In this video, I’m putting two modern off-road legends head-to-head: the new Toyota Land Cruiser 2.8 diesel and the Land Rover Defender D250 with the 3.0-litre diesel.
Both of these are proper go-anywhere machines with serious heritage behind them, but in 2026 they’re aiming at very different buyers. The Land Cruiser stays true to its roots with a focus on durability, simplicity, and long-term dependability, while the Defender blends its iconic design with modern tech, comfort, and performance.
I drive them back-to-back on real roads to see how they compare as actual cars you’d live with every day — not just weekend off-road toys. We look at the engines, interiors, ride comfort, practicality, and the overall driving experience, and try to answer the big question: which one really makes the most sense to own?
So if you’re choosing between the Land Cruiser 2.8 diesel and the Defender D250, this is the comparison you’ll want to watch.
AI Generated·May contain errors
If you want an off-road vehicle which is solid and looks cool,
but realistically you're only ever going to use them on the school run,
then look no further than these two vehicles.
The Land Rover Defender and the new Toyota Land Cruiser.
Honourable mention is also the Ineos Grenadier,
but we couldn't get that today.
And in today's video we're going to compare these two impressive cars
by doing a series of tests.
We're going to compare how fast they both are from 0-60.
Oh there you go, already this is much quicker.
This is very fast with them.
See which one my dog prefers.
Do you like the colour?
And we're going to score each car to really determine which one is better.
So let's see which is better suited for everyday use.
It's Japan versus England.
I'm Max Haftervarney, welcome to Driven Plus.
Now first we're going to talk about the design of both cars.
We're going to start with the new Land Cruiser here.
And it's a very boxy design, but so is the Defender.
You've got the square grilles here, the Toyota badge.
You haven't got Land Cruiser like the Defender has Defender on the top there.
Of course on the Defender too you've got the checkered plating.
Whereas on this it's more of a cleaner design, shall we say.
But also I think when you compare this against the Defender and we compare the lights,
the first edition model which the Land Cruiser came with,
came with circular round lights like the Defender.
And then normal Land Cruiser models get these rectangular lights
with that kind of straight DRL here, which I actually prefer.
So on the front so far I prefer the look of the Land Cruiser.
Now let's move to the side here.
You've got 20 inch alloy wheels and they're nice and thick, they look quite nice.
And also you've got boxy design ring mirrors here, side steps too.
And I think the overall profiles of the Land Cruiser,
especially when we come to the back here,
I like this little hump when you come to the back.
And the fact you've got big nice roof rails too,
which is something you don't get on the Defender.
Moving to the back, I'm a big fan of the design of the new Land Cruiser.
One thing I really like is this button here.
You press that and up comes the rear glass,
which is something you don't get on the Defender.
But one thing you do get on the Defender but you don't get on the Land Cruiser
is the placement of the spare wheel.
I have to say, let's just go quickly have a look at the Defender for one minute.
We're going to touch on this in a second.
But that looks more off-roadish, doesn't it?
That looks utilitarian, it looks good, it looks ready to rock and roll.
But over here, the spare wheel on the Land Cruiser has been hidden away.
So it's on the bottom down there.
One thing I prefer on the Land Cruiser is the way the boot opens.
I'll show you what I mean in a minute.
So it opens electronically like that.
And you also get a third row of seats.
1,060 litres of storage in here.
It's massive, it really is very good.
And it comes down with a click of a button.
So say you go shopping or somewhere, this is easier to live with.
And I'm going to show you what I mean in a minute.
But the design of the rear lights, I like this.
But I have to say, I like the design of the rear lights of the Defender too.
Let me show you the Defender, let's go.
As you can see, it's very wide, it's got more presence about it.
And it's very bullish, if I was to be honest.
And I like the checkered plating you get on the top here, I have to say.
It's not as much of a cleaner design as compared to the Land Cruiser.
But I do like the Defender badging going on here.
You get some square grilling going on here.
