ARTH 4037 Lorenzo Ghiberti

Lorenzo Ghiberti
1 follower
2 Video Views·Mar 25, 2026
Art Historian Dr. Vida Hull
ETSU Online Programs - http://www.etsu.edu/online
Italian Renaissance
AI Generated·May contain errors
I'm going to talk about Lorenzo Ghiberti.
And we're going to start talking about the competition
reliefs for the north doors of the Baptistery of Florence.
And this took place 1400 to 1401 is when the competition
reliefs were created.
You remember that the Baptistery of Florence
has three separate entrances.
And in the 1330s, Andrea Pisano created the south doors
of the Baptistery, which had the life of John the Baptist.
And now, in the early years of the 15th century,
the Opera del Duomo, the works of the cathedral,
the committee of the works of the cathedral,
decided that they were going to commission an artist
to create the north doors of the Baptistery of Florence.
At that time, they thought that they
would use the Old Testament as the subject.
They later changed their minds and used the New Testament.
So today, the north doors are the subject
is the New Testament.
But the competition reliefs are the sacrifice of Isaac.
And we're going to talk about those.
There were seven finalists, all Tuscan artists.
And they submitted sample reliefs.
Now, presumably, the committee must
have told them what figures to put it in,
as well as the subject.
Because we have not only the three main figures
of Abraham, Isaac, and the angel,
but we also have sort of the extras of two servants
and a donkey in both.
And so here, we're looking at two of the competition reliefs.
They're the only two that survived.
So presumably, the other five were melted down
and the bronze reused for the doors.
Bronze is very expensive.
So it's interesting.
It's curious that these were saved.
And of course, we don't know why.
Guess?
Maybe there was a controversy about which one
would be chosen, and they saved them
to serve as evidence if anybody objected to the choice.
But that's just a guess.
So here, we are looking at Brunelleschi's and Ghiberti's
competition reliefs, both showing the sacrifice of Isaac.
The story of Abraham and Isaac is a very important subject
in Christianity.
Because it is believed that the sacrifice of Isaac
is a prefiguration or a type for the crucifixion of Christ.
The story of Abraham is that he believed
that God wanted him to sacrifice his son, Isaac.
And in obedience to God, even though he didn't want to do it,
he took his son out and is prepared to sacrifice him,
to send his son to God, in a sense,
in order to prove that God is before all for him.
Well, God doesn't want him to sacrifice his son.
And so he sends an angel, which stops the sacrifice.
And then there is a sheep, a ram,
caught in the bushes next to the place
where they were going to sacrifice Isaac.
And they use that as the animal sacrifice instead.
This, of course, is a time when there were animal sacrifices.
And evidently, it's a transition from human sacrifice
to animal sacrifice.
And here, we're going to look a little closer.
And you can see the difference here in the figure of Isaac,
particularly.
The Ghiberti's Isaac is this classical, nude, beautiful,
ideal figure, very gracefully posed
in this kind of curving arc, which you'll
see throughout Ghiberti's work.
If I have to have one word to describe Ghiberti's style,
it's going to be either elegant or graceful.
Brunelleschi, however, is using something
that's much more emotive or powerful, even violent,
because we have the figure of Isaac twisted around
with these very angular forms as though he
is resisting the knife.
And his father, Abraham, is just about to plunge the knife
into his throat when his arm is grabbed by the angel.
As you can see with Ghiberti, there's
still a little bit of time, a little bit of space.
It's not the imminent death.
So first, we're going to look right here at Brunelleschi's
sacrifice of Isaac.
And you can see that it is, as we said,
very dramatic, very violent.
And it has what we call planar recession.
If you look at the figures of the servants and the donkey,
you'll notice the donkey is parallel to the picture plane.
The servants seem to be about the only figures that actually
bend toward us, that they are shown
with some kind of foreshortening.
But there seems to be a plane right there
that's at the bottom of the hillside.
And then there's another plane at the top.
Then you can see that the angel is coming in
parallel to the picture plane.
The ram's body is parallel to the picture plane.
Isaac's body is turned.
So it is parallel to the picture plane.
And Abraham, likewise, is in profile,
parallel to the picture plane.
So this is a way of showing death.
It makes perfect sense for Brunelleschi, too.
Because Brunelleschi, as an architect,
used planes, his walls.
We often talk about Brunelleschi's architecture
as being very planar.
We know that Brunelleschi was trained as a silversmith.
But look at his technique.
