We May Have Just Passed the Point of No Return

Financial Freedom
10 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
It's only been a little bit less than a month, but already the economic and financial fallout
from the Iran conflict is taking shape as we search for that point of no return.
Sentiment has dropped, the real economy showing signs of being threatened, even the stock market.
Major stock indexes around the world are in correction territory.
And while central bankers are running around with their hair on fire in an inflationary panic,
all the signals that we're getting back from the real economy
suggest that this is increasingly a full-blown oil shock.
So we should expect nothing less than at least full-blown financial volatility,
not just in equities either, but also bonds, with the latter trying to gauge,
then try to price, just how much panic there will be among central banks.
And to that end, while everyone thinks there will only be rate hikes,
this past week saw one major resume rate cutting.
And for all the reasons we're going to get into here,
is that Iran fallout gets to be a little bit clearer.
And that applies to the entire global economy.
We're getting updates from around the world, starting with US jobs,
but including influential surveys in Europe.
And as I mentioned, stocks all over the map, surpassing correction levels,
heading further toward the dreaded bear market status.
Then there's oil itself.
New highs on Friday and historically wide spreads that are proving
the panic buying hasn't really diminished, and not diminished nearly enough,
which means this thing is going to go on at least somewhat longer.
And that means the chances of seeing,
and even driving right past the point of no return,
keep rising with each and every day.
So Steve, there's a number of different ways where we could start here.
The fallout, at least the initial fallout from the energy shock,
seems to be already showing up.
Like I said, consumer sentiment is down, business sentiment is down,
stock markets are down.
But it's interesting how most central bankers think this is going to be inflationary,
at least outside of Mexico.
Yeah, Jeff, it's really fascinating,
because even if we just looked at the nonfarm pay report,
which you and I know, not very accurate, gets revised a lot,
it's been on a downward trajectory.
Inflation is still staying elevated.
And so we see all the early signs of stagflation building,
not just here in the US, but clearly all over the world.
And all of a sudden, the Iran conflict hits.
Now we're getting spike in energy prices across the board.
It's following through now.
We're starting to see some early signs, not just at the gas pump,
but how this is going to impact consumer prices.
And now you've got full-blown stagflation brewing.
And yet, again, central bankers are just running around
with chickens with their heads cut off,
because they're worried about rising energy prices.
But what they can't see is that the labor market has already been weakening,
and consumers have been warning about this.
And so my concern is, as we head into the next nonfarm pay report,
we could see another negative print.
We're going to see hours down.
And next thing you know, we're going to find out
that the market is, once again, well ahead of where the Fed is at.
The Fed or any of the other, I mean, the Europeans have been much, much worse.
The European Central Bank, in particular,
talking about rate hikes as soon as April.
With the European markets taking those statements and saying,
geez, there's a good chance that the Europeans hike a couple of times
before they have to turn around.
I think that's really the takeaway from the initial fallout
from the Iran conflict that we've gotten in the data so far,
is most people are not expecting this to be anything
other than traditional oil shocks.
Oil shocks come along.
What ends up happening is employers get pressured at the margins.
They have to pay for energy.
And as you said, Steve, before we started recording here,
I mean, California gasoline prices, we already see that there.
They're sort of highlighting the upside to energy costs here.
Diesel, this is another big one.
But diesel prices going up and the costs that have to pass along
to the rest of the business sector are going to come out of somewhere.
What they're going to come out of is employment.
So a lot of businesses that are already struggling, as Steve said,
nonfarm payrolls have been negative,
reflecting the flat beverage environment that we've been in already.
So businesses that are already struggling, you get higher energy costs.
What are they going to do?
They're not going to pass them along to the customers that they don't have
or if they do try to pass them on to customers,
as we've seen too many times, business falls off.
So the only choice that they have left is to cut back in hours,
certainly not hire anybody.
They haven't hired anybody in years anyway, and maybe even lay off a few more.
So it's unemployment that ends up being the problem.
And we already see that creeping into the initial data.
Like I said, consumer surveys have fallen.
The University of Michigan just came out.
Final numbers from March, lower than they were in the preliminary estimates.
No surprise there.
Not a big jump in inflation expectations among the Michigan survey.
Instead, it was more, hey, we've been worried about unemployment for over a year.
