Couple Therapy: Eleanor and Chidi from THE GOOD PLACE

Love Arcana - Where Love Finds Depth.
4 followers
6 Video Views·Mar 27, 2026
Licensed therapist Jonathan Decker and filmmaker Alan Seawright are taking a look at accepting influence and how healthy relationships form with Eleanor and Chidi from The Good Place. They talk about what the characters think they want but actually need. That’s growth, baby!
AI Generated·May contain errors
This episode is brought to you by Squarespace, your all-in-one platform to build a beautiful
website and grow your online brand.
He's also incredibly patient and kind and surprisingly jacked.
And oh, fork, I'm in love with Chidi.
She has fallen for all of these things that she never thought that she would have wanted,
but it turns out is what she needs.
I know you have trouble saying how you feel.
I love you too.
They grow into the best versions of themselves just by knowing each other.
I think it applies to relationships too.
You gotta try.
Eleanor has grown into an ethical, moral, compassionate, selfless person.
And Chidi has grown into somebody who knows what he wants, makes a decision, and decides
to live now in the moment.
The reason it's a great love story isn't the romance of it.
Hello and welcome to Cinema Therapy.
I'm Jonathan Decker, licensed therapist who loves movies and TV shows.
This is...
Derek.
Maximum Derek.
So we're going to be talking about The Good Place, one of both of our favorite shows ever.
Derek.
We are so in sync.
We're finishing each other's...
It is one of the greatest TV shows ever made for television.
So we're going to be doing couples therapy on Eleanor and Chidi.
Well, a lot of you request in the comments, can we have more examples of healthy relationships?
What does it look like?
What does a healthy relationship look like?
And the biggest factor for Eleanor and Chidi is accepting influence.
So she is learning from him how to be a good person, how to be a moral, ethical person.
But he's learning from her how to, like, ever make a decision.
So let's do this thing.
One thing real quick, before you start.
What's this about?
Well, here's what I realized.
It's not just that helping me is a full-time job that you feel you have to do.
The real problem is that the more you help me, the greater the chances that I can stay
here.
And me staying here means you'll never get a real soulmate.
I'm basically a utilitarian nightmare.
Every ounce of my happiness leads to a ton of pain for you.
So every time the simple fact of my existence starts to bum you out, I want you to hold
this up.
At which point, I will leave you alone for as long as you need.
I know we'll never be soulmates, but we're friends.
Now get in this boat and read some poetry.
I need to get one of those printed up for every one of my co-workers.
So he always wanted to sit in a boat and read French poetry.
And then his anxiety kicks in.
I've never actually done this before.
This is a theoretical fantasy.
How do you row a boat?
Now she's wrong, spoiler alert, when she says we'll never be soulmates.
We're just friends.
But that's what I love about this.
They're not a couple yet.
This is just people being decent to each other.
And this is a big step for Eleanor, who has been, by her own admission, a selfish Arizona
dirtbag her entire existence to do something thoughtful for him.
And this is an example of her accepting influence because this is how he has treated her.
But for the first time, she's reciprocating and it means the world to him until he's panicked
in the middle of the lake.
Have you seen our Cinematherapy website?
I have, and it was so easy to build and customize using Squarespace.
We found a template that worked really well for us as a starting point.
From one of the many professionally designed templates that you can choose from.
And then it was so easy to customize with intuitive drag-and-drop editing and awesome
visual designs.
Way easier than fixing an afterlife system that dooms humanity to eternal damnation.
Squarespace Domains also makes it easy for you to find the best site name for your business
all at one inclusive price.
No hidden fees or add-ons required.
And every Squarespace Domain also comes with advanced privacy and security tools included.
Squarespace SEO tools will help you get discovered fast, faster than a train to the medium place.
Nothing's faster than Janet, but it is fast.
Every website is optimized to be indexed with an auto-generated sitemap, meta-descriptions,
and more.
So your site will show up on more search engines.
And reach more of your ideal audience or your customers.
So whether you need to build a website for your new frozen yogurt shop.
Or sell more of your custom mailman calendars.
Or for your courses about how to become an afterlife architect who doesn't punt dogs
into space.
Squarespace will work for you.
And you won't have to spend months building a website.
Check out squarespace.com for a free trial.
And when you're ready to launch, go to squarespace.com slash cinematherapy and use code cinematherapy
to save 10% off your first website or domain.
Squarespace.
It's a good place.
Ooh.
I like that.
No.
You're wrong.
There are way more things I hate about Chidi than like about him.
Like what?
His stupid Clark Kent glasses.
His extensive turtleneck collection.
Oh, and he loves ethics so much.
