Is The Duke Of York The Unluckiest Royal Title? All The Men Who Have Been Duke Of York

The Origins
18 followers
Apr 7, 2026
Is the Duke of York the unluckiest title in the British monarchy?
It's been held by 14 boys and men, not including two pretenders,
and a surprising number have come to very sticky ends.
In this Royal History Documentary from History Calling,
I take you through all the Dukes of York, including the fake ones,
and explain what happened to them and why future royals might want to steer clear
of what is arguably an increasingly tainted, if not seemingly cursed, title.
We begin with Edmund of Langley, born in 1341 as the fourth surviving son
of Edward III and Philippa of Hainaut.
Originally made the Earl of Cambridge in 1361, even though his older brothers were Dukes,
he was eventually made the first Duke of York in 1385.
He was married to Isabella of Castile in 1372,
whose sister was the second wife of his elder brother, John of Gaunt,
and together they had three surviving children,
Edward, Earl of Rutland, who we'll hear more about in a couple of minutes,
Richard, Earl of Cambridge, and Constance, Lady Dispenser.
Isabella died in 1392, aged only 37.
He remarried to Joan of Kent, not to be confused with the woman of the same name,
who had been the wife of Edmund's brother, the Black Prince, in around 1393.
They had no children and Joan lived until 1434.
Though he took part in several military campaigns,
Edmund has not acquired the reputation of a great soldier,
nor has he made a favourable impression on historians in other ways,
in part thanks to descriptions of him by the chronicler Jean Foissard as
and by John Harding as someone who
Appointed as Keeper of the Realm three times by his nephew Richard II,
and long thought loyal to the Crown,
he nevertheless defected to his other nephew, Gaunt's son, Henry Bolingbroke,
when the exiled Bolingbroke invaded England in 1399 and opposed Richard,
who was then in Ireland, having left York behind as Keeper, and he became Henry IV.
York was rewarded for his efforts with lands, money and titles,
but had little time to enjoy them, dying in August 1402 in King's Langley.
He was buried with Isabella in the Church of the Friar's Preacher.
Next we have Edmund and Isabella's son, Edward, born in circa 1473.
Known as either Edward of Langley or Edward of York,
you will sometimes see him called Edward of Norwich, but Rosemary Horrocks,
writing in the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography,
my main secondary source for a lot of the information in this video by the way,
says that this is probably a misreading of Deverick of York,
the appellation regularly used during his father's lifetime.
Knighted at the coronation of his cousin Richard II in 1377,
he was made the Earl of Rutland in 1390,
and remained close to Richard for many years as one of his favourites,
travelling with him on campaign and also being granted an Irish title, the Earl of Cork.
He was made Duke of O'Mal in 1397 and Constable of England.
By 1398 he was married to Philippa Mohan,
who seems to have been at least 20 years older than him and had no children by him,
meaning that his heir was his nephew, another Richard.
Just exactly what happened between Henry Bolingbroke and his cousin O'Mal in 1399
when Bolingbroke became Henry IV is not clear.
Initially Edward seems to have remained loyal to Richard II,
but at some point things evidently changed and he ended up on Henry IV's side,
just like his father.
Still, it was a difficult time for him.
Though he wasn't executed as a Ricardian, he did lose many lands and titles,
including his dukedom, and became once again the Earl of Rutland.
He was involved in a plot to kill Henry and his sons early in the new reign,
yet apparently betrayed the details to the new king,
thus potentially saving Henry IV's life.
Certainly the monarch seems to have been sure of his cousin's loyalty,
for Edward was rewarded with fresh lands and continuing signs of favour over the next few years,
such as important governmental positions.
When Edward's father Edmund died in 1402, he inherited the dukedom of York,
making this one of only two times in our story
that the title has passed from father to son at the father's death.
In February 1405, whilst dealing with serious financial troubles,
he was accused by his sister, Constance Lady de Spencer,
of conspiring against the crown and locked up at Pevensey until October.
He was back in favour a year later though, when he was made Constable of the Tor of London.
In his later years, he spent much time campaigning in France,
and it was at the Battle of Agincourt in October 1415,
where he fought for King Henry V, who had inherited the throne from his father in 1413,
that York died.
His remains were returned to England and buried in the Church of Fotheringhay, Northamptonshire.
His wife survived him until 1431.
