What Caused History s Greatest Civilisation Collapses BBC Timestamp BBC Studios

ancient literature
168 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
For the last 30 years, Egyptian archaeologist Fekri Hassan
has been looking for his own explanation of why Egypt turned from stability to chaos.
I felt compelled to find out why did it happen when it did, especially when Egypt was doing so
well, when we had the pyramids, when we had temples, when we had the statues, when we had
major achievements in arts, literature and everything else. Why did it end at that time?
And so I had to pursue that question. I had to find out for myself the reasons
for the sudden and unprecedented collapse of the old kingdom.
Fekri Hassan has always challenged orthodoxy. The conventional wisdom is that the old kingdom
fell apart after the death of a pharaoh, and the battle for succession caused a major political
conflict. For Fekri, this just didn't ring true. The first seed of doubt was planted in 1971,
when Fekri found evidence of something far more devastating than political unrest.
This little known tomb in southern Egypt has an astonishing story to tell.
The tomb belongs not to a pharaoh, but to a local governor called Ank Tifi,
who lived just after the collapse of the old kingdom.
For me personally, it's an incredible find. This is a remarkable tomb. This is one of the
most outstanding tombs in all of Egypt. It's in Ank Tifi's writings that Fekri
found the vital clue. The hieroglyphs tell of horrendous famines and the sufferings of ordinary
people. It is rarely that we have a voice from the past that gives us a poignant account
of what has happened, of the horrors, the famines that happened 4,000 years ago.
And to have them reported in such a concise and clear fashion is unprecedented.
The entire country has become like a starved grasshopper, to such a degree that they're
eating their children. For Fekri, the writing on the wall was far too powerful to be ignored.
In these caves, Meera Bar-Matthews has found a unique record of past climates.
All the water here comes from rainfall. As the rain filters down through the rock,
it dissolves the limestone, forming stalactites and stalagmites.
And as these gradually build up over the years, they trap ancient rainwater. Meera has discovered
a way of calculating rainfall thousands of years ago, by taking tiny samples of the stalactites.
The ancient rain contains two different types of oxygen, a light one and a heavier one.
If there is more of the light type, it was a very wet period. More of the heavy one means
it was dry. Analysing the samples in a mass spectrometer gives the ratio of light and heavy
oxygen. Meera had been analysing stalactites stretching back over thousands of years,
when she got to one sample 4,200 years old. As soon as she saw the results,
she knew something unusual had happened. The striking finding was that there is a very
important change in the amount of rainfall that was in this area.
Meera had found a staggering 20% drop in rainfall. This suggested a sudden and significant climate
change. This drop is dramatic. This event is the largest event over the last 5,000 years.
Even though Egypt and Israel have different weather systems, this finding was very exciting.
Rapid climate change was the culprit Fekri had been searching for.
He believed it was the prime suspect in the catastrophe that destroyed the old kingdom.
The reason why this powerful civilisation disintegrated at the height of its glory.
I firmly believe that in addition to gradual changes on millennial scale,
climatic change can also happen very rapidly, suddenly and swiftly with dramatic consequences
for people. Because abrupt climatic events happen very rapidly, within a few decades
they can influence the livelihood of people, causing famines and droughts. They are of such
magnitude and of such rapidity that people cannot deal with them in the way they would deal with a
protracted long-term climatic change. The bogs of Ireland. Slices of trees from these bogs
contain a record of climate stretching back over 7,000 years. Each year the trees put on a ring
of growth. During the good years, those growth rings are thick. In bad years, so small they can
be hard to measure. When Mike Bailey measured the tree rings in one particular sample,
something made him sit up and take notice. This is a piece of Irish oak. It grew for about 300
years and then was buried in a peat bog and has survived to the present time. It was actually
growing about three and a half thousand years ago. Now my interest in this is that when you
look at the exactly dated rings across this period, you find that the tree has been growing
quite well up until 1628 BC, which is this ring, and 1627 there's no summer growth, nor in 1626,
nor for about 10 years thereafter. These are the narrowest rings in the entire life of this tree
and clearly it's the worst growth conditions that this tree had seen in its lifetime.
The trees can't tell us exactly what happened but the logic is that they were probably responding
to increased coldness or increased wetness or possibly both. The thing about wetness on a peat
bog is that if you raise the amount of water in the peat, raise the water table, you're likely
to cover up the roots of the trees and affect them in that way. So I certainly became interested in
whether this environmental downturn, probably involving cold and wet, was due to the eruption
of Thera. Absolute proof that the Irish oak trees were stunted by the eruption of Thera
has just been reported from one of the most desolate parts of the world. The ice sheets of
Greenland have built up over thousands of years from annual layers of snow. As the snow falls,
anything lingering in the atmosphere is swept up and locked into the ice. Sulfur from volcanic
eruptions is trapped as sulfuric acid. The snow that fell three and a half thousand years ago
is now over 700 meters deep. When Danish scientists tested the ice at that level,
they found a layer of sulfuric acid. Embedded in that acid layer were tiny shards of volcanic ash.
The shards have just been chemically fingerprinted. The unpublished results
have convinced the scientists that the ash came from Thera. I mean it's fantastic news because
what it gives us is the final link in the chain. What you've got is Thera linked to the acid in
Greenland. The acid in Greenland is occurring at exactly the same time as this reduced growth in
the Irish trees. So what you're seeing here are the direct environmental consequences of the
eruption of Thera. That is fantastic. The waves can travel thousands of kilometers across oceans.
