Octopus is considered a delicacy - grilled, boiled, or fried. But rising demand has consequences, and in several regions of Europe, this intelligent cephalopod is already considered overfished.
Stocks are shrinking dramatically, especially in the Mediterranean. In Greece, illegal traps are often used for fishing. Together with the coast guard, the environmental organization Sea Shepherd has removed thousands of these traps from the seabed - part of a mission against environmental crime. The film crew embarks on an investigative journey along the coasts of Europe and Africa. In Galicia, northwestern Spain, there are several large fish processing plants that cut up octopuses, freeze them, and prepare them for the international market. Fishing is subject to strict regulations because natural stocks are shrinking rapidly. To meet the high demand, factories are increasingly resorting to imports from African waters. A corporation is planning to breed octopuses in aquaculture. However, the plan has been met with fierce criticism from environmentalists, and the project has been put on hold for the time being. The breeding of octopuses is ethically and ecologically questionable: the animals are highly intelligent and sensitive, suffer from stress in captivity, and no humane slaughter methods exist. In addition, their meat-based diet puts strain on marine ecosystems, and thus goes against sustainable aquaculture. In the Mediterranean, the common octopus (octopus vulgaris) is caught in many places. In Greece, for example, long ropes of plastic traps attached to buoys are placed on the seabed. A local fisherman shows the camera team how the yield is steadily declining - a direct consequence of overfishing. The ecological consequences of octopus overfishing are already visible: in Italy, the invasive blue crab is spreading uncontrollably. It is one of the octopus's favorite foods - but without natural enemies, it is now destroying mussel farming in the Po Delta and thus posing a threat to livelihoods. Could the return of octopuses be the solution? An organization from Austria is testing exactly that, off the Croatian island of Krk. There, researchers are investigating whether octopuses can settle in artificial caves, reproduce, and contribute to the long-term stabilization of the ecosystem. The experiments are still in their infancy, but hopes are high: a sustainable model for the entire Mediterranean region could emerge.
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
For more visit: http://www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610 Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: https://p.dw.com/p/MF1G
AI Generated·May contain errors
Octopuses are majestic and under threat.
On the one hand, they have a huge social media following.
On the other, we like eating them.
Many are killed every day.
If the octopus finish, what are they going to do?
How are they going to live?
Environmentalists fight against overfishing
and free octopuses from illegal fishing pots.
And they're watched as they do so.
That's quite suspicious to me.
The environmentalist actions are causing problems for Mediterranean fishers.
They don't do nothing, only destroy families.
The front lines have hardened.
Should we even be eating octopus anymore?
Many of these enigmatic creatures live at the depths of the ocean.
They're masters of camouflage and change colour to avoid detection.
With eight arms at their disposal, they're quite capable.
And lightning fast.
And most can shoot ink out to mark the waters.
Some are just a few centimetres long, others more than five metres.
And they're ancient.
Octopuses even predate the dinosaurs.
They're also a huge hit on social media.
Warren Carlyle founded the world's largest social media platform for octopus content.
He's been obsessed with the creatures since childhood.
My personal fascination is the octopus's eyes.
If you look at an octopus's eye, they have this horizontal bar in their eye.
And it actually allows them to see 360 degrees around their bodies
because they're like a highly preyed upon animal.
And over hundreds of millions of years, they've developed a wider field of vision.
And so I think it's a really remarkable creature
when you're looking at resilience, adaptability, all these really cool values.
Millions of people click on videos like these,
thereby boosting the octopus's popularity and changing how we view them.
You can't just mess around with life on this planet and kill,
you know, millions and millions and millions of octopuses.
People have a right to be upset,
and that octopuses, with how intelligent they are,
definitely, it should be looked at more.
The octopus seems to have figured life on this planet out,
and I think we should be more inspired by it.
And so I think that's, you know, a huge reason I created OctoNation.
When in danger, most cephalopods expel a dark liquid.
Octopuses comprise about 300 species.
Their ability to camouflage themselves is extraordinary.
They can change colour and texture in a flash.
There are also around 300 species of squid,
which have 10 arms, 8 short ones, and 2 longer tentacles.
Squid also have an internal shell for extra stability
during high-speed jet-propelled swimming.
Cuttlefish can be recognised by their flat ovular bodies and calcareous cuttlebones,
an internal shell that gives them structure and protection.
Cuttlefish are also excellent at camouflage
and can adapt their colour and pattern to their surroundings.
Their undulating fins are perfect for slow-speed cruising.
Why do we kill such intelligent creatures?
The seas of Croatia off the island of Kirk
are home to the octopus vulgaris, or common octopus,
the species prevalent across the Mediterranean.
