DIGITAL MONEY AND THE IMPACT ON NATIONAL SECURITY- Ambassador. Erik Bethel

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 28, 2026
24th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, Panama🇵🇦- February 23 – 24, 2023
-Ambassador Erik Bethel
Distinguished Fellow, Chamber of Digital Commerce; former U.S. Representative to the World Bank
AI Generated·May contain errors
Alright, can you hear me?
First of all, thank you, Alejo; I was nominated to be ambassador to Panama.
But I was nominated, yet not confirmed, due to the change in elections.
But before becoming the U.S. nominee to the Republic of Panama,
I was the U.S. director at the World Bank.
And before that, I've spent, who knows, 20 or 25 years in a financial career
at Morgan Stanley, JP Morgan, etc.
First, I would like to thank Congressman Pittinger.
I am deeply honored to have been invited to this meeting.
And thanks to Lucas, who is his assistant, who is always behind me,
behind the entire world, and thanks to Alejo.
Well, today I'm not going to talk about politics, but I'm going to talk about digital currencies.
And since to a certain extent it's easier for me to explain these things in English,
And since I have written a speech in English, I will now switch, please excuse me.
I am going to switch to English to talk about this topic.
So, switching here to English very quickly,
I'm going to talk about the fact that the world has been washed clean of the cryptocurrency fever.
What is a cryptocurrency? I'm going to talk a bit about this.
What is a central bank digital currency?
What is a digital currency? I'm also going to discuss this.
What is a stablecoin?
All these things are remarkably absent from an educational perspective,
but they have profound national security implications.
So, let me begin with what I would call bipolar cryptocurrency fever.
Cryptocurrency mania, bipolar.
Cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, Ethereum, etc.
They may recall that during the pandemic, Bitcoin increased fivefold.
And then it broke suddenly.
Since then, a cryptographic token called Luna
It collapsed, taking with it $90 trillion in capital.
More recently, a cryptocurrency exchange called FTX
It burned spectacularly.
But this is strange.
And the stranger has distracted us from what we should be looking at.
because it affects national security,
It is the central digital currency of banks.
The latest survey by international banks
It says that 90% of central banks around the world
They are trying to create their own version of coins.
Digital currencies, but for the country.
More recently, in the United States,
The Biden Administration proposed a white paper
and an executive order that called, among other things,
toward the creation of a U.S. digital currency.
But before going any further,
Let us take a step back and explain
What is a digital currency, a central bank digital currency?
It's simply a legal tent,
an official government website in digital format.
You can have a dollar bill,
What is a piece of paper,
or you could have 100 dollars,
or you could have four quarters,
or you can have a QR code,
all executed by the same source.
Everything is a legal matter.
So a CBDC, a central bank digital currency,
It's basically a digital currency.
Are you with me?
Is the digitization of money inevitable?
So the other day I found a VHS tape in a store.
I looked at it and showed it to my children.
I said, hey, kids, come here. Look at this.
And my children are, what do I know, 12, 10, and 14 years old.
And the video cassette, right?
And they say, "What is this?"
Well, that's how I used to watch movies.
And they said to me, in the 1900s?
Yes, in the 1900s.
But the point is that it has become,
became a DVD,
And that became Netflix.
Then, for me, the coins,
Let's take a look at pieces, coins, and banknotes in museums.
In the end, they will be relics of the past, anachronisms.
It is inevitable that money will be digital.
That is the second point I would like to mention.
Now, why are central banks doing this?
What's the point of creating a digital version of coins?
I'm going to talk a little about the positive aspects,
And then I will talk about the world's greatest creator of digital currencies,
And that is China.
And then I will discuss the implications for national security.
Starting off, what's the point of this?
Why do central banks,
90% of central banks in the world,
Are they investigating or issuing digital currencies?
Why? What's the point?
The first good reason is financial inclusion.
Financial inclusion.
So, there are many people around the world
who do not have bank accounts,
But maybe you have two phones, right?
So, if you can issue money in a digital currency,
It will be much easier, safer, more portable, etcucchini
Number two, governments can currently collect taxes.
So right now, the tax ratio to GDP
In the developed world, it is over 50%.
That means the governments of the OECD world
They collect approximately 50% of GDP in taxes.
In the developed world, in Africa,
In Africa it is 16%.
So it is very difficult to collect taxes.
So, what if you could create a digital currency?
in which you would have a commission
and in each transaction that might automatically go to the government,
would help governments collect taxes,
meaning they do not have to rely on tax rates
what harm the poor people, and so on.
Then, you can collect taxes,
Can you help support the marginalized?
Can you elaborate on how we trace illicit financial flows?
I believe we all agree that it is important
halt money laundering and transnational crime
and other illegal activities.
It is estimated that in Africa, 88.6 trillion dollars
each year from the African continent
in flight of illicit capital.
88 trillion dollars is the amount, if not more
of annual official assistance income
and foreign direct investment.
Then, digital currencies
They have many valuable use cases.
to promote financial inclusion,
trace illicit financial flows, etc.
But let's talk a little about China.
In China is where things get interesting.
Really, really interesting,
because this is the direction in which things are going
They could go in the future.
As I mentioned before,
central banks around the world
They have been looking for digital coins
for many years
The 90% of central banks
They want to launch their own digital currencies.
But only one country has been so uniquely
focused on this like China.
Over the past decade,
the banknotes and paper coins
They have disappeared in China.
In fact, the last time I was in China,
You had pilgrims with signs
that they didn't say money,
They had a QR code
Where could you scan the money?
and give it to the pilgrim in the street.