What you have is the flat background shape,
the quadrilobe shape, this Gothic shape
that we saw Andrea Pisano using as well.
But all of the figures are cast separately.
And they're solid bronze, riveted to the back.
So if you were to look at the back, you'd have a flat back.
So these are all separate pieces that he has cast.
Keep that in mind.
Because it is relevant to the choice of artist.
Now, there are, in both of these works of art,
references to classical antiquity.
What Brunelleschi has done is show you the servants
as though they're examining their feet,
maybe taking a thorn out of their foot or pebbles.
And this is a kind of direct quotation
of a very famous classical statue that is in Rome,
the Spidario, or the boy taking a thorn from his foot.
And here we see the other figure,
a slightly different pose, but also leaning over.
Ghiberti's figures are very different.
The words that come to mind are things
like elegant and graceful.
And you'll notice, for example, that Abraham
is a curving form, a graceful arc.
And Isaac leans back in the same direction, another arc.
And also notice the swinging folds of the drapery.
Even the hillside that here separates the servants
from what is going on with Abraham and Isaac
is a kind of rocky curve.
You'll notice that there's a fair amount
of foreshortening of parts of figures coming toward us.
The angel, instead of coming sideways,
parallel to the picture of the plane,
comes out as though he's coming from heaven
and the back is being penetrated and he's coming forward.
The elbow of Abraham is raised up
and it's projecting out toward us.
It's showing in foreshortening.
And even the head of the donkey, there's
not quite as much emphasis on the donkey.
The donkey has been covered up with the standing servant,
whom we see from the back.
But the donkey's head, instead of being
parallel to the picture plane, curves out toward us.
So this gives a more spatial feeling to it.
One thing you should also notice is the edge of Abraham's drapery.
It seems to flutter in the breeze
and forms a very graceful pattern.
Your book calls Isaac the first truly ideal Renaissance nude.
And think how small that is.
It's a very small little piece, but it
shows the classical ideal proportions.
It's a graceful figure.
It's a beautiful figure.
And what you're seeing here with Renaissance art
and with Ghiberti is elements of naturalism
combined with idealism.
And that is really a Renaissance way of representing forms.
Now, Ghiberti's technique was finer than Brunelleschi's.
It seems surprising.
Ghiberti was trained as a painter.
However, his stepfather was a bronze caster.
So perhaps that's where he learned his bronze casting.
And if you could look at the back of the relief,
it would not be one flat piece.
It would be indented.
It would be hollowed out where the figures are.
This was cast as one piece, except for the solid figure
of Isaac, which was added to it.
And the figures are hollowed out.
Now, this has several advantages.
It means that the relief itself is less weighty.
It literally weighs less.
It's stronger, because it's not all these little pieces.
And it uses less bronze.
Now, think about that for a minute.
Bronze is very expensive.
So if you're using less bronze, you're
being more efficient with it, then that's a finer technique.
And it also would be something that the committee
would look for.
It will cost less to create these doors, which
are going to be very expensive.
In fact, if you start with the reliefs,
it's what, 24, 25 years that Ghiberti
spends on the first doors from 1401 to 1425.
These are on the north doors, his first doors.
And then when he gets to the second set of doors
that he does, the east doors, that's
27 years, from 1425 to 1452.
So this is going to cost a lot.
It's going to spend a lot of time and a lot of material.
So if they can save some money with the bronze, why not?
So I suspect that those two factors, the grace
of the figures and the more efficient use of bronze,
may have been some of the factors
that the committee considered.
Interestingly enough, it was not the committee
of the Opera del Duomo that actually made the decision.
They passed it on to the oldest and one
of the most powerful guilds, which
was the Guild of the Wool Merchants,
the refiners of imported wool.
And they had a committee, and they made the final decision.
So here we see the north doors of the Baptistery of Florence.
You can see you have seven rows and four columns
on the two doors, and it shows you
what the different subjects are.
By and large, there are New Testament scenes
with four evangelists and four doctors of the church.
And you can see that it's bronze,
and then some of the figures are picked out
with gold leaf and gilding.
They're picked out with gold leaf, which
is what gilded bronze means.
Now let's look at some of the figures.
Here you have the Annunciation.
We're kind of looking up at it, and then a picture
that's been taken so you can see it straight across.
And some of the characteristics that we saw before,
these curving, graceful forms that sort of form an arc.
And in this case, the angel seems
to be just about to land.
His feet are not quite on the ground.
He's got little clouds at his feet,
and he's lying in this wonderful curving shape.
And then his arm makes another curving form
toward the Virgin Mary.
