On March 19, 2026, the Rhode Island House Committee on Corporations met to discuss a package of bills introduced by House Minority Leader Michael W. Chippendale (R District 40 - Coventry, Foster, Glocester) aimed at addressing the state's rising electricity costs.
Rep. Chippendale introduced three bills (2026-H 7176, 2026-H 7177, and 2026-H 7174) proposing rollbacks or modifications to state-mandated green energy programs, such as the Renewable Energy Growth Program and net metering. He argued that these mandates and surcharges function as hidden taxes that disproportionately burden middle- and lower-income ratepayers.
The hearing features debate and questions from committee members representing diverse perspectives on how to balance ambitious climate goals with economic realities and consumer affordability.
House Bill No. 7176 BY Chippendale, Newberry, Nardone, Place, Santucci, Brien, Quattrocchi, Hopkins, Fascia ENTITLED, AN ACT RELATING TO PUBLIC UTILITIES AND CARRIERS -- THE RENEWABLE ENERGY GROWTH PROGRAM (Repeals the renewable energy growth program.) {LC3575/1} » http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/BillText/BillText26/HouseText26/H7176.pdf
House Bill No. 7177 BY Chippendale, Brien, Newberry, Nardone, Place, Santucci, Quattrocchi, Hopkins, Fascia ENTITLED, AN ACT RELATING TO PUBLIC UTILITIES AND CARRIERS -- MORATORIUM ON NET METERING, LONG-TERM CONTRACTS AND SUBSIDIES FOR HEAT PUMPS (Places a moratorium on net metering contracts, subsidies for heat pumps and long-term contracts for the purchasing of solar or wind energy.) {LC3582/1} » http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/BillText/BillText26/HouseText26/H7177.pdf
House Bill No. 7174 BY Paplauskas, Fascia, Hopkins, Santucci, Place, Roberts, Newberry, Brien, Quattrocchi, Nardone ENTITLED, AN ACT RELATING TO PUBLIC UTILITIES AND CARRIERS -- DUTIES OF UTILITIES AND CARRIERS (Repeals the energy efficiency charge.) {LC3600/1} » http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/BillText/BillText26/HouseText26/H7174.pdf
Thank you Chairman and colleagues on House Corporations. I will be introducing House Bills 7176, 7177, and Rep. Papawoskis' Bill 7174.
They are part of the package of bills that you all on this committee are familiar with by now because we've been doing them for several years.
I'll address them all at once because these bills all address the same core issue, which is the cost of electricity in Rhode Island.
Right now Rhode Islanders are effectively paying for 15.5 months of electricity every year, and that's not an exaggeration.
The average monthly electric bill is about $163, and roughly 37 of that, or nearly 23%, comes from state-mandated green energy programs.
That's about $450 per year per household, driven not by federal policy but by decisions made here in Rhode Island.
These costs come from a series of programs established in statute, the Renewable Energy Growth Program, net metering and distribution subsidies,
the energy efficiency charge, renewable energy certificate requirements, offshore wind contracts, and participation in regional greenhouse gas emissions.
Each of these may have been created with good intentions, but each and every legislator in this building is hearing from our constituents
that they cannot afford to pay their increasing electricity bills with good intentions.
It requires money, and a lot of it.
In fact, it's such an issue in the lives of our constituents that our governor, who largely decides his policy petitions by public polling,
has adopted many of these very same proposals that Republicans have been introducing for years,
and that tells us that people across the state are in line with these proposals.
These fees and surcharges collectively are driving costs far above market rates
and contributing to the fact that Rhode Island's electricity prices are among the highest in the country,
in some cases 60 to 100% above the national average, and these costs are not evenly distributed.
Many Rhode Islanders cannot install solar, cannot access rebates, and cannot participate in these programs
because they themselves are financially struggling just to pay their bills, yet they are still required to subsidize them.
In many cases, this functions as a regressive cost shift, placing a heavier burden on those least able to afford it.
7177 is about making that reality clear.
It identifies the true drivers of our energy costs and establishes that this is a state policy issue, not a federal one.
7176 takes a direct step by repealing the Renewable Energy Growth Program,
which requires ratepayers to fund long-term contracts at roughly 32 to 34 cents per kilowatt hour compared to the wholesale rates of 5 to 7 cents.
That is a 4 to 6 times markup written into statute and passed directly onto ratepayers.
7174 addresses another major driver, the energy efficiency charge.
This is mandatory surcharge on every electric bill and gas bill, accounting for roughly 4 to 5% of a household's total cost.
It functions as a hidden tax, pooling money from all ratepayers and redistributing it to rebate programs.
But in practice, renters and lower-income households cannot take advantage of these benefits.
