A state audit found that a Southern California school district issued California high school diplomas to students in China who never set foot in the state and never attended a single class here. The scheme ran for years before it surfaced. How does something like that go undetected?
In this episode, Sonja Shaw, President of the Chino Valley Unified School Board, walks us through what the audit uncovered and what an ongoing investigation still needs to answer. Joshua Philipp, host of Crossroads, explains how this case connects to larger concerns about foreign influence in American schools.
There is a state audit that's showing a California school district was giving
degrees to students from China that were actually in China in a private school in Qingdao.
These kinds of events are not unique. There are so many of them happening right now in California
because the Chinese Communist Party, the Chinese government, has been systematically trying to
build relationships here with different organizations, cities, counties, school districts
to see how it can use these relationships for its own benefits. Today we sit down with Sonia
Shah who's the president of the school board of Chino Hills. Also she's running for the
superintendent of California. Insiders came to her and asked her to look into this issue
and she's here to tell us what she's found. We also sit down with Joshua Phillips, our own
investigative journalist for Epoch Times, who's been covering the Chinese Communist Party and how
they infiltrate the U.S. I'm Tiamat Karami. Welcome to California Insider.
Sonia, it's great to have you back and welcome back. Thank you. It's always good to be back
with you. We want to talk to you about a situation at one of the school districts in California where
kids were getting degrees from China without really being here attending the school, which
is illegal, right? Can you tell us what you have discovered? Absolutely. So a school district,
Val Verde, here in California, apparently, allegedly, according to the new state audit,
was found giving diplomas to students in Chinese that never stepped foot here in California.
And, you know, uncovering all this, it actually came to me by somebody on the inside. They came
to me and said, hey, Sonia, they're trying to cover this up again. And I guess previously,
we are hearing, you know, previously for a few years when this was first discovered,
they were trying to cover it up again and not have the public aware of it. So I immediately took the
audit findings of what they were saying and I looked through them and I was kind of in shock.
It broke my heart to see what was going on. And then eventually that led me to trying to look up
some documents on the district and seeing how, you know, the transparency is supposed to go
through, especially being on our school board. I know how you're supposed to document audit
findings, whether they're good or bad findings, you have to make sure that the public knows what
you're displaying. And that was one of the findings in the audit. And then they kind of
just put presentation on there. So I knew there was something deeper. So the audit was marked as
presentation. It wasn't like marked as an audit. Yes. So February, the audit findings finally came
out of this year. And in March, March 3rd, the school district, one of the things that you have
to do when you have an audit finding, whether they're on the good side or bad side, you have
to put them on the agenda and do the findings in public. And so when I went to go try to find
these findings and see if they fulfilled their duties, I went to their agenda online and, you
know, there's Brown Act to keep people honest. And I looked and it just said presentation. That's it.
So it didn't even give the public an opportunity to come and make comment or even watch to see if
they wanted to, you know, make sure they looked into seeing if there was something that was
not appropriate in the findings. So that kind of set me off to be like, OK, these people who
are coming forth to tell me are really scared because they don't want to lose their jobs,
but they are trying to expose what's been going on that they've known long time standing with,
you know, Chinese students in China getting, you know, services that are supposed to be meant for
California students. And who were the people that came to these teachers, school staff? What kind
of people were they? Employees also from the county side and from the school district itself.
