EXTINCTION OF DOMAIN LAW, AN EFFECTIVE WAY TO FIGHT AGAINST TRANSNATIONAL (....)- Mr Jonathan Riggs

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Mar 28, 2026
24th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, Panama🇵🇦- February 23 – 24, 2023
Topic: EXTINCTION OF DOMAIN LAW, AN EFFECTIVE WAY TO FIGHT AGAINST TRANSNATIONAL CRIMINAL ORGANIZATIONS
-Mr. Jonathan Riggs
General Secretary of the Ministry of National Security of Panama
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good afternoon, everyone. It is my turn to speak this afternoon.
on the forfeiture of assets, a bill introduced by the Republic of Panama
seeking to incorporate into the legal framework a mechanism for criminal prosecution that would enablepretty
quite a significant financial resource for weakening their operational structure,
its financial structure and generate a balance in the frontline combat against organizations
criminals. In this regard, the Ministry of Public Security together with the judicial authority,
to the Ministry of Economy and Finance, to the Public Ministry, drafted a project
of the law that brings together international best practices. We will now examine the definition
What is asset forfeiture for those who are unfamiliar with it, and why is it necessary?
a law on forfeiture of ownership, issues that have generated controversies within the framework of
the discussion of bill 625, countries that have adopted the law, judicialized operations
against organized crime in 2022 and the expected outcomes if this is approved
Law. What is expropriation? It is nothing more than a patrimonial legal consequence.
consisting of the loss to the State of economic resources that lack legitimacy
of constitutional protection. And by stating that they do not enjoy legitimacy or protection
constitutional, we start from what our constitutional text establishes, which states that
The right to legitimately acquired property is respected. Article 48 of the
The Political Constitution of Panama expressly establishes that private property entails
obligations for its owner due to the social role it must fulfill. Yesterday I was talking with
one of the victims of human trafficking who, fortunately, has managed to transform the negative into something positive
in a positive way and be a testimony of life for those who suffer from that humiliation, that affliction
of freedom and being sexually and laborally exploited, and to generate a balance that
has allowed him to travel around the world and bear witness to that reality which they face
victims for not being considered, for not being effectively compensated. And the Extinction
From the Domain seeks that casually, to reweave the social fabric, to restore the victims
and strive to achieve a balance regarding the impact on human sustainable development, which is seen
impacted by activities of organized crime. And it said in a forum that it turns out
It's fascinating to see how humanity confronts the onslaughts of organized crime.
what has sought to generate greater balance among offenders than among crime victims
if not, let's see what the accusatory penal system has generated worldwide in seeking to grant rights
those who have attacked collective security, and where are the rights of the
victims. Then, the Extinction of Ownership would generate that balance, would generate that capacity
of the effective compensation state to crime victims, and we are the victims
All of us can potentially benefit when the Extinction of Domain is generated, because that
geographic displacement of violence translates into the perception of insecurity that
many times one feels about citizenship, the impact it has, or the natural fear that arises
any person feeling intimidated by a crossfire where in our
reality, we have seen how innocent people have become victims of that dispute that exists over
the control of drug sales, for example. Therefore, Asset Forfeiture is aimed at
any asset capable of economic value, any asset capable of economic value
know titles, skills, values, properties, and how we will see next how the State can
benefit from receiving these funds in a timely manner because there is a difference that
distinguish between what countries call penal forfeiture and what is known as the extinction of ownership
allows states to generate an early sale from an early disposal that enables them
allow the State to use these assets for the benefit of society at large. According to
in a report, one of the latest reports by the United Nations, organized crime generates
About 4% of the world's Gross Domestic Product, approximately 3.75 trillion dollars.
