F1 Now Has a Legitimacy Problem

Formula 1 News
151 followers
4.3K Video Views·Mar 30, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
I think we really need to talk about this, folks.
Because the drivers have certainly been talking about it.
And you'll really need to look at how hard Toto Wolf is defending these rules.
You're giving the game away, man.
Look, the strongest way to understand this whole mess is to stop treating
Behrman's crash as the beginning of the story, because, well, it's not.
After multiple warnings from drivers about this hypothetical scenario,
the story has now become impossible to soften.
I also need to make it very clear that
I do believe there is potential in these regulations,
but to believe that there is no need to change anything whatsoever
and we just have to deal with it for the rest of eternity
until the next regulation cycle?
You're dreaming.
And before Suzuka, people could still play the Taste Game Car Race.
We don't need to change anything.
Look at the racing, it's exciting.
Yes, it can be exciting.
It certainly was very impressive to see Oscar Piastri finally show hands.
Fans might be able to adapt to it,
especially at tracks where qualifying won't look as ugly as it did at Suzuka
and at Australia,
and if the old guard didn't get used to it,
they would just move on with their lives.
But then we saw that 50G crash with Oliver Behrman,
and, uh, yeah, the closing speed difference was very, very striking.
With that, the driver's worst fear had been realised,
that the ruleset showed its most overt signs of being unstable in real-world conditions.
And then a hoped presentation would paper over the cracks.
The FIA goofing?
Well, sad to see.
I do get they're trying to talk to teens,
but when we're the one management?
Insulting everyone's intelligence?
That I cannot abide by.
How very dare you, Stefano.
We're in a situation where we're looking to what Ben Sulian was saying last year
about V8s with sustainable fuels and going,
oh my god, I can't believe we're all agreeing with Ben.
What has the world come to?
Also, Behrman himself voiced his concerns about these rules back in February.
Him describing the whole thing about energy management
and lifting and coasting as annoying and sad.
Then the crash happened,
and we pretty much just got the same things he was describing
then put to him in real life.
Thankfully, he was able to get out of the car,
and to see yet more scrutiny held at my favourite circuit?
The slander is so, so painful.
But one thing I must make really clear is that
if it wasn't Behrman who crashed,
and it was somebody else on the grid,
whatever nationality it was,
I would be saying the same thing.
So I would just like you to put the bias card down now, please.
And let me introduce Carlos Sainz,
the co-director of the Grand Prix Drivers Association.
He's been warning folks about this for ages now,
that this incoming new package was just begging for a big crash to happen.
And he's been very consistent with it too.
After the crash, he said drivers had already told the authorities this would happen,
and that this is what you get when you listen only to the teams.
Then, that leads into Lewis's comment not long after,
that the drivers have no power.
That indeed, only the teams get heard because they're at the table,
whilst they, the racers,
they're effectively waiting outside the meeting room in the corridor.
If teams that have built a good car within this rule set,
which right now you could argue is the case for Mercedes and Ferrari,
then them using their political heft to ensure that
any changes get slowed down somewhat,
or only certain changes get through the net,
then it just becomes a political conflict of interest.
All disguised as governance.
No, they are there to protect their advantage.
Because you're asking these teams to weaken any sort of advantage that they may already have.
We may be romanticising all of the stuff that Ferrari maybe could be the ones
to take down Mercedes,
but even though I must admit that all of the politicking
that was going regarding Ferrari's legit concerns about start line procedures,
they were ignored.
So Ferrari decided,
well, okay, we're going to tackle the initiative ourselves.
Then when it came around and the teams realised the error of their ways,
Ferrari wouldn't budge.
All of this came down to political argy-bargy over the course of a year.
All this political shoving,
it's just gotten really, really ugly,
because people wanted to stop Red Bull and McLaren from winning,
and they wanted to win.
And it just gave science's comments more legitimacy,
because the drivers' voices,
even though they have a huge social media following,
that same following does not carry over into the boardroom.
