Have Scientists Finally Figured Out the Spinosaurus?

Mysteries Of Ancient History
7 followers
I love stories like this because they remind me how unfinished even the biggest “solved” dinosaur stories really are. Spinosaurus still feels like a creature caught between worlds, and every new fossil seems to make it stranger, more dramatic, and somehow even harder to pin down.
#archaeology #history
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hi, it's Katrina! The Spinosaurus Saga is essentially the great debate of the paleontology
world. Every few years it goes from a land-dwelling giant to a river monster and then back again.
Today we are diving into the latest breakthroughs that might finally settle the score,
along with three other dinosaur mysteries that have finally been solved.
The New Spinosaurus
Under the scorching hot Saharan sun, paleontologist Daniel Vidal saw a bone sticking out of the
He was on an excavation in the African country of Niger,
and he knew right away it was a dinosaur bone. I don't need to tell you he was very excited.
You would be too if you found a dinosaur bone in the desert.
What at first Daniel thought was a vertebrate turned out to be a curved,
sword-shaped crest from the head of one of history's most bizarre predators, the Spinosaurus.
Vidal from the University of Chicago told reporters it was like finding a unicorn,
only this unicorn grew to be the size of a bus and would have eaten you like a piece of popcorn.
The discovery is from 2022, when Vidal was part of a team led by paleontologist Paul Serino.
Paul has the prestigious title of being a National Geographic explorer.
He led the team to a remote fossil site known as Jenguebi, and there the crest revealed itself.
It took some time, but now researchers have figured out exactly what kind of creature the
crest belonged to. It was a Spinosaurus, but a new species of Spinosaurus.
This beast of a dino stomped across the ancient river ecosystem 95 million years ago.
Scientists have named it Spinosaurus mirabilis.
In English, that translates to astonishing spine lizard.
The discovery of this fossil could not have come at a better time.
As we speak, there is a raging debate over whether Spinosaurus was aquatic,
semi-aquatic, or fully terrestrial. One side of the argument has been telling us for years that
Spinosaurus could swim in the water, that it used its long snout for catching fish,
and that when it got bored of hosting pool parties, it went on land and terrorized animals there.
Other paleontologists aren't so sure. They say there isn't enough proof.
Well, there is now.
Big thank you to Incogni for sponsoring today's video.
Your information is everywhere. Have you googled yourself lately?
Because it is scary what is out there for everyone to see.
Full name, home address, phone number, social security number,
your family members, their full names, financial details, even personal interests and beliefs.
It's shocking, right?
My mom got a call one time where someone who used her full name
gave her my full name and said that I was in trouble and needed money.
This happens all the time, and now things are getting more and more sophisticated.
Scammers are targeting parents by using AI to mimic their child's voice.
This has probably happened to you even, or someone you know.
But how do they get all of this information?
How do they know not only your phone number, but your age,
where you work, what credit card you have?
It's because certain websites collect this information and sell it.
Your information is being actively bought and sold by data brokers.
These sites are a goldmine for criminals and identity thieves.
So what are you supposed to do about it?
That's where Incogni comes in.
Incogni tracks down and removes your personal data from multiple sites,
including online directories, people search sites, and even commercial databases.
Incogni will contact these brokers,
push for your data removal, and ensure it remains offline.
The process is fully automated for hundreds of known data brokers.
And since data can reappear on these sites, they repeatedly remove it for you.
You can see I've been using Incogni for a couple years now
and it has a chart that shows me what they've been able to remove and what's in progress.
There is also a custom removal feature to take down almost everything
that's exposed about you online.
You just send them a link and your dedicated privacy expert will handle everything else.
With Incogni, you can reduce the risk of scams and protect your privacy online.
All you have to do is create an account and authorize Incogni
to search and remove your information.
They can't hurt you if they can't find you.
To get started, go to incogni.com slash origins
and use the code origins to get an exclusive 60% off an annual plan.
That's incogni.com slash origins.
And feel safer online.
Now let's get back to it.
Niger has attracted fossil hunters for nearly a century.
In the 1950s, French geologist Hugues Farré uncovered a dinosaur tube there,
which inspired Paul Serino to follow in his footsteps.
