BOSS TWEED- The Most Dangerous Politician You Never Learned About

Artifact Archives
9 followers
1 Video View·Mar 29, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
In 1871 a simple newspaper cartoon did what judges and politicians would not do.
It showed a bloated man in an expensive coat standing on piles of stolen tax money
and instantly the entire city knew the face. People who could not read a word understood the
truth in a single image. Their government had been taken over by a criminal empire
built on bribes, intimidation, violence, murder, and exercised absolute control.
At the center of it all was one figure who ruled New York with money, muscle, and fear.
The people already knew the name of Mob Boss before there was a mob. A man known simply as
Boss Tweed, one of the most corrupt and violent men in New York political history. Who was Boss
Tweed? How was he corrupt? What did he do? What was his fate? Hello I'm Colin Heaton,
former history professor, Army and Marine Corps veteran, and welcome to this episode of Forgotten
History. William McGeer Boss Tweed was born on April 3rd 1823 in New York City. His grandfather
had immigrated from Edinburgh, Scotland and Tweed grew up in a working-class family. He left school
at age 11 around 1834 to work alongside his father and later apprenticed as a saddler. In
the late 1830s and early 1840s he became a bookkeeper and invested in a brush making company.
On September 29th 1844 he married Mary Jane C. Skaden and the couple lived with her family for
the first two years of their marriage. In 1852 Tweed left the brush company and joined the family
business. Tweed had political ambitions so he became a member of the Odd Fellows, the Masons,
and became a volunteer fireman with Engine Company No. 12. At the time volunteer fire
companies competed for territory and many were partners with violent street gangs. Each company
had an ethnic flavor such as Irish, German or Italian with strong allegiances to their respective
immigrant communities. Often serious emergencies would be ignored and property burned because
the rival fire companies were too busy fighting each other. The city leaders had to fix the
problem so in 1848 State Assemblyman John J. Riley joined Tweed and others to create the
Volunteer America's Fire Company No. 6, also known as the Big Six. Their emblem was a Bengal tiger
which became the symbol for both Tweed and Tammany Hall. Tweed became known for his violence and
intimidation using an axe during these confrontations between fire departments fighting
for territorial control. He was seen as a reliable leader and was elected foreman of the Big Six.
However, many people deplored his overt violence as it drew attention and Chief Engineer Alfred
Carlson had Tweed removed from the company. But the fire companies, much like the police department,
were fertile recruiting grounds for political parties at the time and the Democratic politicians
who ran the Seventh Ward promoted Tweed as alderman in 1850 at just age 26. He was elected
to the United States House of Representatives in 1852 serving one term. Tweed was the kind of man
they wanted. Afterward he rose in prominence in the executive committee of New York City's
Democratic Party organization called Tammany Hall in 1856, starting his reign in city government,
politics, and business. Tweed himself was the central figure on the New York County Board of
Supervisors in 1858 when he became the head of Tammany Hall. Tweed joined the Forty Thieves,
the most corrupt politicians in the city's history. Tweed joined the New York County
Board of Supervisors which had 12 members, six appointed by the mayor and six being elected,
and Tweed fit right in. The board forced all businesses to pay a 15% tax to get contracts.
The board had six Democrats and six Republicans, but Tweed often paid off a Republican to sway the
board, such as when he bribed coal dealer Peter P. Voorhees who received $2,500 to be absent for a
critical vote along with Henry Smith. Tweed owned them and he managed to have his friends who owed
him appointed to other important city and county positions, which became known as the Tweed Ring.
By 1860, Tweed chaired Tammany Hall's general committee controlling the Democratic Party's
nominations and appointments to all positions. Tweed's corruption even extended to Judge George
C. Barnard who certified him as an attorney despite Tweed having no legal training. Tweed then opened
a law office on Duane Street and received large fees from various corporations for his legal
services. He ran for sheriff in 1861 and lost, but he became the chairman of the Democratic
general committee and was then chosen to be the head of Tammany's general committee in January
1863. The New York draft riots of 1863 displayed Tweed's moral bankruptcy as he did nothing to
stop the violence against black residents. Some Tammany Hall crooks fueled anti-black sentiment
to protect their Irish voter base. Afterward, Tweed helped pay for damages as a political gesture.
