The Current Luxury Watch Market Situation

Charm Diamond
62 followers
#watch, #luxurywatch, #wristwatch, #timepiece, #watchlover, #watchcollection, #watchaddict, #fashionwatch, #menswatch, #womenswatch, #smartwatch, #vintagewatch, #automaticwatch, #chronograph, #swisswatch
AI Generated·May contain errors
The watch market just had its 13th straight quarter of price declines, but you'd never know
if you're only watching Rolex and Patek. Some brands are holding strong, even gaining, while
others are in free fall down. Over 40% from retail, we are seeing tariffs shaking things up,
our certified pre-owned explode, and a sharp divide between brands that collectors trust and
those they are walking away from. So in this video, I will break down the biggest winners
and most painful losers, the side effects you won't believe, and what all of this means if
you're buying, selling, or just watching the market unfold. So this is the Q2 2025 watch
market report. So let's get started. And on a quick note, before we get into it, this is all
taken from the watch charts and Morgan Stanley watch reports. You can, I think you can subscribe
to the newsletter or you can, you know, make yourself an account there and then you will
receive that same report as well. I can only highly recommend it. It is very informative.
And this is where I've got the statistics from. So like I said, go subscribe to that or just get
an account. It is really great. So let's have a look at the data and we're going to start with
the big picture and set this scene so we can all start on the same page because the secondary watch
market might finally be finding its footing after more than three years of consistent declines.
You might've already watched my other video that I did about the last market review. And from that,
the things have not been looking too great, but let's see what updates we have now that we're
six months into 2025. So the second quarter of 2025 prices on the secondary market fell just 0.3%
quarter over quarter, which means we're comparing Q2 of 2025 with Q1 of 2025, the lowest rate of
decline since the second quarter of 2022. That is also the 30th consecutive quarter. So one right
after the other without skipping a month of price drops, but at least now the descent is more
like a slope than like a cliff and a sharp fall down. So yay for that. I mean, you can clearly
see that the curve is slowly, but steadily sort of flattening, no crazy ups and downs, which is
always great. So what's behind this soft landing? Well, that is obviously not a simple black and
white reasoning. And unfortunately it is not the whole market that's stabilizing. What or who is
really the key driver here are really just four key brands doing the heavy lifting.
Very obviously we have Rolex, Patek Philippe, but also Omega and Cartier. Rolex, Patek, Cartier,
and Omega all delivered steady to slightly positive results in the second quarter of this
year. These brands continue to sort of lead the market more or less within the respective price
ranges. Rolex and Patek Philippe at the high end, you know, with the prices above like on average,
$10,000 and above, and Omega and Cartier in the mid range. So about like $3,000 to the $10,000
price range. So as of Q2, they remain top performance both for the quarter and over the
past year. This consistent strength shows me that consumer demand remains focused on the well
established so-called blue chip brands. So that's one of what trains are finding it harder to
compete. A trend I have to say that has continued from the first quarter. This isn't something that
is like super surprising or shocking. We've already seen that development before. And you
know, these aren't just random outliers. These brands, they hold the largest shares of the
secondary market and their relative strength is hiding, unfortunately, the broader market's
weakness. And here's the kicker. Outside of these four that I've just mentioned, nearly all other
brands saw price drops. Of the 24 brands they track in this report with an average retail price
of $3,000. 18 of them experienced price declines of at least 1% compared to the previous quarter.
The only notable exceptions were Tudor with a plus 0.1% and Bvlgari with a negative 0.2%.
So in total, 29 out of the 35 brands posted negative results for the quarter with most
losing more than 1%. And although the Watchtower's overall market index has appeared stable so far
this year, that figure is largely driven by a handful of strong performers. The reality beneath
all this, the surface, is a more uneven and polarized market, which becomes clear when looking
at the performance of specific Swiss watch groups as a detail, which we're now going to talk about.
So while headlines might say the market is stabilizing, what's really happening is
polarization. So in this context, polarization means that the performance of the secondary
watch market is becoming increasingly divided between, you know, a few very strong performing
brands and large number of weak ones. So while top brands like Rolex, Patek, Alcatel, Omega
are holding their value or even gaining slightly, most other brands are still seeing significant
price declines and they sort of create this gap where the market isn't moving like as a whole
thing, as a group. Instead, it's splitting up into winners and losers with very, very little
middle ground. So if you're holding something outside of the top four, odds are it's still
losing value. It's a trend we've seen developing since 2024, but the second quarter of this year
really confirms it. The secondary watch market is being propped up by just a few strong performers
and the rest is still pretty much on a shaky ground. So let's take a closer look at the top
performers and see how they're doing. So while most of the watch market is still trending downwards,
a very small group, like I've mentioned, is pretty much defying gravity. I just went wicked.