We're still worried.
Now we're even more worried because of energy costs going up.
Yeah, Jeff.
And let's talk some more about this profit margin squeeze
because in a normal healthy economy, yes, businesses,
they could absorb this for a month or two.
If you go back and look at what happened to businesses, it was the tariffs.
And so what happened, we had healthy margins before that.
And then all of a sudden, they got compressed to just barely over zero
based on some of the latest data from the Fed.
So at this point, businesses have no margin.
There's no way they can absorb increasing energy prices
because that means they go negative.
They go out of business.
So you're right.
You said consumers can't afford it and they can't, but businesses know that.
So like, well, we're going to have no choice.
We're going to have to pass this on to consumers.
Consumers are then going to have to start becoming very selective about what they buy,
which is something you don't want to happen.
We already know that means discretionary spending is going to drop.
And next thing you know, retail sales drop.
And at that point, what happens is, as you said,
businesses are going to look right now and hope this conflict ends.
They're going to hope it starts to unwind very quickly.
The risk is it doesn't appear that's going to happen.
Their first reaction is, lay off who you have to,
cut hours of those you want to keep, and then hope everything works out.
But as long as margins stay compressed here and consumers don't come out and buy,
which we know they don't have the money to,
then the inevitable response is there's going to be more layoffs.
I think that was one of the interesting takeaways from, say, S&P Global's PMI,
their preliminary data for the month of March.
What they said was that for the first time in, I think, about a year, a little bit over a year,
the employment index fell into contraction territory,
which means that at the very least, I mean, as we know,
employment has been contracting in the U.S., we've been losing jobs.
So S&P Global was somewhat more optimistic than the actual data.
Now their optimistic data is looking more like the actual data,
which means that the chances of further employment losses are going way up,
because what they really pointed to was exactly what you said, Steve.
I think there was this initial reaction to the oil shock, which was,
OK, let's hope this thing gets done quickly, it gets resolved.
You know, traffic starts flowing through the Strait of Hormuz again,
energy prices back off, and this is all just a short-run phenomenon,
just like it was last year in the 12-day conflict.
So that was sort of the initial expectation.
It would be over within a couple of weeks.
It wouldn't be great, it wouldn't be fun.
You know, oil goes up to $90, $100 per barrel,
but even for a couple of weeks, that's not a good sign or that's not a good thing.
But it comes right back down.
We're all good.
However, you know, here we are almost at the end of March, heading into April.
There's no sign of a resolution anywhere.
And so what S&P Global said, not just in the U.S. PMI,
but also European PMI, Japanese PMI, and around the rest of the world,
was that sentiment, not just short-term sentiment,
but longer-term sentiment is starting to fall
as businesses have to reprice and recalibrate their expectations,
realizing this is not going to go in just a couple of weeks.
It's already, you know, almost a month into it,
and it looks like it's going to be here for a prolonged period of time,
which means it turns into a genuine, legitimate oil shock,
and we know how that ends.
And that's kind of what businesses were saying.
They're saying that we know how this ends,
and this ends in us cutting back on workers and employment.
Now, as this oil shock goes further, it's only going to add even more pressures,
not just on the real economy,
but also the credit market and private credit,
the bust that's going on there.
I just did a very deep dive into not just the credit market situation,
but the process behind it.
You really need to understand how these things go.
So I did a webinar a couple days ago.
There's a link in the description.
You can see a replay.
I laid out the exact process by which a credit bust becomes a crisis,
and even went over how the 2008 crisis fits that model,
so you can clearly see in a concrete example how this thing really works.
We also went over one of the biggest developments yet in the current bust,
the JP Morgan collateral downgrade,
and why that's such a huge milestone
and how that plays out into our crisis framework as well.
So it's not just about what's going on,
but also how to interpret all these various signals
and then make full sense of them.
It's a roadmap to follow the credit bust as it turns into credit crisis
and then threatens to potentially go even further into systemic territory.
So if you want to know what to look for next,
especially with stage three sitting right here,
I'm also offering a one-time webinar deal
on Eurodown University's full subscriptions and library.
Not only will you be able to stay on top of everything,
you'll also know why things are happening, what to look for,
and most importantly, what it all means.
And using information, data, market signals, interpretations no one else does
because either they don't know it exists
or if they do, they don't really know what it means.