When they hit land, the results can be cataclysmic, as they were a century ago in Southeast Asia.
Krakatau in Indonesia, 1883. 36,000 people killed by an eruption that was far less in intensity,
less than half the intensity of this eruption here. Those people were killed by tsunamis.
This means then that we should perhaps be looking for tsunami deposits here,
deposits left by these large waves. Evidence of those deposits has eluded archaeologists for
decades. Now Floyd has heard of an intriguing find that just might be what he's looking for.
In 1997, a team of geologists came to this saltwater marsh. They drilled deep down into
the ground and removed a core of mud. Back at a laboratory in Britain, one of the team started
sifting through the core. After months of patient work, Dale Dominie Howes found what he was looking
for. Tiny fossilized shells called forams. And forams are actually very helpful to us because
they live in a whole range of different environmental settings. Some like living in
very shallow marine conditions like on marshes. Others prefer to live in estuaries and some in
much deeper water. They're actually very useful because each individual species looks very
different. Under the microscope, the difference between the shells becomes clear. The one on the
As Dale examined the mud core more closely, he found something very peculiar.
As you go down through the core, you're going back in time. And all through the larger part
of the core, we're finding absolutely no forams at all. When you get to this point,
something very exciting happens. There's a very thin band or layer of sand, and this sand is
absolutely stuffed with marine forams. This type of forams found in the layer are fully marine and
come from much deeper water offshore. This means something very unusual happened here.
The very unusual high energy event that's brought these deep water species from offshore into the
marsh. So I suspect that this is actually the signature of a tsunami that's flooded into the
Dale's evidence suggests the volcano on Thera produced waves that traveled 100 kilometers
across the open sea. Their effect would have been felt right along the northern coast of Crete,
but most of all at harbor towns like Palai Kastro.
Much to his delight, Mexico's meticulous weather records revealed just what he'd hoped to find.
6.25, 89.62, 7. It turns out that in the last century there was one severe drought.
It was really a pretty bad drought. In fact, it happened in 1902, 1903, and 1904.
And given the fact that really severe drought is so rare, we're really pretty lucky that it showed up
in this 100 year record that we have here. A drought that lasted three years proved to Dick
that severe droughts not only could happen, but had happened. This was certainly a very
extraordinary moment. I hoped maybe if a pretty bad drought happened at least once,
maybe it happened twice, and maybe that other time was when the Maya disappeared.
But one destructive drought in the last 100 years
was not enough to hang a whole theory on. He had to search further back in time.
To delve more deeply into Mexican history, Dick had to visit a most unlikely place,
the city prison. Now the National Archives, it houses a unique collection of handwritten books,
some dating back to the 16th century.
After months of searching, Dick found a number of haunting accounts of
devastating droughts from the Yucatan province of Mexico, the heartland of the ancient Maya.
These reports that are contained in these books here are reports made by the Spanish
colonial authorities to their superiors in Mexico City or in Madrid. And this one,
for example, that I found is a plea for help from the authorities in Yucatan.
The crops had been very bad in the year 1795. They were running out of grain and they were
very much afraid that the terrible death that they had seen so often in the past
was going to repeat itself again. So they say, send help now.
Dick was now certain that he was on the right track.
If we walked outside right now, we'd be able to tell that it was cloudy,
we would be able to tell that it was cool and that there wasn't a great deal of wind,
but we wouldn't know about the greenhouse gas content. We wouldn't know if it was stormy out
in the oceans. We wouldn't be able to tell as richly what we can tell from the ice core record
going back through time. And that's a pretty odd thought when you think about it. We've captured
something that's almost better at telling us about the past than we're able to tell by going out
sniffing the air outside. Paul has constructed a uniquely accurate history of global weather
from his ice cores. When he heard about Dick's drought theory, he decided to check his cores
for the 9th century. Would he be able to find any evidence of dramatic climate change in the
Northern Hemisphere? First thing that we looked at was our record of ammonium. And ammonium is
a chemical that gets up into the atmosphere, which tell us whether or not there was a lot
of vegetation in the Northern Hemisphere. If there's a lot of vegetation, one assumes it was
probably warm and wet. Low amounts that it was probably drought conditions, that there weren't
a lot of plants, the soils had probably dried up. And when he looked at the ice that was 1200 years
old, he was astonished. We found that there was a tremendous drop in ammonium. They in fact had
probably not experienced a drought like this going back to maybe 3000 years.
So the ice cores confirmed Dick's hunch. At exactly the time of the Maya collapse,
it was dry and cold across the Northern Hemisphere.
The very conditions that would indicate drought in the Maya areas.
But archaeologists remained unconvinced. If there had been such a severe drought,
why was there no record of it in the Maya's own chronicles?
The Maya carvings tell of great battles of ruling dynasties and all powerful gods.
I decided to see whether the Maya had written anything about drought. We don't find anything
on their monuments and buildings, but I thought that if drought were a regular part of Maya life,
that they must have written about it somewhere. Then he had a stroke of luck. He came across this
rare manuscript written by the Maya. One of the few that had not been destroyed by the Spaniards.
So I came to this Maya book to see whether there was any discussion of drought. And right here on
the last page, there it is. There is a hieroglyphic symbol for drought. They did write about drought.
It was an ongoing issue.