Paul and company traveled to Djenguevi,
a dry and barren hellscape of sand and scant, gnarly trees.
The Tuareg community who lives there calls the area where Vidal found the fossils
Sirig Tagat.
And I know you're going to love the English translation.
It means no water, no goat.
I think that means it's not the best place to hunker down and build a village.
Paul believed that somewhere in the great expanse of shifting sands and harsh, dry winds,
a monster was waiting just below the surface.
Of course, one does not simply walk into the Sahara Desert.
The team had to hire local guide Abdul Nasser,
who helped the team scout the site in 2019.
During that original scouting mission,
Paul and Daniel found a Spinosaurus jawbone.
They knew then that they were in the right spot.
They packed up, headed home, and returned three years later in 2022.
During that next expedition,
they found more fossils than you can shake a dinosaur bone at.
They uncovered bones from three different S. mirabilis specimens,
fossils from the megalithic dinosaur Carcharodontosaurus,
turtle fossils, and even a few 12-foot-long fish remains.
I'm not here to talk about fish that could swallow you in one gulp.
I'm here to talk about the crest.
Most different Spinosaurus species, known together as Spinosaurids,
had head crests.
But until now, they were pretty boring.
Imagine a small lump structure on their head,
like a dinosaur tailbone for the skull.
But this?
What Vidal found in the sand is unparalleled.
It's a huge crest, shaped like a scimitar,
and covered in a sheath of keratin.
But don't take my word for it.
Here's a picture of the recreated skull.
See that curved thing on the top?
Scientists think it may have been even longer in the flesh.
But what the heck was the point of having a sword on its head?
Unless...
Spinosaurus wasn't skewering its prey, was it?
Ponserino believes the crest was a major standout feature for this particular Spinosaurus.
He compared it to the head crest of the modern helmeted guinea fowl,
and thinks it probably played a similar role.
For the guinea fowl, only males have these head crests.
If there is a single ladybird seeking out a mate,
or the other way around,
the bird knows exactly which one is the male because of the headgear,
and the males probably use it to show off.
Spinosaurus may have had head crests for the exact same reason.
After all, they were just oversized lizard birds.
Paul said the head crest could have been for mating,
or even for signaling to rival mates that the territory is off limits.
The only problem with trying to confirm that suspicion is that as of now,
scientists don't know what differences there were between male and female Spinos.
They have no idea which fossils are from males,
and which ones are from females.
But they do have modern animals to look at for comparison, like the fowl.
Outside experts who weren't involved in the field trip,
but studied the data, agreed the crest was a signal.
It was either to say,
Hey, look at me.
I'll make the best husband because I've got the best crest.
Or it was to say,
Back off.
Don't mess with me.
These are typical animal behaviors,
seeing everything from birds to lions.
It makes total sense.
It also wasn't the only breakthrough the team made.
They found bones from the top and bottom jaw.
These jaw bones allowed researchers to finally confirm that Spinosaurus had interlocking teeth.
If that sounds scary, it's because it is.
Take a look at a crocodile's mouth.
That's what I mean by interlocking teeth.
The Spinosaurus had a mouth like a crocodile,
a snout like a vacuum attachment,
and conical teeth.
Those cone-shaped teeth were designed to pierce slippery fish,
while their interlocking configuration worked to trap them in place once the jaw snapped shut.
It was, in Vidal's own words,
a fish trap.
That makes Spinosaurus the only known dinosaur with a fish trap for a mouth.
And yes,
fish trap is an actual term for creatures with this kind of bite.
The teeth,
the fish trap mouth,
the head crest,
they all add to the bizarre picture of Spinosaurus.
Every new piece of information just makes it a little bit weirder.
Scientists know it loved water.
They know it ate fish.
But they are still stuck trying to figure out why this dinosaur was so different from the others.
For years,
dinosaurs were all lumped into the category of terrestrial animals.
There were the marine reptiles like plesiosaurs and the mosasaurs in the sea,
and then the dinosaurs were on land.
But when Spinosaurus aegyptiacus fossils were found in Morocco in 2014,
that stereotype changed.
Suddenly,
there was a dinosaur that wasn't a land lover.
The team that found the original fossils more than 10 years ago
announced Spinosaurus as the first known swimming dinosaur.