And it really adds more credence to the idea that the GBDA,
whilst a very noble organisation,
and it's nice to see it back in existence again,
really does not have that much sway,
because y'all remember the open letter towards Mohammed bin Suleiman,
and his response was basically,
mind your own business, drivers.
Even though he treats them like his own children,
which is awkward,
this has gotten to a point where the drivers do need a seat at the table,
because, well,
the worst fear that they had has actually happened now.
But with Carlos's comments, they still carry weight.
But nevertheless,
he's still acting like one of the few people in the sport who understands that
all of this is drifting out of the zone of stylistic dislike,
and into a safety problem,
and making use of the elevated platform that,
indeed, drive to survive has bestowed upon the drivers.
These guys have millions of followers and eyeballs on them,
so make use of them.
Play the game Formula One management wants them to play.
Yes, Berman is British, yes,
and you might be thinking that's the only reason people care about this,
but his own team boss, Ayo Okamatsu,
explained the crash in regulation-shaped terms.
He didn't rally around his driver, Oliver, blindly.
According to the team principal,
he'd gone for an overtake, Oliver,
with the extra power boost given,
and misjudged the pass due to the differing speeds manifested by the ruleset.
This isn't a Haas from the Gunther Steiner era,
where they are down on their luck,
and they would have every reason to rail against the regulations
for having given them a bad hand.
Haas are forth in the constructors, dude,
that they are very much ahead of Red Bull,
and Alpine,
and Williams.
Haas, the smallest team on the grid,
have gotten a really good start to the season,
as we all thought they would,
with scoring in every single Grand Prix thus far,
three in a row,
a very worthwhile achievement.
Them actually pointing to the regulations and going,
hang on a minute,
this is something really concerning,
that should be telling in of itself.
The regulations?
They're not hurting Haas, that's for sure.
So with this team principal coming out,
and stating the whole thing around them,
and isn't to do with the fact that one driver took out another driver,
which is why Colapinto most likely didn't get a penalty with the FIA,
it's down to the fact that,
well, these are the cars that we've been dealt with,
and this is a legit concern that the drivers did share,
so that's the line I'm going to follow,
the one that my drivers have been expressing,
and what we've been dealing with.
And indeed, with Haas being the smallest team in Formula 1,
even with Toyota's backing,
politically speaking,
they are tiny.
Yes, this part of the discussion,
it goes beyond nationality, folks, come on.
And then if you come up with the point that,
oh, because it happened to a British driver,
this is an excuse to kill unpopular rules that they themselves do not like,
that just becomes straight up denial.
As I said earlier,
I'm quite a patient guy,
and I understand that sometimes these rules do have to pan out
in the real world to get some proper real world findings,
but admittedly,
the FIA does need to pull its socks up,
because this has become a safety issue,
and we would rather something happen before somebody gets seriously hurt.
Oliver was really, really lucky
due to the advancements in safety technology,
thankfully pioneered by many bright minds,
to be able to actually stand up in the garage just minutes later.
I seriously recommend you go back and look up
how hard Jackie Stewart fought for safety
back in the late 60s and early 70s of Formula 1,
how often he was mocked for it,
and called a pansy for it.
This issue is bigger than who crashed people.
Even teams with every incentive to defend the formula
are describing the danger in the same language as its critics.
But, fortunately,
the FIA doesn't look like a wounded blindsided animal here.
It knew from the start this formula might need live correction.
As I discussed earlier last week,
they made that mega dual change to qualifying
on top of what they did in Australia
to let the drivers push more naturally in that session.
It helped a bit, but it was only a small start,
because even with that change,
Charles Leclerc was lamenting his lot,
because this is a man who really does like his qualifying,
and he did not like that qualifying.
It got his hackles up.
Then we go back to testing.
As we pointed out multiple times on this channel,
the FIA had been in discussions with the drivers
regarding feedback from testing
and all the stuff from the shakedown,
and the drivers had been giving positive feedback.
These regulations weren't all doom and gloom.
In terms of acceleration and wheel-to-wheel combat
and the ability to follow other drivers,
it was all good.
