John Jackson DipWSET a/k/a Attorney Somm explains the cellar defender concept, introduces Chateauneuf du Pape, and reveals 5 top producers of Chateauneuf du Pape wines that are excellent wine cellar defenders. In so doing, Attorney Somm identifies 7 top red wines that cost between $40 and $80 that make for ideal wine cellar defenders for wine collectors.
This video is NOT sponsored. The link to the flash site is a referral link that is made available to anyone who signs up for this flash site. That means that if you use the link, you will get $10 off your first order and I will receive a modest credit. Likewise should you purchase anything from my Amazon storefront, I will receive a very modest commission.
There's no place like Rome. In this video, I'm going to be discussing one of my favorite regions
in the entire world, Chateauneuf-du-Pape, from the southern Rhone region of France.
After briefly discussing Chateauneuf-du-Pape, I'm going to explain what makes it an ideal
cellar defender, and then identify five of my favorite producers from Chateauneuf-du-Pape from
which to buy year in and year out. But first, what is a cellar defender? In simple terms,
a cellar defender is a reasonably priced wine that's sufficiently interesting that you will
always enjoy it, but which will also help you from indulging in the temptation to open up a
wine that should be aging in the cellar. And by that, I mean a wine that is not yet ready to enjoy
and which will continue to improve and gain complexity with age, such that it would be a
shame to open it now. Just to make sure we're on the same page before we get too far down the road,
Chateauneuf-du-Pape is an appellation and a village in the southern Rhone region of France,
near Avignon. There's 13 permitted grape varieties, or 18 if you count color variations for five of
them. Grenache, Syrah, and Mourvèdre are the most common grapes. It is permitted for a producer to
make a wine from 100% of any of the permitted varieties. However, most producers choose to
make Grenache, Syrah, and Mourvèdre, or so-called GSM blends, that are Grenache-dominant but include
some components of Syrah and Mourvèdre, and sometimes a little bit of other varieties as
well. The climate is remarkably consistent in Chateauneuf-du-Pape, and the grapes are capable
of ripening pretty much every year. For that reason, it's truly unusual for the southern Rhone
region, and Chateauneuf-du-Pape in particular, to have a truly bad vintage. Chateauneuf-du-Pape wines
are bold with rich plum and red fruit flavors, and they also have garrigue descriptors. Garrigue
refers to the weeds that sometimes grow on the side of the road in Chateauneuf-du-Pape, generally
sage, rosemary, and lavender. With age, Chateauneuf-du-Pape can also take on some leathery descriptors.
Why is Chateauneuf-du-Pape an ideal cellar defender? Well, there's at least a couple reasons.
First, in many instances you can enjoy it either on release, or you can age it 12 to 15 years,
or even a bit more. This gives you tremendous flexibility in terms of when you open it. My
personal preference is to open it either on release, or within the 8 to 12 year point for
most producers. Chateauneuf-du-Pape is also an excellent cellar defender, because it remains
one of the most compelling values in the entire world of wine. Despite the general very high
quality of wines from Chateauneuf-du-Pape, many of the wines can be purchased for $40 or $50.
This certainly compares very favorably to a number of other well-known regions that have wines that
are much more expensive than that. With that by way of background, we're ready to get into my top
five picks. More specifically though, I'm actually identifying seven wines, but these wines are from
five different producers that I recommend buying from year in and year out. Of course, Reyas,
Clodopop, and Beaucastel are excellent, and some of my favorites as well, but they're beyond the
scope of this video, because due to their price point, I don't generally consider those wines to
be cellar defenders. The wines I'm identifying in this video are primarily in the range of $40 to
$75 a bottle, although one or two of them may be a bit closer to $80. My first pick of Chateauneuf-du-Pape
wines is Domaine Roger Sabon. Roger Sabon was founded in 1952 and is currently run by Roger's
sons, Dennis and Gilbert. They have about 18 hectares of vines in Chateauneuf-du-Pape, including a number
of parcels in the famous Lacroix Plateau. Importantly, Lacroix contains an abundance of the famous
which are large smooth pebbles in the vineyards that absorb heat during the day and then radiate
that heat to the vines at night, which helps to ensure ripening even in vintages that are a little
bit substandard. Roger Sabon ages their wines in concrete and large oak foudre. Their wines tend
to be a little bit more on the elegant and ethereal side, which I enjoy very much. In general,
Chateauneuf-du-Pape can be either more Burgundian in nature or can be more robust and full-throttle,
and this is definitely the former. I recently found this wine advertised by a national online
retailer for around $50 a bottle. The 2019 is a classic GSM blend that can be enjoyed on release
but will certainly age 15 years or so. Domaine de la Jeunesse Chateauneuf-du-Pape is my second favorite
Chateauneuf-du-Pape. This producer is relatively recent by European standards, but it's one that I
visited several years ago and I've been a big fan of ever since. They have several different
bottlings, two of which I will discuss here. The first wine is the Domaine de la Jeunesse
Chateauneuf-du-Pape Tradition. This is their flagship wine, and it consists of 65% Grenache,
20% Syrah, 5% Cinco, and the rest being permitted varietals. 2019 is the current release, and that
one was highly regarded and is also available for sale for about $50 to $60. This is an excellent
choice, especially for those who enjoy the more modern style of wines. Jeunesse also produces a
wine called Chopin, which is 100% Grenache and made from very old vines, many of which are 100
years old or more. This one is a bit more expensive and often retails for more like $75 to $80,
but it's my favorite wine from this producer, and it's an excellent choice in that price point.