There's a lot more going on compared to the Land Cruiser.
And when you look at the lights, I do like the design of these lights.
But I prefer the design of the Land Cruiser lights.
Now let's have a look on the side.
You get 22-inch alloy wheels, so they are bigger than the Land Cruiser.
And you get lower profile tyres.
However, this does sit on all-terrain tyres, whereas the Land Cruiser doesn't.
So when we take it on the road test later,
it'll be interesting to see which one has the better ride.
Because the Land Cruiser comes with a good old traditional ladder frame chassis.
This comes with a monocoque chassis.
I like the step in the trim here.
You get the side vent with the Defender logo.
I'll tell you one massive similarity between the two cars,
is the shape of the wing mirrors.
Very, very similar.
Side step here, which does look like it is missing the step.
And you get roof rails on this, as opposed to the Land Cruiser,
you get good old roof bars.
So it'd be probably easier to hitch things to the roof of the Land Cruiser,
as opposed to the Defender.
And when we come to the back here, it's a very continuous design throughout.
It's all very straight, whereas the Land Cruiser has a step in it.
And I like the glass, the introduction of this glass on all new Defender models.
Moving to the rear design of the Defender,
and I would say this is more sporty looking than the Land Cruiser.
And I like the introduction of the spare wheel here.
Because if you have a spare wheel, which is hooked up underneath the vehicle,
it's a pain getting it out when you're stuck.
Because I have actually been in that situation before,
when I've been stuck and I've had to get a spare wheel from underneath the vehicle.
It's an absolute nightmare.
So this is easier.
So well done Land Rover.
You get a spoiler on the top there, which makes it sporty looking.
And I do like the rear lights of the Defender.
I do like the rear lights of this, but I also like the rear lights of the Land Cruiser.
I'm going to give a point to the Defender in terms of the design of the rear lights.
Not a point overall for the design, but I just think I prefer the rear lights on this.
I think I said I prefer the rear lights of the Land Cruiser,
but I changed my mind now, because this is a different design.
And therefore, I think the Defender should be given a bit more credit.
Now, this is what I mean by the difference between the doors and how the boot opens.
This is like a door, so it's a little bit less practical.
Because when you've parked and you're putting your shopping in,
you have to account for that behind you, which is quite a big space.
Whereas on the Land Cruiser, it's easier.
It comes up like so, so there's less space.
But it's really easier loading stuff in.
One problem about this is how heavy the rear door is,
because obviously you've got the spare wheel on the back here.
There's no button you're pressing that does it itself.
Oh no, it's all manual in this.
But I think in terms of the overall design of both cars,
I'm going to give the point to the Land Cruiser.
Andy, you prefer the design of the Defender, don't you?
There you go, he does.
Well, it's all personal preference.
Personal preference for me, I prefer the Land Cruiser.
But I think one thing here between these two cars in particular,
one thing which is massively going for it in the Defender's favour is the colour.
I don't like the colour of the Land Cruiser.
I think the best colour to get the Land Cruiser in is the black.
If that Land Cruiser was in black today, I think you'd change your mind a lot.
That's why I prefer the design of the Land Cruiser.
Next, we're going to talk about engine choices of both cars.
And I'm sure, firstly on the Defender,
this won't be the last time the bonnet will be open.
Anyway, starting with this, this is called the D250 model.
So it's a 3-litre straight-six diesel engine.
However, you can get this with a four-cylinder diesel engine,
six-cylinder petrol engine, six-cylinder diesel engine.
And you can also get this with a V8 engine.
One being the P525 and, of course, the Land Rover Defender Octa,
which is a pretty cool vehicle.
So loads of options for everyone.
And this has 250 horsepower and 570 newton-metres of torque.
So that's pretty good considering it's the D250.
My sweet spot on this, the one I like, is the P400.
That's a nice vehicle.
Anyway, moving to the Land Cruiser, where things...
Yes, you don't get those type of options in this vehicle.
