The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
UK Constitutional Law refers to the body of law and principles that govern the structure, functioning, and organization of the United Kingdom's political system and government. Unlike some countries with written constitutions, the UK's constitution is not found in a single written document but rather is a combination of various sources, including statutes, conventions, common law, and historical documents.
A. Bradley, K. Ewing & C.J.S. Knight, Constitutional & Administrative Law (18th edn, Pearson, 2022). R. Masterman & C. Murray, Constitutional & Administrative Law (Cambridge University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In the previous lesson we started looking at the concept of the separation of powers in the
United Kingdom and we explored this as a fundamental building block, a fundamental principle of the UK's
constitutional setting. In this lesson we're going to move on to the next major principle which is
this idea of the rule of law and we're going to explore the rule of law in two lessons. We'll
talk about the rule of law in its generality in this lesson and then we will talk about the rule
of law more specifically in relation to the works of A.B. Dicey in the next lesson. So we've been
examining the various different principles of the UK constitution. We looked specifically with
reference to the doctrine of separation of powers, the way in which this applies to the UK's
constitutional framework. In this lesson we're going to explore the next of these major principles.
This is the idea of the rule of law in more detail. So as we noted in our lessons on the English
legal system, the rule of law is a particularly difficult thing to define precisely. For those
of you who want to have a basic overview of this go over to our lessons on the English legal
system that we've done already. But it's true, it is difficult to define precisely what the rule of
law actually entails. Now the majority of legal theorists, what they do instead is talk not about
trying to define the rule of law by just giving us a simple definition but instead try to highlight a
number of the basic qualities that the rule of law entails. So looking at the different things
that the rule of law encompasses rather than looking at a specific and strict definition of
the rule of law. So we'll be focusing the majority of our time looking at some of those basic
principles which have been elucidated by constitutional theorists. So ultimately if we take
a leaf out of the work of Joseph Raz from 1977 we can see that there are a number of principles that
can be said to encompass the rule of law. Now for the most part you would see broad agreement among
many constitutional theorists about whether or not each of these principles actually do form
part of the rule of law. At least there is a general consensus that the rule of law
is encompassing at least some of these principles. So things like the principle of
prospectivity in law, the principle of stability of law, the principle of clear and concise lawmaking,
the idea of an independent judiciary, the concept of natural justice, the idea of judicial review,
judicial accessibility, as well as checks on state authorities. These come from Joseph Raz as cited
by Partworth in 2020. So these are basic conceptions of what really solidifies the basic
understanding of what the rule of law is. We're talking about the idea that the rule
that law should be prospective. It should be clear when lawmaking is done.
There should be an independent judiciary that is able to adjudicate over various legal disputes.
There should be the idea of natural justice as well as checks on state authorities. So given this is
the case, let's look at what some of these mean in more detail. We won't go through all of them
because some of them are particularly very easy to understand. So, for example, clear lawmaking or an
independent judiciary. These are things that are quite easy. Some of the things that are a little
bit more complicated, things like natural justice, for example, and as I've cited here, the concept
of prospectivity of law. The idea that law has to be prospective essentially prohibits the idea
that law can be retrospective. That is the idea here. You could essentially
define this principle either in the positive or the negative. You could say law has to be
prospective or that law should not be retrospective. It ought not to be retrospective. What does
retrospectivity mean when we talk about law? Well, I could not and you should not be able to pass a law
tomorrow which outlaws an act that is committed today but then go on to prosecute individuals
for that action. So you can't retrospectively go back and start prosecuting people who committed
crimes when at the time it wasn't a crime. So if, for example, there was a repealing of all the
abortion laws in the United Kingdom, everything to do with abortion laws, it was now outlawed
completely. We lived in a very deeply religious Catholic state and it became the case that
abortions were illegal. The state should not then be able to go back and find every single person
who has aided in giving abortions or who has actually gone and had an abortion and then gone
and prosecute all those people because at the time they were not crimes. At the time they were not
committing an act that violated the law. It's only now that they are doing so. So the idea that law
should not be retrospective is a very basic principle. The common law has consistently
made it clear that law is not retrospective. For example, in the case in 1870 of Phillips and Eyrie,
we have this idea that retrospective laws are no doubt on its face of questionable policy
and contrary to the general principle that legislation by which the conduct of mankind
is to be regulated ought, when introduced for the first time, to deal with future acts and ought not
to change the character of the past transactions carried upon the faith of the then existing law.