He once talked about John Rawls for two hours.
I timed it.
And he only stopped because he saw me timing him.
Granted, he laughed and kind of made fun of himself.
It was a nice moment.
But still, he always twitches his eyebrows when he says absolutism, and he tilts his
head whenever I say anything ignorant.
But he never makes fun of me, which is nice.
He's also incredibly patient and kind and surprisingly jacked.
And oh, fork, I'm in love with Chidi.
Let's take a little break.
I know this is awkward, but as your advocate, and I hope friend, I think you should tell
Would a hug make you feel better?
No, I don't think that it would.
Too late, you're getting one.
Thanks, Bombajohn.
That does make me feel better.
So when it comes to love and romance, it's very similar to what you talk about in filmmaking.
There's what the character wants, and there's what the character needs.
And a lot of the best stories, not just romantic stories, but stories period, are about a character
pursuing what they want, only to discover that what they need is something else.
Correct.
And it is important to be self-aware enough and recognize what you want, what you're looking
for in a romantic partner.
Eleanor's never really done that beyond, I mean, you notice when she talks about him
being jacked is when she realizes that she's in love with him.
Yeah, no, this woman does not know the meaning of the word introspection.
But because her whole life, being jacked was basically her criteria for what she was interested
in.
But as she's rattling off all of these tiny little details that she's noticed about Chidi,
she's paid so much attention to him.
She has fallen for all of these things that she never thought that she would have wanted,
but it turns out it's what she needs.
And so there's a balance.
There's a balance between kind of building out a list in your brain of what you want
and being so married to that list that you miss out on opportunities that could be wonderful
for you if you're too rigid.
And in Eleanor's case, back to the theme of accepting influence, accepting Chidi's influence
in her life, he's a guy on earth she never would have given the time of day to, would
have thought that he's a huge nerd, and in fact, initially only start spending time with
him here out of sheer self-interest and self-preservation.
You need to be a better version of yourself, okay?
And I do too.
And our only hope right now is this kind, selfless, amazing nerd.
But as she's learning to be selfless, as she's learning to be kind and compassionate, she
realizes I'm really drawn to that.
And one of the things I love about The Good Place is it's an example of not just a good
man, but like a good person, that being the most attractive thing, which is different
as we've talked about before from being a nice guy, right?
Nice guy is performative.
I do these things with the expectation that you will then desire me, sleep with me, fall
in love with me.
That's transactional.
That gives me all the ick as a therapist and as a human being.
Okay.
Sit down, baby.
I dated many annoying guys, okay?
They would call me all times of the day just to talk or ask me if I'd taken cash out of
their wallets.
Stupid stuff.
And when I stopped having fun with them, I'd leave.
Usually wouldn't even call or anything.
I'd just bounce.
Gotta go spend that money you stole.
Point is, you are way more of a buzzkill than any of those dudes.
Okay.
Thanks for this conversation.
But somehow, I never want to leave you.
Eleanor is giving Mr. Darcy vibes right here.
Because I love you.
I think.
No, I'm pretty sure.
Yeah.
I love you.
That's embarrassing.
I feel so itchy.
Sorry.
Don't say anything.
I just needed to get that off my chest.
Okay.
I'm gonna go.
Catch you later, silly Billy.
Love has made me a nerd.
Bye.
You know what I mean about Mr. Darcy, though, right?
Yeah, of course.
I've fought against my better judgment, the inferiority of your birth, my rank and circumstance,
all these things, and I'm willing to put them aside and ask you to end my agony.
I don't understand.
I love you.
I do have a bit of therapy to do here for Eleanor.
Ooh, go.
All right.
I do love straightforward confessions of affection and feelings and just gauging where the other
person is at.
Sure.
I think that's so mature and adult and preferable to beating around the bush or dragging it
out or just trying different tricks to see what the other person is thinking and feeling.
I love the straightforward approach.
However, if you're going to say, I love you, and then go, hmm, I think so.
Yeah, I love you.
Actually, probably sort that out.
Before you say it?
Yeah.
Because once it's out there, there's no take backs.
Yeah.
Right?
I mean, she tries.
I will point you back to the lack of introspection.
Yeah.
No, exactly.
I know, but that's why she-
It's perfect for the character.
That's why she needs therapy.
So here, I did something.
Oh, here we go.
Um, about what happened earlier.
To my point.
I've been kind of all over the place today.
An hour ago, I thought Jean-Yu was my soulmate.
And the fact that that kind of made sense means you and I could never be meant for each
other.
Plus, Jean-Yu's married to Janet now.
Okay.
What?
I don't really love you, but I think more in a best friend, afterlife, savior kind of
way.