She sort of leans back in a form that answers that.
And they're almost sort of sweeping together.
There is a suggestion of architecture.
She stands in a doorway.
And of course, that would have been
one of the characteristic names of Mary,
that she herself is, in a sense, the portal into paradise,
because it is in her womb that the savior of the world
will come into being, will be born.
We also see the small figure of God the Father in half length
and foreshortened, once again, coming in,
sending the dove of the Holy Spirit.
And you remember at the Annunciation, Mary says,
the angel Gabriel tells her that she will bear a child.
And she says, how can this be?
I know no man.
And he says, the Holy Spirit will overshadow you.
And so the dove is the symbol of the Holy Spirit.
And here you see it's just a slightly different point
of view when we're looking at the figure of Mary.
Her hand is raised.
One of the first things the angel says is, fear not.
So there's that slight, let's say, apprehension, perhaps,
in the figure.
Giberti creates a beautiful flagellation.
And I know that sounds contradictory,
because the flagellation would be horrible.
It's when Christ is whipped.
And yet, look at this.
You have the horizontal entablature going at the top
and these slender, classicizing columns behind the figures
as a kind of vertical rhythm.
Christ in the center is this beautiful figure,
a classical, ideal figure, with the weight on one foot,
the other foot flexed, and once again, that curving form
that you see.
And then the tormentors who are scourging him
form kind of reverse parentheses,
if you will, on either side in a very symmetrical composition.
But each form individually is very graceful.
The same thing can be said of the crucifixion.
And in this case, as you can see,
the figures of John and Mary seated
at the base of the cross just fit perfectly
into the curving shapes of the lobes,
of the quattro lobe, of the design.
And then you see this curving form again with the angels
and then with Christ's arms as they hang from the cross.
So the main figure is being silhouetted there.
You have this detail of Mary, and of course,
very melancholy, resting her head on her hand.
You'll notice that in this case, though, the gold
has pretty much flaked away.
And yes, you'll see different photographs.
Sometimes they'll have been newly restored
with new gold placed on them, and they'll
be all nice and shiny.
And other times, the gold is flaking away.
And sometimes in photographs, it almost
looks like a negative because the high points is
where the gold would flake off first.
And so they are actually the darker shape
the bronze is showing through.
Although Ghiberti spent most of his life
working on the two sets of doors for the Baptistery of Florence,
he also managed to do a few other sculptures.
And he did several sculptures for Orsanmichele.
Now, I need to explain what that is.
As you can see, this is a very large three-story building.
And it is in Florence.
And it was originally a grain market and grain storage.
The lower level is converted into a church.
And so you see there's great arches
with all of the tracery in them.
And your doorways are completely filled
in with kind of blind arcades.
Those were originally open to the market.
And so when they made it into a church,
they filled it in with this beautiful cutwork,
this beautiful tracery.
And as you see against the walls, there are niches.
And in each of these niches was to be
placed a statue of a saint.
The guilds of Florence were each assigned a niche
to decorate with the statue of saints,
often their patron saint.
When you're passing by, this is more
the feeling of when you're passing by,
you may not be looking up and seeing
how tall that building is.
It's where they would store the grain up above.
But you can get the idea of where
you might be in relationship to these niches.
So the niches would be just above your head.
Tall person, perhaps, at the bottom of the head.
And the niche would be, as you can see,
kind of similar to the place.
Some of these figures are in bronze,
which is more expensive.
Some of them are in marble.
From about 1405 to 1417, Ghiberti
created this statue in bronze of John the Baptist,
San Giovanni Battista in Italian.
Giovanni Battista was the patron saint of Florence.
So this was a very important statue.
It was also a very large statue, over 8 feet high,
8 feet 4 inches.
And so it was an important technological feat
to create a statue of this size.
Nothing like that had been done in this area for centuries.
So it certainly shows his casting skills.
This was commissioned by the Arte di Colomalla.
Now, arte means guild.
And this is the guild of the wool merchants,
or the refiners of imported wool.
And that was the oldest and one of the wealthiest guilds
in Florence.
So they could afford bronze, and they
had the honor of commissioning the patron saint of Florence.
You'll remember the swinging folds
of the draperies of Abraham and the servant in the competition
relief.
Well, here, he's also using these swinging folds.
They've been called sword blade draperies by de Wald,
who's one of the art historians.
And he relates them to the kind of draperies
that you might find in the international Gothic style,
the late Gothic style.
And so I brought in a Gothic virgin and child.
