Joe Lawler on Elizabeth Warren's wealth tax on families with over $50 million

Elizabeth Warren's News
3 followers
Apr 5, 2026
But for your company, it's very, very difficult, as you may know that infamous quote about
Trump saying that his valuation, his net worth based on his company changes from day to day
based on the markets or even what he feels internally.
So yeah, that is a huge challenge that would make the tax really difficult for the IRS
to maintain.
Welcome to The Debrief, where we talk with the Washington Examiner's top journalists
about the headlines they're covering and where the story's going next.
I'm Sarah Bedford, and I'm here with Policy Editor Joe Lawler.
Joe, Senator Elizabeth Warren has rolled out a new wealth tax proposal, and potentially
this could be something that could position Democrats to have more to run on in the midterms
and beyond.
Tell us what's in this wealth tax proposal.
Sure.
So the proposal is to tax wealth specifically, not income.
So what we have in the U.S. now is an income tax, right?
You say how much you earn each year, and you get taxed on that.
What Warren is proposing is for very rich people, they'd have to say how much wealth
they have, their net worth, and then a tax would be applied on that.
So it'd be for those with more than $50 million in wealth, a 2 percent rate, I think, maybe
going up to 3, and then it would be higher for billionaires.
And it would actually go up even to 6 percent in the case of the money being directed to
a health care plan.
So it's a plan that is tied in some ways to the things that she wants to spend, that Senator
Warren wants to spend the money on as well, such as health care, housing, efforts to
stop climate change, and things like that.
So basically what it is is a more left-wing version of what we've ever had in the U.S.,
right?
We've never had a wealth tax like this.
We've only had income taxes.
So this might be a financially illiterate question, but under a proposal like this,
what would wealth look like?
Is it your houses?
Is it your stock portfolio?
How do they judge how much money you have?
Because in theory, you could be making millions a year and just blow it all on European vacations
and stuff and not, on paper, be as wealthy, right?
So what are they taxing?
That's right.
And that's really the question that is very difficult to answer, and it's why these wealth
taxes have generally not worked in the places they've been implemented, because it's almost
impossible to implement them.
In the case of this one, it would be stocks and bonds, and also privately held companies.
And that's where it gets very difficult, right?
Because how do you value something that's not trading on the market?
If it's a stock, you can tell very easily, you can just go to the stock market and see
what the price is, and you can tax that.
Same for anything else that's traded publicly.
But for your company, it's very, very difficult, as you may know that infamous quote about
Trump saying that his valuation, his net worth based on his company changes from day
to day based on the markets, or even what he feels internally.
So yeah, that is a huge challenge that would make the tax really difficult for the IRS
to maintain.
Now, do you think that this is something that Democrats want to be promoting Hennigan to?
We're already in this midterm cycle and in the presidential cycle.
Do they see themselves getting mileage out of tax increases if they're just aimed at the wealthy?
Yeah, it depends on which Democrat, I guess, right?
So this is, I think, an effort by Warren to sort of set the left edge of the party saying,
if you endorse this tax, then you're with us, the progressives, the liberals, the left-wearers
who want to tax the wealthy and get them to pay their fair share and not use loopholes
to avoid paying taxes on the wealth that they've accumulated.
But more maybe market-oriented Democrats, more centrists, might want to steer clear
of this one, and that could be a potential fault line within the party.
And maybe it's something that we'll see in the Democratic primaries.
Well, Joe, thank you so much for being here today.
You can get more from Joe and the rest of the policy team at WashingtonExaminer.com.