Absolutely gravy.
But the energy management side of things,
at Bahrain, it really did need work done.
So, at least we can say the FIA weren't fully asleep at the wheel.
But it also tells me that the FIA knew that going into 2026
that these were going to be difficult regulations to be handling
and that there might have been other hands
steering this particular ship going into it.
This wasn't wholly the idea of the FIA.
Somebody had inspired them or insisted upon them.
So, uh, let me get the spanner out for this bit.
And now the real-world evidence has become impossible to ignore.
But, thankfully, we do know from recent history
the FIA can, on the grounds of safety,
move very, very, very quickly,
after Imola 1994 especially.
Teams only had weeks to make adaptions to their car,
including the plank,
otherwise they couldn't go racing. Simple as that.
But that is also a problem,
because it showed that the FIA could be reactive,
but we would all rather them be proactive.
They really did drop the ball here.
But you've also got to give them credit
for actually doing some listening and some discourse,
but now please focus on the drivers a little bit more.
That'd be great.
So, if this formula was already understood to be something
that would ideally need real-world correction,
why were the drivers' warnings treated like background noise then?
You can't sell a package this flexible
and then act as though the people inside the cars
are only being dramatic.
All it shows that the power figures involved
in formulating these rules were just too overconfident.
Yes, the Suzuka qualifying tweak had unanimous backing
from the power unit manufacturers and the drivers, reportedly.
It does mean the sport isn't wholly trapped.
There is more willingness than we thought,
but then we got Hamilton's comment.
Science is words.
They do carry a fair bit of political heft,
at least figuratively,
whereas Hamilton, he carries a lot of heft regarding the people,
and it gives this whole argument an even gnarlier spine
because recent reports have suggested
that there will be a very big meeting taking place on April 9th,
and that, according to some sources,
they are not going to be inviting the drivers
to this particular meeting.
And yes, the drivers were allowed to give feedback,
but it wasn't something that really gave them proper control
in terms of the structure.
It could be written down, it might be heeded,
but it didn't necessarily have to be acted upon
as part of a formal vote.
It's the teams who are at the table,
as well as the power unit manufacturers.
All the drivers can do is pass on their feedback to the teams
and hope that the teams agree with them,
and that can then get something pushed forward.
But as with Kamatsu's comments with Behrmann,
Verstappen and Red Bull not seeing eye to eye
regarding the whole journalistic fiasco,
sometimes these two entities aren't necessarily on the same page.
The drivers' concerns might get through,
but it's not a guarantee.
Then the FIA and F1 commission,
yes, they did discuss driver input,
but they then moved the refinements
through the formal machinery above them.
That suggests the decisive weight still sits with the teams
and manufacturers, especially before testing,
when everyone was relying on simulations
and piecemeal mule car data over recent times.
Once you realise that,
Behrmann's crash starts to look like
the visible consequence of a system
that had the most exposed people outside the room
where the rules were talked upon.
That's why I feel like the mood is somewhat different this time,
unlike it was in 2022,
because you've got to remember,
we were all up in arms regarding the driver's safety
after seeing all of the image of Lewis
barely able to get out of the W13,
having his back completely shot.
It then casts a big foam of doubt here.
Why were the drivers not consulted
over something so fundamental?
The biggest rule changes in Formula 1 history
comprising many different facets of the sport.
Seriously, who might have been the person
that instigated all of this?
TOTOOOOO?
Yes, it's my belief Toto Wolff has overplayed his hand here.
Hasn't he been too chirpy lately?
While other team bosses have at least acknowledged
there are rough edges,
Toto is still calling this pure and exciting racing.
Excuse you?
Now is not the time, mate!
And he's also been using 2014
as a political shield for a while
to ensure change doesn't happen
before the cars get out on the track.
It's all starting to look a bit too convenient, people,
as that was the main argument
for when Christian Horner last year clapped back and said,
Well, you know, we should be really doing a 64-36 split.
It's going to ruin the spectacle unless we do that.
And then Toto just whacked that down.
Horner's gone.