I think it's Bohemian.
I've been trying to look it up.
But I found that it had some of these swinging draperies
as well, so you can see.
And they fall in graceful, rhythmic patterns.
The drapery is usually pulled up to one hip
and then falls in a kind of cascade
on both of these figures.
I don't mean that Ghiberti ever saw
that particular virgin and child.
It was just one that I had a picture of that I thought
particularly showed this kind of swinging drapery.
Now, it's often said that this shows that Ghiberti is still
creating art that has Gothic elements about it.
He creates this unity through linear rhythms
and these exaggerated curves and shapes.
Hart disagrees with de Waal.
He says that Ghiberti's linearity
has been called Gothic, but nothing
could be further from the truth, that these types of draperies
were derived from classical antiquity.
It could be both.
He could look at some classical drapery
and find swinging folds.
And he could also look at Gothic art
and see the rhythmic possibilities.
So I'd say that the sword blade drapery probably
is closer to some kinds of Gothic art.
But the graceful rhythms of both Gothic and classical art
could have attracted Ghiberti.
And that as he develops it, he moves
more toward a more classical understanding
of rhythmic draperies.
And just think of things like the annunciation
of the north doors of the baptistry
that we just saw with this beautiful figure of the Madonna.
And then we will soon be seeing such figures
as the Jacob relief in the east doors of the baptistry,
in which there's a lot less pattern,
but still graceful movement to the drapery.
We want to look at some of the details.
John the Baptist, as a saint with gaunt cheeks and very high
cheekbones, he, of course, went out into the desert,
lived on locusts and wild honey, and wore a goatskin.
And so you see just a little bit of the goatskin
peeking through his mantle.
And there's just these beautiful, graceful arabesques
of curving forms, which are very similar to the curls
of the beard.
And so he has this beautiful linearity in his sculpture.
And I thought this was interesting.
I found this picture on the web.
And it shows you what this looks like from below.
And the drapery seems to swing up.
And the proportions seem to correct themselves.
And you'll find that this is true of the Renaissance
artists.
You're going to find this with Nanni di Bronco,
with Donatello, that they design their sculpture for the place.
And a lot of times people come along,
and they get up on scaffolding, and they take photographs
straight on.
But that's not how this was going to be viewed.
So because we've been seeing it from below,
he may seem to have a longer torso.
But that's corrected when we look up
at the image in the niches.
Ghiberti was also commissioned to create the bronze
statue of St. Matthew.
And this was done for the Arte di Cambio,
which is the banker's guild.
If you go to Florence, or anywhere in Italy,
you will see signs up saying Cambio,
which is where you can go and change your money.
Well, the banker's guild wanted to do some one-upmanship,
I suppose, on the wool merchant's guild.
And so they specified that their statue
had to be at least as high, as tall, as large
as the John the Baptist statue.
And it's actually about 6 inches taller.
It's 8 foot 10 inches.
And it was done succeeding years, in 1419 to 23.
As you can see, there's still elegance,
but there's increased realism.
You have the swinging folds, but they're not as sword blade.
They're not as abstracted.
And you have the weight on one leg.
You can see one leg is flexed, and it's
pressing against the drapery, as though there really
is a body beneath the figure.
And it's been suggested that that
could be the influence of a work we'll
see soon, which is Donatello's St. Mark, which
is shown in contrapposto, or with the leg on one.
In contrapposto, with the weight on one leg.
You see the graceful hands of the figure.
And of course, here, Matthew is holding up his gospel,
the Gospel of St. Matthew.
The first book of the Christian New Testament.
And here, we're seeing Matthew from below, once again.
We're going to return to the Baptistry of Florence
and talk about the East Doors.
So for over 25 years, for about 27 years,
Ghiberti worked on the East Doors
to the Baptistry of Florence.
This has a particular name that has been given to it
by none other than Michelangelo.
He called these doors the Porta della Paradisia,
which we translate as the Gates of Paradise,
or the Doors of Paradise, or the Portals of Paradise.
In other words, the entry into heaven.
So he's saying that they are beautiful enough
to adorn heaven itself.
Another possible interpretation, I
guess a more theological one of Michelangelo's statement,
was that Christians believed that you
had to be baptized in order to be saved,
in order to enter heaven.
So in that sense, it also, are they gates of paradise?
They lead you into the baptistry to be baptized.
He probably was thinking, though,
of the beauty of these doors.
You'll notice that the shape of the scenes is totally different.
The quadrilobe shape was very much a Gothic shape.