The third Duke of York was Richard Plantagenet, grandson of Edmund of Langley,
nephew of Edward of Langley, and son of Richard of Conisborough, Earl of Cambridge.
His mother was Anne Mortimer, a descendant of Edward III through that king's second son,
and so young Richard, born in 1411, was descended from that king twice over.
His maternal descent also gave him a better blood claim on the throne
than that of Henry IV, his son Henry V, who died in 1422,
and then his son Henry VI,
because they were descended from Edward III's third son, John of Gaunt.
Richard's claim on the crown would shape his whole life,
and make him one of the major players in the early part of the conflict
which became known as the Wars of the Roses.
Orphaned in childhood, his mother died of natural causes,
and his father was executed in 1415 for trying to depose Henry V,
he became Duke of York upon his uncle Edward's death,
and married his cousin Cecily Neville in the 1420s.
If you see my videos on her life, you will, by default,
get a much better biography of Richard than I have time to give you here,
but in short, they had seven surviving children,
including the future Edward IV and Richard III,
and Duke Richard played a huge role in the reign of his cousin Henry VI,
to whom he was the presumptive heir until 1453,
when that king and his wife Margaret of Anjou finally had a son.
Richard of York spent much of his time in France,
where he was the king's lieutenant twice in the 1430s and 1440s.
Back in England in the 1450s though, he was made protector of the realm twice,
the first time because of Henry VI's mental breakdown which began in 1453,
to be specific though, the protectorate dated from March 1454 to February 1455,
and again for three months starting in November 1455 for slightly murky reasons.
King Henry's branch of the family was known as the Lancastrians,
due to their descent from John of Gaunt, who was the Duke of Lancaster,
while York's was known as the Yorks for reasons which I hope are obvious.
By the mid 1450s, they were engaged in battle after battle for the throne,
sometimes with one side faring better, sometimes the other.
This was the conflict known as the Wars of the Roses,
and so named because the Lancastrians sometimes used a red rose as one of their emblems,
and the Yorks sometimes used a white.
At one stage, York ended up in exile in Ireland with his second son,
another Earl of Rutland, after losing the Battle of Ludford Bridge in October 1459,
and he was attainted by the English Parliament.
But with the help of his eldest boy, Edward, Earl of March,
he managed to regain the upper hand in 1460,
and that October, an Act of Accord was passed in Parliament,
which named him the heir after Henry VI's death,
completely bypassing the King's young son,
who was then on the run with his mother Margaret,
with whom Richard had had a pretty terrible relationship for years.
It was all looking very good for the Duke of York,
who could expect to become Richard III in due course.
But then, disaster struck.
Whilst at Sandal Castle in the north of England,
he and his second son, Lord Rutland,
left the safety of its walls to engage a Lancastrian army,
and both were killed at the Battle of Wakefield on the 30th of December.
York's head was spiked and a paper crown placed on it
to mock his pretensions to the throne.
After an initial burial at Pontefract,
he was moved many years later by his son Edward
to the Church of St Mary and All Saints, fathering Hay.
Before we move on to the next Duke of York,
and the one who held the title for the shortest amount of time,
please remember to give the video a like, a hype,
and subscribe to the channel if you haven't done so already.
If you activate the notification bell,
YouTube will also keep you up to date with all my uploads,
and you can get bonus material from me,
like badges next to your name and extra posts,
by joining as a channel member.
There are even more bonuses to be had
by becoming a patron over on patreon.com forward slash history calling,
including extra podcasts, early access to ad-free videos,
plus membership of the really nice little community that we have over there.
This week, for instance, I'll be providing a bonus podcast
on the nursery rhyme, The Grand Old Duke of York.
For free bonuses, you can join my mailing list on my website,
historycallingofficial.com,
to get two complimentary downloads,
all about spotting bad history books
and interviewing family members about your genealogy,
plus my newsletter.
Finally, if you have Irish ancestry,
why not check out my book, Find Your Irish Ancestors Online,
available from Amazon as an e-book and paperback,
and linked below for you.
That brings us to the next holder of the title,
Duke of York,
Richard's eldest son, Edward, Earl of March.
Born in France in 1442,
this 18-year-old, good-looking,
exceptionally tall youth,
had already proven himself a formidable military commander
by the time of his father and brother Rutland's deaths,
and he technically held the title, Duke of York,
for the next two and a bit months,
until his stunning victory over the forces of Henry VI
and Margaret of Anjou
enabled him to take the throne as Edward IV in March 1461.