Unfortunately, I can't give their names because they are scared and I don't blame them because
unfortunately, when you do come out with truth, sometimes you're attacked and they don't want to
lose their jobs. This is how they provide. And they came to me. First, it was somebody in the
county that came to me and said, Sonia, the person or the new superintendent in the county is really
trying to do the right thing. But unfortunately, the school district is still trying to hide the
findings of the state audit that just came out. And so that's kind of what alarmed me to kind of
look into it. And then when I found it, I was literally in shock. And I did a, on the side of
a street in between meetings, you know, I did a video and I didn't know that it was going to go
viral, but I felt like I had a duty to tell people what I just saw in the state audit. And so I did
that video. And within that video, within 48 hours, I had people coming from the school district
itself and telling me, Sonia, I was offered a job in China, you know, to go and work in this school
called Pegasus in China, and then come back with a possible raise and my job given back after the
leave of absence. And that triggered even more things and more people talking and more conversations
happening. And my heart again, was just hurting to know that our students are suffering and our
resources here in California were being used for Chinese elite families in China, instead of our
kids here in the United States. And then it gets deeper because then I had reporters kind of saying,
Oh, I was trying to report this years ago, but they weren't even aware that the new audit came
out. Cause again, they were trying, the school district was trying to hide it and you go back
and it even shows that there was relationships and alleged that a lot of these actors in this
position were making deals with universities and giving these students access to the universities
before our own students in California as well. So it gets deeper.
So they will try to get these students in China to get accepted into universities?
They weren't trying, they were promising them. So apparently from what I'm being told, and of
course, you know, it has to be put through an investigation. And that's why I'm really hoping
that the Riverside district attorney takes this seriously. And I heard that he's on the right side
of making sure criminals are held responsible. But we need him to do a further investigation
because the audit found a lot of alleged things that are very inappropriate, but we need them
to investigate and finally hold these people accountable. A lot of these are, you know,
alleged, but an audit to find that I want to tell you to the district's audit that the one that they
did back years ago did not show the same things as the state audit, right? So you have discrepancies
and that shows, you know, unfortunately the state audit has to be non-biased.
You can't choose your auditor and all these other things, and it has to be done by the county board.
So I think there's a lot of great people trying to uncover this, but for some odd reason,
people are very resistant. But looking through the findings and the documents,
there is a lot of people including former state superintendents, former state education secretaries
that are all involved in this university, you know, people that worked for the universities
allowing this. And we're also being told that these same students from China didn't have to
meet the same requirements, obviously, but they were also promised degrees faster and easier
than our own students who are struggling to try to get into there and also get their degrees.
Can you tell us more about this setup? How was it done and what did the audit find?
Going back into it, you even had people dig up documents now that are showing a resolution was
made not only between the school district, but the California Department of Ed as well,
a relationship, because I told you former state superintendent was involved as well.
And they were talking about, you know, this is a sister school now with working with California.
And with the sister school, we are going to teach, you know, students about culture and things like
this. So these things are tied into trying to make it look to the public like it's great, right?
This is very normal. The Chinese Communist Party comes to different cities and they do sister
cities. And now in this case, it's been normalized. So it doesn't really raise a red flag
to really the agenda that's put behind it, right? Yeah.
So yeah, they did that. They connected that. And then, you know, they sent district employees
who are put on, you know, leave of absence, knowing they would come back in a year or two
to give their jobs to China. And they even had non-credentialed employees go as well.
So they will go to China to train them or to teach them.
Yeah. So you're using again, California resources, right? To send them to China.
With pay or without pay? So without pay, but paid over there,
without paying taxes of the United States. And when I heard a very, very nice salary
with paid places to stay and your food. Did we pay for it or did China pay for it?
It's not clear. Yeah. There is alleged bribery
and things in the findings as well. There's also current board member that, you know,
took trips allegedly according to the findings to China, all paid. So these people are getting
luxurious trips, you know, according to the findings as well. And then the findings show
alleged bribery, alleged things like that, which, which to me sets off an alarm. I mean,
again, our kids are failing at reading, writing a math. Services are not being
provided to California students. And then we have outsiders in China getting these services
and our own employees that are supposed to be teaching our California students. Right.
And what did they do afterwards? How did they get the degrees?
They actually told them they will get entry ways into certain
UCs here in universities, prestige ones in California. And then I don't know, we need more,
more. So they told them that you could get into the UC schools.
