George Lucas, JK Rowling, and the Curse of Creating Your Own Story

J. K. Rowling - the writer
1 follower
2 Video Views·Mar 29, 2026
In this video, we explore a deeper pattern hiding in plain sight.
Not just where life mirrors art, but where creators begin to live out the very tensions, conflicts, and structures of their own work.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Life mimics art. This is a theory that Oscar Wilde postulated in 1899 that people consciously or
unconsciously model their lives and their behaviors and their perceptions on the artistic styles,
narratives and images that they consume or create. A less formal way of saying you are what you eat
or you are what media you consume. We have seen this portrayed in our culture over and over again
whether that is in the story of Titanic sinking 14 years after the publication of Futility,
a novel that depicts the events of the Titanic almost exactly, or perhaps Tom Clancy's Dead
of Honor which portrays a plane crashing into a government building, specifically the Capitol,
prior to the events of 9-11 and eerily mirrors the cultural imagination of that kind of event.
I would have previously mentioned The Simpsons, but given what we now know about the creator of
that series and where they have spent their time, honestly that conversation gets a bit murkier.
That starts to fall less into life mimics art, more into what some people call predictive
programming, which is the idea that art can normalize or precondition us to accept
what we would otherwise feel is unacceptable. Back to life imitates art, there is also a phenomenon
called nominative determinism. It's a fancy term for the idea that people are drawn towards
occupations that reflect their names. This shows up particularly in places like Great Britain
where last names have been more stable over time and less disrupted by slavery and immigration.
So you get examples of meteorologists named Amy Fries or surgeons called Dr. Bone,
chefs named Cook, and Usain Bolt who is a sprinter. There are even more extreme,
there are even funnier examples like Ernest Tramp was a young man who set the trampoline
record for number of consecutive flips. And if you look into it, there are entire communities
that track this nominative determinism experience. We extend this to life mimics art because who we
are as people is an art and our names are included in that. And so today we are going to go deeper
into this concept and we're going to mix it with another one because let's face it white mansplainer,
it is that deep. We're not just going to talk about where life mimic arts but where an artist's
life begins to mirror the very story that they created. There is a line and we're going to combine
it with this idea that Jonathan Nolan said in The Dark Knight, you will either die a hero or you
live long enough to see yourself become the villain. In other words, we are going to examine
artists whose lives begin to resemble the tensions, structures, and conflicts of their own work. And
we are going to focus on two examples, George Lucas and J.K. Rowling. Fittingly, Christopher
Nolan actually sits near this conversation also given the fact that his brother was the one who
actually wrote the line about heroes and villains but that is for another video. So let's orient
ourselves and give ourselves what we're talking about. If life imitates art and if you bring art
into the world you become its hero and then given enough time you either become its villain or you
experience its villainy in a very strange sort of way. I'll give you some quick examples first.
Michael Jackson created Neverland which was embodying the archetype of Peter Pan, the eternal
child. Then he spent the rest of his life shadowed by accusations tied to that same narrative, the
idea that he was stealing lost boys. And even if those accusations are debated, the structure of
the story followed him throughout his life past his death. Or Orson Welles who created Citizen Kane,
a story about a man whose power isolates him only to find himself living a version of that same
trajectory after his meteoric rise following the success of the film. Then we have real life
examples like Elizabeth Holmes who built Theranos around the idea of seeing everything inside a
blood sample only to have us not be able to see what was actually inside of her and her own
psychology and her own leadership. So this pattern shows up. But where it becomes more interesting is
where we stop treating the story as something that we create and we start seeing it as something that
we are already inside. In other words, you create a world that mimics your own life and therefore
your life then extends into that story. So first we're going to talk about George Lucas. George
Lucas built a story in Star Wars that is constantly navigating the tension between being in alignment
with the force and attempting to control it. What is interesting is that honestly that is the
simplest explanation I can have for the dark side and the force because there really isn't an agreed
upon definition, at least in the Star Wars saga, for the dark side. Sometimes it's bureaucracy or
endless senate proceedings, it's figureheads, performative leadership, it's clumsiness, masking
is more as something more dangerous, it is being too focused on the future and not the present,
or it is anger and jealousy and fear. And in the prequels especially we see that the empire does
not arrive all at once. It emerges through fear and through control and through the need to impose
order on something that is inherently alive. The empire is not chaos, it is overcorrection,
a system that begins by promising safety and ends by consolidating power. Now look at what
happens outside the story. The corporation that acquired Lucasfilm is one that has repeatedly
taken complex, strange, and often chaotic intellectual properties and translated
them into something that is globally legible. You can feel this most clearly with Pixar.