The main obstacle for Toto is now having to wait
to get an opportunity to get back in.
But let me make this clear.
I am not pointing at Toto and saying
he was responsible for Oliver Behrman's crash.
I am not saying that.
But what I am trying to get at here
is that maybe these regulations,
upon further revelations
and all of the interviews that we have been seeing,
the main reason for bringing them into existence
might not have been through electrification
and pure green technology progress.
No, this might have all been down
to a straight up power play,
as well as Mercedes having a technical preference
for the results that we actually got,
and especially connections with other things
that Mercedes got themselves up to in the early 2020s.
And with Toto being the longest serving team principal,
by far,
and having a very solid business brain
instead of being a pure engineer,
he has used that influence
and the clout and the experience
to put his tendrils throughout everything
to do with Formula One.
He very much has gotten that sport on a plate.
And then you've got to bring the comments
from the Formula E president,
Alejandro Agargue, into consideration
because he had a straight up conversation with Toto
where Toto, I'm paraphrasing here,
said,
I'm going to take all this technology
and bring it into Formula One.
And then Agargue was agog and going,
uh,
even though Alejandro thought Formula One
shouldn't go as far as their own sport,
him claiming Mercedes and Toto
were a major force behind these regulations,
then considering Mercedes' willingness
to drop the MGU-H
to welcome in the Volkswagen Group,
which then became Audi.
And it's fair to ask
whether this was pure pragmatism
or another power move that suited Mercedes.
Now, I'm not saying this was
some kind of grand conspiracy,
but it might be saying
That maybe Toto looked at
the turbo hybrid Mercedes unit
and evaluated which bits and pieces
that he could maybe do without.
The MGU-H,
it wasn't road relevant.
That pleased the FIA
because they do like being road relevant.
And Toto was saying,
ah, don't worry, we can do without it.
And then you've got to look at
the sport's original intentions
for these regulations
many years ago
to realize that it's now become
a list of broken promises,
which ultimately mean
you can't just hide behind buzzwords
and call it vision.
Because one of the four key pillars
back in the day
was to maintain the spectacle.
And it specifically said
the rules would avoid
excessive performance differentiation
to improve raceability.
Read that now,
and it's almost laughable
because excessive performance differentiation
was at the heart of the fear in 2022.
And we got the crash with Berman anyway.
The sport must be measured
against the standards it set for itself
when it sold this project to us
in the first place.
It wasn't just Berman's crash either.
There was then the moment
where George made a mistake
deploying battery
and derating around the same corner,
which resulted in him
falling in behind Leclerc.
I also recall Bortoletto in Australia
making a comment
that he made an overtake unexpectedly.
He wasn't trying to pass the driver.
He just did.
And then Fernando,
not long before the Grand Prix of Japan,
said that we are seeing a situation
where you're making takes
when you've not really
planned to make overtakes.
And that is eventually
going to lead to a crash,
which then it did.
Then there's Wolf's tone before Suzuka,
which really got me nettled.
And it really did give the game away
regarding him a little bit.
Motorsport reported him saying
the main goal was whether fans
liked the product or not,
and that the driver's view
was only one perspective.
They're the ones driving the car, Toto.
Their perspective is the central perspective.
One of many.
The same battery managed behaviour
that could be sold as
tactical entertainment
was also central
to the closing speed fear
that showed itself
around Spoon Corner.
And there's a really uncomfortable twist
sitting right in the official explainer.
Formula One's own beginner guide
says overtake mode
lets the attacking car
harvest an extra 0.5 megajoules
so it can sustain
a higher speed for longer,
which could result in
more attacks in unusual places
and therefore more position changes.
Now, I'm not saying that
overtake mode was the sole cause
for Berman having his collision.
No.
But it does mean that
the use of overtake mode
and the boost button
suggests that it encourages
the driver to make overtakes
where otherwise you wouldn't necessarily
be making overtakes
just to bring the overtake number up.
And I know that we saw many charts
over the last couple of years
from unofficial statistic websites
charting overtakes
at different circuits,
but that is only bonus information
for people that may want
to take a look at it.