And therefore, I think this car's biggest problem
is the fact that you are limited.
In the UK, this is the only engine you can buy.
It's a 2.8-litre four-cylinder diesel engine.
And there's nothing wrong with it.
But I just feel as if you look at the Defender
and you go from a four-cylinder all the way to a V8.
Whereas in this, you only get a four-cylinder.
205 horsepower and 500 newton-metres of torque, which is really good.
Also, in the US, you can get this with a 2.4-litre four-cylinder hybrid engine.
But that's it.
The problem is, you cannot buy the new Land Cruiser with a six-cylinder or V8 engine.
And when you look at the Lexus version of the Land Cruiser, the GX550,
you can get that car with a 3.5-litre V6 engine, which is twin-turbocharged.
Wake up, Toyota, please offer that engine in this vehicle.
So therefore, for that reason,
the fact that you get so many limited options with the Land Cruiser's engine choice,
the point here goes to the Defender.
So, we're on the road and we're going to start by driving the new Land Cruiser.
And let me outlay the positives to you.
It's got a brilliant drive position.
I have to say, the way you sit on the road is fantastic.
The vision out is great.
You can see in every direction.
And I particularly like the rear-view mirror too.
And when you flick that switch, it switches to a camera.
So, that's a good gimmick too.
And another thing is, I really like the compliancy of the suspension of this car.
It's not too firm and it's not too loose, if you get what I mean.
It's just right.
So therefore, the comfort levels of this Land Cruiser is very good.
And I kind of get a sense in this vehicle that this will last forever.
And it is actually built very well when you're driving it.
Will I get the sense that the Defender will last forever?
Well, I'm not so sure.
We'll find out in a minute.
And next, we're going to talk about the engine.
And I do quite like this engine because it's torquey.
It's diesel.
It's quite good.
I like a diesel engine.
Just tickle the throttle and it drops down the gear and off you go.
It produces good torque.
500 Newton meters, in fact.
And the horsepower is just over 202.
So the engine-wise, it's pretty good.
However, it's a little loud for what it needs to be.
And I don't know whether Toyota have done this on purpose.
So therefore, it feels like you get a bit more of an older school experience in a new SUV
or a new off-road vehicle.
If they have, brilliant.
They've done very good at that.
And the other thing is just the overall noise of the vehicle too.
You get a lot of wind noise.
And I don't know whether these massive ring mirrors are doing that.
But when you're sitting on the motorway at 70, 80 miles per hour, it's quite a loud place to be.
It's not as refined as you might think.
But there's one place where this engine will come into its own.
And that's MPG.
This car has been averaging 29 to the gallon, which is very good.
And that's where this four-cylinder diesel engine will come into its own.
And that's not even after a long run.
That's just going around town.
And it's not the most aerodynamic vehicle, is it?
Because when we look at the Defender, we're going to see what the Defender does later on.
I don't think it's going to be that because it's six cylinders.
So I suppose that's one good point about this engine.
So my overall experience of driving this Land Cruiser is very good.
Once you've got all the safety features switched off, it's a much better place to be.
So let's see what the Defender's like.
So on the road in the Defender, and okay, this is a commercial vehicle.
So I understand it's got no rear windows.
And I am missing the natural light coming in from the panoramic sunroof you get in the Land Cruiser.
So in terms of the driving experience, I feel better about myself for driving the Land Cruiser.
It gives me a better driving position.
And the vision out from the Land Cruiser is better too.
Because the windows are lower down.
It's got a better windscreen.
And the vision out the back too is better in that remark.
But in terms of overall ride, I think the Defender is probably a better place to be.
I think it's smoother.
It's more comfortable.
And it's much more refined.
And I think that refinement comes from its engine.
That silky smooth 3-litre straight-six diesel engine.
You're going to struggle to beat the refinement of a straight-six.
And the ZF 8-speed automatic transmission.
Once you combine those two things, this car is very good.