WALL-E opens in dead silence, there's a dead earth, there's no explanation, it's just decay
and loneliness. Ratatouille ends up with a foo critic having an existential collapse about taste
and class and memory. Up begins with a full life of love and loss and almost no dialogue. These are
not safe openings and they assume that the audience can sit in discomfort. And then you look at the
post-Disney Pixar films. Inside Out explains emotion, Soul explains purpose, Turning Red
explains identity, Luca explains belonging. Yes, great, fantastic, they're all wonderful things,
but they are homogenized. They are more guided, the ambiguity is reduced, and the discomfort
is shorter lived. The stories become more consistent, more melodramatic, more legible,
and more repeatable. Lucas built a story about how systems slowly turn into empires,
either dramatically and how they swing back and forth between control and living in alignment.
And then he sold that story to one of these empires, not because he was forced to,
but because he chose to step away, which mirrors another part of our story. In some ways, he's like
Yoda. He's present, powerful, deeply involved in the beginning, and then after failure, chooses
exile, watching the system rise from a distance rather than directly intervening.
Lucas moves from full creative control to advisory presence to absence. The story continues,
but it changes form without him because the empire won. Next we have J.K. Rowling. Rowling's
story is about identity, belonging, and the lines that we draw between people. Harry and Voldemort
are not just opposites, they are mirrors. Two characters navigating the same underlying story,
the same underlying question, who belongs and what makes someone legitimate. The world of Harry
Potter is filled with these divisions, pureblood and halfblood, wizard and muggle, insider and
outsider. And what we see, especially in Voldemort, is a character attempting to resolve uncertainty
by creating absolute categories, clear lines, no ambiguity, safety through separation. And then
you look at what happens in real life. The cultural conversation surrounding Rowling
becomes centered on identity, belonging, and who is allowed within certain categories.
The debate itself takes on the same structure as the world she created. There are clear lines in
her mind, there are strong divisions in her mind, a need for certainty in a space that is inherently
complex. This is not about whether she is right or wrong, it is about the pattern that she is
repeating. The story explored a world organized around identity and belonging, and years later
her life becomes embedded in a cultural conflict organized around those same things. Am I calling
J.K. Rowling Voldemort? I don't know. Is she Harry? Is she Voldemort? She's certainly following the
same story. So why does this happen? I don't think that the subconscious is just a storage unit of
forgotten memories waiting to sabotage. If you look at Jung or Heidegger or others working in
narrative identity, the subconscious is not just reactive, it is generative. It is constantly
organizing experience into story. And art is one of the ways that story becomes visible.
So when someone creates a world, they are not just inventing something, they are expressing
the structure of a story that they are already living inside. And if that story resonates widely
enough, it means that it's not just their story, it is something already moving through the culture,
which is why years later it shows up again, oftentimes ironically within their own life.
It's not fiction, it's their life. I'm Christina Wiltze, I look at story and art and the way that
they are mirrored back in the structures that we live inside of. I am building something called
the InterVillain Deck, which explores these patterns more deeply so that you can understand
what story you're in and what character you're showing up within that story.
Hopefully you're not like Rowling and showing up as Voldemort.
Thanks for listening, please like and subscribe if this is at all interesting to you.