They get all their information from central bankers and economists.
So Eurodown University's got you completely covered
from background in history to today's biggest market shifts and potential.
I highly recommend you check out the full webinar.
There's a link in the description
and also one for our webinar subscription deal.
Yeah, that's right, Jeff.
And we know going back to the 1970s,
four of the last five oil shocks went right into a recession.
They can lead to a financial crisis as we saw in 2008.
But you really can't blame a lot of these businesses
for their sentiment changing because as you said,
in the PMIs, what happened?
Inflationary costs went up.
They all said that.
Growth went down.
And yet they noted that, hey, there was some demand there,
as you said before the show,
that there was a lot of front-running in these reports.
But the reality is they know once that's over,
that demand is going to drop off.
And when it does, they really don't have a choice.
Factories just don't have the money to stand people around
if the equipment's not running.
And so the risk is, again, we admittedly see hours get cut,
which I think is going to show up
in the next non-farm payroll report,
that the risk is we continue to see another negative report
that Powell said was, hey, the labor market
looks to be fairly stable.
It's like, I'm still not sure, Jeff, what he was looking at,
but a downward directory does not look stable to me.
Stable compared to what?
I think that's the other part of it, right?
It's stable compared to the depth of 2009, for sure.
That's not exactly a decent comparison to make,
but you understand.
What else is he going to say at this point?
But you're right, Steve.
Just to be clear, what Steve was referring to
is that in the PMI data, what S&P Global showed
was that there was a pretty sharp pickup
in manufacturing activity.
And S&P Global was very clear about why that was.
It said that repeatedly, place after place after place,
region after region, the reason was
there was an influx of orders and activity in production
as businesses up and down the supply chain
tried to move up production, move up activity
to get ahead of the increase in energy costs,
as well as to get ahead of any disruptions
that might take place because of the Iran conflict.
In fact, for the US PMI, supplier lead times
were the highest they've been since October of 2022,
which is not a good sign because, as Steve said,
what that means is everybody's busy today
trying to get everything done today.
But after today and after tomorrow,
what happens next is there's another payback period.
So in other words, manufacturing is experiencing
another major positive artificial high distortion,
not unlike we saw last year with the tariffs.
And when that unwinds, what's left?
What's left is an economy that's pressured
by higher oil costs that aren't going
to go away in the short run.
Therefore, greater chances of unemployment,
greater chances of consumers pulling back in spending.
And it just leads to this toxic mix
where the initial indications from the oil shock
that we're getting right now already suggest
that businesses are coming to grips
with a more than short run problem
that continues to go forward into the near term future,
which is going to force them to do things
that they'd otherwise don't want to do
or force them to do things which they've started doing,
the negative payroll reports, and have to do even more.
And that's really the risk.
Yeah, absolutely, Jeff, because you look
at a business's perspective right now.
And again, if this conflict would have been very short,
it would have been like, okay, well, this kind of sucks.
We'll figure out a way to pass this along,
absorb it into our costs, spread it out.
We'll get through it.
But the risk now we have is there's real damage
to infrastructure around the world.
So you look at that and say, wait a minute,
even if the conflict into tomorrow
and the US and Iran hugged and said, okay, we're all good.
Let's open up the street.
Even if there was just minimal damage,
we could be months before we were back to full capacity.
In some cases, Qatar's saying this is gonna take years.
So the reality is businesses are now saying,
wait a minute, I've got a problem.
I've now known that my input prices
are going to remain high.
I was unable to pass these costs on before.
I'm certainly not gonna pass them on as they've gone higher.
What am I going to do?
Because I already know, and they've said this
for months and months and months,
consumers can't afford these prices.
So there's gonna be winners here.
There's gonna be losers.
The problem is it's going to be the global labor market
that's gonna be the biggest loser out of this.
Yeah, we said that before.
I mean, we saw that.
We talked about it before March,
before the conflict showed up.
I mean, you had Pepsi, you had McDonald's,
you had all these companies coming out saying,
gee, we're gonna have to start cutting prices.
We tried raising prices for years
and all it did was lead to lower and lower volumes.
Now we're seeing too low of volumes.
We've got to start cutting prices
to try to win back market share.
It was big company after big company after big company.