If 100% they did, according to the findings and also people who are whistleblowers behind the
scenes, they are alleging that they promised them spots. So, you know, you have to earn these spots,
but they're almost impossible to get because they have a California diploma, which I'll show you.
So they gave a California diploma, which is in a sense illegal, right?
This is very illegal to give a California diploma without meeting the requirements.
Without being here physically. They were never here physically, not even for a day.
And they gave them this diploma signed, you know, by all the people that I'm telling you.
And they gave them that diploma, which allowed them entry into the universities, number one,
but they were also promised. And allegedly these are Chinese elite families in China,
including what I'm being told, even military families and not U.S. military. We're talking
about Chinese military families. This is what we have been covering here at Epoch Times. And
the Chinese Communist Party has been trying to come into the U.S. from different ways.
Yes. And they come in an innocent way. They try to build these relationships like the sister city,
sister school in this case. And from there, they get people to do what they want.
And unfortunately, a lot of people that are now seeing, you know, this particular video go viral
and the findings being exposed. Again, my heart hurts for everybody that's involved that are
innocent because you do have people coming forward and saying, I didn't know it was illegal. They
told us it was legal, right? And so they pretty much, the bad actors forced the good people to
think that what they were doing was right and legal. And that's where I can't sit here and not
try to expose this because that is really sad when good people get dragged into really bad things
that are harming our most beautiful nation here. And when the Chinese Communist Party approaches
people, they say, we want to have our kids become like you guys. We want them to learn. You guys
are so great. Yes. And then they don't present themselves as they want to come here and get
something. Yes. And by default, California people have, I believe, really big hearts to people in
other countries that are experiencing bad things. So I honestly, with conversations that I've had,
even with you, I'm finding that a lot of times they'll use that these kids and these students
are under a communist regime, right? So they're coming to us to have an open heart to help these
students, right? To escape the communist party and the regime, which I can't blame anybody for
not wanting to try to do that, but there should be legal ways to do that. You can't give, you know,
California taxpayer dollars to people who are doing things illegally. That's wrong because our
students continue to suffer. And especially when the Chinese Communist Party is involved, whenever
you make a deal with the government, you know, you always, there's always the Chinese Communist
Party on that side and they always have agendas. And they're planting people here to do very bad
things like how they do in China, to do them here in California, especially because, you know,
California doesn't necessarily hold people accountable when they do bad things, unfortunately.
So yeah, I just see a lot of good people are dragged into a very bad thing that needs to stop.
And what are the next steps from here? So there's bigger investigations right now going on, right?
Yes. So I did make a call to Sheriff Bianco, who is the sheriff of that county. And I said,
is this on your radar yet? Which I knew it wasn't because they were trying to hide it,
right? And it wouldn't be on his radar unless the DA were to take the case.
And I said, I couldn't get through to the DA, but I'm hearing the DA is great in Riverside. And we
live, I live very close to that. And I, you know, San Bernardino County always looks to Riverside
County as being kind of a model for the state on holding bad people accountable for doing bad
things. And so I made a phone call to Sheriff Bianco and he immediately made a phone call to
the district attorney. And he did confirm with me that this will now be under investigation.
I just think we need to pursue that. It is under investigation. The investigation doesn't stop.
And that, you know, California, our government doesn't try to stop
the investigation from happening at the local area.
How about the process of giving these degrees? Has it stopped at this school district?
Yes, I'm being told it has stopped, but unfortunately they found other loopholes,
which I'm finding out from other people speaking up all throughout California,
with California having very strict laws on not asking immigration status of students
and also not being able to pursue to get visible copies of their visas. Because there's certain
visas, you can come in here and have a California education if it's on the right kind of visa,
right? And with that though, the students do have to, the parents do have to pay for their
tuitions, right? To come over here. So taxpayer dollars don't get involved.
It's kind of out of state tuition, you know?
Yes. So that's their legal way now, because California has strict laws against pursuing,
asking for the visas. And I have to look into this further, but I think it's going to take a
lot more hands on deck. B1 and B2s that are usually generally not allowed to come here.