The scientific community reacted as if it had been slapped.
And in came the questions.
How do you know it was aquatic?
How did it swim?
Why was it in the water?
What did it eat?
What was its favorite color?
I don't know.
They asked a billion questions and the scientists didn't have the answers yet.
They said that Spinosaurus was aquatic
because they found its fossils in river delta ecosystems near coastlines.
They also based their information on the creature's remains,
since its long mouth,
even fossilized,
looks like the perfect tool for catching fish.
The new fossils in Niger switched things up a bit.
This is the deepest inland that Spinosaurus fossils have ever been found.
These bits and pieces of bone were uncovered hundreds of miles from the nearest marine coast.
Either Spinosaurus really liked to go on nature walks,
or it was only semi-aquatic.
That's the crux of the argument.
Some say it could swim.
Others say it only waded into the shallows like a heron to snatch prey.
To get to the bottom of this conundrum,
Paul Cirino and his team did some digging.
Or rather, some comparing.
They looked at the skull, neck, and back legs of the newly discovered species.
Then they compared those to other Spinosaurids.
Then they compared both of those to a variety of dinosaurs,
birds,
and reptiles.
The team was looking for patterns.
Anything that would indicate the true nature behind Spinosaurus' unusual features.
Weirdly enough, the data revealed that Spinosaurus had more in common with storks
than crocodiles or other dinosaurs.
This led the team to speculate that Spinosaurus was semi-aquatic,
wading into the water to snatch prey and living in the forest near rivers,
alongside long-necked dinos.
But as it goes with every new discovery,
not everyone is convinced of the connection.
The critics say if Spinosaurus was like a heron or a stork,
why was it so big?
Those types of wading birds have extremely long legs and very light bodies,
the polar opposite of Spinosaurus.
Long legs allow these types of birds to get into the water without splashing.
That way, they can surprise their prey.
But that's a little bit difficult to do when you weigh 13,000 pounds,
which Spinosaurus did.
Plus, birds have low bone density so that they can tread lightly,
which dinosaurs did not.
Spinosaurus was more like a runaway roller coaster than a ballerina.
Another argument critics have for the aquatic explanation
is that because Spinosaurus was so gigantic,
it couldn't have been picky about what it ate.
When you're that big, you have to eat often or you'll starve.
Spinosaurus could not have only eaten fish
unless the rivers were so full that there was a never-ending supply.
Experts like Thomas Holtz Jr. from the University of Maryland
say Spinosaurus was an opportunistic predator.
It would have eaten whatever it could have to survive,
which means it likely wouldn't have developed a specialty
to hunting in shallow waters.
On the other hand, Spinosaurus may have just been a total savage
that charged into the water and ate everything
that didn't get away fast enough.
It may have been like a bull in a china shop sort of predator.
Rampaging on land and in the shallows,
like a dog with rabies chasing everything that moved.
The evidence in the bones is even more confusing.
When scientists analyzed Spinosaurus teeth,
the results showed that they ate both fish and other dinosaurs.
Nobody can agree on whether that means Spinosaurus lived primarily off fish
but would chase land animals that got too close,
like a crocodile snapping at a gazelle getting a drink.
Or if Spinosaurus roamed around hunting dinosaurs
that also sometimes ate fish when it was available in massive quantities.
I mean, I think it was probably doing both.
It was wading around sometimes,
maybe swimming a little bit and trudging through the forest too.
But if it could swim, which is the biggest question mark,
Matt LaManna from the Carnegie Museum of Natural History
said he doesn't think it would be swimming very fast.
Well, I mean, that was probably a good thing.
Spinosaurus was nearly 50 feet long,
had no flippers,
stomped around on two massive hind legs like Tyrannosaurus,
and had a big fat tail.
The tail may have helped it swim,
but it wasn't moving very quickly underwater with those stocky tree trunk legs.
Then there's the question of the sail.
On its back was a huge sail about six feet high.
As with everything else Spino-related,
experts can't agree on its purpose.
They say maybe the sail helped regulate the creature's body temperature.
Maybe it was part of an elaborate mating ritual.
It may have even helped to propel the dinosaur through the water.
But it's all just speculation,
especially since no one knows what the flesh looked like.