So when a new law is passed, it is going to regulate the future. It does not regulate previous
actions that had been committed by individuals. Retrospective law making is also not just only
a violation of principles from the common law, it is also a violation of article 7 of the European
Convention on Human Rights for which the United Kingdom is still a member at the time of recording
and I'm recording this lesson on the 20th of October 2023 and at the moment we are still
members of the Council of Europe and the ECHR. So what about the idea of openness in law making?
Well this idea essentially tells us that the law must not be vague or it must not be inaccessible
or it must not be uncertain when it is being made. The law must be such that people are able
to understand and follow the rules which are being put in place. So there shouldn't be any kind of
really really difficult to understand, convoluted, inaccessible and uncertain ways in which the law
should operate. It should be very very easy. This not only fits into the concept of the rule of law
but it also fits into the concept of the logic of law. Law should be logical and coherent and
it should be very clear that the rules that are in place are the rules that are very easy to
understand. This is why, by the way, whenever somebody tells me that doing a law degree is
very very difficult or that law is somehow a very complicated subject, I would come back to them and
say that the thing about law is it is supposed to be very very clear, very very accessible and very
very certain in the way that it operates. That's not to suggest that it isn't and it's not to
suggest that there aren't complexities that exist when studying law, but for the most part it is
quite easy. And that is not only a principle of the logic of law from a philosophical perspective
but it is also a principle of the rule of law in this way as well. Again according to Parkworth
in order for people to understand what it is that the law requires them to do or refrain from doing
it is necessary that the law is free from ambiguity and uncertainty. If you don't know whether or not
you have to perform a certain act in a certain way because you don't know what the law actually says
because it is uncertain as to what the actual rule is intended, then that is a violation of the rule
of law. Continuing on then, what about the principle of natural justice? What does this actually mean?
Well natural justice is just the general principle that individuals have a right to a fair hearing
on account of what is being accused. So this is essentially the right to a fair trial, the right
to a fair accounting of the facts, a fair accounting of what has been accused with the absence of any
kind of bias. It pertains mainly to the idea of the fair and free judicial process which of course
instills a number of further principles such as things like the right to a fair trial, the right
to a trial in and of itself, the presumption of innocence at trial and the following of proper
and effective judicial procedures. In addition to principles of natural justice it should also be
noted that the judiciary ought to be completely independent and it should be free from bias which
sort of fits into a principle of natural justice that we previously explored. If the government
is able to influence the decisions of the judiciary then this suggests that they would not
be able to properly deliver the rule of law in cases where the government may be a defendant
which is actually quite a lot of the case and a lot of the time the government is a defendant
especially within administrative law and judicial review procedures. There's lots of examples where
the government represents or is either a claimant or a defendant in judicial cases.
This is achieved through a number of mechanisms this idea of judicial independence so things like
security of tenure, security of pay, the sort of obligation to ensure that pay is fixed and
there is no question of bribery. Finally then let's think about what access to justice means.
So the ability for an individual to gain access to justice is an important part of the rule of
law. The case of the crown and Wiltham the Lord Chancellor says that access to the courts is a
constitutional right it can only be denied by the government if it persuades parliament to pass
legislation which specifically permits the executive to turn people away from the court door.
This is quite interesting because it says here that ultimately access to court access to justice
is a constitutional right and many would argue that this fits into the broader narrative of the
rule of law but then they qualify it and they say that we can only deny access to justice we can only
deny this principle if the government is able to get parliament to pass legislation and this really
ties into the question of which of these principles is most important because what
this is saying here is that it is highlighting a principle of the rule of law but then it is
talking about how this rule of law principle can be trampled on in the face of the principle of
parliamentary sovereignty the idea that if the government wants to deny the right of an individual
to access justice they can only do so by getting the parliament to pass legislation. So that sort
of brings you gives you a bit of an idea as to the position of parliamentary sovereignty in this
broader conversation of which is which is the next principle that we're going to get to in future
lessons time.