Now, a discussion of the rest of Edward's life
could fill a whole video,
so allow me to just give you the highlights here.
He secretly married the beautiful,
but older English Lancastrian widow,
Elizabeth Grey,
near Woodville in 1464,
with whom he ultimately had 10 children,
including Princess Elizabeth of York
and two boys who would become known
as the Princes in the Tar.
There were also at least two illegitimate children,
a son called Arthur Plantagenet Viscount Lyle,
I'll leave my video about him linked for you,
and a daughter called Grace,
about whom practically nothing is known.
There also seems to have been another daughter called Elizabeth
and rumours of several others,
because Edward got around.
During his lifetime,
he had the seemingly unwavering loyalty
of his youngest brother,
Richard, Duke of Gloucester,
while his middle brother,
George, Duke of Clarence,
was a constant thorn in the King's side,
along with their cousin,
Richard, Earl of Warwick.
For the first decade of his reign,
Edward IV was plagued by attempts
to take the throne off him.
At one point,
he was captured and imprisoned in Warwick Castle
by Clarence and Warwick,
who then had to release him
when they realised they couldn't govern England with him
as a public king.
There was a much more successful deposition in 1470
after they defected to Margaret of Anjou
and her son,
then living in France.
Edward and Gloucester were forced into exile,
Queen Elizabeth had to go into sanctuary
in Westminster Abbey with her children,
and Henry VI was released from his prison
in the Tower of London,
where Edward had been holding him since 1465
and put back on the throne.
It lasted six months.
Edward came back in the spring of 1471,
Clarence defected back to him,
and the York king thrashed his opponents.
Henry VI's son was killed,
followed soon after by the Lancastrian king himself,
who was almost certainly murdered in the tower
on Edward's orders,
and as for Warwick,
he died in battle.
The second reign of Edward IV
lasted until his untimely death
at the age of almost 41 in April 1483,
of natural causes, I hasten to add,
and was marked by his decision
to have his brother Clarence
executed by drowning in wine
in the Tower of London in 1478.
The king was buried
in St George's Chapel at Windsor.
Other than dying young,
he hadn't done too badly,
perhaps because he only held
the title Duke of York
for a little over two months.
Plenty of those who are yet to come on our list
held it far longer
and faced much more unpleasant fates.
The next duke was Edward IV's younger son
by Elizabeth Woodville, Richard of Shrewsbury,
born in 1473
and created the Duke of York
the following year.
It was the first time
the title was given
to the monarch's second son,
but as we'll see,
it set a precedent
which has continued to this day.
In 1477,
he was married off to Anne Mowbray
when he was four and she was six.
His little duchess died in 1481, however.
Richard was in London
with his mother and sisters
when his father died in April 1483
and when his uncle,
the Duke of Gloucester,
seized control of the new king,
12-year-old Edward V.
Elizabeth once again
took her remaining children
into sanctuary in Westminster Abbey.
She was famously compelled
to hand York over
to the Archbishop of Canterbury
and the Duke of Buckingham though
in the middle of June
on Gloucester's orders.
He was placed in the Tower of London
where his older brother was already housed,
supposedly in anticipation
of the new king's coronation.
However, it was immediately postponed.
Then the marriage of their parents
was declared void,
they and their sisters
were declared illegitimate
and the two boys were never seen again
after that summer.
It was assumed by many then and now
that they were killed
on the orders of their uncle Gloucester
who had become Richard III.
In 1674, workmen at the tower
found the skeletons of two young boys
under a staircase
in the central white tower
which were believed to be the boys.
They were interred in an urn
in Westminster Abbey
on the orders of Charles II
but their identities
have never been confirmed.
Now Richard III
didn't hold the throne for long.
He was deposed and replaced
by his distant cousin Henry Tudor
who became Henry VII
after the Battle of Bosworth
in August 1485.
Henry married Edward IV's eldest daughter
Elizabeth of York
and together they had seven children.
The third of these was born in 1491
named after his father
and created the Duke of York
in November 1494.
History knows him better as Henry VIII.
Once again the second son of the monarch
had been made the Duke of York
but in little Henry's case
it wasn't just a matter
of following the precedent
set by his maternal uncle
the presumed dead Richard of Shrewsbury.
It was about combating an imposter
pretending to be that very uncle.