He was also elected to the New York State Senate in 1867 and he became involved with the New York
Mutuals, one of the first professional baseball teams bringing in thousands of dollars per home
game by increasing admission costs and gambling on the team. He started the practice of spring
training in 1869 by sending the team to New Orleans. In 1868, he became a state senator and
the Grand Satcham, principal leader of Tammany Hall, and he dominated the Democratic party in
both the city and the state, having his various candidates elected as mayor of New York City,
governor, and speaker of the state assembly. Tweed took control of the New York City government
after the election of 1869. His protege, former mayor John T. Hoffman, became governor, giving
Tweed enormous influence at both the city and state levels. With support from industrialist
Peter Cooper and the Union League Club, Tweed pushed through a plan that returned power to
city hall by dismissing the Republican state commissions. The move was secured with roughly
$600,000 in bribes paid. Tweed's law firm extorted money by disguising bribery and kickbacks as legal
fees. He then appointed himself deputy street commissioner, giving him direct control over
contractors and city project funding. Tweed also purchased the New York Printing Company,
which he turned into the city's official printer, and bought the Manufacturing Stationers Company
as well. Together, these businesses formed a monopoly that routinely overcharged the city
for goods and services, funneling public money straight into Tweed's pocket. Tweed accepted
almost $100,000 in bribes from the Erie Railroad in return for favors. He also became one of the
largest land owners of real estate in the city while creating the Tweed Ring with members holding
public office, such as George C. Bernard, the recorder of New York City, Peter B. Sweeney,
who was then New York County District Attorney, and Richard B. Connolly, the city comptroller,
along with several other members of the Tweed Ring. They systematically plundered New York
City of sums estimated at between $30 million and $200 million. One bill charged $41,000 for brooms,
another $179,000 for chairs, ridiculous even by Gilded Age standards. For example,
the construction costs of the New York County Courthouse, begun in 1861,
grew to nearly $13 million, about $360 million today. Tweed owned a marble quarry in Sheffield,
Massachusetts, providing the marble. More corruption followed. After the Tweed Charter
to reorganize the city's government was passed in 1870, four commissioners for the construction of
the New York County Courthouse were appointed. The commission never held a meeting, though each
commissioner received a 20% kickback from the bills for supplies. Friends received no-bid
contracts. A carpenter was paid $360,751, roughly $10 million today, for one month's labor in a
building with very little woodwork. A plasterer got $133,187, or about $3.6 million today,
for two days' work. Tweed and the ring then received kickbacks. The Brooklyn Bridge project
was a shady deal. State Senator Henry Cruz Murphy asked Tweed if New York's aldermen would approve
the proposal. Tweed's response was that $60,000 for the aldermen would close the deal, and
contractor William C. Kingsley delivered the cash in a carpet bag. Tweed and two others from Tammany
Hall also received over half the private stock of the bridge company, the charter of which specified
that only private stockholders had voting rights, so that even though the cities of Brooklyn and
Manhattan put up most of the money, they essentially had no control over the project.
Tweed and Tammany Hall also controlled elections and polling stations, often using thugs to
intimidate immigrant voters, ensuring voting fraud at elections was rampant. They bribed voters,
intimidated opponents, and padded ballots to keep power. He used repeat voting and fake
registrations, sometimes having the same man vote multiple times under different names.
