Professor Ken Manning 3-22-2026

WBSM 1420 AM
58 followers
Mar 25, 2026
UMass Dartmouth Political Science Professor Ken Manning offers insight into the SAVE America Act and its prospects.
AI Generated·May contain errors
This is Bayard Winthrop, founder of American Giant. I started this company because I was fed up with
cheap clothes that didn't last and companies that shipped manufacturing overseas. We believed we
could still make incredible clothing right here in the U.S. with American cotton and American
workers earning real wages. That's what we stand for, making clothes that actually last. Get 20%
off your first order when you use code GIANT20 at American-Giant.com.
Good morning and welcome to Town Square Sunday. I'm your host, Jim Phillips.
The War in Iran and Congressional Debate headline our program this Sunday.
Debate over the so-called Save America Act, which could tie up Congress for days,
weeks, or even longer. Meantime, the Israeli-U.S. attacks on Iran, which is a sponsor of
terrorism around the world, Iran is of course, and the counterattacks by Iran,
have many Americans still asking questions. Why now? Why aren't our allies lining up to support
our efforts? No one seemed to be pushing for this conflict, yet here we are once again.
Well, joining me today is a professor with the UMass Dartmouth Political Science Department,
Professor Ken Manning. We haven't spoken in a while, Ken, but welcome back.
It's good to be with you, Jim.
So we'll get to the war in just a moment, but first, let's talk about the Save America Act,
which is short for the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act. My thought is that the bill,
which is now in the Senate, would significantly change how America votes. Mandating voters have a
government issue ID to vote, proving their citizenship when registering to vote.
It would also require states to report their voting rolls to the Department of Homeland
Security, and would vastly restrict mail-in voting as well. These are some real changes
that have proven successful, at least in most people's eyes. But I know there are doubters
about mail-in voting, and there have been since day one for that. What do you think about this
bill? Is some of it good, some of it not so good? What's your thoughts?
Well, I think you've hit some of the highlights of the proposed legislation well. I might quibble
with your contention that it's been proven well or good. A lot of the stuff that's being
proposed here hasn't been proposed at the national level before. The headlines have
talked a lot about the proof of citizenship to register to vote. This legislation would require
that, and that would mean presenting a passport or a birth certificate or other certain government
IDs. Under current law, individuals can register by mail. You can register when you get a driver's
license. You can register in some states online. All of that would be changed quite dramatically
by this. You would effectively have to register to vote in person because this law would require
the presentation of that documentation. Another provision that's been discussed is the
name change issue. The legislation requires that an individual register to vote and that the name
on the registration match their birth name. And if it didn't, then they'd have to provide
additional documentation. Well, since it's, of course, a custom in the United States for
women oftentimes to change their name if they're married, this would mean that a huge percentage
of the American population would find it much more difficult to register to vote because then
they'd have to present additional documentation, say a marriage certificate. Not only that, you
have to do this every time you register to vote, which means, of course, an individual moved,
changed their address, they'd have to go to a government office and present this additional
documentation. You mentioned the idea that the states would have to share certain voter
registration information with the federal government. This is unprecedented. Under the
Constitution, elections are administered by the state. Voter registration is conducted at the
state level, and this legislation requires a sharing of information that a lot of legal
scholars say is probably unconstitutional since states oversee elections. And as you pointed out,
it would pretty much end mail-in voting, except for very narrow, limited circumstances, a military
service overseas or an illness or disability, something along those lines. Effectively,
there'd be no more mail-in voting. This would essentially change the way elections are done
in some states. Oregon, for example, has 100% mail-in voting. And of course, even here in
Massachusetts, we now have no-excuse absentee voting by mail. It would be a truly revolutionary
piece of legislation were it to pass. That said, the political prospects, I think, of this
legislation are pretty dim. But yeah, it would be revolutionary in that way.
Yeah. For those looking at it from a certain point of view might say,
geez, the makers of this bill, the creators of this bill want to make it harder for people to
vote, not easier. No question about it. In fact, that is really the primary aim here,
is to make it much more difficult for individuals to vote. And the thinking behind it among the
supporters is that it would effectively make it harder for lower-education, lower-income voters
to participate in the process. And that, in general, would tend to benefit Republicans.