Moreover, active laundering accounts for between 2% and 5% of the world's gross domestic product, that is
between 1.88 and 4.7 trillion dollars. It is important for the legal framework to
incorporation of the Extinction Law that would allow us genuine restorative justice and
I was telling him about restorative justice because the victim of trafficking I spoke with yesterday expressed that
it has been around 10 years now seeking that the State provide it with an economic compensation
recompense that harm to which he was subjected, even by the very state apparatus that inflicted it
was issuing permits to traffickers, being herself a victim of human trafficking, and today
It has not yet achieved that economic compensation, despite there being a judicial ruling. Within
the conceptualization of the Extinction of Ownership, therefore, generates for the State that
the possibility of recovering assets in a timely manner, and incorporating a catalog of crimes
that enables the Public Ministry to conduct investigations into high-impact crimes
It refers to people involved in kidnapping, extortion, robbery, gang activity, assassination, and other types
penal measures that in one way or another generate that geographical displacement of violence
We see it every day. Protection of Human Rights. I pointed this out at the beginning of my intervention.
How do we prevent constitutional guarantees and the right to free movement from being affected?
what we all have as citizens and what is affected when gang members promote among
They are a dispute over territorial control of drugs. Who protects the human rights of the
collectivity? Who truly manages to rebuild that social fabric that is affected by the
organized crime in all its manifestations? The protection of private property. It is discussed
among the detractors and those who oppose the incorporation of the law
extension of the domain of an impairment to private property. I ask the forum: Can
to enjoy constitutional guarantee of legitimacy the assault on a bank and that the person go and carry it out
a conviction? Who tells me that those two million dollars can enjoy legitimacy?
Did someone steal? In no forum I've been to have they been able to give me an affirmative answer because no
something that has been obtained cannot enjoy legitimacy or constitutional protection
illegally, and in the same manner, one who claims ownership cannot argue that because they complied
A convicted person has the right to the usufruct or to use those ill-gotten funds. We have what
it is established based on imprescriptibility and retroactivity, which are issues that also
have generated controversy regarding the implementation of名人 the extension law
The domain and Article 46 states that laws do not have retroactive effect except for those of public order.
public or of social interest when expressed as such therein and expressed within the bill
625, which is a law of social interest and public order, because it will attack the finances of the
organized crime that causes such impairment of the rights of the collective
feel safe in order to avoid being affected by the violence promoted by organizations
criminals. Third parties who are free from fault and here I wish to mention the competence
the deception that also generates financial resources through the facade of simulation
a lawful activity and these third parties acting in good faith, exempt from fault, are obliged to prove
that indeed those resources that have been provided to them, that have been entrusted to them
They are legally obtained through the distribution of dividend assets
in the case of a private company through inheritance through the work it generates
a legitimately established commercial activity, not simulated or carried out through a facade that conceals
truly, the illicit origin of those assets that generate instability within the sphere
commercial. Seeking that balance, we also incorporated within the project the
Court of Cassation, and the question that arises is to examine what occurs in the civil sphere regarding
appeal proceedings in which it is easy for up to 20 years to pass while seeking a positive outcome.
The bill is ambitious considering the state's needs.
to discourage new generations from making crime their way of life. We have sought
this consensus, and we have tried to give an opportunity to those who have generated this
type of controversy and that in one way or another generate misinformation to demonstrate that the law
are those who have made crime their way of life. Law-abiding citizens who
We are the majority; we shouldn't worry. Who should worry? The one who hasn't been doing their part.
legal matters. Within the legal instruments that have been taken into consideration
They are the ones watching on screen the United Nations Convention against Illicit Traffic
and astonishingly, the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime,
the United Nations Convention against Corruption, recommendations of the group of
financial action and the United Nations model law. Countries that have adopted the law
Forfeiture of domain, each with its fields for improvement, given their reality, I can tell you that in the
experience of Colombia, Honduras, Guatemala, and El Salvador are countries that have demonstrated that the
The use of these assets has enabled them to generate a benefit for society. In the
case of Honduras, for example, I can tell you about the City of Children and Girls, which is a
educational project hosting 900 to 900 students, boys and girls who receive a
full tuition, it is a boarding school, allowing students to develop a life project. Therefore, our
country seeks another way to generate impact in education, in culture, in the
sport and ensure that new generations avoid making crime their way of life. Let us examine some
judicial proceedings against organized crime and the assets that have been seized
which are awaiting a judicial decision that would actually allow the use of these funds
and furthermore, we will see a parallel between the benefits of a civil forfeiture law and what
faces the state for lack of a law on asset forfeiture. Operation Neptune, Operation Fisher
Operation Fortress, Operation Don Quixote. In 2021, only Operation Fisher enabled
the seizure, the confiscation of 10 million dollars in a single operation and what was carried out
During the year 2022, approximately 10.2 million dollars among bank accounts, properties,
properties, financial institutions, and vehicles. They are awaiting a judicial decision.