Tweed became the third-largest landowner in New York City and a director of the Erie Railroad,
the 10th National Bank, the New York Printing Company, the owner of the Metropolitan Hotel,
etc. He was a major stockholder in iron mines and gas companies, a board member of the Harlem
Gas Light Company, the Third Avenue Railway Company, the Brooklyn Bridge Company, and the
president of the Guardians Savings Bank. He had it all. When Grand Sachem Isaac Fowler, who paid
$2,500 to buy off the Republican Voorhees on the Board of Supervisors, stole $150,000 in post
office receipts, United States Marshal Isaiah Renders, a Tweed crony, was sent to make the arrest,
but the fix was in. Renders allowed Fowler to escape to Mexico. After the New York City Charter
passed in 1870, Tweed created an audit board where he and his cronies could take control of the city
treasury. The Tweed ring then proceeded to milk the city through such devices as faked leases,
padded bills, false vouchers, unnecessary repairs, and overpriced goods and services bought from
suppliers controlled by the ring. In true fashion, Boss Tweed's relationship with black
New Yorkers was questionable, as he was supportive of them when it benefited him and then indifferent
or even hostile when it didn't. Boss Tweed never took a moral or legislative stance on child labor
because he profited from it, seeing he saw the problem not as a social issue but as an economic
and political resource. Children working in factory sweatshops, brickyards, and on the streets
as boot blacks and newsboys was common. Child labor reformers such as Charles Loring Brace
and Jacob Reese fought against it, but Tweed and his cronies prevented change that would harm
profits. A prime example was Tweed's public image-building schools, churches, hospitals,
supporting orphanages, and expanding public works projects to make him seem philanthropic,
but every project relied upon cheap child and immigrant labor with the contractors belonging
to Tammany Hall. Tweed understood that in 19th century New York the flood of Irish, Italian,
and German immigrants represented political power waiting to be organized. Newly arrived immigrants,
mostly poor, Catholic, and often illiterate, were met at the docks by Tammany agents.
These Tammany Hall men found them jobs, often in city departments or on public works projects,
helped them find housing in overcrowded tenements, provided food, coal, or money in emergencies,
and offered legal assistance or bailed them out if they got into trouble, which was easy because
Tweed controlled the police department. In exchange, immigrants voted Democratic, always for
Tammany candidates. It was transactional, loyalty for survival, and that system still exists in
Democrat cities today, much to their own detriment. Tweed also created a voter base when his ward
bosses offered work to children of poor families, but it served several purposes. Voter dependency,
profits, and enhancing his image were paramount. These exploited families became political
supporters, and Tweed's Tammany Hall was in serious conflict with the Children's Aid Society,
opposed to child labor. But Tweed's position on child labor was the same as his position on
everything else. If it made money and votes, he was for it. If it cost either, he was against it.
He did the same for blacks who often worked more cheaply than non-immigrant whites,
especially immigrant Irish who competed with blacks for low-wage jobs and were openly hostile to them.
Tweed benefited from it. The system worked both ways. It gave poor immigrants a political foothold
and a sense of belonging, but it also trapped them in a cycle of dependency on Tammany Hall,
much like being trapped in welfare today. Reformers called it benevolent corruption,
help wrapped in chains. But boss Tweed was on borrowed time. By 1871, Tweed had become the most
powerful man in New York, controlling city contracts, elections, and even state appointments.
But his arrogance drew attention. Reformers had long suspected massive graft, and the New York
Times finally got its hands on the city ledgers, showing the staggering overcharges on public works,
especially the New County Courthouse. Thomas Nast, the political cartoonist at Harper's Weekly,
attacked Tweed in his cartoons, creating a grotesque symbol of corruption. The bloated
man in fine clothes, surrounded by stolen gold. Tweed reportedly said, stop them damned pictures.
I don't care so much what the papers say about me. My constituents don't know how to read,
but they can't help seeing them damned pictures. Public outrage spread fast. Reformers and rival
politicians smelled blood. The Committee of Seventy, a group of opposition and mostly
Republican civic leaders and businessmen, organized to dismantle Tammany's control.