While wealthier homeowners and businesses capture the majority of the subsidies,
it also guarantees demand for certain products and services, effectively subsidizing specific industries.
If these investments truly paid for themselves, households and businesses would already have every incentive to make them without a mandate.
Importantly, even recent proposals to reduce this charge were opposed by legislative leadership and stakeholder groups,
underscoring how difficult it has become to unwind these cost drivers once they're in place.
Together, these three bills do two things.
They bring transparency to what is actually driving energy costs in Rhode Island,
and they begin the process of relieving ratepayers from some of the most expensive mandates in the country.
This is not about ending renewable energy efficiency.
It's about restoring balance that was once their inspector.
It's ensuring that we pursue these goals in a way that's affordable, accountable,
and most importantly, fair to every single Rhode Islander, even those who are poor.
At a time when the cost of living is one of the top concerns of our state, we do have an obligation to act.
And I know, good colleagues, that you do receive calls and concerns from your constituents.
I do as well.
We're at a point now where we are an outlier.
We've seen that repeatedly.
We are very ambitious.
This is something that was stated when a lot of these goals were put into place.
And there's nothing wrong with ambition, but it has to be tempered by reality.
And the reality is that the technology that we are counting on the most is not quite where it needs to be
in order to power our state.
But what we are doing, as I stated in my testimony, is driving up this cost for every single Rhode Island ratepayer,
even if they're not able to pay for it.
Thank you very much.
Testimony. Are there any questions from the sponsor?
Chairman Serpa.
Thank you, Chairman.
I know that there are many bills on the agenda tonight, but I wanted to make a comment.
I mean, I believe it's a good idea.
I happen to agree with you.
I think it's a good idea.
Listen, Rhode Island Energy is a for-profit business.
It's not a charity that exists for the benefit of distributing energy at little or no cost.
We can't control everything, really.
They have products to buy.
They have gas lines to pay for.
They have employees to pay for.
But I don't believe that it has to be an all or nothing, and I think maybe your next bill addresses that.
Why can't we just slow down some of the ambitious accomplishments that we put for a deadline by, what is it, 2028?
My memory is...
And 2050 is the big...
It doesn't have to be all or nothing.
I don't believe that.
But I believe we can slow it down a whole lot, especially in this time when everything is so expensive.
Why don't we control what we can and not pontificate about what should be?
There's a lot of things in this world that should be, but they just can't.
And you can't forget what the world or even this state is going to be like by 2015.
So, I kind of agree with the concept of your bill, but I think you're talking more or less all or nothing.
So, what these bills are seeking to do, and in my remarks I did point it out, this isn't...
We're not proposing to throw away renewable energy.
If you recall, during the Act on Climate, or the Climate Act of 2021,
the Republicans stood strongly on the point that what that bill did, in addition to putting in place those ambitious goals,
was to remove existing guardrails that were in the statute, which are exactly what you stated, rather,
where if things got out of control cost-wise, they would be pulled back into line.
Without those guardrails, those cost considerations are gone.
And we've seen that. We've seen that since 2021.
Our energy prices have gone up and up and up.
And without those guardrails, nothing is stopping.
So, this isn't an all or nothing.
This is a, let's let off on the throttle.
Let's give some relief to the ratepayers who have died.
And as things become more realistic, because frankly, the Act on Climate was not built out of realism.
It was not. It was built in a perfect world, and we all know we don't have a perfect world.
So, those realities, those things that are restricting the ability for renewable energy to be as ubiquitous as it's supposed to be,
have to be factored in, because those realities are what we're dealing with right now.
And unfortunately, what our constituents are dealing with every single day, you know,
and it's not something that everyone can deal with.
It's students and everyone.
And you're right, Lita.
We all have some Democrat and Republican constituents in our constituency,
and the majority are suffering.
They're hard-working, mostly, which is true for my district,
mostly middle-class people who go to work every day with very high-paying bills,
and it doesn't look like the price of gas will be going down any time soon.
God only knows where the prices of that are going to.
But you're absolutely right.
Let's roll some back.
Let's look at the most costly ones, the costliest ones.
Let's roll a couple of them back, implement maybe one or two of the least ambitious ones,
see how it plays out in consideration with the economy of the time in one year, two years,
and take it from there.
And I know this isn't a popular opinion.
I know that.
But I think it's a practical opinion.
Like I say, control what you can.
One of my favorite saints, and I don't mean to preach, is Saint Francis of Assisi.
Control, learn to control what you can.
Don't worry about what may or should be.
And we can control this.
So that's enough from me.
I think you have great ideas.
But you can't ask me to sign them.
I'm sorry to do it.
I'm sorry.
Thank you.
Representative Pinkham.
Thank you, Representative.
You mentioned that the intention of the bill is to not repeal the Renewable Energy Program,
but specifically House Bill 7176, which does repeal the Renewable Energy Program.