And by 1425, that would have been hopelessly old-fashioned.
These are approximately squares.
They're not exactly squares.
See, they're a little taller than they are wide.
But they give the appearance, as you look at each scene,
as though you're looking through a window frame.
And this is the kind of phrase that Alberti would have used
when he was writing his book on painting.
Alberti was a humanist scholar and an art theorist
who wrote a number of books, including
three books on painting, and another on sculpture,
and another on architecture.
And his book on painting came out in the mid-1430s,
around 1435, first written in Latin
and immediately translated into Italian.
And we often use some of the phrases from the book.
And one of the things is this idea
of looking through a window into a world,
an illusionistic world, that the artist is
trying to create something that appears to be reality.
Now, as we said, the committee changed their minds.
They decided for the north doors,
instead of using Old Testament scenes,
they would have New Testament scenes, which
means that the last set of doors to be created,
the east baptistry doors, the gates of paradise,
are, of course, Old Testament scenes.
They are in gilded bronze.
And here you can see they gilded the entire scenes.
And the sort of framework is different statuary.
We're going to look closely at one of these works
and then look at several others.
This is the story of Jacob and Isaac.
And it is the story of a dysfunctional family.
This is when Isaac has become an old man.
And he's gone blind.
But he has two sons by his wife, Rebecca.
And they're two twin boys.
Although they are obviously paternal twins,
they have nothing in common, it seems.
Esau was born just a few minutes before Jacob.
And it says that when they came out of their mother's wombs,
Jacob was holding Esau's foot.
And the idea was that they were fighting together,
even in the womb.
So Esau is the oldest son.
He is the favorite of his father.
And as the oldest son, by the rules of primogeniture,
he will inherit all of his father's goods.
Jacob's not very happy about that.
And we'll see what he does.
Now, one of the things about Esau
is that he is an outdoorsman.
He's a hunter.
And he will often bring back game
and make a game stew or soup his father really, really likes.
And that will figure prominently in the story.
We see a number of scenes.
It's what's called simultaneous representation.
If you look right in the center, sort of the middle ground,
you'll see just one figure who seems to be striding forward
and throwing his bow on the ground.
And you can just barely see the figure of Jacob
behind the figure in the foreground.
Well, this is probably the beginning
of these really serious troubles between the brothers.
Esau comes back from hunting.
He either hasn't caught anything or hasn't
had time to fix any food.
And he comes in, and he's been gone for days.
And he is so hungry.
And he sees his brother making a bowl of soup.
And he says, give me that soup.
I'm just starving.
And Jacob says to him, give me your birthright,
and I'll give you some soup.
His birthright is his inheritance.
And what does Esau say?
He says, what good does it do me if I starve to death?
Give me the soup.
You say, how could he be so foolish?
How could he possibly exchange his birthright,
all of his inheritance, for a plate of soup?
Well, one of the questions that the medieval commentators,
or we call this exegesis, when they
find additional meanings beyond the literal text in the Bible.
And during the Middle Ages, they interpreted this scene
as symbolic, that Esau became the symbol of a worldly man.
Who only cares about things of this world,
and will sacrifice the things of the spiritual world
for things of the physical world, which simply are just
not as important.
So the plate of soup stands for worldly goods, worldly desires.
And the birthright stands for the spiritual realm,
things that are really important.
One of the reasons they needed to explain it away, too,
is Jacob does not come across very well in this story.
And yet, as the story unfolds, he seemed to be the hero.
He seemed to be favored by God.
So there has to be some reason for that.
And so they tried to do it with symbolism.
Now, one of the things you'll notice about this
is that you have these grid lines on the ground that
seem to converge at a vanishing point.
And you'll notice that the lines on the floor that
seem to be inlaid floor tiles go back,
and they become closer and closer together.
Well, this is the grid lines that,
when you were figuring out how to do linear perspective,
you would have to draw these grids
and figure them out mathematically.
And in the 15th century, it almost
seems like the artists are figuring out,
we went to such work to do this, we might as well
incorporate them into the painting.
And so here, we have grid lines on the ground,
which are representing the tiles or the stone on the floor.
So Ghiberti here is using linear perspective.
He's also using a kind of atmospheric perspective
that you can do with sculpture.
In other words, having high relief in the foreground.
Some of these figures are very, very high relief.
And then very shallow relief in the background,
which does give it a hazier quality,
as though it's further away.
You'll also notice that the architecture is classical.
It's got rounded arches and pilasters,
as Roman art might have.