Although Tweed guarded Watson's estate in the last week before his death, and another ring member
tried to destroy the records, the replacement auditor Matthew O'Rourke, an associate of former
Sheriff James O'Brien, secured the books and turned them over to O'Brien. Tweed's image began
to fall apart after the riot in 1870, after eight people died when a crowd of Irish Catholic
laborers attacked the Irish Protestant parade. His public image decreased further after the
Orange Riot in the summer of 1871, which was even worse. Tammany Hall banned the parade of
Irish Protestants celebrating the Battle of the Boyne. After pressure was applied, Tweed gave it
the green light. The result was an even larger riot in which over 60 people were killed and more
than 150 injured. In 1871, Tweed was still at the height of his political power, but County Auditor
James Watson, working in Comptroller Dick Connolly's office, kept the ring's books, and he had been
approached by federal authorities. Watson died a week later after his head was mysteriously smashed
by a horse in a sleigh accident on January 24, 1871. An investigation of the bookkeeping saw a
commission of six businessmen appointed by Mayor A. Oakley Hall, a Tammany man, which included John
Jacob Astor III, banker Moses Taylor, and others who benefited from Tammany's actions, and they
found that the books had been faithfully kept, letting the air out of the effort to dethrone
Tweed. But more problems surfaced when County Sheriff James O'Brien had tried to blackmail
Tammany by threatening to expose the ring's embezzlement to the press, and when this failed,
he provided the evidence he had collected to the Times. Shortly afterward, County Auditor
Matthew J. R. Warke supplied the additional details to the Times, which was reportedly
offered five million dollars by Tweed and Tammany not to publish the evidence. The Times also
obtained the accounts of the recently deceased James Watson, the Tweed Ring's bookkeeper. The
paper published the records day after day, culminating in a four-page special supplement
on July 29 titled, Gigantic Frauds of the Ring Exposed. By August, Tweed had begun transferring
ownership of his real estate empire and other investments to his family members. Tweed was
arrested, charged, and released on one million dollars bail, and Tweed was still re-elected to
the State Senate in November of 1871 due to his personal popularity and influence. But in general,
Tammany Hall did not do well, and the members of the Tweed Ring began to flee the jurisdiction,
many going overseas. At that time, Tweed was re-arrested and charged with fraud, larceny,
and forgery. He resigned from his city position and was replaced as Tammany's leader. Once again,
he was released, this time on eight million dollars bail, but Tweed's supporters, such as Jay
Gould, felt the repercussions of his fall from power and his empire crumbled. His allies turned
on him, and his fortune evaporated in legal fees and restitution claims. Tweed's first trial in 1873
ended with a hung jury thanks to bribery and intimidation, but his second trial that same
year convicted him on 204 counts of corruption. He was sentenced to 12 years in prison, later
reduced to one year by a judge who was a Tammany man. After serving time, the city sued him in a
separate civil case for six million dollars, which he couldn't pay, so he was re-arrested and jailed
again. Then, in 1875, while under partial house arrest, Tweed escaped. He fled to Cuba, then to
Spain, using a fake passport. Ironically, he was recognized in Spain from a Thomas Nast cartoon,
was arrested, and then extradited back to New York. Back in U.S. custody, Tweed tried to bargain
for leniency by revealing how Tammany's corruption worked, but the state wanted no part of a deal.
He died in jail in 1878, at age 55, in the Ludlow Street Jail, reportedly sick and broken,
a former titan surrounded by the wreckage of his own empire.
Tweed's downfall didn't kill Tammany Hall, it just mutated. The machine rebuilt itself
under new bosses, continuing to dominate New York politics well into the 20th century.
Tweed became the cautionary legend, the face of unchecked political corruption,
and the reason Americans started demanding government reform and transparency laws.
Today, many see modern-day comparisons in Democrat cities and states to the Tammany
Hall days of Boss Tweed in New York, the master of graft and corruption.
Thank you for watching this episode of Forgotten History. If you liked what you saw,
please click like, share, and subscribe. And, if you would like to assist with the ever-increasing
cost of production, please consider becoming a channel member and joining our Patreon page.
Thanks for watching.