This imposter was in actual fact
called Perkin Warbeck
and he had begun to call himself
Richard Duke of York
younger of the Princes in the Tar
and rightful King of England
in 1491.
Probably born in about 1474
in Tournai, France
he likely worked in the cloth trade
in his youth
and at European courts.
He found himself in Ireland in 1491
and that is where he began
his impersonation
of the almost certainly dead
Richard of Shrewsbury
encouraged by the former Mayor of Cork
John Atwater
and English exile John Taylor.
He gained a lot of prominent support
including from the Earl of Desmond
Charles VIII of France
Edward IV's sister
Margaret of Burgundy
Maximilian King of the Romans
and King James IV of Scotland.
Even members of the English court
who were unhappy with the Tudor regime
were drawn into the plotting.
Ultimately it was all for nothing though
though he did invade England
in September 1497
his attempts to take the Crown failed
and he was captured by Tudor forces
in Bewley Abbey
and brought before Henry VII
on the 5th of October
where he confessed to being an imposter.
Though fairly well treated at first
and taken around England
to be shown off as the pretender he was
after he escaped Henry's custody
and was recaptured in June 1498
he was placed in the stocks twice
then locked up in irons
in the Tower of London
where the Duke of Clarence's
long-imprisoned son
Edward Earl of Warwick
was also being kept.
The following summer
the two were found to be conspiring
against Henry VII
and so the King had them executed in 1499.
Warbeck was hanged at Tyburn
on the 23rd of November.
Back to the other Duke of York
alive at this time though
the future Henry VIII.
He continued to be known by that title
until after the death of his older brother
Arthur Prince of Wales in April 1502.
He was then made Prince of Wales himself
in 1504
and no longer known as the Duke of York
though he did still have the title
until he became King in 1509
as it is only if you become monarch
that all your other earlier titles
are subsumed by the crown.
I trust I don't need to give you a rundown
of the reign of this infamous King.
In short he married six times
had two of his wives judicially murdered
fathered Edward VI
Mary I
and Elizabeth I
and split from the Catholic Church in Rome
despite actually being a Catholic himself
thereby setting England up
to become a primarily Protestant nation.
He died in January 1547.
From 1509
the Duke of York title
became dormant for the remainder
of the Tudor era
and it was only when
James VI of Scotland
inherited the English crown
from Elizabeth I in 1603
that the opportunity to revive it came up.
James I of England
as he is often known
had two surviving sons
with his wife Anne of Denmark.
The eldest became Henry Prince of Wales
the second named Prince Charles
had been born in 1600
in Dunfermline Palace
and was initially the Duke of Albany
the title traditionally given
to the Scottish monarch's second son.
He moved to England in 1604
to be with his parents
and was made the Duke of York
the following year.
Just like Henry VIII though
his fate was to take an unexpected turn
after the early death of his older brother
which occurred in 1612
when the Prince of Wales was just 18.
The almost 12 year old Charles
was now the heir to the throne
and was made Prince of Wales himself
in 1616.
He would continue to technically
hold the Duke of York title though
until he became king in 1625.
Charles married Henrietta Maria of France
soon after his accession
and had nine children with her
of whom five made it to adulthood
including the future Charles II
and James II.
His reign famously ended in disaster though.
Having alienated many MPs in his parliament
the country descended into civil war
in the 1640s
which Charles ultimately lost.
After being captured and escaping
then being recaptured
he refused to agree to a constitutional monarchy
and was ultimately executed
at Banqueting House in London
on the 30th of January 1649.
He was buried with Henry VIII
and his third wife Jane Seymour
in St George's Chapel at Windsor.
England entered into a republic
run by Oliver Cromwell
which lasted until 1660
when the monarchy was restored
and Charles II took the throne.
The following Duke of York
was Charles I's second son
James, later James II
and the title was not the only thing
he shared with his unfortunate father
for he too would lose the throne
though luckily not his head.
Born in London on the 14th of October 1633
he was immediately named the Duke of York
though this was only made official in 1644
and he would hold this title
for most of his life.
The civil wars kicked off
when he was still just a child
and he was taken captive
along with two younger siblings in 1646.
Having escaped without his younger siblings
he went to Holland in 1648
where his married sister Mary
was living as the Princess of Orange
then lived in exile in various places
in mainland Europe
serving in his cousin
Louis XIV of France's army
until his brother Charles's
restoration to the throne in 1660.
