaelites.
Jesus was not an Ishmaelite.
Other sources of the time, including Christian ones, clearly mention that they are followers
of Muhammad whom some even consider to be still alive at the time.
But that's not of concern to this video.
I have a separate video about that.
Then we have a source from 665CE that mentions that Caliph Muawiyah chose to
place his throne in Damascus and refused to go to the seat of Muhammad.
We also have a source from 687CE by one Janbar Pankai who mentions that Muhammad
was the instructor whose tradition these Muslims followed.
Clearly, the Christians didn't think that Muslims were just followers of Jesus.
Some did believe them to be a heretical belief stemmed out of Christianity but even they blamed
Prophet Muhammad for distorting Christianity rather than blaming Muslims for distorting
Jesus into Muhammad.
For example, John of Damascus, in or around 743, writes that Prophet Muhammad devised
his own heresy after having read the Old and New Testaments.
The claim that's usually put forward is that Prophet Muhammad was made up by Umayyad
Caliph Abd al-Malik around 692CE.
So we should expect the mentions of the Prophet before that to look like Jesus, no?
But they don't.
There are no mentions of any kind of resurrection or anything that's usually found in Jesus'
biography.
They don't follow similar archetypes at all.
Prophet Muhammad is very clearly a warrior prophet as told to us by sources from 634
and 660.
And Jesus is the farthest thing from a warrior.
The similarity is literally just that the praised one can be a title for Jesus.
In the same way, my name Siyavash means the one with the black stallion and if you own
a black horse then you're Siyavash too by that logic.
So the date 692 has come up twice in this video so let's talk about that.
When the Prophet passed away in 632, we know that his followers invaded greater Middle
East, Syria, Palestine, Iraq, Iran, and Egypt.
They conquered it and established an empire called the Caliphate.
This empire's population was divided largely between Christians who were previously Roman
subjects and Zoroastrians who were previously Persian subjects.
Now both of these people groups were very adamant about their cultural, religious, and
ethnic identities.
So these Arab Muslims who ruled them, who were a small group of people following some
new kind of religion and who were only a decade earlier naked nomads from the desert, weren't
keen on trying to rub it in their faces that they were being ruled by them.
So the Muslim Arabs stayed in garrisoned towns, away from the Christians and Zoroastrians.
An example of how powerful and influential the Christians and Zoroastrians were still
is that Caliph Muawiyah tried to issue his own coinage but the coins were rejected by
the Christians due to a lack of the figure of Jesus on them and by the Zoroastrians because
they didn't have the figures of their previous kings on them.
Muslim Arabs also didn't develop any real infrastructure at the time and did no state
building.
Rather, they employed everything that the Romans and the Persians had used before them.
So in this environment, we can see why we don't get a lot of public mentions of the
Prophet Muhammad.
Then in 692, a new Caliph comes to the throne, Abd al-Malik, who has just won a civil war
and who wants to flaunt his muscle.
And so he starts with all these public displays of imperial power and the religious tradition
that's associated with it.
He built the Dome of the Rock on the Temple Mount as a very clear symbol of Islam dominating
Christianity and Judaism in Jerusalem, the holiest city to Christians and the Jews.
He makes Arabic the state language as well and sort of begins crafting the Arab identity.
So that's why we start seeing public mentions of the Prophet at this point in Islamic sources.
Keep in mind, again, that plenty of non-Islamic sources from before 692 do mention the Prophet
as I have shown you before.
Now, Abd al-Malik's Islamization was a clear break from that of his predecessor, Muawiyah,
who had, upon his coronation, visited Christian holy sites such as Mary's tomb and the Church
of the Holy Sepulchre and he had prayed there.
To some, it seems to indicate that Muawiyah was Christian and indeed that all early Muslims
were actually Christian.
But that's really not enough evidence to suggest anything of that nature.
Muslims see themselves as part of the Abrahamic tradition and Jesus is very much a venerated
and beloved Islamic prophet.
He's mentioned in the Quran some 20 times.
Additionally, Muawiyah was just coming out of a civil war where he had been supported
by Christian Syrians and Syria was his power base.
He was also married to a Syrian Christian woman.
So he wanted to appease them and those visits were a way for him to tell them that he respects
their religion and that his new religious tradition is not supplanting Christianity.
He also tried to make himself look like Christianity's new defender given that he and his people had
defeated the Byzantine Empire.
So, in this context, it just doesn't look like Muawiyah or any other early Muslims thought
of themselves as Christians.
So, in the end, most scholars do believe that Prophet Muhammad existed and his story, if
you disregard some of the fantastical elements, is entirely plausible.
There's no shortage of evidence that supports his existence and there's no virgin birth
or resurrection or even a sacrifice here.
It's a pretty clear cut story of a man who preaches monotheism and becomes a local lord,
a first among equals of sorts.
That's much easier to believe than that Jesus was distorted into a figure called Muhammad
or that he was invented out of thin air by a Caliph 60 years after him.
Of course, there's many other questions about the Prophet's life that have been and are
being debated.
Like I mentioned, this video is a part of a series called The Historical Muhammad and
in other videos, I talk about some of these questions and discuss the Prophet's biography
from a historical perspective.
So, be sure to check that out.
See you next time.
Don't forget to subscribe and press the bell icon.
On the screen right now, you can see the names and tiers of the patrons.
You can join them by pledging a dollar or more to support the channel.
Thank you for watching.