And what does that mean?
It means exactly what Steve was saying.
Before we got to March, companies were saying,
we can no longer even think about passing on costs
to customers because they're just disappearing.
And they're disappearing in ways
that they weren't even a year ago.
So the idea that higher diesel prices
are gonna somehow translate
into a sustained consumer price increase
just doesn't meet with reality,
which is why you're seeing all of these other surveys say,
we're expecting the economy to fall off,
not for inflation to skyrocket.
What they really say is that we expect prices
to go up in the short run,
which is exactly what we're saying.
It's exactly what's gonna happen.
The CPI for March is gonna be ugly.
We already saw it with Spain.
Spain was the first European country
to report its CPI for March, its preliminary estimate.
And while it was not nearly as high as many had feared,
they were looking at it to go up
to around 3.7% year over year.
It was still above 3% versus where it was
around 2% last month.
So there's a big increase in consumer prices
and consumer price rates in March,
which we're gonna see.
We're gonna see them extend into April.
That's gonna happen.
But that's not inflation.
All that's gonna do is lead to more unemployment.
And that's what the preliminary data is all saying.
Consumers are saying it, businesses are saying it.
Another one, IFO in Germany.
They basically said, you know,
we were hoping the Germany's economy
and the European economy were gonna recover.
Now we have this oil shock to continue with.
Basically, I think the quote was from the head of IFO
is the recovery is on ice now.
Not inflation is going to soar,
but the recovery, the economic growth
that we thought we were gonna get is disappearing
because at higher energy costs,
just pressure businesses that are already,
they're already at the limit to begin with
and just make a bad situation worse.
Yeah, Jeff.
And so you, again, we look at, you know,
the preliminary survey is saying,
look, this is what we see coming,
but we're actually getting some real data here.
In fact, we can go up to look at the UK's retail sales
went from plus 2% last month or the previous month
down to minus 0.4.
Now we know that retail sales can jump around a lot.
So it's possible that it could be a one-off print.
But if this is an indication of what's going on
in the real economy right now,
what we're about to see is country after country reporting
that there's a huge drop in retail sales.
And then you start to wonder why people are trying
to get out of these private credit funds.
Well, because they lent against a lot of that stuff.
But now consumers are saying, look,
there's no chance I'm gonna buy it
because I'm relatively convinced
I'm not going to have a job.
So you start to see all the seeds starting to germinate here.
We don't wanna say they're just so,
we're seeing them burst up out of the ground,
saying there's a whole lot of problems.
And these aren't the green shoots that the Fed likes.
These are the kind that the Fed
literally is like a deer in headlights.
They don't know what to do until it's too late.
And by that time,
what we're facing is a global labor market
that's just gonna continue to weaken as demand plunges.
And then due to all of that pull forward in demand
from problem after problem,
you've got all this rotting inventory
that's gonna sit around
that the banks are holding loans on.
Yeah, and I think that's, you know,
one of the more reasonable takes on everything here
came from the Bank of Mexico,
the Banks of Coz it's known
where they said exactly what Steve did is that,
look, we understand where the economy is today.
And we're more worried about the downside in it
than we are to a rising consumer price.
In fact, they said,
consumer price environment is uncertain,
which, okay, sure, it's uncertain.
I don't think it really is all that uncertain,
but it's uncertain.
But they weren't saying like the Europeans
that we need to raise rates
because this is gonna be inflationary.
What they said was more likely than not,
this is gonna add even more pressure to an economy
that's already under significant pressure.
I think that's the point, you know,
Steve, you just made it
that we need to reinforce and repeat with emphasis here
is that the situation wasn't good to begin with.
It's not like we have one problem facing the economy,
just oil or just private credit
or just a couple of negative payroll reports.
It's all of these things combining at the same time,
which creates an even worse downside potential.
So at least one central bank has bucked the trend
where everybody is convinced
that rates are gonna go skyrocketing here
for the rest of the year because of all this inflation.
We got one central bank that is not only cutting rates,
they restarted the rate cuts
because of what's taking place in the energy markets.
Because when it all comes down to it,
what we're really talking about, Steve,
is just basic, simple economics,
really simple common sense.
Think about it.
You've got economies where unemployment is already rising.
In many places, it's already uncomfortably high.
