22 Years of Rental Income – The Brutal Financial Reality!

Profitable Property
4 followers
17 Video Views·Apr 1, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
What actually happens if you buy a rental property with $0 down and hold it for over two decades?
That's exactly what I did with my first rental property 22 years ago. Since then, I've bought
dozens of rental properties, but that very first one taught me some of the most important lessons
about real estate investing. Because after owning it for 22 years, the results were not exactly what
I expected, especially with the cashflow. So in this episode, I'm going to show you
exactly what happened with that deal, including all of the numbers and my key takeaways.
And in case you're curious, after owning the property for 22 years, it's produced about
$41,300 in cashflow. Using the tenant's rent, I paid off about $38,000 of the original loan,
and the property is now roughly worth $244,000 after buying it originally for $95,000.
But those final numbers don't tell the real story because the early years of this investment were
pretty rough. So let's go back to the beginning. Back in 2004, I bought a three-year-old, simple,
three-bedroom house in Easley, South Carolina. Easley is in the upstate of South Carolina,
very close to Greenville, which is a beautiful small city and also the headquarters of BMW and
Michelin North America. But just two years earlier, I had graduated from Clemson University,
and although I didn't have any personal debt thanks to a football scholarship, I was very
short on cash. And I didn't have a regular job or income because I was trying to be a full-time
real estate investor. So in order to buy this first rental property, I had to be scrappy and
creative financially. Here's what the numbers look like when I bought it. The price I actually
paid for this property was $94,050. And at that time, I was out looking for properties,
doing different things. I actually put signs out that said, I buy houses, and I got a call from a
seller. And they were interested in selling it because they had two houses they were making
payments on. They'd recently gotten married. This is a property that was sitting vacant.
They didn't like the fact they were making payments on it. So we discussed the property,
and we ended up making a deal where I took over payments on their existing mortgage. This is a
deal structure called buying subject to the mortgage. Not something I do a lot anymore,
but I have videos and episodes on my channel if you want to check out more about how that works.
But essentially, I was able to use their existing mortgage of $87,900, and we got the deed to the
property. And we ended up paying them $5,500 in cash. The seller walked away with $5,500.
We also had $650 in closing costs. So there's still some cash, which I actually didn't have
at the time. I've mentioned to you that I didn't have a lot of cash. So we ended up also borrowing
a second mortgage from a private lender. This happened to be a close family member who had
$6,500 that they were willing to loan at 7% interest. And so we basically borrowed the
entire amount of money we needed for the property. So I mentioned there was no money down. Subject
to mortgage, $87,900, $6,500 second mortgage at closing that we used to pay the seller their
money. Because I was a new investor, I was excited that I was able to buy this first rental property
with no money down. And I also ran the numbers thinking that the numbers looked pretty good.
And here's approximately what they were at the time. I thought the rent was about $795
to $895. And I knew there were some expenses. And the expenses I thought I would have were
property taxes, $487 per year or $41 per month, insurance on the property, $698 per year or $59
per month. And it was a relatively new property, three years old. So I thought the maintenance
would be pretty minimal at $50 per month. So at the naive numbers I was running as a new investor,
for those of you who are more experienced, you know I'm missing some things like vacancy
and capital expenses and other things. But the numbers I ran at the time, I thought we would
make an NOI, net operating income, of $645 to $745 per month. That's the money you make before you
make your mortgage payment. And then we had a $574 payment on our first mortgage and a $38 payment
on our second mortgage. So we thought $33 to $133 or maybe about $100 a month was the amount of
cash flow we would make. And we also looked at the value of the property. We bought it for $95,000.
We estimated that the value was about $105,000 to $115,000. So we thought we had a little bit
of equity if we wanted to resell the property as well. But the actual reality of this rental
was not as good as I had hoped or expected. In 2004, we actually lost $2,329. That's negative
cash flow. 2005, negative cash flow of $3,472. And in 2006, negative cash flow of $3,572.
Now, if I'm honest with myself, I wasn't even keeping track of numbers that well
as a new landlord. I was just trying to figure things out, trying to survive,
trying to get to the next step. And so as I thought about this deal, I went back and
reconstructed all the actual numbers into a spreadsheet. And I want to share that spreadsheet
with you so you can see what actually happened over the years and how this deal that started
really badly actually became a good deal over time. So the spreadsheet I made helps me track
cash flow, the growth, and even the return on investment of this one property over time.