With his royal position restored
he was made Duke of Albany
just as his father had once been
and promptly married his mistress
Lady Anne Hyde
who was already pregnant with his child
at the time of the wedding
in the summer of 1660.
That baby died young
but the couple would ultimately have
two surviving children
the future Mary II and Queen Anne.
The reign of his brother
was often difficult for James
having been exposed to Catholicism
during his time in France
and initially reluctant
to have anything to do with it
he had converted to the religion
by the late 1660s
and when it became widespread knowledge
in the mid 1670s
after he stopped attending
Anglican services
there were calls for him
to be barred from inheriting the throne
which he was first in line for
as Charles had no legitimate children.
This long-running saga
was called the Exclusion Crisis
and was prompted by
the virulent anti-Catholicism
in England at the time
not helped by the Popish plot of 1678
which was a supposed plan
to kill Charles
and replace him with James.
The King stood by his younger brother
but at one point
James was dispatched to Brussels
then Scotland
to keep him out of the way.
His private life was complicated too
Most of his children with Anne Hyde died
then she did too in 1671
having first converted to Catholicism
as well by the way
and their daughters were raised Protestant
on the orders of Charles II.
James remarried to the 15-year-old Italian
Mary of Modena in 1673.
By 1685 though
all of their children were dead too
and in February that year
King Charles died as well
and James became king
with surprising support
despite his religion.
With no sons
and two Protestant daughters as his heirs
who were both married to Protestants too
his reign was expected to be a bridge
between Protestant monarchs
and did not raise the concerns
it had in previous years.
His illegitimate nephew
Charles II's oldest son
the Duke of Monmouth
tried to usurp the crown
but he was defeated and executed.
Had James and Mary of Modena
continued with no further children
or only daughters
everything likely would have been fine
but when the queen produced a healthy son
named after the king in June 1688
on the back of some pro-Catholic measures
from James over the preceding three years
England erupted in panic
at the prospect of a new Catholic dynasty.
False rumours
encouraged by James's daughter Princess Anne
were spread that the baby was a changeling
who had been smuggled into the birthing chamber
in a warming pan
and therefore was not the real heir
and by November the king's nephew
slash son-in-law William of Orange
married to his daughter Mary
had invaded England
under the guise of protecting its laws.
James plagued by nosebleeds
fear and the defection of his daughter Anne
and her husband George of Denmark
among others
put up no strong resistance.
He sent his wife and son to France
on the 10th of December
and was captured by William's forces
on the 13th.
He escaped on the 23rd
likely with William's connivance
and went to France too.
William and his wife Mary
were declared joint king and queen
and the whole episode has gone down in history
as the Glorious Revolution.
After one serious attempt
to reclaim the throne
by battling William in Ireland
at the Battle of the Bourne in 1690
James lived out the rest of his days
in exile in France
with his wife, son
and another daughter named Louise
who was born to the couple in 1692.
He and his descendants by Mary
are known to history as the Jacobites
after the Latin version of the name James
which is Jacobus.
He died in 1701.
The crown passed
through William III
and his wife Mary II
then to her sister Anne
then upon her death
with no surviving children in 1714
to the Hanoverians
a distant branch of the family
descended from James I
and crucially Protestant
at least for the most part.
George I was the first of these monarchs
and it was his brother
Ernest Augustus
born in 1674
who was made the next Duke of York and Albany.
This was unusual
because Ernest was not the son
of any King or Queen of England
Scotland or Britain
nor was he the elder
of George's two surviving brothers
though the other Maximilian was Catholic
and could not be in the line of succession
which might explain why he was overlooked.
Ernest grew up in Osnabrück and Hanover
and led the life of a military man
fighting in the Nine Years' War
and in the War of Spanish Succession.
He may have been gay
and his correspondence with another soldier
Johann Franz Dietrich von Wendt
which he began in 1703
is sometimes seen as a romantic relationship.
At any rate he never married.
When his brother acceded to the English throne
Ernest stayed behind in Hanover
to represent the family interests there
George I was also the Elector of Hanover
and to be guardian to the second in line
to the British throne
seven-year-old Prince Frederick
grandson of George I
and son of the future George II
who was also left behind
to represent the family in Hanover.
Ernest became the Bishop of Osnabrück in 1715
and in 1716 he was made
the Duke of York and Albany
and the Earl of Ulster
perhaps according to the Oxford DMB
to emphasise dynastic unity
and the identification of the family
with Great Britain.