After eight years of work,
after eight years of work,
China launched its own digital currency.
And this has created
Some very, very big news.
Human rights organizations
They are very concerned about the power.
and the control that a digital currency
may have over citizens.
National security experts
They are expressing concern
due to the fact that the technology currency
It can be exported worldwide.
Let me say it again.
China has exported its technology.
China is excellent at exporting things.
So, if you are exporting to Huawei,
Get ready, because you are going to be exporting
the technology that supports
your digital currency around the world.
Now, this matters because digital currencies
represent a rest
of traditional currency systems.
Physical cash is anonymous.
If I have it in my body,
It is called a charging device.
I'll leave you all the data
economic aspects of the Treasury.
But it is a charging device.
It is anonymous.
And while anonymous money
presents problems
for illicit activities,
Sometimes we have to balance it
in the name of personal freedom,
autonomy and privacy.
And China, its digital currency,
It is called ECNY.
Your digital currency is designed
specifically to do the opposite.
Your coin is a supervisory instrument.
disgusted as a payment mechanism.
It is specifically designed
to improve government control
instead of protecting personal freedoms.
Then, we should wait
that the Chinese government
Use this to monitor
to their citizens 24 hours a day
and 7 days a month.
Raise your hand if you've heard about it
of China's social credit system
For those of you
what they don't know what it is
There is a social credit system in China.
that monitors everything you do.
If you buy shoes,
You are a good father.
Your credit increases.
If you walk in the right direction
from the street,
Your credit increases.
If you go to a democratic center
in Hong Kong,
Your credit is lowered.
Everything in your life is monitored.
controlled
according to your social credit score.
Imagine that the government
It has access to everything you purchase.
A person here
He could have bought a glass of wine.
Are they alcoholics?
Or are they having a party?
Who is at that party?
A person there
It could have bought something very private.
that they don't want others to know
But the Chinese Party
will have eyes
Looking at everything you do.
It is a major concern.
Now, let's talk
Why this is important
For all of you.
Many of you are parliamentarians.
and many of you
will be involved
in the legislation
to create
his own
own
nations
Consider the following.
China has expanded
trade
in the calls
route and boat
for many, many countries
around the world.
For example,
in this hemisphere,
Ecuador
Pay more money to China
that he can pay back.
Argentina pays
money to the IMF,
50 trillion dollars.
How are they going to pay that back?
Well, maybe China can come.
Well, maybe China wants something.
Maybe they want a port in Ushuaia.
Perhaps they want minerals
from Ecuador.
But perhaps
They're going to cut a few trillion dollars
trillions of dollars
from many countries
Back for what?
China can help you
to create
your own digital money.
And if you can't
generate it in your country,
Well, you can generate it
For you
in a cloud
in Beijing.
Then,
what I entrust you with doing
es
when you look
The future of money
Keep that in mind
the following three things.
I have one more minute.
So keep that in mind
A couple of things.
Digital money can be used
for many things
But keep in mind
what to preserve
privacy
and freedom
should be
among them.
Point number one.
Number two.
Digital currencies
his inevitable ones.
They are watching.
Forget it.
I'm not talking
of Bitcoin.
I'm not talking
of Ethereum.
These are
digital currencies
It is inevitable.
And number three.
China
certainly
will export
your technologies
around the world
and will be used
as a tool
of supervision
and a great
threat
of security
national
Then,
These are the things
what you should consider
So,
Thank you very much.
And now I can
My minute is ready
Yes, okay.
So,
if someone has
If you have any questions,
forward.
I arrived on time.
I scared everyone.
No one has a question.
Oh, I'm five minutes away.
Oh.
Well.
Does anyone have questions?
I can't hear.
Thank you very much.
Hello, how are you?
Hi!
Hey, a question.
If it would be considered
like a threatrored
all of this
What is China doing?
to clarify
her technology,
I would think
in that order of ideas
probably
United States
have a counterpart
for the same development
of technology.
Then,
My question is
in the long run
What would it be
the solution
to mitigate
this problem
in terms of what
if it is being used
a technology
in some country
and some person,
say,
He/She is going to send
remittances
He/She/It is going to travel
He is going to do something.
In what way,
given that it will no longer exist
The currency
How do we know it?
in cash
in what way
They can be done
these exchanges
using
as a,
say,
a cross
between both
technologies?
Well,
The Chinese are working.
about a new system
that is outside
of the institutions
What do we have?
already existing.
For example,
the SWIFT
They have created
their own SWIFT
what is it called
C-I-P-S
CIPS
y
a ver
How's it going?
With regard to
what he/she is doing
United States,
Look,
The truth is that
I don't know,
why do we have
what is called
an alphabet soup
of regulators,
No?
Between the SEC,
Is it me?
The OCC,
What will it be?
Yes
the Chinese
They don't want me to speak.
Well,
We have so many,
so many people
included in the subject
what
The truth is that
I don't know when
United States
is going to launch
its own digital currency.
Now,
the Boston Fed
Yes, it has started
a new technology
what is it called
Project Hamilton
that they can do it
Google Earth
con
the school
of engineering
of MIT
But
This is what comes next.
I don't know if I have answered
to the question,
but
United States
On their part
He is trying
to do something.
The Chinese
are
trying
bypass
the dollar
and the dollar system
and surely
that the countries
friends
"China"
so,
the Russians,
the North Koreans,
the Iranians,
and so on,
Will it be added up?
to that block
of coins
and that block
de
cross-border currency
Good afternoon.
I wanted
I have a question for you