What I mean is that all anyone has are bones,
so how are they supposed to know what the animal's body looked like?
A lot of scientists have said that in life,
Spinosaurus may have had a hump instead of a sail.
Let's play a game.
I'm going to show you a skeleton,
and I want you to tell me what animal that skeleton belongs to in the comments.
Can you tell what animal it is?
Is it a mammal?
Is it aquatic?
The point I'm trying to make is that just by looking at a skeleton,
it's impossible to know that this animal had sharp spurs on its hind feet
that could deliver deadly toxins.
It's difficult to tell that the creature had a bill like a duck,
a tail like a beaver,
and fur like an otter.
It's a platypus.
But you would never be able to guess all of its bizarre characteristics
just by looking at its bones.
And the same thing is likely true with Spinosaurus.
Going forward, the full and complete picture of Spinosaurus
won't be solved until scientists find more bones.
They did once have more bones,
originally dug up in the 1910s,
but they were stored in Munich at a museum,
and that museum was bombed during World War II.
So that kind of set us back a bit.
What are your thoughts on the Spinosaurus?
Was it a river monster?
Was it a normal dinosaur?
Do you love it?
Hate it?
Let me know in the comments.
Dinosaur Cold Case Solved
This might be the coldest cold case ever solved.
Scientists working out of the University of Leicester
have solved the deaths of two dinosaurs from 150 million years ago.
Take that, Sherlock Holmes.
The mystery has been puzzling researchers for years.
Two juvenile pterosaurs were found in southern Germany
in such a bizarre state
that no one could figure out what killed them.
The flying reptiles were unearthed at the Solnhofen limestone,
which contains deposits from a prehistoric lagoon.
It's famous in the world of paleontology
for producing incredibly well-preserved fossils of pterosaurs.
And everybody loves pterosaurs.
I like to think of them as the giant lizard bats
that lived throughout the entire reign of the dinosaurs
from 252 to 66 million years ago.
Ish.
You know, give or take a decade.
Hundreds of pterosaur fossils have been found at Solnhofen,
but there is a weird pattern here.
Almost all of the fossils belong to small, often baby pterosaurs.
There are a couple of adults, but they are rare and often in pieces.
Meanwhile, the skeletons of dozens of babies are perfectly intact.
This is strange for many different reasons,
chief among them that larger animals are more likely to fossilize completely.
Younger animals have more delicate bones
and are far less likely to be fossilized intact or fossilized at all.
It's weird, isn't it?
Only a few adults, but a bunch of babies.
The first thing that springs to mind is probably that this was a nursery,
but it wasn't.
Scientists haven't found any evidence of eggs or nests,
meaning it wasn't a pterosaur or children's bark that got flooded.
Paleontologists didn't know what to make of it,
so they embarked on a journey to solve the case.
Rather than investigate every single fossil,
they focused their attention on two baby pterosaurs.
As it turns out, they were killed in a storm so powerful
it belonged on Jupiter, not Earth.
Did you know that pterosaurs were some of the most diverse creatures of the dinosaur age?
And while sometimes we call them dinosaurs, technically they were not.
They were flying reptiles.
Lizards with wings.
But just like the dinosaurs that lived below them,
they ranged in size dramatically.
Some were as teeny as a sparrow.
Others were as monstrous as an airplane.
And that's not an exaggeration.
The two baby pterosaurs belonged to the genus Pterodactylus
and were nicknamed by the team Lucky and Lucky 2.
Okay, someone clearly enjoys their irony.
Each baby had a wingspan of less than 8 inches.
They are some of the smallest pterosaurs ever discovered.
But what intrigued the team members was their injuries.
Both suffered the same injury, just to a different wing.
Lucky's left wing and Lucky 2's right wing suffered a fracture to their humerus.
It was the clue that broke the case.
When any flying animal has a broken wing humerus,
it typically means the bone was ruptured by a powerful twisting force.
And what more powerful twisting force is there than a gust of hurricane wind?
Based on these injuries,
scientists determined that the juvenile pterosaurs flew into the storm to end all storms.
The wind was so intense that they couldn't ride it out
and they were twisted up in a tornado.
I feel kind of bad talking about this
because it must have been horrible for these poor little pterosaurs.