As far as I'm aware though
he never came to England
or any other part of the British Isles
Instead he lived alternatively
in Osnabrück and Hanover
and it was in Osnabrück
that he died on the 3rd of August 1728.
Next on the list
we have the second pretender
to the title of Duke of York.
This was Henry Benedict Stuart
the younger of the two grandsons
of James II
via he and Mary of Monmouth's son
Prince James Francis Edward Stuart
that's the baby born in 1688
whose birth sparked the Glorious Revolution.
Born in Rome on the 6th of March 1725
Henry's mother was the Polish princess
Clementina Sobieska
and his older brother is known to history
as Bonnie Prince Charlie
or the young pretender
to distinguish him from their father
known as the old pretender
and by Jacobites as James III.
He was created the Duke of York
as an infant
in opposition to Duke Ernest
who was still alive
until Henry was two and a half
and had a troubled childhood
as his parents' marriage disintegrated
and his mother then died in 1735.
Henry was not as caught up
in trying to fight for the British throne
in the way that first his father
and then his older brother were.
Though when he learned
that Charles had gone to Scotland
to try to retrieve the crown
he was desperate to go with him
but never made it further than France
before the Jacobites' resounding defeat
at the Battle of Culloden in April 1746
was disclosed to him.
His relationship with Charles
who began drinking heavily
then fell apart
and Henry who was always very pious
became more interested
in joining the Catholic Church
which he did in 1747
much to Charles's chagrin.
He was known as Cardinal York
and still used his Royal Highness title
so he certainly hadn't rejected
his family's claim to the throne.
His father died in 1766
and his brother in 1788
after which Henry styled himself
King Henry IX
but he never made any attempt on the throne.
He died in 1807
and was buried in St Peter's Basilica
in the Vatican.
His death effectively marked the end
of the Jacobite cause.
During Henry Benedict's life
there were several other
acknowledged Dukes of York
even after the death of Ernest Augustus
in 1728.
In 1739
Prince Edward Augustus of Wales
was born to Frederick Prince of Wales
and his wife Princess Augusta.
He was their second son,
their elder became George III.
The Prince had a naval career
starting in 1758 when he was 19
and was well known for his promiscuity.
He was created Duke of York and Albany
and Earl of Ulster
on the 1st of April 1760
and after his grandfather's death at October
his father had already died back in 1751
he became the heir to the throne of his brother
the new George III
until George became a father in 1762.
He was made a member of the Privy Council
and lived in St James's Palace
continuing to be employed in the Navy
but not allowed to actively serve
until it was clear
that the new Queen Charlotte
would be producing a child in the near future.
After a brief stint at command in 1762
he didn't have his own ship again
though he was made an admiral in 1766.
The rest of his life is frankly
rather unremarkable.
He travelled around Europe
enjoying himself
and doing some light diplomacy work
and was a great patron of the theatre
back in England
even acting in private productions himself on occasion.
Despite numerous mistresses
he never married
and he fell ill with a fever
on a trip to France and Monaco in 1767
and died in the Principality
on the 17th of September that year.
His body was returned to England
and buried in the Henry VII Chapel
in Westminster Abbey.
We now move from George III's brother
to his son.
This was Prince Frederick Augustus
born in 1763
to George and Queen Charlotte.
Made Bishop of Osnabrück
by his father at the tender age of six months
it was a formality
and he was never intended for the church.
Instead he joined the army in 1780
at the age of 17
and on the 27th of November 1784
he was made the Duke of York and Albany
and the Earl of Ulster.
He travelled around Europe
between 1781 and 1787
before returning to England
where he gained a reputation as a gambler
and even fought a duel
with the future fourth Duke of Richmond
in 1789
in which he simply fired into the air
after letting his opponent fire first.
He married Princess Frederica of Prussia in 1791
but the marriage was a failure.
The couple quickly separated
and there were no children.
Prince Frederick fought in Flanders
in 1793, 1794 and 1795
but did not impress with his military capabilities
which were limited.
Nevertheless, nepotism is a powerful force
and he was still made the commander-in-chief of the army
by his father in 1798.
He didn't do particularly well in the job.
His command of an army sent to invade Holland in 1799
turned into a failure
and though he tried to reform the army somewhat
to eradicate some abuses
and improve the lot of its soldiers
there was a scandal when it emerged
that his mistress Mary Clarke
was using her connection to him
to sell military offices.