And in terms of the comfort levels and the overall engine noise and wind noise,
this is on another level compared to the Land Cruiser.
What car would I rather live with on a day-to-day basis?
But it'll actually be this.
Because I don't have to raise my voice to speak to you.
I can turn my head to the passenger.
And not be annoyed by all the driver detection safety features you get in the Land Cruiser.
Which is far too sensitive in my opinion.
And the suspension.
It's good in the Land Cruiser.
But the overall body lean and body control is better in the Defender on the road.
Simply because it's a monocoque chassis.
And that's the difference between the two cars.
And one thing we spoke about in the Land Cruiser was MPG.
And that was averaging around 29 to the gallon, wasn't it?
28.9.
Or something like that.
And this is averaging.
Let's have a look.
Let's go through the menus.
Wow.
27.9 to the gallon.
So one mile per gallon difference.
And that's the difference of two cylinders.
And an extra 200cc.
And you're thinking, well how does that do it?
Why did Toyota really put a four-cylinder diesel engine in their Land Cruiser?
Well they can't really blame economy.
Because this is there or thereabouts on par with the Land Cruiser.
And it's more refined.
And it's smoother.
I don't think it's a better place to be.
I actually prefer the interior layout of the Land Cruiser compared to this.
But this is still nice.
But it's a bit basic compared to the Land Cruiser.
So therefore the Land Cruiser is a nicer place to be.
But this is better to drive.
And it's got better suspension.
So it's actually quite hard to pick between the two.
Mind you, at the start of the video I said we're going to find out
which is the better car to live with on a day-to-day basis.
So for that we're going to give the winner of this round to the Defender.
It's just an overall better car to drive.
It's not the better place to be.
Because I think the better place to be is actually the Land Cruiser.
But if we were to include an off-road test, I think the Land Cruiser might win in that.
Now this is my dog Tilly.
And Tilly's going to help us define the winner of this round.
And we're going to see which one is the most dog-friendly vehicle.
And how we're going to do that, we're going to get Tilly in the front seat,
the back seat and the boot.
And we're going to see which one she gets in the easiest.
So Tilly, what do you think about the Defender?
Are you giving it a good snooze?
She's trying to walk away from it.
So that's not a good start.
Come on, let's go get you in the front seat.
See how you're getting this one.
She's already ironed it up.
She already knows how to get in.
Do you reckon you can get in here?
Go on, what's it like?
Very simple.
Sit down there.
Sit.
So what's the room like for a dog?
Well, if you lie down for a minute, please, Tilly.
Lie down.
She's on the seat, okay.
And she's making herself comfortable.
She's sniffing.
Gwyn, the owner of this car, also have dogs.
So she is probably sniffing those dogs.
Right, let's get you in the back.
Come on, get down.
What's she like getting out?
Very easy there.
So the back seat.
Now this is a commercial vehicle.
So it's a little bit different.
So therefore it's higher.
So this isn't fair, actually, is it?
Anyway, come on.
You can get in here.
Let's see what you like getting in.
Come on, go on in.
No, she's not going to do that.
Come on.
No, that's a fail.
Although I'm not going to knock the defendant for that
because it is a commercial.
Let's try the boot now.
Over here we go.
And it opens like a door.
Come on, Tilly.
Do you want to get in here?
Oh, it looks higher than the cruiser.
Big jump there from Tilly.
Oh, and she wants to come straight out by the looks of it.
Come on then.
Hmm.
Well, let's see how she responds to the cruiser.
Right, Tilly.
What do you think of the Land Cruiser?
Do you like the colour?
She's putting her nose up for it.
So I understand what she thinks of the colour.
Right, come on.
Let's get you in the passenger seat.
See what you think of this.
Go on then.
Can you get in it?
Pretty easy.
Straight in.
Oh, and then straight up on the seat.
She's sitting down already.
I already think she's much more comfortable in the Land Cruiser.
Well, she's used to Land Cruiser because I have one.
And what's she like getting out?
