Structure of the UK Government _ Public Law

History of Law
11 followers
#education #law #learning
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
A. Bradley, K. Ewing & C.J.S. Knight, Constitutional & Administrative Law (18th edn, Pearson, 2022).
R. Masterman & C. Murray, Constitutional & Administrative Law (Cambridge University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome back everybody to Public Law. In this lesson we're going to talk about the structure
of the UK's government. This is going to be an overview lesson for us to get a better understanding
of the various different institutions and processes that we're going to be exploring as
we carry on exploring and examining the UK's constitutional framework and UK constitutional
law more generally. So we're going to take a formal look at the structure of the UK government,
we're going to talk about the concept of the separation of powers, we're going to examine
parliament, we're going to examine parliament as a bicameral legislature and the principle of
bicameralism within the parliamentary process. We'll talk about the role of the crown and the
royal prerogative in brief detail as well before we talk about the executive, the government itself,
the prime minister, the role of the executive in the cabinet, and then finally we'll talk about
the broader executive which is sometimes described as the civil service. So the concept of the
separation of powers is something that we will explore as time goes on in more detail when we
look at the principles of the UK constitution but within the broader corpus of constitutional
theory this is a very liberal idea which derives again out of the enlightenment and a number of
different enlightenment thinkers and it's the idea and the concept that what really ought to be the
case is that power should be separated between the various different institutions of government
and the reason for this is to ensure that no one person or as more likely the case in some
circumstances no one institution becomes too powerful and as a result of which could
establish itself as a formal dictatorship or totalitarian state all of which would not be
great for the concept of the separation of powers and the concept of democracy. And so as a result
of this many constitutional frameworks around the world opt to establish this idea of a separation
of powers and power is usually in this context divided into three modern concepts within the
constitutional framework you often have a legislature an executive branch and a judicial
branch and the reason for this is so to ensure that these are the three kinds of authorities
the three kinds of powers that government has within a constitutional setting and so as a
result of which they are separate and should be divided amongst themselves such that no one
institution has the ability to have legislative executive and judicial power all at the same time.
So what do these things actually mean? Well when we talk about the legislature and legislative power
the concept of legislative power relates to the idea of passing law the idea of making law and
making legislation so in the UK's constitutional framework the remit of this is obviously done
through parliament. Parliament has the authority the sole authority in fact to make and pass law.
The executive branch is responsible for the enforcement of law and the executive branch
exists in the form of the UK's government the executive branch itself so the prime minister
government ministers etc etc etc etc as well as the civil service more broadly. The judiciary
the judiciary is of course situated and housed within the various judges and courts that exist
in the UK's constitutional setting the highest of which being of course the UK Supreme Court
there are various other courts of appeal that exist as well within this process and the judiciary is
responsible for the interpretation and the application of the law they apply the law to
facts they interpret legal precedent they interpret legislation that has been passed by parliament.
So the idea here is that the concept of the separation of powers instills the fact
that those who make law should not also be the people who enforce the law
and also interpret and apply the law they should be separate and in the UK's constitutional
framework we will see in future lessons time that the separation of powers is relatively limited
in the sense that we have a fusion of the legislature and the executive branches of government
and the judiciary is only separate to the extent to which that there has been a separation
formally with the establishment of the supreme court in 2009 but that there are also or that
there were also institutions and officers which branched all three of these different distinct
branches of government for example the role of the lord chancellor had significant authority
in both in all three in fact in the legislature the executive and the judiciary he was the head
of the judiciary he was a speaker in the house of lords and he also sat in the cabinet making
him a member of the executive branch of course this is a stark contrast and a stark violation if
you will of the concept of the separation of powers so this contrasts in fact to the formal
jurisdiction and the formal separation of powers which can be enshrined in various different
codified constitutions one notable example of this is of course the united states the united states
has a codified constitution which clearly sets out the powers of each of the branches of government
as well as this sets out the authority and power that one branch of government has over the other
branches of government this is known as a system of checks and balances the way here is that not
only is power separated across these three institutions and the institutions are clearly
separate but in addition to this the institutions can also have power over each other such that
no one authority can have too much power because it can be checked by the other two branches there
are various examples of how this works in the united states for example the the the legislature
the congress has the ability and the power to make law to make legislation but the president has the
power to veto that legislation and so that is representative of a check that the president has
over the congress over the legislature but then as a representation of the check that congress
has over the president if the president vetoes a piece of legislation then congress can actually
override that veto if they have enough votes and so you can see there just in one process the process
of passing law that there are multiple checks on both from both situations in terms of branches
of government in addition to that the supreme court in the united states has the power to check
the legislature as well because it has the power to strike down any law that is unconstitutional
so if congress passes a law that is unconstitutional then the supreme court can say no this law doesn't
doesn't exist this law is is wrong it's unconstitutional it is no longer enforced
so these are the various ways in which checks and balances can be enshrined within the us system
compare that then to the uk's system of separation of powers where we have a significant limitation
before the implementation of the of the constitutional reform act and the 2005
constitutional reform act before it was formally implemented i.e the supreme court was opened in
2009 all three branches of governments sat in parliament the highest judicial office was the
lord of appeal in ordinary which sat in the house of lords the the the law lords the the supreme
court obviously changes this formally separating those two institutions they go across the square
and they now sit in the in the old middlesex hall opposite parliament the aim here is of course to
show representatively a clear separation of powers some clear blue water between parliament the
legislature and the supreme court the judiciary but when it comes to the executive branch the
executive branch sits in the house of commons and is derived out of the legislature the government
is made up of members of parliament have they have constituencies who they represent they have a vote