They were just trying to go for a nice flight
when they took a wrong turn and ended up tossed around like ragdolls.
David Unwin from the university said they were in the air when the injuries occurred.
I can't even imagine how intense that wind must have been to break bones mid-flight.
Of course, it wasn't just the two babies.
It was all the babies.
I'm not sure if that makes it more or less tragic.
They were either just a few days old or a few weeks old.
And they all flew into the storm and were tossed down in the lagoon below,
where they were swallowed by the murky waves.
Once in the lagoon, the flying reptiles sank to the bottom.
The storm churned the water and they were buried under the mud.
And then they were fossilized.
It was a terrible accident and a sad tragedy,
but also a stroke of luck that they fell into the perfect cauldron for fossilization,
at least for paleontologists.
They were sealed beneath that lagoon for tens of millions of years
until some English dinosaur fans went knocking with their tiny hammers and brushes.
It's a little odd because for years,
scientists knew about this spot and these fossils
and assumed the region was dominated by a small species of pterosaurs.
Now, with the mystery solved, the truth ended up being so much darker.
125-Year Mystery Solved
Paleontology might just be the slowest of all the scientific fields.
It took 125 years for paleontologists to identify the fossil of a mysterious Triassic theropod.
But hey, better late than never.
A group of researchers at the University of Bristol were the ones who finally cracked the case.
They used the newest in digital scanning methods
to take a fresh look at a jawbone fossil found in 1899.
It's not the age of the fossil that blows my mind,
it's the fact that it's been displayed for decades without anyone knowing what it was.
Seriously, you could have looked at this impressive jawbone at the National Museum of Wales,
but if you asked anyone at the museum about the animal it came from,
they would have shrugged and directed you towards the woolly mammoths.
The jawbone isn't even real.
The specimen is only a natural mold preserved inside of a rock,
with all the original bone gone.
How do you study a bone that isn't even there?
The answer came from student Owain Evans, who helped create a 3D digital reconstruction of it.
He started with photogrammetry, which is basically scanning the mold to get it into the computer.
Then Evans and his team inverted it, creating a digital negative.
Next, they fused the two sides together to create the finished product.
All that was left was to begin analyzing the anatomy.
Ta-da!
This was the first time scientists studied the bone up close, and it was a breath of fresh air.
The digital reconstruction was so well done, they didn't even need the original bone.
The digital scans produced such fine details,
there is no way this could have been done just a few years ago.
Every single groove, every tooth, every ridge was illuminated.
Even the serrations along the edges of the teeth that you can hardly see with your naked eye
were brought to life in the digital model.
It was so impressive, scientists made a 3D model of it.
By the way, even though the dinosaur was never identified previously, it was given a name.
In 1899, Edwin Newton called it Xanclodon cambrensis.
Since that doesn't really track anymore,
as the dinosaur has nothing to do with the Xanclodon early reptiles,
the name has been changed to Newtonsaurus.
Scientists said because it was different from all the other dinosaurs that lived alongside it,
Newtonsaurus needed a distinctive name.
It's definitely got one now.
The first job was to confirm whether the jawbone belonged to a dinosaur
or some kind of other ancient reptile.
Sure enough, it was a dino.
Evans confirmed that the specimen belonged to a large predatory theropod,
one that dominated the shores of Wales during the Triassic period.
But this was not your average theropod.
Newtonsaurus had a surprising amount in common with Spinosaurus.
The definitive features of Newtonsaurus are its teeth.
The way they are designed convinced the team that this thing was a fish eater.
It probably lived on the coastlines,
hunting marine animals and fighting with other dinosaurs.
Sound familiar?
That was what Spinosaurus was doing, only much later.
The spino roamed the world about 95 million years ago.
Newton was closer to 200 million years ago.
The Triassic period, when this creature prospered,
was the very first era of the dinosaur kind.
It was 252 million years ago.
The Permian extinction had just racked up.
The first dinosaurs emerged on the supercontinent Pangaea,
and it was hot, hot, hot.
The era of the dinosaurs was just getting started.
The beginnings of the Triassic are a huge mystery for paleontologists,
with fossil beds from that time being exceptionally rare.
That makes finding an early dinosaur like this really important.
What surprised the team the most was how big the animal was.
