The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
UK Constitutional Law refers to the body of law and principles that govern the structure, functioning, and organization of the United Kingdom's political system and government. Unlike some countries with written constitutions, the UK's constitution is not found in a single written document but rather is a combination of various sources, including statutes, conventions, common law, and historical documents.
A. Bradley, K. Ewing & C.J.S. Knight, Constitutional & Administrative Law (18th edn, Pearson, 2022). R. Masterman & C. Murray, Constitutional & Administrative Law (Cambridge University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
In the previous lesson what we did was examine the fundamental principles of the UK's constitution
and we did so from a sort of generic introductory perspective. We talked about the concept of the
rule of law, we talked about the concept of parliamentary sovereignty and we also talked
about what is going to be the first of our concepts that we're going to explore in more detail,
this idea of the separation of powers. Now ultimately what we're going to do in this
is start to look at these principles in more detail. So we're going to take the first of the
fundamental principles of the UK constitution, this obviously being the idea of the separation
of powers. I'm going to talk about how this is operationalised within the UK's constitutional
framework. So fundamentally the separation of powers is quite an old concept, to an extent you
may argue that it has its ancient and Aristotelian origins in some regards, but in terms of its
modern conception and the way in which we can understand the separation of powers today,
we can really date ourselves back to the more Enlightenment philosophers that exist. For example
provincial French nobleman Montesquieu argues that ultimately when legislative power is united
with executive power in a single person or in a single body of the magistrate there is no liberty
because one can fear that the same monarch or senate that makes tyrannical laws will execute
them tyrannically. Nor is there any liberty if the power of judging is not separate from the
legislative power and the executive power. If it were joined to legislative power, the power over
the life and liberty of the citizen would be arbitrary, for the judge would be the legislature.
If it were appointed to executive power, the judge could have the force of an oppressor. This is
really a passage that explains what the importance of the separation of powers ultimately entails,
why the separation of powers is an important concept. Because if power was not separated,
if you have these distinct concepts when it comes to government structure, the idea of making laws,
executing laws and upholding laws, and that they were all united under one single unitary body or
one single person, then you have this idea of tyranny. You have somebody who is able to make
a tyrannical law and then also execute the tyrannical law and have no pushback in doing so.
When we have a separation of powers and when we have checks and balances on each of the
branches of government, you have the ability for certain branches to potentially pass tyrannical
laws, but then for other branches to check that authority and to ensure that those tyrannical laws
are not executed or not upheld, for example. And so really the common understanding here is the
rationale behind the separation of powers. And we can see the traditional rationale in this
formal passage. The aim here is of course to preserve the liberty of the citizenry by distributing
state power across various and separate distinct branches of government. Remember that what is
happening when we talk about the relationship between the people and government is the people
are delegating to the state a significant amount of authority. We are as people delegating to the
government the ability to make laws that we have to follow, to uphold those said laws and to hold
the people to account if those laws are broken. So the general idea here is what we are trusting
in the government, a certain amount of power, and so in order to preserve the liberty of the
citizenry that power has to be checked. And one way in which it is checked
is through the separation of powers, by distributing authority across different branches.
Another way of course is through democratic election, as you can probably understand.
So the result of which is that no one branch becomes too powerful and so the insurance here
is that we do not have the suppression of civil liberties. So given that that's the rationale for
the separation of powers, what do we look when we see the separation of powers as applied to the
United Kingdom? Well ultimately the traditional understanding of the separation of powers
entails a delineation of authority between three major branches of government. We have an executive
branch of government, we have a legislative branch of government, and we have a judicial branch of
government. And this is what is considered to be the traditional understanding of separation of
powers, at least from a level which is from the same level should I say, because in some cases
you have a federal state where not only is power separated horizontally across three different
branches, but is also separated vertically between federal, state, and local government institutions.
In the US we have these three branches of government for example. At the federal level, so
making it clear that we're talking about this at the federal level, the US Constitution outlines
three distinct branches of government. We have the executive branch which is representative
at the federal level with the President and the White House mostly. We then have the legislative
branch or the legislature. Again this is represented by Congress, the houses of Congress,
the House of Representatives and the Senate. And then you have at the federal level the Supreme Court
which represents the judiciary. And the Constitution outlines that each of these three branches will
have the power to check all of the others. And it also makes it very clear that these three
branches are clearly distinct and separate branches. You cannot be, for example, a member of the
executive and a member of the legislature at the same time. Sometimes you have members of Congress
who want to run for President, they would have to resign as Congress people, or at least
don't run for re-election during a Congressional election, in order to then run for Presidential
election instead. And if they fail they can go back to Congress, but they cannot hold the position
of being a member of Congress and a member of the executive at the same time. This strict and
constitutionally mandated separation of powers, however, does not exist when we apply our principles
to the United Kingdom. Because one of the reasons why is because we have an uncodified Constitution.
We don't have a specific document which outlines the exact ways in which the different branches of
government have relationships with each other. Instead we have what is sometimes described as a
partial separation of powers. So rather than having, for example, an executive and a legislative
branch which are both completely distinct and separate, these institutions are in fact fused.
So we have the fact that the government, the executive branch, sits in Parliament and has
parliamentary legislative authority. It has the authority and contributions to the passing of law.
Now this is not to suggest that they are so merged that we cannot delimit them, we cannot
delineate between the government and the legislature, or between government and Parliament
within our system, but it's just that they perform similar functions. They perform the same functions,
they sit in the same institution. And so in the next lesson we'll go through
essentially the ways in which the separation of powers is applied to the UK system.
We will talk specifically about this idea of a fusion of powers between the executive
and the legislative branch. We'll talk about the changes in separation of powers when we
looked at the ways in which the judiciary has become separated from this legislative centre.
And we'll also talk about the role of specific institutions such as that of the role of the Lord
Chancellor.