It shouldn't be used as a USP.
That's a unique selling point, by the way,
as in something you shouldn't be
blowing your own trumpet about.
It's something that
if people want to find out,
that's that they can look at
and go, oh, OK, cool.
Yeah, we can see a trend there.
It should be used
as part of an overall trend,
not as one single bit of information.
And it's leading to the driver's
own concept of what is normal
in Formula 1 to be drastically skewed.
For Oliver and Franco,
if they were both going
pretty much the same speed,
this most likely would not
have happened at this crash.
Berman might have prepared
for a pass before 130R
or maybe get it done
before the start finish straight.
So in that light,
it's why I'm landing on Stefano's crew
more than Ben and Nicholas's crew.
The FIA, they look like regulators
trying to wrestle with a flawed
but salvageable concept
as long as the drivers can take
that more control in the power unit.
Fortunately, the aerodynamic
side of things as well as chassis
do look pretty cool,
that there is some hope for the future
that if the power unit
gets tweaked a little bit,
you could get yourself
a really good car,
because I saw plenty of examples
of three abreast,
almost into turn one.
But all of this is just
tying into the idea
that in the last few months,
especially in 2026,
Formula One management
has really been turning things up
in making Formula One
an absolute juggernaut
of a commercial machine,
doing whatever is necessary
to paint the picture
that everything is fine.
The latest example,
as we've talked about
and you've probably seen for yourself,
Kimi Antonelli's onboard video,
mostly not being on board.
Now that was claimed to be
due to a technical glitch,
but the fact that we're
even talking about this
and getting our own foams
of doubt out about it,
tells us all you need to know
that there is a lack of trust.
There has been a breakdown in faith
that what we are being given
is the truth.
And that whole thing
regarding a technical issue,
oh, would you look at that?
Just hours later,
they found the footage
of Kimi going through 130R
for the ghost car video.
Where was that then?
If it was available,
wait until that became available
to then post the onboard video
and then we wouldn't
be talking about it.
There's a point here
where all of the silence
and selective framing and posturing,
it doesn't look like confidence anymore,
but it looks like you're
trying to dodge the point.
A refusal to acknowledge reality,
what the audience can actually see.
We are not stupid.
The commercial side
is curating something
instead of just straight up owning it.
Yes, it will take a hit
on their bottom line.
But if you take a look
at their stock price,
it's gone down 17% this year.
They're already doing it to themselves.
So if they want to try
and maybe, I don't know,
restore investor confidence,
then maybe just fess up
and realize that,
hey, OK, we're sorry
because we wound up
with a situation
that every single bit
of Formula 1 presentation
ends up working against the product.
And that is a horrible situation
for any sport to find themselves in.
As you pointed out to me yourself,
other motorsporting series
are getting in on the act,
making fun of the sport.
You don't have to worry
about any of these.
You can just get back to pure racing.
You made a rod
for your own back, Stefano.
Seriously!
A business like F1
trades on inevitability
and its premium feel,
as well as the belief
that it knows how to modernize
without humiliating itself.
With all of this,
it just feels manipulated,
divisive and faintly unsafe.
This is going to weaken
that premium feel of theirs
if they don't act quickly enough.
Yet their instinct
is to package first
and explain later
or not explain at all.
It's just so clumsy.
And then the attention
goes back to Ben,
despite his relative
radio silences of late.
Remember when he was
talking about simpler
future engines last year?
Thanks to hindsight,
they're not as random
as we first thought.
You know, he originally
talked about bringing back V10s,
then that got shot down
because that wasn't road development.
Then maybe V8s with sustainable fuels,
the kind of stuff
that Sebastian Vettel
has been peddling.
And admittedly,
there is a market for that
in terms of synthetic fuel,
as long as the price can go down.
But we've got synthetic fuels anyway,
and they are being
basically charged an arm
and a leg of the teams
in comparison to the regular fuel.