So those highly trusted iconic names that collectors and investors tend to flock to when
the rest of the grey market is really super shaky. So in the second quarter of 2024,
four brands stood out for their strength in the secondary market, which is, as I said,
Patek Philippe with a plus 1.1% quarter on quarter, Cartier with a plus 0.9%, Rolex
has a negative 0.2% quarter on quarter, which is almost like a bad thing, and Omega is barely down
with a negative 0.1% Q on Q. So but why does it matter? Because these four brands together
dominate the secondary market by volume. They have the most listings, the most interest,
and the most influence on the overall market trends. So let's break them down a bit. With a
1.1% increase, Patek was the best performing major brand in the second quarter. The Aquanaut
and Nautilus collections played a big role, no surprise here. Aquanaut was up 2.2% and even the
new Couvetous collection, goodness me, commanding at 79.9% premium over retail. Who would have
thought that anybody was going to buy this? But yeah, people seem to love it that much. Cartier
too surprised the market, which I'm very happy to hear, I love my Cartier. So prices rose 0.9%
on Q on Q largely thanks to the strong demand for the Santos collection, no wonder here, which is
trading at just negative 23.3% discount, relatively good compared to its peers. Even more interesting,
Cartier was the only major brand whose value retention actually improved, albeit slightly,
by I think it was 0.6 percentage points since April. I mean, yeah, I guess we still have to add
that while Cartier's value retention improved by 0.6 percentage points, it did so as a result
of the discontinuation of many highly discounted models on a like-for-like basis. Its value
retention still declined by 2.2 percentage points. Oh, and this, when I say like-for-like,
this means the analysis compares the same specific models across two time periods. So
excluding any new release or discontinued models, it helps them to isolate the true performance of
unchanged inventory by removing the ones from any catalog changes that might've happened. So
for example, if Cartier discontinued some poorly performing watches in the second quarter,
its average value retention might look like it improved, but the like-for-like value retention
would reveal whether the models that stayed actually performed better or worse. So it is a
cleaner, more kind of apples to apples comparison. So just so you know, that's what like-for-like
means. So yeah, all other brands saw a sequential decline in value retention,
both with and without adjusting for like-for-like models, but it did decline
most for Patek Philippe and Audemars Piguet, largely as a result of retail price increases.
Now we've put up a graphic that you can see while Tudor and Cartier were the least ones affected.
And let's move over to Omega. Omega saw a minor dip at 0.1%, but held up better than most of
its peers. Its Speedmaster line continues to lead, no surprise here, with a value retention of
negative 29% compared to the negative 35% average across Omega, which I think isn't all that
surprising, though you still read a lot about how people get more and more annoyed by the endless
stream of speedy releases. It is still the most iconic Omega, and an entry into the brand for most
people. Obviously closely followed by the Seamaster line with a dive with William M, for example,
that now have gotten some refreshing updates too.
And finally, we have to take a closer look at Rolex. Of course, Rolex stayed virtually flat
at 0.2%, which in this market is still a win. The Datejust and Oyster Perpetual collections
even posted gains, with the Datejust having a plus of 0.7%, and the Oyster Perpetual with a
plus of 0.6%. Q&Q, which I think is a really cool development to see a shift from, at least for
me, bulkier sporty models like the Submariner and the GMTs, to more classic, less sporty lines like
the Datejust or, you know, the Opies. Would be interesting to see if there's a correlation
between a changing taste in luxury accessories and other worldwide happenings. I don't know,
maybe this is too much of a stretch. Just something that I just had to think about. I'm
sure there will be some kind of statistic that correlates with this. But yeah, I mean,
you can see it for yourself. It's the losses in sports models like the Submariner and the
Yachtmasters that are both down, I think it is negative 1.3%, which are holding back the overall
results of Rolex. Right, so we have talked about the winners, the ones that are holding up this
whole thing. Let's see who exactly it is that is underperforming and what might be the reason
behind it. Because while a handful of brands are keeping the market stable, the vast majority are
still poo-pooing on it, sliding down, and some in pretty dramatic fashion, if I might say so.
In fact, out of those 35 brands tracked in this report, 29 had negative price performance in the
second quarter of 2025, and 25 of them dropped by more than just 1%. And I want to start out
with the biggest shocker, Vacheron Constantin. Once a flagship name in haute horlogerie,
it posted the worst value retention of any brand. It's negative 41.1% below retail on average,
and its secondary prices fell a negative of 3.4% queue on queue. And just so you know,
this isn't at all an indicator about quality or any kind of evaluation or a more specific
devaluation of the design or craftsmanship or anything like that. I mean, these figures could
potentially imply these things, but they remain hard facts that have multiple factors playing
into them. So please, if you love Vacheron, don't call me a dumb in the comments because
I'm discussing statistics here. I like them too. Just letting you know. Thank you very much. Let's
get back to it. So it's 56 and other collections trade at negative 38%, nearly negative 50% below
retail. And only one model from the overseas collection is selling above retail. And even
that one is an outlier. Right. But let's move over to Audemars Piguet AP, part of the so-called
Holy Trinity, also Vacheron too. And yet for the first time, its average secondary market prices
fell below retail. Its value retention is now at negative 1.3%, which marks a down from plus 5.3%
in April of this year. That's a 6.6 percentage point drop. And this drop is mainly due to a
plus 6.7% retail price increase while secondary market price actually fell negative 1.4% at the
same time. That kind of plays into all of this. And here's the twist as well. 61% of Audemars
Piguet's models still trade above retail. It's just that the brand is dragged down by poor
performance. Like you've got the Royal Oak Offshore with a negative 22.7% value retention,
the Code 11 59 that they like to just shove into your face when you're at an AP boutique is down
a shocking negative 33.3%. They will shove it down your throat if you're in an AP boutique.