The Croatians love it, first and foremost on their dinner plates.
Restaurant owner Katica Juracic cooks it in a traditional pan called a peka.
It goes in whole after being tenderised
and immersed in boiling water for 10 minutes.
When you put it in peka fresh, it's too salty.
Where do you get it? Where can you buy it?
From local fishermen.
The best octopus is from winter.
Not now, because now has got the young.
The recipes are hundreds of years old.
Octopus is a culinary favourite throughout the Mediterranean,
usually roasted or in a salad.
Small restaurants like Katica's are also supplied by friends and acquaintances.
One of the fishers bringing in his catch is Ivan Juracic.
I've been fishing for 30 years.
Of course I do it for the family.
And if I catch more, I give them to friends.
It's not about business.
Fishing is his great passion.
Every week he sets off to check his licensed fish traps.
These are located a mile out of the harbour.
But the first basket is empty.
No octopus, just a bit of leftover bait.
Ivan restocks the bread and meat scraps.
OK, let's get this sorted.
The octopuses swim in here.
Then they can't get back out because of the sharp wire.
Maybe he'll have better luck with the second trap.
Yes, in this one he finds a medium-sized common octopus weighing about 3 kilos.
Ivan kills the animal quickly with a precise stab of the knife to prevent any suffering.
One octopus.
That's the entire haul for a week.
There used to be more.
They are far fewer.
Far, far fewer.
And more people are hunting them.
And fewer octopuses.
Is the Mediterranean being overfished?
How bad is the situation?
In Greece, the environmental organization Sea Shepherd
operates two different-sized ships in the Aegean Sea.
The activists suspect that fishers aren't complying with bans or closed seasons
and intend to check this out.
This 12-metre boat sets sail with a team of scouts
on the lookout for any illegal fishing gear.
Over here I would like to go and check with the anchor.
It's a tip that we got.
And I would like to throw a little grapple in
and check if we can find anything.
They've been given coordinates.
It should be around here somewhere.
I think there's something.
It's at least more tension than it was before.
What we brought up is some old net, but not very long.
They're clearly not quite in the right place.
The search continues in the vast open sea.
Then they spot a plastic canister
often used as a marker buoy attached to an octopus trap.
A fishing boat appears.
Are the occupants about to cut the rope
and prevent the activists from finding the illegal fishing gear?
What we're looking at in the photos is to see if they are actively fishing
or if they are just standing by to keep an eye on us.
That's quite suspicious to me.
But they don't have any pods?
Not yet.
Right now we just have the line which is connected to their fishing gear.
There's a long rope attached to the canister.
That's what the environmentalists are looking for.
The fishing boat sails away.
A sea shepherd diver and a cameraman go down to investigate.
What will they find?
They follow the rope.
First they hit sand.
Then they find the first octopus trap.
It's not supposed to be here.
And it's not the only one.
There are hundreds of plastic containers like this down here.
The traps that we've just mapped now are super illegal actually
because first of all it's the season where octopus traps are not permitted at all.
And furthermore these ones are in four meters of water
and any depth shallower than 10 meters all year round it's banned.
The common octopus lives across the entire Mediterranean
mostly on the seabed.
It can grow up to a meter in length and weigh up to 10 kilos.
The animals initially live in shallow waters like these.
They shelter in the pots.
But these containers are deadly traps catching octopuses en masse.
These activists plan to call in the larger ship to help recover
the kilometer-long line of illegal fishing traps found at this location.
Local port police have neither the personnel nor the boats to conduct checks themselves.
Dimitris Sianis from the Regional Fisheries Authority
is heavily reliant on the environmentalists' support.
We do a great job with the help of Sea Shepherd.
And if we manage to clean the bottom of the sea from the traps
the number that is allowed to have for each vessel
which is about 1,500 it's not the reality.
Each vessel might have 10,000 pots
and it's not really easy for the authorities to find them
because it's in the depth of the sea.
So are fishers ignoring the official limit on trap numbers?
There's plenty of octopus at this market stall.
But how come?
It's close season as he's well aware.
Then he explains that he and his father don't catch the octopuses in pots
but in small nets.
These are illegal in limited numbers.
You speak English?
This fisher has just returned from the sea.
And no octopus today?
No luck for them either.
Although not for want of trying.
I've got 900 traps but another guy here has this many.
He writes down the incredible figure of 30,000.
The captain of the biggest ship in the harbour confirms
catching octopus is his specialty.
Yes, hello, good morning.
How do you fish?
With net or pot or how do you do?
With these boxes.
With this one.
Ah, so this is okay.
And you have got on the ground?
Yes.
How many you need?
A lot.