that allows for the use of those funds and resources, which the deterioration often does not facilitate
the use of funds when a judge has already issued a final ruling allowing their use
of the same. The current system generates deterioration of assets, there we see it, it creates the possibility of
The seized funds cannot be used until a final judgment is issued, non-compliance
of the obligations of custodians and administrators who have assets under their care
pursuant to a judicial order. With the extinction of the aim to achieve incorporation, a sale could be carried out.
anticipated, an early alienation that allows for timely utilization of these
resources that may be allocated for social interest projects will allow the accounts
the cautionary measures taken by banks may also generate revenue for the state. It can be justified that
Assets obtained through illicit activities become a binding figure
for investigations, in such a way that asset forfeiture strengthens the investigation
criminal, it establishes a balance in the administration of justice and truly enables justice
restorative one that enables society to rebuild that social fabric affected by
of violence in all its manifestations generated by organized crime. The results
expectations regarding the approval of the bill and a direct impact on finances and capacity
operational aspects of organized crime, strengthening of criminal prosecution and administration
justice, prevent deterioration, and promote the best management of the assets obtained
through asset forfeiture, promote the use of recovered money and assets
for the financing of social interest projects, prevention programs, as well as the
strengthening of educational, sports, social development, cultural, and other institutions.
Promotion of peaceful coexistence and a culture of peace. To conclude, I must point out to you
that we hope this year the National Assembly will allow us to achieve that incorporation into
legal framework and respond to citizens regarding public safety. Thank you very much.
I remain attentive to any questions from the audience. Many thanks for this.
A rather comprehensive explanation. My name is Víctor Alvarado, I am from the National College of
Professionals from the Police Services. We have seen the advantages that it has or would have.
materialize this law. The question is very simple. Why have we not achieved the law? Where
Is it stuck? Why is it stuck, and how could organized civil society collaborate?
to make that law materialize? Thank you. Many thanks. Among the topics that have
The controversial issue is the alleged infringement of rights that is claimed not to have been
respects the right to property, which we have demonstrated to be the case in the Panamanian constitutional text
generates that balance of respect for property legitimately acquired. The other issue is
establish the catalog of crimes, which in the first instance the project establishes that it be reviewed
all criminal offenses established in our legal system that allow for,
I explain that criminal prosecution must be effective for all types of crimes.
generated a catalog of crimes, giving priority to high-impact crimes,
extortion, kidnapping, gang activity, contract killings, human trafficking, and others, to give him the opportunity
the legislator to generate that balance which they were demanding. The other issue is the
prescription immunity. We were saying that if establishing the prescription of a case that has generated a
negative impact for life, as is the case with human trafficking, how could it possibly be that
we may establish by law that at the age of ten, that trader, that person who has
caused damage many times irreversible, may still enjoy legitimacy of the money obtained
of the crime of human trafficking? There is no way whatsoever to claim that this could enjoy
legitimacy. Then the debate has focused on that kind of argument that affects the
collectivity, as we have said. We always strive to raise awareness and have generated a series
campaigns aimed at informing the general public about what extinction entails
of ownership, why is the extinction of ownership necessary, and who should be affected by the extinction
From the domain of those who have made crime their way of life. That's it. Many thanks, Jonathan.
Riggs, for the contribution of the asset forfeiture today, which was important to mention.
Please give a round of applause for Jonathan, Secretary General.