And if you want to follow along or just get this as a template to use on your own properties,
you can actually get it for free at coachcarson.com forward slash first rental spreadsheet. I'll also
have a link to that in the YouTube and the podcast description below. But as you start looking at
the spreadsheet, you'll notice that it sort of broke down into three different phases of my
ownership of this property. And as I mentioned before, the early ownership was not pretty from
a cashflow standpoint. You can see these red cells here. The first five years were negative
cashflow. And you're probably asking yourself is like, why was it negative cashflow? You ran the
numbers and it looked like it was okay when you pencil those numbers out. And actually the
insurance cost that I estimated was about right. The taxes were about right. When I looked at those,
even the maintenance was about right. The problem we had was we were learning how to become a
landlord. Actually, we're learning how not to be a good landlord because we had a tenant who was a
very nice person and we let her move into the property, but she was self-employed and she was
very up and down with her income and with her payments to us. And so we actually averaged a
lot less than the market rent. You can see I averaged out like the monthly rent each year
that we averaged for that year. It was $600 in 2005, $415 in 2006, 636, 561, 692. So for the
five or six years, we didn't even get up to that bottom level of our market rent. And it wasn't
until 2011 after the great recession. So we also ran into the great recession where we just had to
hang on to any good tenant we could get and our rents weren't as good. So we had a rough go at it
for seven, eight years until we kind of hit this phase two where we turned a corner and we finally
started getting some positive cashflow in those 2009, 10, 11, and 12. And really 11 and 12 were
big years, 4,000 and 4,796. And so the lesson I took from that was hanging on and just having
rents grow over time. They can stay flat for a half a decade, sometimes even a decade. And so
you have to be pretty patient and make sure it cash flows on the front end or make sure you can
handle the negative cashflow during those early years. And so when we hit phase two, we're finally
getting a little bit of positive cashflow. Even then there's some roller coasters. So we had some
ups and downs. We had some turnovers in 2012 that really kind of reduced the amount of money we were
collecting. We actually had some extra expenses that year, I'm sorry, 2013. We had some bad
collection years, a lot of turnover and some vacancies while we were trying to get the
property re-rented. So we had a little bit of a roller coaster, but it got back into positive
cashflow. And really the phase three of the property has been the last five or six years.
And I told you earlier in this video that we averaged, we had a 41,000 plus in cashflow
during the entire 22 years. But if you look at it, the last five years averaged about 7,000 bucks.
So 7,000 times five is 35,000. Almost all of the cashflow came in the end of this rental
properties journey, not in the beginning. And so that's really something you've got to get
your head around. That's not uncommon, particularly when you use leverage or debt, particularly when
you use no money down. Even though we had no money down, our down payment was the fact that we had a
very, very tight cashflow. In fact, it was a negative cashflow. So our investment in the
property, you can think about it as the down payment, was the negative cashflow in those early
years. But now if we just sit on this property and want to start collecting cashflow, it's now
making a solid cashflow and we've paid the debt loan down a lot. We have a lot less debt on the
property. And so that helps as well. But it just gives you the picture of the phases of cashflow
as you hold and grow your rental property. So you might be wondering that after a 22 year period,
I made just over $41,000 in cashflow. Is that enough? Was it worth even doing the deal in the
first place if I wanted to build wealth and I can only make $41,000? And the answer is that when you
own a rental property, there's actually three different core wealth building engines going on
at the same time. And in this case, cashflow is definitely a part of it, but it was only 18%
of the total wealth that I built on this deal. There was also debt pay down. So just by collecting
rent and even if I broke even and I made my mortgage payment every single month, a little
bit of each mortgage payment was going towards principal. And then aggregate in total over that
time, it was almost $38,000. But then the biggest portion of the wealth building in this deal,
65% of my total came from the appreciation of the price of the property. So remember,
I bought it for 95,000 and at the end, it appreciated much more than that. And so 150,000
almost in wealth was built just because of the change in price of the property. And I want to
show you what that looks like over time, because remember, I bought it in 2004 for 95,000. And you
can see on this chart that in the early years, there was a little bit of a bump early on where
it might've been worth $107,000 a year after I bought it, because I bought it a little bit below
the full value, but it was very flat over those years. And I hit the great recession. And so
things were even flatter through 2012 to 2013. And this is really the nature. And one of the
key lessons of buy and hold real estate is that you go through these waves of appreciation. And
at least I've had a hard time ever figuring out when those waves come. And I think anybody has
a hard time. And so the only solution to that is buying a property and holding it for the long run
so that you can catch those waves a lot like a surfer catches the waves when they just sit out
there in the water until the right wave comes. And you can see that wave with this chart, because
it starts growing up a little bit in 2015 to 16. I can get a nice little bump there. It's flat for
a couple of years, probably because I had the same tenant and I didn't want to raise the rent on them.