Why don't we just continue
to innovate that,
make it cheaper,
then bring back older blocks,
maybe with a little bit of battery tech
to act as an alternative to a turbo?
Yeah, it could be good.
Maybe Ben had a point there,
but at the time,
it just got brushed aside
as nostalgia bait,
or him trying to wield
far too much power
than he thought he actually had.
Because yes,
he is the FIA president,
one of the biggest figures
in global motorsport.
But he couldn't treat that
as a regular presidency
of a country per se,
because the FIA is meant
to be a non-profit organization.
It is not a corporate business,
or at least it isn't yet.
But now,
the current backlash
Formula 1 management is receiving,
it's making Ben's take
much more grounded.
That being said,
that doesn't fully vindicate him,
because on his watch,
these 2026 regulations were ratified.
He did support them to begin with,
but when it became clear
there was going to be
a lot of blowback,
he got quieter and quieter about them
until he didn't really
talk about it at all.
So therefore,
the FIA does have to take
certain responsibility,
as they have now been introduced to us.
But still,
the critique that Formula 1
may have drifted too far into complexity
now carries more force
than it did in 2025.
It makes the whole push
toward a more electrically defined F1
look far more political
than when it was solved
as a simply environmental concern.
I do believe in battery technology,
but it needs to be refined
and made cheaper and lighter.
And it is one of an option
of powertrains,
including hydrogen,
including synthetic fuels
in existing combustion engines,
depending on the use case.
But thankfully,
the FIA is starting to behave
a little bit more realistically,
a little bit more rationally,
unlike its commercial sidekick.
So yes,
the April break is
an absolute gift to them.
Because Miami becomes
a big moment for the sport,
instead of them having to suffer
through Bahrain and Jeddah
having to deal with the same arguments
again and again and again.
It could have been even worse
in Saudi Arabia,
because the amount of battery starvation
at the Corny circuit,
it would have been
even worse than Suzuka.
Also, it's a sprint weekend.
This, by choice,
Stefano has made
to be a showcase event
because he very much likes his sprints.
He wants more sprints.
In fact,
I personally don't mind sprints.
And then there's another
three weeks after Miami
before the Canadian Grand Prix
to then pass through
that particular data
and then introduce
something more robust
later in the year
and then into 2027.
If nothing meaningful
changes by Miami,
the consequences will be brutal
from a sporting point of view
and a commercial one.
Because, again,
sprint weekends are meant to be
Formula One management's halo event.
But at the end of the day,
Oliver's crash now looks like
the moment Formula One's
whole power structure was exposed.
The drivers warned them,
but they still had no
voting power of their own.
There are signs the FIA knows
this can't be just shrugged off,
but the key meeting
they're having in April
will not have the drivers
at the table still,
with some teams probably
reluctant to do anything
before next year.
So what do the drivers
do about it then?
Do they just have to
put up with it
whilst the grown-ups,
the team principals,
carry on negotiating?
They themselves,
the ones operating these cars,
and whilst nothing drastic
has happened yet,
Thurman was the biggest
red flag yet in 2026.
You could even say
the drivers have become
effectively crash test dummies
for a political compromise.
That can easily make
a legitimacy problem
turn nasty very, very quickly,
because now,
I mentioned Formula 1
had an honesty problem,
it's now evolving quickly
into a legitimacy problem.
Because the chassis,
and the acceleration of the cars,
and the size of the cars,
they're all absolutely gravy.
They're cool.
The drivers like that bit.
But the sport itself
is dealing with an
even simpler problem.
Can it maintain
its current pitch
whilst the data is showing
more and more resistance?
When the evidence outruns
the sales pitch.
Because once the fans
start to figure out
exactly who was responsible
for formulating these regulations,
all of the arguments
for these regulations
are going to become
much harder to justify.
And Toto Wolff's position
is going to look
even more shaky
as him being the kingpin.
And let's just watch
how he reacts
as these revolutions go on.
But I trust you to stick around
and watch this video here,
which I know that you will like.
I'll just go and get myself changed,
and get a drink,
and I'll be right with you.