in the passing of laws through parliament and so as a result of which you have not a separation
of powers between the legislature and the executive but you have a fusion of powers
now ultimately parliament does have the authority and one of the major roles of parliament within
the uk's constitutional framework is to essentially check and hold the government to account but they
do so from inside the house of commons from inside parliament itself so ultimately let's think about
the structure of parliament then parliament is what we describe as a bicameral legislature what
does this mean well it means that it is divided into two chambers you have the house of commons
and you have the house of lords similar to other other legislatures in in other parts of the world
again i refer to the united states the u.s legislature is of course congress at least
at the federal level and congress has two chambers as well it has the house of representatives
and then it has the senate you can have situations where there are there are three chambers something
known as a tricameral legislature i believe spain for example their legislative branch
and has a tricameral legislature or it might be italy or maybe both but there are multiple
different ways in which you can structure structure legislative branches you can have
some institutions that are unicameral which have just a single chamber in which law is passed
within this whole process the crown exists as a very interesting as a very interesting power and
a very interesting check because ultimately the united kingdoms constitution is a monarchical one
it is a constitutional monarchy what this means is we have monarchical authority we have a monarchy
which still plays a significant role in the administration of government but that the
monarchy is limited by the constitution and this is of course owing to the historical relationship
that the monarch has had with parliament as well as the sort of tumultuous years under the stewart
dynasty the the restoration of the monarchy the limited restoration of the monarchy with the
glorious revolution of 1688 but regardless of all of this the crown still plays a significant role
in the administration of government the exclusive powers which are incurred sorry conferred to the
crown in their authority as monarch are known as the royal prerogative we're going to get to the
royal prerogative in more detail when we examine the the uh the the sources of the uk constitution
but by constitutional convention what we see here is that the powers of the prerogative are actually
conferred not on to the monarch per se but to members of the executive who are then accountable
to parliament so we sort of see how on paper and in theory the monarch is still um severely uh
powerful in terms of their ability to to to do things in terms of their authority within the
constitutional framework this is done through the royal prerogative but by way of constitutional
convention the powers of the prerogative are conferred on to members of the executive
who are elected members of parliament but who are also accountable to parliament as well
and so this sort of plays a role as a as a democratic process and almost a self-regulating
democratic process by which the powers of the crown still technically exist but are limited by
the powers of parliament the monarch will still act on the advice of the prime minister and the
device by the government by way of convention they cannot act on any other advice they cannot
take any other advice outside of the advice of government and this is also a constitutional
convention and like i've said we will get to the details of the prerogative in future lessons time
in far more detail as we go on speaking of the government let's think about the executive branch
the executive branch of the uk government is also confusingly described as of the government
when we look at the house of commons for example we make a delineation between the government
and parliament and when we talk about the government in that context we're talking about
the executive branch we're talking about the prime minister we're talking about the various
other ministers of states the various other departments of state and the and if we're going
to go even further we're talking about the civil service and various members of the civil service
as well but obviously when we talk about the government as in the uk government we can also
be referring to just the whole picture the whole holistic understanding of judiciary the legislature
parliament uh number 10 downing street the prime minister everybody um but when we talk about the
executive branch we're talking about a specific institution within government that we also call
the government um the government has the responsibility for drafting and implementing
laws as well as drafting and implementing policy within the united kingdom ultimately the executive
is usually formed when a political party wins a majority of the seats in parliament
so whenever when a general election is called and a general election happens
there will be a party that often wins a majority owing to our first past the post electoral system
it's supposed to give us majorities but not always um ultimately we get a majority in parliament
and then the crown by convention invites the leader of that uh the leader of that political
party to form a government in their name this isn't always the case of course you have circumstances
where there is not a single party um within uh with a majority this is sometimes known as a
hung parliament the result of this is of course the fact that when you have multiple different
parties all vying for power and you don't just have a dual party system then it is more likely
that you're going to have hung parliaments and no single majority because given the fact that
in the united kingdom you have the conservative party and the labour party which sort of come out
as strikingly the two most popular parties but then you also have the scottish national party
the liberal democrats you have the greens and you have um in previous elections you have parties
such as uh ukip etc etc all of which vying for power and authority means that um that takes
votes away from the two larger parties meaning that it's less likely to get a single majority
compare this again to the united states where de facto they have a two-party system there are
other parties that are allowed to to run but they don't get a look in for the most part you are
either going to vote for the republicans or you're going to vote for the democrats so ultimately when
you have a hung parliament multiple parties may come together and form a government um collectively
this is sometimes known as a coalition government the last time we saw this was in 2010 between 2010
and 2015 when the conservative party under david cameron teamed up with the liberal democrats
under nick clegg to form a coalition government finally then we have the civil service now the
civil service is sort of described as the structural components of the executive branch
the reason for this of course is because when you talk about the implementation of policy
and the enforcement of law and all of these different complicated issues you need a very
big and vast network of individuals who will work to do the run the to do the running of the
the day-to-day implementation of government policy so um the civil service is responsible for
a great variety of different tasks from the very high level tasks such as contributing to the
drafting and the creation of legislation to some of the smaller tasks such as the paying of benefits
or the issuing of student loans that's a civil service task that those of you who are at university
studying law at the moment will will obviously be familiar with the issuance of student loans
and tuition fees and things like that the running of prisons as well as the issuing of driving
licenses everything from the drafting of legislation to the issuing of student loans to the
issuing of driving licenses are all things done under the remit of the executive branch i.e. under
the remit of the UK civil service