A lot means how many?
More than, I don't know.
We must have 1,500.
Oh wow, okay.
The precise legal maximum amount in Greek coastal waters.
The area where his ship is moored is littered with pots like these.
Some of them belong to him.
Where do you go to fish?
It's far away or?
No, this time we go to the international water.
It's not the time for the Greek waters.
In international waters there are no regulations.
To prove his point he shows us his recorded GPS coordinates outside Greek waters on a map.
He has 15 different lines and nets in the sea, each up to 10 kilometres long.
Would he take a camera crew on board?
He says he'll think about it.
Mediterranean squid is also a top culinary expert to Germany.
Squid are very popular.
We've also got several dishes on the menu.
Calamari absorbs spices, flavours and breadcrumb coatings very well.
That's why it can be used in so many different ways.
Grilled, roasted or the classic, fried.
Supermarkets mainly sell frozen and breaded calamari,
rings cut from the body of the squid.
There's a code on the back of the packet denoting its origin.
As with most of these products, that's Spain.
Europe's largest fishing fleet is based in Galicia, in the northwest of Spain.
Spain also has the highest catch figures in Europe.
Fish factories line the harbour.
This one specialises in octopus products.
Junior manager Miguel Otero gives us a tour of the facilities.
Around 4,000 octopuses are processed here every day.
We classify the octopus by size here and then we cut it there.
Products for the entire European market are prepared here.
Individual arms or whole octopuses.
Fresh, chilled or frozen.
One destination, German supermarkets.
First, the cephalopods are cooked.
Then they're placed in another steel tank for cooling.
Here in Galicia, octopuses are caught in the traditional way using fish traps.
This company doesn't operate its own boats and buys from other companies.
It's a fifth generation family business.
CEO Pilar Otero-Gonzalez says her company isn't contributing to overfishing.
We buy mainly in Galicia, where we specialise in regional products.
We've also been awarded two quality certifications
issued by the regional government, for example.
These seals certify that our products are fished
and processed in Galicia using traditional methods.
Which means they come from sustainable sources.
But where do these huge quantities come from?
She herself says the octopus comes mainly from Galicia.
Is it being caught anywhere else?
If there aren't any here, we go to Africa.
Specifically Mauritania, where the octopus is fished with trawl nets on the seabed.
A controversial method that's not at all sustainable.
Things in the Mediterranean aren't looking good either.
In parts of Italy, the ecosystem has already been thrown off balance.
The effect of dwindling octopus stocks can be seen south of Venice,
where hundreds of shellfish fishers and farmers operate.
Denis Mantuan wants to show us the connection between shellfish and octopuses.
His business is difficult to locate in the sprawling lagoons.
Denis Mantuan makes his living from shellfish farming, primarily clams and oysters.
However, for the past two years, his livelihood has been under threat.
There's been an invasion of blue crabs throughout the northern Adriatic Sea,
with a devastating knock-on effect for the region's shellfish farmers.
The crabs are destroying the nets.
This year, they've destroyed all the nets and we can't fish anymore.
Our equipment is out of action.
Blue crabs are an invasive species in the Mediterranean Sea.
Octopuses eat them, but there aren't many left in the waters that feed the lagoons,
leaving the blue crabs with few natural enemies.
The blue crabs have left a trail of devastation evident in the shallow water.
Thousands of empty clam shells.
The crabs have eaten all the clams and now they're attacking the oysters too.
Oysters are more resilient because they have a harder shell,
but we're having problems with them now too.
How much?
The harvest has declined by 90%.
Now we're taking protective measures to see if anything can be done.
Mantuan and his colleagues are trying to protect their clam beds with nets.
All the fishers here are frustrated at the invasion of the voracious crabs.
They take the clam and break it because here the clam has a nerve that moves
and they cut the nerve and the clam opens.
For the octopus, this would be a veritable blue crab banquet.
Yes, but if the octopus has to eat all the crab, you must put more octopus than water
because there are a million, million, billion of these crabs.
Many colleagues have already given up.
Denise Mantuan has started catching blue crabs and set up traps everywhere.
He receives one euro per kilo from the state for the crabs.
This is part of an emergency aid program
implemented by the Italian government to combat the invasion.
Most of the crabs are disposed of, but Denise sells a few to restaurants.
I catch 400 kilos a day.
We can sell the heavier male crabs, but not always the females.
The young animals are destroyed, but this involves costs for everyone.
More octopuses would help the shellfish farmers, but how to get them here?
Is the planned introduction of octopuses a solution?
In Croatia, environmentalists are trying to break new ground.
Activists from the group Marimundi want to study the octopus and also breed it.