It's quite simple, though, to sort of suggest
that this is a long time ago.
This is early in history.
We also see that the clothing, some of it
seems to be contemporary.
The two boys, Esau and Jacob, are
wearing these little tunics and boots
that could be contemporary young men about town in Florence.
But some of the other figures are wearing what I sometimes
call amorphous biblical robes, or draperies and robes
that are inspired by classical art,
particularly those of the young women, and of course,
of Jacob as well.
The figures are idealized figures.
They are beautiful.
They are graceful.
The young ladies in the lower left
are these beautiful ideal figures.
They're extras.
They're the maidservants around the house.
But he uses them to show this grace and idealism
and the beauty of the human body.
You have the one figure whose back is toward us.
And you can see how the drapery curves around and presses
and her body presses against the drapery.
And it just leaves a very, very graceful effect.
And you have some of the swinging folds.
The figure that's holding what seems to be laundry on her head
is a very familiar type of pose in Renaissance art.
We see it in painting.
We see it in drawing.
And we see it in sculpture.
It's probably derived from a classical statue
or a classical relief with the drapery that
surges out of the supposedly windblown drapery
in this kind of circular pattern.
And the dress that she's wearing with the high waist
and the sort of poof over the stomach area
is a classical type of drapery that
is found on some sarcophagi.
Donatello had a statue in this pose that no longer survives.
It's called the Dovizia.
And so it may be that it is either directly
from the Dovizia or from that and a classical model.
And just quickly, let's take a look
at some of the other works of art.
This is the creation of Adam and Eve, various scenes
from the Genesis story.
In the lower left, you see this figure
of Adam being pulled up by God.
And he's giving him life.
In the lower right, he is creating Eve.
And she seems to almost float out of Adam's side
at the command of God.
And then if you look in the background, where
you have this very shallow relief just above Adam,
you can see that there is the fall of man.
Adam and Eve partaking of the forbidden fruit,
tempted by the serpent.
And it also gives you an idea of how far in relief
these foreground figures are.
I mean, God the Father, the top part of him
is separated from the background.
And you can see also that Adam's head is separate.
He's almost a figure in the round, except he's not.
He's up against a background.
And then to show a distant view, as we
said, some more atmospheric, you have the very shallow figures.
And there's also, of course, the expulsion.
When Adam and Eve are expelled or thrown out of Eden.
And that's shown in a combination
of high and low relief.
You have the beautiful figure of Eve, and behind her, Adam.
And they are in high relief.
And this archway that marks the entrance, or the exit
in this case, into paradise, into Eden.
And as you can see, the angel is flying through.
And the angel's being sent by God, who
here is in very, very low relief,
surrounded by a host of angels as he
is expelling Adam and Eve.
And then here we have the story of Abraham.
Again, what changes have been made from 30 years, perhaps?
Maybe even more.
You can see that the story of Abraham and the east doors
is in this rectilinear format, as we said,
like a window into a world.
It has several events in the story of Abraham.
Down in the lower right, you see Abraham
kneeling to three angels.
And the Bible tells us that there
were three messengers of God, which is what an angel is.
There are three men that come.
And Abraham entertains them.
He gives them food and drink.
And the phrase, I don't know if you've ever heard the phrase,
entertaining angels unaware applies
to the story of Abraham.
And then the guests reveal themselves
as messengers of God.
And they tell him that he will indeed have a child,
that his wife, Sarah, who is 80 years old, will bear a child.
Well, Sarah has been infertile all her life.
She's tried to have a child.
She hasn't succeeded.
So she thinks that's probably not going to happen.
She has a great deal of doubt about it.
But of course, as we know, it comes to pass
that she bears Isaac.
The other half of the scene shows the sacrifice of Isaac.
And you see the same players that we saw before.
Here we have the servants and the donkey
down at the lower right.
Here the servants are sort of just seated around,
taking their leisure.
They don't know what's going up on top of the hill.
And the donkey is shown from the rear.
Renaissance artists love to show donkeys and horses
from the rear because it shows their skill in foreshortening.
And I have to admit, he makes even the rear of a donkey
and this curving tail seem graceful.
And then at the top of the hill, we
see Abraham about to sacrifice Isaac
while the angel intervenes.
Of course, this is in a very low relief.
And the two scenes are divided by the landscape,
by the verticals of the trees, of the rocky mountainside,
which now seems more believable.
And the whole scene, of course, has not only two scenes,
but seems much more spacious.
There's much more air in the picture, if you will.