Now we're not allowed to pursue asking for those documents if they say, oh, we just don't have them
because California, and I want to believe it's even the nation, has to legally give education to
students if they're here, regardless of their documentation. So the general idea is that people
that are from China, that their parents haven't paid taxes in California, they should pay for
the school system if their kids are going to the school as foreign students. But in this scenario,
they're not really checking the visas. They're not really checking the backgrounds. They just
say, if you're here, you can just attend the school, even though you haven't contributed
with the taxes. Absolutely. So I think it gets bigger. They always find a way once you
expose that, you know? And I have to give credit to a lot of people and a lot of investigators,
a lot of reporters back when this was originally happening. It seems like, you know, from what all
the documentation that I ended up finding afterwards, they were really trying to push
and expose it and expose what was happening into our universities. Unfortunately, there wasn't a
state audit done until years later. And look, again, they try to cover it up. I will say,
you know, again, $130 billion a year is spent on education here in California, and only 47%
of our kids can read and write. I will tell you, as a school board president, a lot of the programs
and the money we receive does go to English non-learners. And you have to give that first
over anybody else. So by design, they've already set it up to support these kinds of things
happening locally without students being here properly and without their parents
living in California and paying taxes in California. Sonia, please keep in touch with us on this issue
as you're getting more and more information. Thank you for being here. Thank you for always
being transparent and providing these kinds of things to California. Now we go to Joshua
Phillip, our investigative reporter with Epoch Times, to see what his take is on this topic.
There's a school district in California, and they have made a partnership with a Chinese private
Chinese school in Qingdao, and they're giving degrees, which is kind of illegal for a California
school to do that. Can you tell us how this kind of programs work? Well, I know it's still being
audited right now. They're still investigating it. But apparently what they found, there's a school
in Riverside, California, sister school program with, I believe it's the Pegasus California
School, they call it. And it seems the whole brand of this Chinese boarding school is, you know,
sending students abroad to study in California and get an American education. With the actual
investigation found, the audit, they say that the kids, a lot of them never even set foot in the
United States. A lot of them never attended in person. And that's illegal, apparently,
under California law. Because what it looks like, the allegation, and again, it's still being
investigated, the allegation is they're effectively falsifying diplomas in order to defraud
universities. So they make it appear that hell, this kid studied in America, in California,
you know, American private school education, $30,000 a year. Obviously, this is a very,
you know, prestigious thing. It looks like a sham. This is what it looks like.
Are these kind of things common with Chinese Communist Party? You've been actually studying
these type of events with China, these type of collaborations.
In terms of falsifying diplomas, I don't know how common that is. I know in China,
it's very common. It's very common for, you know, the sons and daughters of, you know, politicians
or Communist Party officials, for them to effectively pay off teachers and so on in
order to get diplomas. You know, East Asia, not just China, but East Asia, whether it's China
or Japan or South Korea or Taiwan. Like, you know, in America, a degree kind of matters there. It's
like it really, really, really matters. And the name of the university really, really, really
matters. Like whatever university you graduate from is part of your title for the rest of your
life. And so going to prestigious schools is a very big deal for them. They're kind of a gold
card is to come to the United States and study. There are reports coming out the Chinese Communist
Party, they call Harvard University the Chinese Communist Party school, because again, so much
money in it. This is an issue overall in the United States. You know, Trump was actually
talking about doing something about all the Chinese students coming here, saying they're
getting on research programs, you know, co-funded by U.S. taxpayers. They're stealing information,
taking it back to China. It's paid military research. It's medical research. He actually
backed off that, though. And it was kind of surprising because the CCP and anti-CCP, it's
one of the few bipartisan topics. It's one of the few things a lot of Democrats and Republicans tend
to kind of agree on. Trump actually backed off that. And what he said was effectively a lot of
universities would go bankrupt if they didn't have Chinese money. Like there's so much Chinese money
in the American school system. When something like this happens, do you think this is organized by
the Communist Party behind the scenes? Because you've been covering how the Communist Party has
been infiltrating different kinds of organizations and trying to systematically build
relationships with local governments and entities. Do you think something like this is tied to a
Communist Party? My personal take, this looks like a normal Chinese fraud ring. This is my personal
opinion. Again, it's still being investigated. We'll see what comes out from the investigations.