And then they move out and I can raise the rent again. Then we had this big wave in 2021 to 2024.
And that's where a lot of the growth happens. Now, when is the growth going to happen? It's
anybody's guess when it does, but all buy and hold investors benefit from that by setting up the deal
in the first place so that you can hold it over the long run. And when you look at the end result,
the actual appreciation rate of my particular deal was 4.59% over those 22 years, which is
actually a very strong appreciation rate. What's also interesting is that the price isn't the only
thing that went up in value. This chart shows the rent and how it went up over time. You remember
in 2004, I had the market rent at $790 per month. I wasn't actually getting that because I was not
doing a good job as a landlord, but it also stayed very flat for years, even dipped a little
bit for us in 2009, 10, and 11, as we just tried to keep good tenants in the property during the
recession. But then just like the price growth, it went through bumps. And sometimes the rent bumps
are at different times than the price bumps, which is kind of interesting to look at. But in 2012 to
14, I had a good bump. 2015 to 16, we had a big rent drop. And then even the last few years,
it's been kind of flat. And that is also the way it works, is you make a lot of your money
in the future years from the cashflow because you keep your mortgage fixed and you let your rent
grow, you let your price grow. And that's really, in a nutshell, these two charts for how you make
money with rental properties using leverage. So by holding this rental property over a 22-year
period, there was time for all three of those wealth engines to work. I got most of the work
from the appreciation of the property, but the cashflow and the debt pay down also contributed
to the overall return. And that brings us to a really important question on this deal, and really
on any investment deal, is what was my actual return on my investment? Because there's always
an opportunity cost. I could have taken that money that I spent in the early years of my deal and a
lot of the time and energy I put into this deal, and I could have put it somewhere else. I could
have just put it in the stock market. I could have put it in the bank. I got a CD. So you always want
to compare a particular investment or a particular strategy to the alternatives you could have out
there. And my favorite way to do that is what you see now here on the screen is an internal rate of
return. And what that means, if you haven't ever heard of that, is you're basically looking at the
entire investment over the length of the investment, the whole length of time, and giving it an annual
return on investment. It takes the time value of money, and it takes all of those returns,
the appreciation, the cashflow, and the debt pay down, and it puts it all together and gives you
an annual return. And on this deal, I was pleasantly surprised to see that we made over a 19% return
over the length of the investment. Now, what does that mean? Again, it means that I invested some
negative cashflow early in the deal. I made a little bit of positive cashflow. At the very end
of the deal, I'm assuming that I sold this property at the end of last year. I still own the property,
but for the purposes of this analysis, I assume that I sold it for the value in 2025, made 6%
closing costs, had to pay a real estate agent, some other fees, and I had to pay my mortgage
off of 50,000 bucks. So what's left over is I got a big chunk of capital at the end, 179,000
in year 2025. And I added that to all the other cashflow I got over the years and asked the
formula, what is that rate of return? And it comes out to 19%. Figuring out whether you have a good
rate of return or a bad rate of return is a very personal thing. You have to compare it to other
alternatives you have and to the risk that you took on the deal. In my case, I'm happy with a
19% return. I think that's a good standard to keep myself to, especially when I use a lot of leverage
like that. You might say, Chad, you had a small down payment. So of course, you're going to have
high return on investment. So I wanted to do one similar analysis where I look at the unleveraged
internal rate of return. And that just means I assume that I didn't have any mortgage on this
property. I just paid 100% cash back in 2004. I paid 94,000 if I had the cash to do it. And I
would say, what would my return on investment be in that case? And what's interesting about that
analysis is I wouldn't have a mortgage, so I would have made cashflow all along, all through those
years. I would have sold the property for the same price, had the same closing costs, but I
wouldn't have had a mortgage on the property. So I would have put a little bit more cash in my
pocket in year 2025. But it does the same analysis, and it shows me that in this case, I would have
made a 9.38% return. So this is a lower return than using leverage, but this is a much safer
deal. There's no risk of leverage, and there's no risk of the up and down of having to pay a
mortgage off. And so this is very typical. It shows you that when you use leverage, you hope,
you notice that there's no guarantee, but you hope you're going to make a higher return,
and there's an opportunity to make a higher return. If you use less leverage, you're typically
going to make a lower return. But in my case, I'm very happy with a 9, 10, 11% on leverage return.
So everything that we've done so far has been historical analysis. We've looked backwards at
this property to see how it did over time. Would I make that decision again? Would I change that
decision? And that's very helpful. But what I'd like to do is bring this back to the present and
do two more things. One, I want to help us make a decision on this property right now. So I have
a choice whether to keep this property, whether to refinance it, whether to sell it perhaps.