Their ship is heading for a colony of artificial shelters known as the village.
We're about 10 meters away from the village.
Now we'll wait and see how the boat settles.
This is what an artificial shelter looks like.
A plastic tube and a brick weight. That's it.
They really love these plastic tubes.
They're great for the octopus's suction cups and, of course, they provide excellent protection.
They're like artificial snail shells.
The plan for today is to place several of these shelters on the seabed.
Marimundi have been permitted to do this just off the island of Kirk.
Will the cephalopods like what they see and take up residence?
There are already some artificial shelters down here.
Baskets, stones and plastic tubes.
The village.
So far no octopuses have been spotted here.
Is a settlement even viable?
Then a surprise sighting.
An octopus sitting in a tube.
So our aim here is to see what kind of shelters they prefer.
And then to film and document the social life of the octopuses in this village community.
An initiative that gives cause for hope,
particularly in areas with few natural shelter possibilities.
Here in Croatia, Wolfgang Slani has further plans to ensure that octopuses are better protected by law.
We're working on establishing a marine protected area or MPA,
particularly around the seagrass beds.
And within this MPA, there'll also be no take zones where fishing is completely prohibited.
No gill nets, trawl nets, fish traps or spearfishing will be allowed.
Once all this is in place, the population within this area will recover.
And there'll be more animals for the fishers around it.
It's a start, but there's still much more to be done.
And unfortunately, regulations differ from country to country.
Time is of the essence.
Many species are already threatened with extinction.
The Vienna Zoo often acts as a kind of Noah's Ark for endangered species.
At the zoo's large aquarium, Professor Michael Kuba and his team have successfully
reared a rare cephalopod from the Gulf of Mexico, the octopus Maya.
Keeping and breeding this Mexican four-eyed octopus is considered challenging and few attempt it.
This octopus also loves eating crabs.
What's special about octopus Maya is that it's under severe threat from rising sea temperatures.
Octopus Maya can tolerate temperatures of around 27 degrees Celsius.
Above 27 degrees Celsius, that's too warm.
Temperatures that have already been reached in the Gulf of Mexico.
This is endangering reproduction.
At the zoo, the animals are kept alone or in pairs in a tank.
They don't get along in groups.
When the researcher lowers a waterproof camera into the tank,
an octopus immediately pounces on the foreign object and in less than 30 seconds
manages to open the underwater housing and completely remove the metal clamps and the lid.
All through physical force and suction power.
It does eventually give the camera back, but only when it's good and ready.
The scientists here equate the octopus's intelligence with that of a dog or cat.
What's exciting is that when we look at this guy,
we can see he's happy that we're here.
Everything's moving freely.
He's got what's called a muscular hydrostatic system
that allows him to move his arms wherever he wants.
And that's also one of the fascinating things about octopuses.
And if you have a large brain, it requires an enormous amount of energy.
It means you have to be able to think and plan.
That's how they survive.
The octopus has an unusual anatomy.
It has three hearts.
Two pump blue blood to the gills, or the third pumps blood to the rest of the body.
As well as a main brain, octopuses have networks of nerves in all eight arms,
each of which functions like a brain.
These enable the octopus to coordinate and control its arms independently.
The suckers are equipped with millions of sensory cells,
allowing the octopus to feel and taste its surroundings.
Miguel Cuba and his team regularly test the intelligence of their octopuses.
There's a crab in this jar.
Not a problem for this clever creature,
which takes just a few seconds to unscrew the lid.
These animals need better protection, say the Sea Shepherd activists.
In the Greek Aegean Sea,
the larger of the two ships sets out after the previous day's discovery.
The environmentalists are homing in on the illegal octopus traps.
Are the pots still there?
Or have the fishers cut the marker boy ropes?
It's a white one, huh?
Oh, I see one.
Yes, I saw it too.
We see a white jerricade in a distance of one mile.
And we're going now to pull up the traps.
We hope it is traps.
Our informers say that it's traps there.
On board are volunteers from all over the world.
The animal rights activists use a motorised winch to pull up the rope.
Every 10 metres, there's a plastic pot attached to it,
each one an octopus trap.
Many of them have creatures still sheltering inside them.
But here in these Greek coastal waters,
the season is officially closed.
All the pots should have been brought ashore.
We know that everybody leave them inside.
No one pull them up.
I hope with the years the situation will change
for the benefits of the octopus
and the local community who live from that.
Freeing an octopus is a joyful moment for the group.
Most of the animals are still very young
and shouldn't be caught at this stage in their lives.
They're very impressive creatures.
You've never really seen something like it because they're so special.
So it's always a special moment even now,
even though we've released a lot now.
So special.
But is this a hopeless battle?
