Illicit Finance, Financial Integrity Software Solutions, and Biological Warfare- Mr. Craig Timm

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
1 Video View·Apr 6, 2026
20th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum | Washington, D.C 🇺🇸 | December 6, 2021
-Mr. Craig Timm
Managing Director, Financial Crimes Compliance Executive at Bank of America
So thanks and thank you very much to Congressman Pittenger for having me today. My name is Craig
Tim. I'm from Bank of America. And what I'd like to talk to you today is about illicit finance,
the role the financial sector can play in combating illicit finance, and I think most
importantly for this audience is the role that you all can play as parliamentarians in helping us
to improve the effectiveness of that system. Now let me just start quickly with the challenge
that we're facing. We've heard a little bit about it so far, but when you talk about, you know,
we've heard follow the money. When you talk about proceeds of crime, we're talking about
two trillion dollars every year in the proceeds of criminal activity. Now that doesn't include
corruption, tax evasion, or cybercrime. You add those in, we're talking about 8.5 trillion dollars
in illicit activity. That's roughly 9 to 10 percent of global GDP. So massive, massive problem.
In order to fight that, most every country in the world now has what they call an anti-money
laundering regime, where there are requirements put on the financial sector to help in this
fight. Now we as a global financial sector spend 180 billion dollars a year in this fight. That's
180 billion spent by the financial sector per year. Just think about that for a second. That is
bigger than the GDP of 161 countries, roughly the size of the GDP of Greece. 180 billion per year
spent by the financial sector. What are we getting for those results? Not a whole lot, if we're honest.
You know, we've heard today multiple times the need to seize more money. We don't, we've got to take
the profit out of crime. That's what, that's what the anti-money laundering regime is about.
And today we seize less than one percent of all these assets. So why is that, right? Why are we,
why are we not getting our money's worth? Why are you as governments not getting what you should
expect out of the financial system? And I think there's a few, a few reasons. And then I'm going
to get to a solution too. I think first, we don't define in our anti-money laundering regimes, no
country on earth, what we actually want to achieve and we don't prioritize. So there's no country
that sets out a clear standard for what does it mean for a bank like mine to be effective at money
laundering. And we don't, there's no country in the world today until the United States this year that
actually establishes national priorities for us to focus on. Instead we've got most every country
in the world, their anti-money laundering regime focuses on suspicion and this broad requirement
that banks report on suspicious activities. No more or no less importance is given to any topic
over another. So we heard about human trafficking before. I'll use that as an example because I
think we can bring that to life. If I identify a human trafficking network, I'm not given any more
or less credit than if I report on a pretty low dollar unusual cash deposit. I mean there's a
problem there. Think about that in any other walk of life. If you don't have priorities, there's no
priorities, right? And so this leads to two significant problems today. One, you get a lot
of reporting on things that are quote-unquote suspicious but probably aren't criminal and not
really helpful to law enforcement. And two, because we as banks have to cover the wide array of every
potential crime large and small, we spread our resources very thinly. So we can't get deep. And
that problem is exacerbated by the things that I think you care about most, human trafficking,
terrorist financing, those things require significant investment. They require time. They
require resources to the tech. So that's problem number one. Problem number two is we operate in
silos. The public and private sector, as much as we're trying to break that down and we're making
progress, we operate in silos that the criminals just don't operate in. They move freely across
countries. They move, any criminal group worth their salt is using my bank and 12 other banks
to split it up and make it harder to detect. And there are, there are structural things in place
in certain countries that prevent information sharing, both between the public sector and
between the private sector. There are cultural limitations sometimes, but it's a challenge we
need to address. And then I think the third big issue is, and I think we'll hear some of this from
from some of my other panelists who I think have, you know, solutions potentially to address some of
this. We've traditionally taken an unsophisticated view of risk. You know, your money laundering risk
was traditionally based on who you are or where you're located largely. So for this group, if
you're a politician, you've traditionally been thought of as automatically high risk because of
potential corruption, right? We know that's not true. We know that for any customer group, the vast
majority of those customers, no matter who they are, where they are, are going to be innocent. And when
we apply things bluntly like that, we spend most of our time, energy, and resources on the innocent
because now I have to collect extra information on all of you. Whereas if I just looked at your
behavior, I could better segment who's actually at risk. If you're a politician, if you're a
parliamentarian, and all I see is your check from the government, normal household expenses, you
are not high risk. And I shouldn't be treating you like that. And so part of the problem traditionally
is until recently, we haven't had the technological solutions to be able to deal with some of this. And
I think you'll hear from some of these other folks about that. So the good news, and the good news
for you specifically, is that we can do something about this. And this is where I'd really like to
salute the US Congress for their work in this area over the last several years. On January 1st of
this year, we passed in this country the Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020. And this was something a
number of years in the works. It was something that really not only is a good policy, it was an
example of good government. Republicans and Democrats coming together, this is not a political
issue. How do we make our community safer? Those numbers that I started with are not acceptable.