I'm not so much hot for teacher as I am eternally grateful for semi-cute, surprisingly ripped
teacher.
If you can't objectify somebody while complimenting them, what's even the point?
Okay, so listen-
Did I do that right?
No, but that's fine.
I'm just going to pretend it never happened.
Side note, I might legit be into Tahani, but that's for another time.
I want to clarify, you don't have to know beyond a shadow of a doubt, I'm in love with
this person and I want to be with them to have a, hey, I've caught feelings, where are
you at conversation.
Sure.
The issue is not that she brought up to Chidi that she had feelings for him.
The issue is that she said, I love you.
Right.
And then goes, do I?
Hmm, yes, I do.
And later came back and said, uh, I've been all over the map and I do love you, but more
in a friend, but you're surprisingly jacked.
The fact is she hasn't sorted through it and that's okay.
She can include Chidi in that conversation.
But what she needs to stop doing is making absolute statements.
Only a Sith deals in absolutes.
Don't make me kill you.
You know, she's like absolutely here.
Absolutely here.
You know, this is all part of her growth.
Of course, like this is the journey of the characters.
I love the idea of having that conversation and just saying, hey, you're attractive.
You're wonderful.
I am starting to catch feelings.
I'm wanting to know whether I should nurture those or just let them wither out so we can
just have a friendship.
Where are you at?
Yeah.
And it's really not that big a deal.
No, but I love you.
And I think we're soulmates.
That is a big deal.
You got to earn that.
Whoa, that's a dope prank.
Got to give it up.
Something wrong?
No.
Yep.
I've been keeping a secret from you.
About you.
What is it?
The thing is, it's not even harming you.
And if I tell you, I feel like it might harm you.
So ethically speaking, I don't think I have to tell you.
Yeah, well, forget all that.
This is freaking me out.
I'm losing my mind.
So just tell me.
And you don't need to respond because I know you have trouble saying how you feel.
I love you too.
I've never been that certain about anything.
I once even tried to rent socks.
How did I say that that easily?
I mean, I get how you said it.
I'm a total smoke show.
How did I say it so easily?
Look, I don't want to talk about this, but after everything that's happened today, I think we gotta.
So let's just get it all out there.
Yeah, I guess.
Do you, I don't know.
Do you have any feelings like that for me again now?
I'm sorry, but I don't think I do.
Sorry.
Why are you sorry?
Because I'm relieved.
Because I don't either.
So, all good.
I mean, I feel incredibly close to you.
No, no, no.
Dude, dude, dude.
You don't need to explain yourself.
We are on the same page.
Okay?
Good.
Hey, guys.
Sorry.
I know it's late.
Can I talk to Eleanor for a second?
Actually, we're chatting about something right now.
No, it's cool.
We were wrapping it up.
Good talk, bro.
What is emotional constipation?
Well, it frequently manifests as avoidance.
Oh.
Here's the thing that I would advise just people in general.
We need to destigmatize romance.
We need to destigmatize attraction, sexual, romantic, whatever, and just recognize that
feelings happen.
Doesn't mean you have to act on them.
Doesn't mean that, like, it has to be awkward if one person feels a certain way or doesn't
There's nothing magical about it.
Because they can fade as well.
If they're not fed, they can fade.
And you can be like, okay, like, I can shift gears.
I need some time to shift gears.
But, like, I love honest, straightforward conversation.
But we're so scared to do it.
We don't trust the other person.
We don't trust ourselves.
And listen, I get it.
Because honestly, sometimes just in, like, out there in the social wild, it will go poorly.
This is one of the reasons why therapy exists.
Because in a therapy situation, I could be like, look, one thing that you have for certain is love and respect for each other.
For one of you, it's romantic and sexual.
There's a component of it.
And for the other, that's not there.
But you can focus on and build on this commonality.
Our friends are going to the bad place.
And us choosing to go with them won't lessen their suffering.
So morally, we're allowed to go.
But let's forget about the ethics for a second.
After everything that's happened, don't we deserve to be together?
And happy for once?
Judge?
Have you made your decision?
Yeah.
We're not going to the good place.
I mean, that was never actually an option.
But for the sake of your test, we're not going.
What do you mean?
Well, I was 99% sure that going was the wrong move.
But since our whole relationship has been me being sure of something and Chidi explaining why I was wrong,
I owed it to him to quadruple check.
The capper came when I realized that ain't Chidi.
The Chidi I know wouldn't argue that he should be rewarded while his friends got punished.
And he would never forget about ethics for a second.
I don't know who this Joker is, but it's not Chidi and Agonyé.