He had to resign his command post in 1809
though his older brother, by then the Prince Regent
gave it back to him in 1811.
Thereafter, he continued to try to improve
the condition of the army.
He was made the guardian of his mentally ill father
in 1818 after the death of Queen Charlotte
and when his brother became George IV in 1820
York became heir presumptive to the throne
as George IV's only legitimate child, Princess Charlotte
was already dead.
The Duke of York could have remarried
after his wife's death in 1820
and tried to produce a child
who would inherit the throne
but he never did so
instead allowing his younger brothers
to engage in the infamous royal baby race
which ensued after Princess Charlotte's death
and which had resulted in the birth
of the future Queen Victoria in 1819.
That said, he was apparently excited
at the prospect of becoming king himself someday
stating that he'd have the same kind of coronation
as his brother
but it was not to be.
He died of dropsy on the 5th of January 1827
and was buried in St George's Chapel, Windsor.
Now you would think that the next Duke of York
would be one of the sons of Queen Victoria
but actually she never conferred that title
on any of them
though she did make her fourth son
the Duke of Albany.
The next Duke of York was instead
one of her grandsons
and also the future George V.
George was born in 1865
and was the second son
of the future Edward VII
and his wife Alexandra of Denmark.
He joined the navy at the age of 14
as it was his older brother, Albert Victor
who was meant to become king.
However, when that prince died in January 1892
George's active naval career
effectively came to an end
as he inherited the job
of second in line to the throne
and also Albert Victor's fiancee, Mary of Teck
who he married in 1893.
He was already the Duke of York by then
having been created so in May 1892
but when his father became king
on the 22nd of January 1901
he was initially the Duke of Cornwall and York
because the monarch's eldest son
is automatically the Duke of Cornwall
and was created Prince of Wales
in November of that year
and thereafter ceased using the York title.
He and Mary had six children
including the future Edward VIII
George VI
and the epileptic Prince John
who died in 1919 aged 13.
George was also a very tough father
whose children were scared of him.
He inherited the throne himself in 1910
also becoming Emperor of India
and steered the United Kingdom
through World War I
stripping relatives who fought for Germany
of their British titles
and even changing the family surname
from the Germanic Saxe-Coburg-Gotha
to the solidly English Windsor in 1917.
When his cousin Tsar Nicholas of Russia
was deposed that same year
George had initially planned
to offer asylum to the family
but changed his mind due to concerns
about how the move would be perceived at home.
Nicholas, his wife and their five children
were later murdered by the Bolsheviks in 1918
to George's deep regret.
George's reign also saw major events
like the partition of Ireland in 1922
and in 1932 he began the tradition
of the monarch's Christmas speech
something which continues to this day.
The manner of his death in January 1936
is highly controversial
for as he lay unconscious
and was nearing the end
his doctor Lord Dawson of Penn
deliberately administered a fatal overdose
to kill him more quickly
partly to spare the royal family
from having to wait any longer
and partly to make the morning papers.
Neither George, his wife or their eldest son
who were both present
were informed or gave permission.
It was regicide
and I'll leave my video
looking at it in detail linked for you.
The king was buried
in St George's Chapel, Windsor.
And so we come to the penultimate
Duke of York on our list
George V's second son
and the future George VI.
Born Prince Albert Frederick Arthur George
on the 14th of December 1895
the anniversary of the death
of his great-grandfather
after whom he was named
he was known as Birdie in the family
and joined the navy in his youth
then later moved to the newly established
Royal Air Force.
He was created the Duke of York in 1920
and married Scottish noblewoman
Lady Elizabeth Bowes-Lyon in 1923
with whom he had two daughters
the future Elizabeth II
and Princess Margaret.
Birdie grew up expecting
his older brother to be king
with seemingly no ambition
for the throne himself.
He famously had a stutter
which made the speeches
that royals are often required
to give absolute torture
and which inspired the movie
The King's Speech.
After his father's death in 1936
his older brother did briefly become
King Edward VIII for 10 months
before abdicating in order
to marry Wallace Simpson
and passing the throne
to the horrified Birdie
who wept on his mother's lap
when he realised the enormity
of his new life.
I have to say though
despite his trepidation
he did a fine job.