Look, regardless of where you stand on how much renewable energy is contributing to the high cost of utilities,
et cetera, et cetera, I disagree fundamentally, right?
I'm not for renewable energy.
We have a lot of projects and we're imposing a lot of bills.
But don't you think with what's happening with the foreign trade, now with the war on Iran,
those factors are contributing to the high cost of utilities more than us focusing on the Renewable Energy Program?
And then now, you know, with a federal government that obviously isn't really pro-environment
or pro-green or pro-renewable energy, we need to have some sort of counter to that countermeasure
from the state government to the federal government.
So what I see here with all these bills is just an attack on the Renewable Energy Program
and on us trying to protect the environment, right?
So the Commission Program, I just wanted you to see if you could clarify.
Certainly, absolutely.
I'm happy to.
First of all, what I stated remains true.
This is not a repeal of Renewable Energy.
Is this a repeal of the Renewable Energy Program?
That's what one of the bills seeks to do, certainly.
But it doesn't touch all the other things.
And before you came into the legislature in 2021 when the Act on Climate was passed,
had you listened to the debates around that, you'd be a little bit more familiar with what we're doing here.
I do have to applaud you, though, for somehow working in the war in Iraq or Iran, rather, in Ukraine,
because I know that those are some of your favorite political issues.
But they have absolutely nothing to do with this.
They predated this.
And so I think that's a non-sequitur to begin with.
So, no, you're absolutely wrong on that.
But thank you for that.
Any other questions from the committee?
Yes.
Thank you, Leader.
7175, the bill essentially requires Rhode Island.
7175?
I got 7176, 7177, and 7174.
Okay.
I don't have a question for that one.
Energy efficiency.
So you just talked about you're not doing a full repeal of all renewables and these bills.
But you also stated that you're trying to bring down prices for consumers.
We also all know factually that gas prices are very volatile depending on global events.
What do you have to say about if we are getting rid of energy efficiencies
or potentially new developments in energy production, what would happen?
Well, I think, again, these bills are strictly looking at electricity,
looking at the electric rates in Rhode Island.
So to the extent that external global factors have an impact on energy prices, as we know,
which is typically oil and gas, I don't think it pertains to these bills.
These bills, while we still generate a great amount of our electricity with natural gas in Rhode Island,
and we will, as every state does, on an ongoing basis, that's outside of our control, no matter what.
But what is inside of our control are these costly mandates,
which aren't really moving the needle as far as the affordability of the state of Rhode Island.
I don't feel technology is there.
It's clear that technology is not there.
But what it is doing is really driving up these costs.
As I stated in my testimony, one of these bills required the purchase of energy that was sold at 32-something cents an hour,
which you could get at the wholesale rate if the mandate wasn't there, but five to seven cents an hour.
So it's roughly four to five times as much money.
That's just to procure that in that bill.
But 23 percent of our bills come out of these mandates, of our electricity bills come out of these mandates.
So trying to peel these back, and, again, we see this now.
A Democratic governor is proposing these very same things in his budget.
And, again, it's a governor who runs every decision he makes with a wet finger in the wind and a pole.
So if he's doing it, we know the people of Rhode Island, in a majority proportion, support these initiatives as well,
because they frankly cannot afford to pay limits.
So just a direct question.
Do you support renewable programs?
Sure.
Absolutely.
Okay.
And you support Rhode Island's efforts to produce cleaner energy?
Do I support us doing it?
Yes.
Do I support the way that it's prescribed in the Act on Climate 2021?
Absolutely not.
So other than the bill that somehow is on my iPad here that's not in play right now,
is there anything that you're proposing other than repealing?
Because I don't see anything that you're proposing that would change our policy.
You're just abstracting policy.
Yeah.
I'm pulling it back.
We're choking the motor because, as I stated, when we passed the Act on Climate,
a lot of the areas that the Act addressed had guardrails built into them.
They were there when the statute was initially passed, where it said if we're on this procurement path or in this program,
if we're over cost or if the cost becomes too high, we would revert back to the less costly alternative.
That was taken out completely of all of our statutes during the Act.
So now where there was a barrier that would stop the runaway train keeping it out of the tracks, it's not there anymore.
So we've seen that runaway.
We've seen that.
And I know you know this.
For the past five years in our bills, our constituents are constantly calling out,
why is there a 43 percent increase?
Why is there a 16 percent increase?
Why is this?
And that's because of this.
This is why.
And that's what we're seeking to address.
Yeah.
Well, we might have a different opinion on that.
But I would argue that all people that serve up here have the interests of their consumers in mind.
And I don't think it's politically motivated.
I think it's in the interests of our community.
So thank you for your bills.
Thank you.