Wait, but what about the...
Well done, Eleanor.
You can take a seat and wait for the others.
And can I have that medallion back? Because it's actually a coaster for my sodas.
There's this great recurring bit where Eleanor is way smarter than she seems.
Yes.
And it comes down to she's actually brilliantly intelligent, but on Earth she was just very lazy.
Uh-huh.
And so I love that she's always the first to figure out when they're being tricked,
when they're being duped, when there's something going on.
This is the bad place.
And in this case, just how much she has grown to know and love Chidi.
This is one of the reasons why, to me, this is a real love story instead of just a
we're attracted to each other and it feels nice to be together.
Is she knows him in and out.
Yeah.
She has observed him. She has groaned because of his influence.
And what I love about it is, the accepting influence piece,
is that she hasn't grown into a better person to win him.
Because what happens if she doesn't win him?
Then the whole house of cards just falls.
She's grown into a better person because she admires him and wants to be like him.
That is beautiful.
That is the type of growth that comes from a healthy relationship of
this person inspires me to be better in ways that I might not have if I hadn't met them.
I'm not sure what I would do if one more insane thing happened.
Hi Jason, I love you.
Oh, word?
Word.
I've been avoiding telling you.
My excuse was that I needed time to evaluate my complex feelings,
but that was just a rationalization.
This might be the last time I ever get to talk to you.
So there it is.
I love you and I hereby stop avoiding this topic
and rationalizing it by saying the situation is complicated.
Or that my brain is grinding like a fork in a garbage disposal.
Alright, whatever.
You're not really a part of this, Judy.
Guess what?
I think I love you too, girl.
I'm not a girl.
I'm also not just a Janet anymore.
I don't know what I am.
Hey man, what's up?
Hot diggity dog.
Oh no!
You said right after we kissed we'll always be hot diggity dog.
Whatever.
It was an honest reaction.
I stand by it.
I think Kristen Bell's one of the most talented performers in the world, honestly.
She's so damn good.
In this show that has the all-time GOAT,
the best sitcom performer of all time, Ted Danson,
Kristen Bell's right there.
Yeah.
She's so damn good.
Speaking of Ted Danson,
we do a long villain therapy deep dive into Michael,
Ted Danson's character from The Good Place,
that is exclusively available on our Patreon.
If you go over to patreon.com slash cinematherapy,
you can sign up, you can support the show,
and you can watch us talk about how much we love Ted Danson for an hour.
This is a beautiful example of the show does therapy for the characters,
with the characters, and we get to watch it unfold.
As Chidi is listening to Janet and Jason, he's hearing his own story.
He's seeing his own situation.
This is one of the truisms of therapy,
is you observe and comment on as a therapist,
and help with somebody else's situation, and it helps you.
This is true of every therapist, whether they tell you or not.
Something that happens in therapy that helps you, helps them.
Something that you say, a breakthrough that you have.
This is, I don't know why we even get paid.
Chidi, I'm scared.
I know.
What am I supposed to be doing right now?
You have to watch the show to understand what's going on,
but this is the two of them.
Glasses is Chidi.
Memories. You need to remember who you are.
You're Eleanor Shellstrop from Phoenix, Arizona.
Your favorite meal is shrimp scampi.
You listed your emergency contact as Britney Spears
as a long shot way of meeting her,
and your favorite movie is that clip of John Travolta saying Adele Dazeem.
You flew halfway around the world because you wanted to be a better person,
and it was very brave.
You're sharp, and you're strong.
You make fun of me a lot.
You once called me a human snooze button,
but you also showed up in my classroom when I was drowning in despair and canned chili,
and you basically saved my life.
You have very high self-esteem and a very low tolerance for men who wear sandals,
and your worst nightmare is someone saying something nice about you to your face,
but too bad, because I need to say it,
because you deserve it,
because...
because Chidi...
Nice work, bud.
Did you mean everything you said,
or did you just say it because the world was ending?
I really want to play this cool,
but I'm afraid that I'm going to ruin it if I try to be sexy.
I already ruined it.
Saying the word sexy is not sexy.
Eleanor is losing a grip on who she is.
Chidi helps her come back to herself.
How? By doing what Eleanor did several clips ago
when she's listing all the things that she's noticed about Chidi and that she's in love with him.
That what real love is isn't just affection or attraction or attachment.
It's truly seeing someone,
accepting them,
and embracing them.
And that's true whether it's romantic love,
familial love, friendship love.
So for example, being vulnerable here,
I feel truly seen 100%,
like you know exactly who this is.
Loved, accepted, embraced, welcomed.
Yeah.
And hopefully you feel the same coming from me.