You throw some energy costs on top of it.
The result of it is not the middle 1970s.
The result of it is 1973, 1974, 1980,
or 1990, 91, where unemployment starts to go up
relatively even faster than it had been.
And I think the initial data we're getting
is consumers and businesses and markets.
Let's talk about stocks.
The markets know what's coming next.
What's coming next is, yes,
central banks might panic into rate hikes,
but they're going to be cutting after not too long.
Yeah, absolutely, Jeff.
I mean, the markets are saying right now,
we actually believe profit margins
are going to go negative.
And you can kind of see that in the short run.
Now, I'm not saying they're going to go
to crisis-level negative prints,
but they're going to squeeze businesses.
They know that already.
The market is pricing that in.
We haven't seen the least from the bond market yet
that has bought into the Fed cutting rates.
But as you just said, and I completely agree,
it could be the next non-farm payroll report
that everyone's going to be like,
oh, yep, they're way behind.
And by the way,
we've got a little ways before the next meeting.
So let's front run the Fed's next move
because at this point, it's game over.
It's too late.
And that's my real fear here
is all this inaction by central bankers.
And it's not that I subscribe to the fact
that a rate cut here would make any difference.
The reality is they proved once again,
they're behind the curve.
The market's trying to tell them that,
and the economy's trying to tell them that.
But the problem is at this point,
and I don't know, Jeff,
if we're past the tipping point,
but I feel like at this point,
even if the conflict ended tomorrow,
I feel like we're there.
Jeff Fischer Yeah, you'll never know
if you're past the tipping point,
but I think that's the point here
is that the data,
the initial data that we've gotten
from the March statistics that are coming in
suggest that there is the same worry
that you and I are sharing this worry
that's shared by other people
around the global system
where they're thinking,
yeah, we need to start thinking
about where that point of no return is
and whether or not we actually have passed it.
Like you said earlier,
the damage that's being done in the Middle East
is going to take a very long time
to take care of,
to get everything fixed
and back up and running at normal capacity,
which means we need to be prepared
for the fact that energy costs
at the very least,
just as a start,
are going to be elevated
for a prolonged period of time.
And as a result,
this is not going to go away in a month
or even a couple months.
And you just have to start thinking
in a different way.
And that leads to exactly what you just said.
It's a longer term process
when you get past the short-run disruption
in consumer prices,
what comes after it
is the more important part of it,
not the short-run consumer prices,
what follows after it,
especially in employment and activity.
Yeah, Jeff,
because you think about the bigger picture here,
we know stagflation goes into recession.
So let's just assume that that now happens.
So let's look at consumers and businesses
massively loaded up in debt,
financial assets all held mostly in stocks,
which typically come down substantially.
Spending from the top 10%
that's been driving 50% of spending
is going to disappear.
And next thing you know,
you're not talking about
like some V-shaped recovery
like we've seen in the past
or, hey, it came down,
we kind of cleared out some of this rot.
Now you're looking at
a potentially prolonged recession
because it's not the wealthy.
And a lot of people think,
okay, well, it's about them.
No, it's about the lower income,
the middle class
where these energy costs
are just going to be
stuck in their lifestyle
where it's going to hammer their spending.
They're going to have to pay back on this debt
and the labor market
is going to continue to be weak.
And then you start thinking about businesses.
They're not going to need to give out big raises
because they're going to have
this huge available pool of workers.
So the risk now we have
isn't that we go into recession
is that maybe we go into a prolonged one
or we get a series of rolling recessions
where, hey, we're coming out of it.
And it's like, whoop, nope.
Hey, nope.
And that's a big problem.
Yeah, it's the combination here,
the negative combination
of all these different things
that are starting to really
combine together.
So you throw an oil shock
on top of the private credit problem
and negative employment and flat beverage.
Like you say, Steve,
there's not a lot of good outcomes here.
In fact, they continue to get worse as we go forward.
And people seem to realize it
even if your European central bankers don't.
Huge thanks to Steve as always.
Check out my webinar.
There's a replay link
in the description of this video.
You are not going to want to miss it.
A deep dive into the process
behind the credit crisis,
some real world examples.
Huge thanks for joining me here.
And of course, as always,
thank you to Uridal University members
and subscribers.
Until next time, take care.