What if we didn't have to catch them at all?
Could factory farming be a solution?
It's an idea being explored by a company in Spain,
octopus farming on an industrial scale.
Northern Spain is already home to countless fish farms,
but operating a commercial octopus farm in Gran Canaria
would be a world first.
The Grupo Nueva Pescanova has submitted proposals
to produce up to 3,000 tonnes of octopus there every year.
However, animal rights activists warn that
as solitary, light-sensitive and intelligent animals,
octopuses are unsuitable for intensive farming.
Following protests, the proposals have been shelved for now.
The company has declined to give an interview
and filming isn't allowed.
The Vienna Zoo runs an octopus rearing programme,
but here the animals are kept alone or in pairs
and under constant observation.
Professor Michael Kuba opposes the idea
of industrial octopus farming.
I'm not a fan of this approach,
because I believe that it's difficult
to keep a non-social animal in groups.
If I want to keep my octopus in a species-appropriate manner,
I have to keep it alone in a large aquarium.
That would be far too expensive
for creatures destined to be slaughtered.
Octopus factory farms would not be species-appropriate.
We need guidelines.
Whether we like it or not, it's required by law.
How should you slaughter these animals?
This discussion is only just getting started.
For researchers and animal conservationists,
what's normal for pigs, cattle and other mammals
in factory farming is inconceivable for octopuses.
Every single time I go to look into octopus farming,
I find that it's just wet chaos.
I mean, there's no other way to kind of explain it
from the standpoint of octopuses are carnivores, right?
So, and they're also cannibalistic,
so they can eat each other.
Warren Carlyle is making it his mission
to protect octopuses by raising global awareness,
initially via social media,
but now also through presentations and events in zoos,
schools and museums.
Octonation's goal is to establish ocean literacy.
And what I've seen that people that do
or want to protect the octopus,
they're able to receive a lot more support
because of octonation from the standpoint of like,
they understand the context of the octopus.
They understand how smart they are now.
As both hunters and prey,
octopuses play a crucial role
in the ecological balance of the oceans.
But they also carry economic weight
in the fishing industry.
Back to Greece.
60-year-old fisher Konstantinos Viamantakis,
who keeps thousands of octopus traps in the sea,
is keen to show that his is just a regular profession.
It's a tough job, but one with a long tradition.
He steers his boat towards the precise marker location
stored in his navigation system.
His crew pulls up the containers,
but for the first half an hour, they're all empty.
Konstantinos is frustrated.
Nothing at all. There are problems.
We'll have to find other ways to make a living.
But then, the first pots with octopuses inside them.
The sailors throw them in a drum full of iced water.
They're left to die and perish within an hour.
The plastic pots are then returned to the seabed
to a depth of 150 meters in international waters.
That there are still octopuses here despite overfishing,
Konstantinos has his own theory as to why.
Something strange happened with the octopuses.
We've been fishing them very intensively.
And in the past, we lost many of our pots.
The octopuses nested in these abandoned pots
and reproduced in them.
The population didn't grow,
but it also didn't decline at first either.
He doesn't blame himself for the noticeable decline,
but rather large industrial fishing companies from Turkey,
also operating in these international waters.
His haul for today, about 40 kilos,
worth around 400 euros for one day's work.
The catch goes to local restaurants and a factory.
Such a low yield leaves him feeling pessimistic.
One, two years, I don't know if we can ship.
Not to mention the environmentalists who seize the traps.
They are doing a big, big job.
But it's nothing, believe me.
They don't do nothing.
Only destroyed families.
They don't do nothing.
Okay.
I don't say nothing.
Such words leave the Sea Shepherd activists cold.
Despite the closed season,
they're finding and confiscating a large number of illegal octopus traps
in Greek coastal waters.
Over the course of four weeks,
the team collected more than 34,000
illegally placed plastic containers from the seabed.
It's not clear whom they belong to.
Organiser Valia is annoyed
that so few fishers care about the regulations.
We understand that they have to leave.
But the thing that they don't understand
is that they're leaving only for today.
There is a lot of fishermen here
that they see the future is not going well.
And they do the right thing.
They take them out in this period.
If you don't leave them,
they cannot recover.
And if they cannot recover, you cannot live also.
So if the octopus finish, what are they going to do?
How are they going to live?
So the answer, I have to leave, is not an answer.
Uncontrolled fishing is far from over.
It's thought there could be half a million illegal traps in the Aegean Sea.
The activists' work is more symbolic,
giving some octopuses their freedom
and encouraging a change in thinking.
When we humans start realising the key role
played by octopuses in the marine ecosystem,
these fascinating creatures may just stand a chance of survival.