My personal feeling, though, my personal belief, this looks like a Chinese fraud ring. And that
would be different from what the Chinese Communist Party would want to use it for.
There are very serious educational programs tied in with the CCP, to name a few. The Chinese
Student and Scholar Associations are the number one concern I would label. These are effectively
Chinese student groups. They're funded by the Chinese consulates. They're operated by the
Chinese consulates. They're tied in with a branch of the CCP. I've actually mapped it out previously.
I've done reports on it. They've deleted the web pages. I saved the archives. I have archives of
everything they did. They admit it. And effectively what the CCP does, if you're a Chinese student and
you go and study at an American university, and they have CSSAs at every single major American
university. There's not a single one as far as I know. They did get rid of them at Columbia,
I believe. It was after a weird incident where a student beheaded another student. We never got
full details of what actually happened. But I believe they might be the only university in
the U.S. that does not have a CSSA, a major one as far as I know. But when Chinese students come
abroad, they're automatically enrolled. You don't have a choice. And what these are, they're student
groups. They monitor other students. They're funded, operated by the consulates. They're tied
in with the entire United Front system, which they call community leaders. You have college
professors who are members of it because it's students and scholars. You have faculty members
at universities who are part of it. They work as the eyes and ears of the CCP on the ground. They
can get Chinese students into taxpayer-funded research programs. The more concerning part,
though, is they can grow the careers of Chinese students and plant them in businesses or
government. And this isn't just in the U.S. So if the Chinese Communist Party wants a spy in the CIA
or a spy in the FBI or a spy in the district attorney's office or a spy working in the cabinet
of a political party or of a politician, they can grow them through the CSSAs and then basically
follow their career. We want you to apply for this job. We want you to get a job with the
government. We want you to get a job in the Justice Department. We want you to get a job
at a major bank or Tesla or something like that, or in the military for that matter.
If you have a college degree, you can actually go through an officer program in the military
and become an officer. A lot of people don't even know, in the United States,
you don't have to be an American citizen to join the military. It's actually a path to citizenship.
You can become a citizen by joining the military, and you have huge numbers of Chinese joining it.
And so this is the kind of stuff the CSSA would do. That would be more in line with the interests
of the Chinese Communist Party. They wouldn't want to pretend they're going to school. They
they could use to infiltrate the government or infiltrate what they want or bring stuff
back to China. That'd be their main interest. Josh, you have been talking to some of these
students, and do you have any recommendations for educators in California? And some of these
students that have been inside these student bodies that the Chinese Communist Party is trying
to recruit them, do you have any thoughts for educators in California? Yes. Beware of the CSSAs.
Chinese Student and Scholar Associations, in my opinion, should be labeled a spy organization.
I think it's insane these are allowed to operate in the United States. I do know there are currently
federal investigations underway into them. The other reality is, though, a lot of students are
added. They're automatically enrolled under the CCP. A lot of them do not have a choice.