Judging strictly on its preserved jawbone, which was about 2 feet long,
the entire dinosaur's body was nearly 25 feet.
For a dinosaur from this early on, the size is ridiculous.
Most early dinosaurs from the Triassic were only half that.
Not even.
It just goes to show how little paleontologists know sometimes.
If we can't even piece together our own human history going back 300,000 years,
how are we going to piece together the history of giant lizards from 10 times as far back?
The mass dinosaur grave.
In Canada, paleontologists have been turned into detectives.
There is a team of scientists currently digging up thousands of fossils
of the exact same dinosaur in the exact same spot, in Alberta's Pipestone Creek.
That in itself is pretty rare.
To find thousands of the same dinos in the same location?
But what makes this especially disturbing is that they were all killed at the same time.
It is a dinosaur mass grave unlike anything
researchers at the Philip J. Curry Dinosaur Museum have ever seen before.
It is so gnarly that scientists have dubbed the site the River of Death.
It is, no exaggeration, a gigantic bed of bones.
The reason scientists have turned into detectives is because it's up to them
to figure out what happened here.
Let me tell you the facts as they are right now.
73 million years ago, thousands of Pachyrhinosaurus embarked on a mass migration
across what is now the interior of Western Canada.
It's thought that they were probably heading north for the summer after wintering in the south,
just like Canadians today.
In that regard, not much has changed.
These creatures were heavy, thunderous beasts on four legs,
looking like armored monsters with three angry horns emerging from the bony frill on their head.
They were close relatives of the more famous Triceratops.
As they journeyed across the landscape,
leaving a plume of dust rising behind them like a sandstorm, something bad happened.
Something very bad happened because they all died instantly.
They were left piled on top of each other as if they were massacred and thrown into a mass grave.
The paleontologist in charge of the bone bed is Emily Bamforth from the museum.
She and her team have excavated an area about the size of a tennis court so far.
Even if you haven't played tennis, you know it's not a super large area,
especially when the bone bed is nearly a mile long.
Emily was shocked by how tightly the bones were found packed together,
skeleton on top of skeleton, with their bones smushed into layers like a cake.
There are almost 300 bones in every square foot of space.
Bamforth called it, and I quote,
The current knowledge paleontologists have of roughly half of all known dinosaurs
comes from a single specimen.
That means about 50% of the dinosaurs you know and love
have been recreated from only one fossilized example.
Pretty crazy, right?
Even crazier is that only about 20% of dinosaurs
have been found with complete skulls and skeletons.
That means the other 80% of dinosaurs have been pieced together by, you know, tiny pieces.
A lot of what scientists know about these prehistoric marvels
comes from things like that jawbone at the National Museum of Wales I told you about.
So many dinos are nothing but a jaw, a tooth, a femur.
I wanted to quickly mention this because of the implications
for what Emily Bamforth is digging up.
While most dinosaurs only have one existing specimen,
Pachyrhinosaurus has thousands.
It could become the most thoroughly studied dinosaur in history,
just because there is now so much of it to go around.
Keep an eye out because you might see Pachyrhinosaurus bones pop up on eBay soon.
So what the heck happened?
That's the big question paleontologists had to answer.
And they already have.
The theory Emily and her colleagues have come up with
is that the majestic dinosaurs were swept away in a flash flood.
This is the only thing that makes any sense.
It's not like they were run off a cliff by some Jurassic hunters.
Although if they were, that would be the discovery of the century.
The more likely explanation is that as the herd migrated,
a rainstorm hit, a flash flood rampaged across the landscape,
and they were swept to their watery deaths.
This explains why their bones are piled on top of one another in such a mishmash.
The poor creatures were tossed into a mountain of misery by the power of the storm.
Going forward, paleontologists have a ton of work to do.
It's not just about digging up thousands of bones.
They also have to be transported to the museum,
where researchers carefully clean, analyze, and catalog them.
Seeing as the site has been known since the 1970s,
and still only a tiny fraction has been excavated,
this project will be ongoing for a while.
Thanks for watching!
If you made it all the way to the end, leave me a heart or a dinosaur emoji in the comments.
And be sure to share any fun dinosaur facts that you have.
Hit that subscribe button and I'll see you tomorrow.