How do we fix it? And so they sat down with law enforcement, with the private sector, with the
public sector to get things right. And I think, I mean, it was amazing earlier today, we kicked off
the day hearing Senator Cassidy speak eloquently about money laundering and trade-based money
laundering, right? That was, that was incredible. And that, I think, is just an example of the
dedication to get this right. And so the Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020, I think, can be a blueprint
for countries around the world to try to attack some of those problems that I laid out. So first,
it establishes national priorities for the first time ever in this country. And I'll talk a little
bit more about that. It requires and demands more information sharing to break down those silos. And
three, it encourages the use of technology that will be so important. And so first, with national
priorities. I mentioned that today, we've never had priorities. And so I don't think you can
underestimate the difference that this could make. I don't spend, our bank does not spend most of our
time on things like human trafficking, terrorist financing today. It's collecting due diligence on a broad
swath of people. It's trying to cover every possible area. You know, by focusing this, you will see
incredible results. I think we, we heard earlier in the human trafficking panel that the UN spends, I
think, $500 million a year on human trafficking. Imagine if we could redirect just 1% of what the
private sector already spends. This is no new money. This is net even. That's $1.8 billion we could direct
immediately to human trafficking. Imagine the effect that would have. And that's just 1%. And so I think
the, you cannot underestimate, I've said this before, that, you know, we're just starting here, the
priorities were just announced in June. We're just learning how to do this in this country. But from the
results I'm already seeing is we're shifting resources to these things. We're not talking about a 1x
improvement. We're not talking about a 2x improvement. It's 50x, 100x. We are going to make a huge
difference on the things that matter most in this country. It's, it's, it's game changing. Information
sharing was the second one. And this is, the AML Act does a few different things to, to improve this. One, it
formalizes an infrastructure to share information. So we've had something called, FinCEN is our
financial intelligence unit here in the United States, and they've had something informally called the FinCEN
Exchange for several years, where you can share information. They bring together the public and private
sector, law enforcement, banks, in a room and talk about problems. The AML Act formalized that. And that, that's
important. We need to have the infrastructure to share information. If we're going to do this at scale, it can't be
something informal. It can't be something we're doing on the sides of our desk. We need to have national
infrastructure led by governments to facilitate this information sharing. Second, the, the AML Act requires the
government to give more feedback to the private sector. Now, now why is that important? It's important for a
couple of reasons. If I'm going to use the technology that we're going to talk about in a second, and, and these other
guys might talk about, I need to know the latest in how criminals are acting. I need to be able to train my systems on
that. And, and there's no better source of information for that than the government. If we think back to that human
trafficking panel earlier too, you know, we, we heard that the ability of public-private cooperation to amplify
work. And, and I've seen that firsthand, right? This, this stuff is for a bank. It can be hard to detect on our own. It's not
easy to detect human trafficking, even with technology. But when the government comes to us and says, look, we know
these are human traffickers. Can you help us? Can you help us tell who they're dealing with? Can you build the network?
That's when you start to achieve great results. That's when you don't just go at the lower level folks who, you know, can be
replaced tomorrow. That's when you start to build up and you start to get at the heads of the organization. You get the
significant asset seizures. You know, public-private cooperation is so important to impacting the, the challenges that we
talked about. And then lastly, it's, it's technology. We are, the, the financial sector can be, you know, as a regulated
industry, slow to innovate. We can't afford to be slow here. The criminals are always early adopters of technology. They're always
first. And if we have any hope of keeping up with them, we need to move quickly. And what does that mean? That means the
government setting out clear rules that say, here's how you innovate responsibly. Here are the rules of the game so that, you
know, if you do this, you can go ahead and go forward. It's not going to be a wasted investment, right? Because today the rules
just aren't simply clear enough. We don't know when we can start using the new technology, when we can stop using the old
stuff that's not working. And you're hesitant. It's like anywhere else. You're hesitant to invest unless you know that
investment's going to pay off. And so what the AML Act does is requires the government to set out those rules of the road. It
actually does more than that. It says we should be innovating. It is encouraging the financial sector to innovate. So I think, you
know, just wrapping up for me, I think, you know, these three things, any of these three things, establishing priorities,
public-private partnership, technology, are important individually. But together, they can make a real difference. And I'd ask
you all, you know, as you look at your own AML regimes, to think about this. Use the AML Act as a blueprint to make yourself
more effective. It will make your communities safer.
Thank you very much, Craig. I think when I saw your name