Even if they went to high school in the U.S.? Yes, it can work like that. Yes. So under the
Communist Party, they have what's called the Overseas Chinese Affairs Office. Basically,
it's a government branch that works alongside the United Front Work Department,
which is their eyes and ears on the ground on the civil level. Those are the guys inviting
people on trips back to China. They're targeting academics, business leaders, politicians,
investors, and so on. That's how they basically infiltrate and carry out spy operations through
the United Front. But alongside the United Front is the OCAO, the Overseas Chinese Affairs Office,
and that has databases on Chinese. They actually regard second and third generation Chinese as
part of their system. So it could be that your mom was from China, or your grandma's from China,
and you're 100% born here. You're still on their system. If you're that level, they're not going
to put you under the Chinese Student and Scholar Associations. A lot of that is more like if you're
coming here to study abroad, but they still do target you, try to recruit you. There's a lot of
stuff like that. On a real policy level, I'd say the concerning thing is this. There are American
citizens who do not enjoy the protection of the American government. There are American citizens
who are harassed, who are followed, whose families are threatened, especially if they have family
back in China, by this system. They're being denied their rights to protest. If they go and
talk about human rights in China or democracy, their families get threatened. So that is a
denial of rights. They're violating constitutional protections. They're going against people's
freedom of belief. If you want to express your religion at an American university or a Chinese
student, you might get attacked by these organizations. They'll go against your freedom
of speech. This is denying people's constitutional rights. It's kind of crazy it's allowed to happen.
I would also add, though, that not all of them are bad, per se. I've known a lot of Chinese
students. A lot of them, really, they're great kids. A lot of them are very much aware of the CCP
to various extents because there's a lot of censorship. And so I'd say treat them with
kindness and compassion, but understand also the CCP has a lot of eyes and ears
on the ground. And they do target these kids and try to control them.
And for the government officials and people that are trying to create these relationships with
China, because California is a very compassionate state, we want to help everyone. And these
government officials are constantly approached by members from China, whether they're the Communist
Party members or individuals. Is there a way to differentiate who is connected to the Communist
Party and who's actually a genuine Chinese citizen that wants to do something cultural with us?
So the challenge that a lot of people in government face and a lot of academics face,
usually the spies are the best spoken, the funniest, the most charismatic, the most easily
integrated into society. A lot of times, the ones who are not like that, they're dodgy.
They've grown up in a system where you have to hide what you're thinking. They might not make eye
contact with you. They might say things indirectly because saying things directly in China can get
you in trouble. And so normal Chinese look a bit suspicious, as weird as that sounds,
because of the suppressed culture under the CCP they grew up with.
Whereas a lot of the spies are charismatic, open, they speak usually very good English or decent
English, and they're very inviting. Oh, let me show you the real China, this kind of thing.
The easiest way you can spot a Chinese spy, though, they really don't do a good job of
hiding it. I've actually encountered several individuals where they literally, on their
business cards, have the name of two or three spy organizations. They don't hide it. And it's
because they know they can act in such a brazen way, and they've never faced investigations.
There's almost nothing that's going after them. They don't have to hide it because they don't
risk prosecution, as weird as that sounds. I'd say the two biggest red flags, pun intended maybe,
are this. Beware of any individual who's part of a Tong. So it could be a fraternal organization,
a benevolent association. We're part of the Chinese American Friendship Association.
So these are the Chinese American Society, this type of associations.
They're not all bad. There are some that are Taiwanese aligned, but you do need to be careful
with them. Even some of the Taiwanese ones, they might be business associations,
and they'll still be very much tied in with the CCP. Beware of anybody who is or was a member
of the CSSAs, the Chinese Student and Scholar Associations. Yes, there are different levels
of involvement, but that should be a massive red flag, especially for people looking to hire
former Chinese students or whatever. Government should be very much aware. In my opinion,
government, if someone was a member of the CSSA, you should treat them as possible spies because
they do grow them for that purpose. They groom their careers for that purpose.
And so beware of these things. A lot of times, again, Chinese organizations, CSSAs or Tongs,
again, fraternal organizations, benevolent associations, friendship associations,
hometown associations, those are things you need to watch out for.
Joshua Phillip, it's great to have you on. Thank you.
Anytime. Thank you.
Let us know what you think about this story. Do you think we should have more scrutiny when it
to make sure we're actually helping the people, not the Communist Party? You can always email us
or comment. We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Khorami. This is California Insider. We'll see you next time.