That's not entirely clear by political science, current political science research,
but I think that is the motivating factor here. Now, publicly, of course, the supporters of
legislation say that this is about making sure that there's no voter fraud and that our elections
are free of any shenanigans or illegalities. But experts who study this stuff really are quite
unanimous in finding that there's very, very little instances of voter fraud in the United States. So
these arguments that people are putting forward to support this legislation really don't hold
water. What's really motivating this is an effort to make it harder for people to vote.
President Trump says he's not going to sign any legislation until this bill is on his desk.
With all the machinations that could happen in debate, he may be waiting a while.
Yeah, well, come on. Donald Trump changes his views on every issue three times a day. I would
not put much credence in that. Now, that said, Donald Trump clearly does see this legislation
as something that he would like to see passed, that he supports vigorously. He's claimed repeatedly,
again baselessly, frankly, he's lied that there was massive fraud in the 2020 election. That's
simply not true. But there's no question that he's in support of this legislation. And Republicans
on Capitol Hill, though they have reservations about the provisions in this bill, they have
largely lined up behind Trump, lest, of course, they really face the ire of the President and,
of course, his supporters. And there's no question that he is the key driving force behind this bill.
Okay, so there's a lot of division. There are some Republicans who are,
they've largely lined up behind Trump, but there are some who are
not anxious to vote on this thing. And I think Democrats, I suppose some Democrats would switch
sides, but I don't think there's going to be many. So this is going to be debated, deadlocked,
I think, for quite some time. And it's going to take weeks, maybe months to get a version of this
bill through, if anything, you know, and they may get maybe nothing, it may just be
at some point, put on the side, put on the shelf. So what's your what's your thought about the
future of? I think that's the likely outcome. I don't think this bill ultimately passes Congress
and gets to the President's desk for a signature. The reality, of course, is that to get legislation,
significant legislation through the Senate, you typically need 60 votes to essentially break off
a threatened filibuster. And they, you know, in legislative language, they call that cloture.
Well, there's no way in cause green earth that at this point, Republicans hold 53 seats in the
Senate are going to get seven Democrats to flip over to their side and support this legislation,
getting 60 votes in order to advance it to the President's desk. So this bill's prospects are,
if not DOA, pretty much close to it, because as it's written now, there's not enough Democrats
that would support this. You might get the support of John Fetterman of Pennsylvania,
who is a Democrat who has been willing at times to back Trump on a number of provisions.
But, you know, saving Fetterman of Pennsylvania, this legislation is nowhere near getting that
many Democratic votes. And so without that support, it doesn't pass the Senate. Now,
Trump has called for eliminating the filibuster rules, changing the Senate debate rules, essentially,
to enable this legislation to pass with a simple majority of 51 votes. Now, of course,
Republicans do have 51 votes at this point. And technically, they'd only need 50 votes since the
Vice President breaks a tie. But there's no appetite by John Thune, the Republican leader
in the Senate, and other top Republicans in the Senate to change the rules in order to pass this
legislation. So while Trump would like to see that happen, fellow Republicans on Capitol Hill are not
on board with that. The Republicans might get a bare majority in the House to pass this bill,
but it doesn't get out of the Senate. It doesn't reach the President's desk.
And as a result, I think ultimately, this is all kind of a futile effort on the part of the Trump
administration. You're listening to Town Square Sunday. I'm Jim Phillips. My guest is Professor
Kenneth Manning of the Political Science Department at UMass Darpa. Let's talk about the Israeli-U.S.
conflict with Iran. Well, some of the statements coming from the Trump administration,
are you surprised by the volume of Iran's counterattacks on U.S. bases in that part
of the world? I am. I thought, you know, there wouldn't be a great deal of counterattacks,
but there has been. People have been killed. Our soldiers have been killed in these counterattacks.
What's your thought about that? Well, I think the Trump administration finds itself in a classic
example of what international relations experts call asymmetrical warfare. The United States,
of course, has an extraordinarily powerful military with amazing technology, and you name
it, we've got it. But all it takes is a few rocket launchers from a few hidden warehouses or buildings
in the backwoods of some sleepy town of Iran to launch some strikes on an oil refinery or a gas
processing reserve in Bahrain or Qatar to wreak havoc on the world economy. And that, in turn,
hurts the United States. So while the United States has the extraordinary strength on the
military side, it's that asymmetric ability of Iran to really hurt the United States on an economic
scale. And that doesn't take much. In fact, it takes shockingly little to wreck that kind of
havoc. And that's exactly, of course, what Iran has done here. The United States now finds itself
really in an awful situation. The Trump administration essentially escalates this battle,
and that, of course, causes all sorts of problems, or it backs down and essentially recognizes that
Iran, for all its limitations and weaknesses, is going to live and fight another day.