And I want to think about and use this spreadsheet tool to help me figure out what I should do at
this stage of my career. And then after that, I want to give you some takeaways. What were the
biggest top lessons that really changed my investing career and the way I think about investing
from this deal? I want to give you those little nuggets, those takeaways, so you can apply those
to your own investing. Let's start with the property as it is right now. Now, I like this
property. I like the fact that it's in a growing area, easily is in the suburbs of Greenville,
South Carolina. So I like to do a non-technical analysis, not the numbers, but just looking at the
region, looking at the property, looking at the neighborhood. And I ask myself a question like,
10 years from now, do I think strongly that this neighborhood and this area is going to get better?
People are moving into it. Do I think it's going to be the same? Do I think it's going to get worse?
And I ask myself that. I ask other people around me, my real estate agent, my property manager,
other investors. And I try to get a pretty strong thesis on what I think that the case is for this
property. And I feel pretty good about this property. So that is kind of the tailwind of my
decision here. But I also like to look at if I'm going to keep this property, what do the numbers
look like? Because the numbers matter a lot. That's how I pay the bills. This is what I use
to pay the bills for my family, are the rental properties like this. And so when I look at this,
I did what's called a proforma or a future analysis of the property. It's very similar
to the cashflow analysis we did in the past. But what I did is I took the averages and the
most recent numbers on all those expenses and the income, and then I project into the future.
So I add an appreciation rate to the expenses. I add a small appreciation rate to the rent.
And then I figure out what is the cashflow going to be. And in my case, it averages around 7,000
bucks or so in the early years. And it goes up a little bit, all the way up to about 9,000 bucks
10 years from now. And you can see it a little bit better through this visual chart. You can
see that the rent that we collect on the top and the blue line is going up because about 3.5%
per year or 3.2% per year was our appreciation rate that we're guessing. You know that's not
going to go exactly in a straight line like that. It's probably going to be flat, maybe down a
little bit and up just like it was in the past. There's no guarantees of the future, but I'm
pretty sure it's not going to go in a straight line like this. But then the expenses are also
going to go up. And if things go like we are projecting them, then we'll have some cashflow
that is more steady over time. And so I can look at this and say, is that good enough? In our case,
that contributes to the bottom line. I like that. But another question I need to ask myself when I'm
making that decision on keep it or refinance it or sell is what's my return on investment?
What is my projected return on investment? So just like when I looked at in the past,
I can do the same analysis. And this analysis is almost as if I'm buying this property back.
So the way I think about it is I could sell the property today. I could pay real estate
commissions. I could take a chunk of equity that I have left over and I can do something else with
it. So if I'm going to keep the property, I want to take that chunk of equity that I could go
reinvest and analyze it as if I'm going to buy this property back and say, what would the cashflow
be? What would the return be? And so I did a very similar analysis, that internal rate of return,
the annual return on my equity today, which I project is about 179,000. And I look at all the
cashflow I'll get for the next 10 years, including me selling the property 10 years from now. I'm
just guessing that I would sell it. And I had to pay real estate commissions. I'm doing all this
pre-tax by the way. So if I had to pay taxes on it, my return would be less, but I'm going to
assume that I can either refinance it or sell it 10 years from now and do a 1031 exchange.
Just keep things simple for now. And if I did that, my return on investment, my internal rate
of return is 8.5%. Now, again, is that a good return? Is that a bad return? Some of you are
going to be like, eh, I would definitely do another deal where I would definitely pull my
equity out and go invest in three other properties because you could have four properties instead of
one. And all that is true. But the thing I want to tell you about is I try to talk a lot on this
channel about the stages of your investing career and how where you are in your career
determines what investment decisions you make. So when you're in the starter phase, the first
phase trying to buy your first deal or two, you're just trying to get your feet under you. You're
trying to buy your first deal. That's it. When you get to the next stage, the wealth building phase,
it's all about return on investment and safely growing your nest egg to a much bigger nest egg.
And that's where I was early in my career when I bought this property. And early in the career,
I probably would have refinanced that and done something else. But where I am now, I'm in the
third phase, which is the harvester phase, where instead of maximizing growth, I'm still interested
in growth, but I'm more interested in peace of mind. I'm more interested in cash flow, and I'm
more interested in reducing my hassle and risk. And so for me, I have a very low debt level. We
could even pay the debt off at some point if I wanted to. I have a private loan to a person who
just likes getting the interest as a family member. That's where most of our debt that we
still have on our properties are. And so they like getting that 6% interest, and they don't
want to get paid off. We don't feel bad about that debt. And so for us, it's a very safe,
stable place to be in. And I could have peace of mind. I could spend most of my energy and time
making videos, being a volleyball parent, going to dance recitals, doing other things that at this
point in my life I'm more interested in. But that's the cool thing about investing, is everybody
might make a different decision. You could use the same tool and say 8.5% is not good enough.