She actually used a sidestep.
Right, rear seats.
No, it's not fair, but let's see how you get on the rear seats anyway.
Come on.
In.
In straight away.
And can you get on the back?
Can you get on the seat?
She doesn't like the seats.
Right, she's down.
I think you're caught in the lead there, aren't you?
Come here.
And this one.
Right, come on.
Let's get in the boot.
In here.
You have to wait until the boot opens.
Oh, we've got some stuff in here.
Apologies.
Up.
Go on.
I mean, I think it was seamless in this.
Andy, what do you think?
You think the Land Cruiser wins?
I think the Land Cruiser wins too.
Come on.
And the fact that she stood on this here and it's kind of more durable plastic,
whereas in the Defender, it was like a glossy plastic,
because that's going to scratch more easily than this.
It's little things like that, which you don't mind this being scratched
because it's made to be scratched.
Whereas that, it's going to be really painful seeing it scratched by your dog.
And it goes down.
So therefore, the more dog-friendly vehicle in this test.
Thank you, Tilly.
Is the Land Cruiser.
Do you agree with me?
I think she's cold.
She wants to go in.
Like me.
So next, we're going to do a 0-60 test between both cars.
And you might be thinking this isn't fair, in which it probably isn't,
because the Defender has two more cylinders and it's got more torque
and it's got 50 more horsepower.
But let's see.
Yes, you can get the Defender with a four-cylinder diesel engine,
but this is the only choice for this vehicle.
So Toyota say 12.3 seconds.
Let's put it in sport mode, which you can.
There we go.
And turn the traction off and no launch control.
So let's just see what we're going to get.
Good low-end torque there.
Come on.
There's 30.
There's 45.
There's 50.
And there is 60.
10.39 seconds.
Well, that's quicker than what Toyota say by almost two seconds.
So for that instance, what should we base it on?
Should we base it on the fact that this car actually goes quicker than Toyota's claimed 0-60
or the fast all-round?
I'll tell you what.
Let's base the point on whatever's quicker than it's claimed 0-60.
That'll make it more interesting.
Time for the Defender.
So it's time for the Defender.
And Land Rover say it's doing 0-60 time of eight seconds flat.
So it has to beat that by two seconds in order to beat the Land Cruiser,
which I don't think it's going to be able to do.
However, this does have an S setting on the gearbox, but it doesn't have a sport mode,
because I've gone through all the different comfort programs and drive select,
and that doesn't have any dynamic mode.
I might be wrong here, but this is what I'm seeing.
There's no sport mode.
So these cars are opposite.
Land Cruiser has a sport mode, but it doesn't have a sport mode for the gearbox.
But this has a sport mode for the gearbox, but it doesn't have a sport mode.
Anyway, let's launch it.
Good torque there.
Tell you what, it pushes you back into your seat slightly.
And that is quicker by the looks of it.
And there is 60.
Oh, 7.88 seconds.
That's a big difference from that first run.
And that's quick.
So it has beat Land Rover's claimed time of eight seconds, but not by two seconds.
But I didn't expect it to beat it.
However, 7.8 seconds is impressive, isn't it?
So in terms of which is the quickest car to its claimed 0-60 time, that is the Land Cruiser.
However, the quicker car in this instance is the Defender.
So let's give the point to the Land Cruiser,
because it was way quicker than Toyota's claimed time.
However, I'm pretty impressed with this, to be fair.
Let's round up.
So which one would I buy?
Well, firstly, let's touch on the Defender.
It's better to drive, it's smoother, and it's a quieter place to be.
The Land Cruiser, on the other hand, is more rugged, old-school, and the cabin is louder.
But which would I feel more comfortable about owning?
Well, that would be the Land Cruiser, due to my personal love for them.
But personal preference aside, the Defender is the better all-rounder, in my opinion.
However, I would buy a black Land Cruiser.
I hope you enjoyed this video, and please leave a like and press that subscribe button.
Thank you, and goodbye.