And so I think the Trump administration now finds itself in really a no-win situation
in this conflict. In the meantime, of course, we all know gasoline prices have spiked because
oil prices have spiked. There was an attack on a gas processing facility. Now natural gas prices
could be going up. The economic costs of this war will far exceed, at this point, any military or
strategic gains. And in that way, I think you have to look at this conflict, at least where things
stand right now, as a failure. Did the speed at which this conflict starts surprise you?
Last year, we were told Iran's nuclear capabilities had been all but wiped out after
bombing runs in June, I think it was. Now we have to drop more missiles and bombs because
of their nuclear threat, or wanting to take out their leadership. Which one is it?
Trump said, and there's a direct quote, that their nuclear capability had been obliterated.
Well, if the nuclear capability had been obliterated last year, then there was no
need for the United States to launch these attacks this year. And the Trump administration
has put forward a number of reasons for this, right? Iran's historic responsibility for support
for terrorism, as you previously correctly noted. Look, the reality is, well, I shouldn't say
did in Venezuela, where it essentially toppled a dictator rather successfully.
I think the Trump administration felt like they could do something similar in Iran,
that with some airstrikes, obviously with the support of Israel, the United States would be
able to take out the Iranian leadership. This would lead to some type of revolution,
and you'd be done with this odious regime. But Iran is not Venezuela, as we all know,
and as international experts know. And the situation, of course, is entirely different.
And so I think the Trump administration, which was urged on by Benjamin Netanyahu,
the Israeli prime minister, who's wanted to launch attacks against Iran for years,
I think the Trump administration thought that attacking Iran would be easy. It would be another
Venezuela-like operation that would ultimately be successful. And as it turns out, of course,
that's not the case. The president invited allies to join in the effort to protect shipping lanes
in the Strait of Hormuz. That hasn't happened. Iranian-sponsored terrorism has certainly caused
havoc in many allied nations. So why haven't they stepped forward to help the U.S. in this cause?
Well, their position is, of course, that we didn't start this war, we didn't want this war,
and that there's other ways to go about dealing with Iran, and containment is the primary goal.
There, of course, had been a nuclear program deal reached during the Obama administration that
involved IAEA, International Atomic Agency, inspectors on the ground in Iran to assure
that Iran didn't develop enough nuclear fuel to be a threat. All of that was thrown out the
window by Trump. So from the European perspective, there was a clear, viable, diplomatic way
to contain and essentially tie the hands of Iran. And the Trump administration didn't want
to do that. They threw that out the window. And now Trump is turning to these folks,
by the way, the same people that he's been disparaging for months, if not years,
the same Europeans that he was insulting on the global stage six months ago, and now he's
turning to these folks for help. Well, it doesn't take rock science to figure out that if you
criticize your neighbor last month, he's not going to come running to help you the next month if
you're asking for assistance. And that's the situation that Trump finds himself in.
Essentially, he's taken a go-it-alone posture toward American foreign policy.
And now these same folks are saying, well, you're going to go it alone, buddy,
because that's what you asked for, and we didn't start this war. This is up to you.
It's amazing he didn't reach out to the allies before they started it and say,
like George H.W. Bush did. Right. And even George W. Bush sought support from the
international community before he launched any strike. Not only did Trump not even seek support,
he didn't give folks a heads up. He didn't even place a phone call with Macron in France or
Starmer in the UK and give them a notification that the United States was going to be launching
a military strike soon. And so, you know, allies, the nature of international relations work two
ways. And if you want allies when you need them, you got to be an ally when you don't. And the
Trump administration simply shown that they're not willing to do that and play that game of diplomacy.
And now they're paying the price for it. My guest has been Professor Ken Manning
of the UMass Dartmouth Political Science Department. Ken, thanks for giving us some time today.
Good to meet with you. Okay. Up next, a new addition
to a South Coast performing arts venue that when Town Square Sunday continues.
After winter stillness, spring invites you to open things up. With Pura's spring collection,
you can explore scents inspired by place. Sunlit terraces, blooming gardens, open air
drifting through familiar rooms. It's not about starting over. It's about layering in something
new. A small sensory shift that refreshes your space and how it feels to be in it.
Open the door to spring this season and shop now at pura.com.