Eh.
Depends on the day.
That's what real love is.
And that is what brings her back.
It's not that he's in love with her.
It's that who she is, is deserving and worthy of love.
And he's willing to give it to her and he wants to give it to her.
Yeah.
And as much as I've talked numerous times about how not cinematic this show is,
it deploys it strategically when it needs to.
Yeah.
You know obviously it was a big effect sequence and there's stuff going on,
but there's also a lot of cinematic language going on, right?
Yeah.
The camera is rotating around them at times when it needs to,
to show, hey, perspectives are changing.
It's not just hard cuts all the time.
There's all of the stuff happening and then when we need to feel the impact
of the emotional stuff happening,
we cut wide and get still for the world to reform
and then to pop back into their real selves.
It's okay.
Cry as long as you want.
I'm going to.
Because my tears taste like the nacho cheese from my favorite movie theater.
It's a really weird incentive to keep crying.
Relationships are stupid.
You're scared you're never going to have a real one
and then when you do, you're scared it's going to go away.
Here's an idea.
What if we don't worry about whatever comes next?
There's a quote I like by Tolstoy.
There is only one time that is important.
Now.
It is the only time when we have any power.
I know that quote.
An unverified Tyra Banks account posted that meme on Instagram.
Well now I hate it.
There is another quote.
First spoken by a very wise, very attractive, occasionally very sweaty philosopher.
You gotta try.
Now she was talking about making the world a better place,
but I think it applies to relationships too.
I've got an idea of something we could try.
Great.
What?
Oh.
Wait, I think I know.
I don't want to assume.
What if we both write down what we think you mean?
What if we didn't?
I chose this clip because the whole theme of this episode is accepting influence.
He is quoting her back to her.
And by the way, when he says, what if we just don't worry?
That is the most un-Cheaty-like thing that Cheaty could possibly say.
Yeah, he has accepted so much influence from Eleanor to get to that point in his life.
It's insane.
So Eleanor has grown into an ethical, moral, compassionate, selfless person.
And Cheaty has grown into somebody who knows what he wants,
makes a decision, and decides to live now in the moment.
And is assertive about it.
And he's assertive about it.
Why?
Because of her.
Right.
He learned it from her.
Cheaty and Agony, just casually making choices.
I never thought I'd live to see it.
Every time you see me get a stomachache, imagine I'm thinking of you.
So, all the time?
Exactly.
Sorry to interrupt.
I wanted to give both of you something before we do this.
Think of it as a going away present.
We could explain everything that's going on, but we won't.
Just watch the show.
You must watch this show.
Please watch this show.
I mentioned earlier, you know, how he gave her total acceptance.
He saw her exactly for who she is.
And that it was okay to be that.
But she did that for him as well.
Which is why, as completely opposite as these two are,
what they share is this ability just to give each other space to be.
And I love that the montage of their greatest moments includes fights.
Yeah.
And reconciliation.
And incredible dancing.
I don't normally cry at movies.
Can't relate.
But that one was pretty good.
That girl was hot.
The guy was too.
Well, I do normally cry in movies.
And I cried in that one.
Yeah.
It's a great show.
It's a great love story.
And the reason it's a great love story isn't the romance of it.
The romance of it is just what...
It's the leaven that elevates it into this beautiful romantic love story.
But if these two never got together, it would still be a beautiful love story.
Because they grow into the best versions of themselves.
Just by knowing each other.
And giving each other unconditional love and acceptance.
And with unconditional love and acceptance,
sometimes we think, well, people won't grow.
Because where's the motivation if we're not judging them
and telling them how much they're a screw-up?
Turns out, when you give someone unconditional love and acceptance,
they grow naturally.
Because growth is how we feel happier.
Yeah.
Growth is how we manage life better.
Growth is how we connect and form healthy bonds more.
We grow when we feel safe, respected, and loved.
And as much as these two have insane romantic chemistry on screen,
they also have best friend energy.
I mean, blech, what am I saying?
This house is stupid, and you're lame, and I hate you.
I love you too.
And this is a love story that you can duplicate
by giving that to the people that you meet.
No notes.
So until next time...
I know, I'm a legit snack.
I mean, I get why you're into me.
I'm an absolute smoke show.
And watch The Good Place.
Yeah, just watch The Good Place.
On loop.
It's the show that's playing on a loop in heaven.
Shout-out and thank you to our patrons
who get extended director's cuts,
commercial-free of our episodes a day early.
Folks like...
Frenzy.
Oscar Carlson.
Kara Gibbons.
EM.
And Frederick.
Frederick.
Yeah, thank you. We love you.
We do love you.