But for me, the friction of doing another deal and having to take an extra hassle is not worth
the extra. I could probably do better than that, but it's not worth it for me in this case,
at least at this point, to do it. So that is the takeaway I want to have for this point,
is you can use tools like this to look in the historical analysis. You can look forward at
the property. You can make a personal decision that's right for you. And then hopefully after
all that analysis that you do and all that thinking you did, like I did on this deal,
you can get some key takeaways and nuggets that can help you do better on the next investment.
So that's what I want to share with you now. I had four big takeaway lessons when I think
about this deal and what's happened over the last 22 years. But if you have different lessons as you
listen to these, I'd love to hear from you in the comments. Let me know what your takeaways were.
My number one lesson was that when you have high debt or no money down or low money down,
as often happens with real estate investing, you're going to have a cashflow rollercoaster,
especially in the early years. I had five years of negative cashflow. I really didn't make any
positive cashflow for almost a decade. Now it's kind of an extreme version of a rental property.
Many people put 20, 30% down, and they might do a little bit better than I did.
But if you're using leverage and real estate, you live by the leverage, you die by the leverage,
and you're going to have to expect a cashflow rollercoaster if you want to get the benefits
of that leverage. Number two, there are benefits to having leverage. There are some risks and some
downsides, and it can be a little stressful at times. But when you combine leverage with
appreciation, and by appreciation I mean price appreciation, I also mean the rent appreciation.
You saw my rents went up over time. That is your number one growth engine as a real estate investor.
That is just a magical thing when you look at the chart over time. If you fix your mortgage over the
long run, that payment stays the same over the next 10 to 20 years, and the rent goes up,
the price goes up. That is the number one recipe still today to make a lot of money in real estate
investing. But lesson number three is in order to do that, to get the benefits of that growth engine,
time is your friend. You have to be patient. And it's really hard to do, especially when you're
having some negative cashflow or some negative situations with your rental properties,
it's hard to be patient. But the longer you wait, the longer you're patient. It's kind of like fine
wine. A rental property gets better over time. I always compare it to planting seeds in a garden.
I like planting blueberry bushes and apple trees in my backyard. And it'd be ridiculous to think
you plant a seed and three years from now, you'd be able to harvest apples. It typically doesn't
happen. You've got to plant the seed, water it, fertilize it, nurture it, let nature do its thing
in its own good time, and then you can pick the fruit from the tree. It's very similar to rental
properties. If you try to force it, you try to tell exactly when you can get the most money from it,
kind of like your apple tree, it's not going to work. You got to be patient and let time be your
friend. And then lesson number four, this is a sort of surprise that I didn't plan this at all,
but buying a relatively new rental has less issues over time. This was my first rental. I bought a
property that was three years old, and I bought other properties after that that were much older,
and I bought them a lot cheaper, and the cashflow looked better on the front end, but I had a lot
of repairs and expenses. This has been a relatively low repair property because it was built 25 years
ago, and we did have to replace the heating and air. We're going to have to replace the roof here
in the next three or four years. So there are things that come up eventually, but newer properties
I like as my rentals, and I'm actually doing more and more of that today to have lower hassle
rentals. So that was lesson number four for me. But again, I would love to hear from you and see
some of the comments you had. So that's the full story of my first rental property after 22 years.
It definitely wasn't perfect in the early years. There was mistakes, there was negative cashflow,
there was things I didn't learn yet. But over time, this one simple rental property ended up
teaching me some of the most important lessons about real estate investing and about patience.
The truth is this deal is just one small example. After more than two decades of buying and owning
rental properties, there are a lot of lessons I couldn't fit in this one story. So in my next
episode, I put together 22 years of real estate investing advice into one place. It's called 22
Years of Real Estate Investing Advice in 46 Minutes. In that episode, I walk you through
the biggest principles that have shaped how I invest today, including finding deals, managing
properties, and investing in a way that you can actually live the life that you want. If you're
watching this on YouTube, you can click on the thumbnail above me here. Or if you're listening
on the podcast or watching on YouTube, there'll also be a link in the podcast or the YouTube
description below. Thanks for watching or listening. I'll see you in the next episode.