He took his father's name
as his regnal name
becoming George VI
rather than the more Germanic
sounding King Albert
and saw the country
through World War II
refusing to leave London
even during the Blitz
and despite the fact
that Buckingham Palace
was bombed with him
and the Queen inside it.
He took Britain from an empire
to a Commonwealth
earned great love and respect
from his people
and when he died of lung cancer
in February 1952
he was a long-term smoker
he was sincerely mourned.
He was also buried
at St George's Chapel, Windsor.
We finish with the most recent
holder of the title
the former Prince Andrew
now known as
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor.
Born to Elizabeth II
and Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
in 1960
he was their third child
and second son.
Like numerous royal princes
before him
he joined the Navy
and earned much praise
for his service
during the Falklands War
in the early 1980s.
It was upon the occasion
of his marriage
to Sarah Ferguson
in 1986
that he was created
the Duke of York
which was by then
the standard title
for the monarch's second son
and the couple had two daughters
Princesses Beatrice and Eugenie
before separating in 1992
and ultimately divorcing
though the divorce
was very amicable
and they have continued
to live together
for many of the years
which have since passed.
Andrew developed
a very poor reputation
with regards to his
treatment of staff
and many others
he came into contact with
coming off as
pompous, arrogant
and frankly
not all that intelligent
if reports are to be believed.
He has also long had a reputation
for being extremely promiscuous
overspending
and using his royal connections
for personal gain.
The thing which brought about
his downfall though
was his association
with Jeffrey Epstein
and I assume you all know
what that dirty little degenerate
was guilty of.
I can't get into details here
in order to keep YouTube happy
but Andrew allegedly
seriously mistreated
again I'm very sorry
I can't be more forthright than that
one of Epstein's victims
the teenaged Virginia Roberts
something he has always denied
and remained friends with Epstein
even after the latter
was convicted of very serious crimes
against minors in the United States.
A disastrous Newsnight interview
in 2019
in which he discussed
but did not express
any serious regret
for the friendship
and in which he made absurd claims
that were shown to be lies
like not being able to sweat
after an overdose of adrenaline
in the Falklands War
and others which seemed very suspect
like suggesting that a photo of him
with Virginia was fake
and that he couldn't have danced with her
at a nightclub in London
or mistreated her afterwards
because he was at a pizza express
in Woking
led to him being effectively fired
from royal duties.
A pretty damning biography of him
and his ex-wife
was released in 2025
see my review of it
linked on screen and below
and later that year
emails between him
and the by now deceased Epstein
were released
they showed that he had further lied
about when he terminated
that friendship
ultimately leading to him
being stripped of all his royal titles
and honours that October and November
and finally forced to give up his home
in Royal Lodge
on the Windsor estate
which he had been under pressure
to leave for some time
he will henceforth live
on the King's private estate
at Sandringham
and that my friends
brings us to the end of this list
I asked at the start
if the title of Duke of York
is very unlucky
even seemingly cursed
let's sum up the fates
of its 14 holders
and two pretenders so far
to see what we think
six were either murdered
executed or died in battle
six didn't make it to their 50s
two were deposed
one has been stripped of his title
possibly two
it's not clear
if Richard of Shrewsbury
would have been entitled
to hold the dukedom
after he was declared illegitimate
and the one who lived the longest
is the one who was a born
and raised Jacobite
lived his whole life in exile
from his supposed country
and wasn't even recognised
as the Duke of York anyway
by most people
these aren't inspiring statistics
do I think the title is cursed?
no I don't believe in such things
do I think it's tainted
by all the horrible things
which have happened to
or been done by its holders?
yes I'm afraid I do
what next for the title though
and could things improve?
well in the normal course of things
Prince Louis would become
the next holder of it
sometime after his father becomes king
but honestly
if I was him
I might be like
seriously dad
it's okay
just keep it
if you want to make me a joke
maybe give me the Cambridge title
which will be available again
once William becomes monarch
there is of course
a precedent for this
as Queen Victoria did not bestow it
on her second son
or any of them in fact
and it might be wise
to follow her lead
and just let this title
remain dormant
until the 22nd century
long after Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor
is dead
let me know in the comments
which Duke of York
is your favourite
or least favourite
and why
and to learn more
about some of the men
and events I've discussed
in this video
or to hear about
other royal titles
try one of these options next
alternatively
open up the description box
under this video
which has a whole host
of related topics
for you to choose from
till next time all
keep learning