I recently enjoyed the 2009 Chopin from Jeunesse, and it is in a fantastic place right now. Just a
beautiful bottle. Since 1891, five generations of the Brunier family have run Domaine du Vieux
Telegraph, which is my next recommendation for Chateauneuf-du-Pape. Located in southeast
Chateauneuf-du-Pape, Vieux Telegraph has an impressive 123 acres of vines located in the
Plateau. The grapes are grown on old vines which average an impressive 70 years of age. The vineyard
is planted to 65% Grenache, 15% Merved, 15% Syrah, and 5% of other permitted varietals.
The vineyards are farmed sustainably. The grapes are hand harvested. They're partially destemmed.
Following 22 months of aging, the wine is bottled unfined and unfiltered. While this is a consistent
producer year in and year out, the 2019 Vintage is currently on release, and it has been well
received by critics. I've seen that one selling for about 50 to 55 dollars from many retailers.
This is definitely one though that I prefer with a little bit of age on it, and I tend not to open
this one on release. It tends to be a little bit more structured and less fruit forward than the
other wines. I recently tasted the 2010 Vintage, however, and that one was extremely impressive
and showing very well. So this is another producer that I recommend very highly. Since 1860, this
estate has been run by five generations of the Boiron family. This is a traditional producer,
and they have two wines that I'm discussing and recommending in this video. The first is the
Bosquet de Pot Chateauneuf de Pot Cuvée Tradition. This is a traditional GSM blend that consists of
75% Grenache and 11% each of Syrah and Merved, with the rest being permitted varietals. I've
recently seen this one offered for sale for as little as $40, which is an exceptional value for
this wine. The second wine is the Bosquet de Pot Chantemerle Vieille Vignée. This is their best
wine, and as the name suggests, it comes from very old vines. These vines range from 70 to 100 years
old and make a wine that's very very concentrated and impressive. The grapes are not distemmed,
and all the different grapes are co-fermented to produce this wine. This one costs around $80,
which is on the upper end of the price point that I'm discussing in this video,
but it's very high quality and one that I definitely recommend at this price.
Next up is the Domaine du Pagot Cuvée Reserva. This is one of my absolute favorites, and one
that I buy year in and year out. The Cuvée Reserva consists of approximately 85% Grenache
and 9% Syrah, with the rest of the blend made up by Merved and other permitted varietals.
The vines are grown in soils that are mostly clay and limestone. Importantly, however,
the vineyards also contain the famous Galet Roulet, or the large pebbles that we discussed
earlier in the video. With respect to winemaking, whole cluster fermentation is used, and the wines
are aged for 24 months in large oak foudre. While it's fun to taste Pagot when it's young,
I typically wait at least five to seven years or so. The decanter is also your friend when you open
Pagot. It's not uncommon for them to need an hour or two, or even more, to show their best.
So be sure that you plan ahead when you open one, or that you have another bottle to open and enjoy
while you wait for it to open up. My favorite vintages so far have been 2003, 2009, 2010,
and 2015 and 2016. Many of my purchases have been in the $50 range, and in fact I'm usually able to
get it pretty much every vintage from one of my favorite flash sites, which I will link in
the description below. If you're interested in other Cellar Defender videos, I have linked
several of them in the links below, so please be sure to check those out as well.