They'll be like, buy this. You don't get anything else. You have to buy this first. But yeah,
it doesn't stop here. Other major brands lost serious round in Q2. So let's quickly have a
look here too. So we've got IWC, for example, down 37.4% in value retention. Tudor with a
39.7%. A. Lange & Söhne down 36.7% and Omega at a negative 35%. Secondary prices for these brands
fell despite rising retail prices, which were meant to kind of offset the US tariff hike that
we had going on in May that's still going on. But instead of boosting value, we thought the
price hike seemed to have widened the gap. Surprise, surprise between retail and resale.
But yeah, I don't want to be all doom and gloom here. There's also been a fun,
one fun little outlier. You might have already noticed from the graphs that I have already shown
you. We have Tissot with a bit of a comeback. We could say after being the worst performer in Q1,
it's secondary prices rebounded 1.5% Q&Q in the secondary quarter of this year. So yeah,
you go girl, Tissot. Congratulations. So yeah, that was that was cool to see. It is a small
but meaningful recovery, especially at the entry level, where buyers need to be more price
sensitive and responsive to bar gains. So yeah, the key takeaway here is this. The polarization
in the market is sharper than ever. While a handful of blue chip names hold steady,
you know, respected brands, even some from the big three, hello, Vacheron AP, are struggling
with a falling demand, aging inventory, and eroding retail value. It is no longer just about
prestige. It's about specific collections, timing, and price dynamics. And that makes navigating the
market more complicated than ever, but also more interesting than ever. If you ask me,
it's extremely fascinating to see how swift decisions from bigger and smaller watchmakers
impact their performance and how sometimes watchmakers rely on pretty much one single
collection to keep like the whole ship afloat. Right. So let me quickly say this. If you're not
interested in Rolex CPO, then you can just skip this chapter and go on to the next one. But let
it be said that you will miss out on one of the most surprising developments of this report. If
so, yeah, I advise you to still stay on, even though you're not the biggest Rolex fan. This
entire Rolex CPO is something that's quietly becoming one of the most fascinating stories in
the watch world to me. The Rolex certified pre-owned program. So it was launched in the late 2022. The
watches are sold on the secondary market and now in the second quarter of 2025, it's growing fast
again. Didn't think that was going to happen because after a pause in the first quarter,
the CPO added 12 new retailers and 30 new Sordorus this quarter, which brings it to a total of 116
retailers with 227 Sordorus with roughly 8,500 watches in inventory that hold an estimated value
of around 190 million US dollars. So yeah, didn't think this was going to happen. We saw a decline
of retailers that were part of the CPO program, but now they have obviously watched my video.
Just kidding. Um, no, the report estimates that the sales in this quarter were hit 120 million
dollars, and that would be a plus 20% increase compared to the 100 million in the previous
quarter. And I talked about this in my last report video. We can still see that the top
selling models remain pretty much the same, which are the Datejust, um, Oysterpetuals,
closely followed by the Submariners, uh, the GMTs and the Daytona, which is now very similar to the
models that gained in value retention too. So very interesting connection here. Um,
in terms of pricing, Rolex CPO is still very much above, um, let's call it regular secondary
market premium. The global average CPO premium is now plus 30.8% compared to non-certified listings.
And what's even funnier, if you can call it that, um, is that the range is wildly depending on the
retailer itself. So it's not like every Rolex CPO has some sort of standard pricing. So for example,
the 1916 company in the US exhibits the lowest markups with, I think it's just about plus 16%
on average. Whereas Bucherer, um, which is European is the most expensive. Hooray! With an eye-watering
plus 42% premium. Um, it is crazy for sure. And I wasn't really prepared to see that big of a
difference in pricing because I kind of thought, like I said, that they sort of had a similar
pricing model or some kind of Rolex mandated pricing standard, but I guess I was wrong.
Um, so yeah, um, that's just on a little side note to give you an update on the CPO situation,
because we talked about it the last time and I'm extremely curious to see how this is going to
turn out as the year continues, especially how prices are going to develop. When we get closer
to Christmas, I think this is going to change a lot too. As of now, it seems Rolex is betting on
brand trust to drive the segment. Um, judging by the 120 million in quarterly sales, it's working.
And some of y'all are buying these watches for those prices. So I don't want to see in the
like, who's buying this? A lot of people are, I mean, 120 million. There are people who are willing
to pay this and I mean, fair enough, but yeah, um, let's shift our focus back on the other brands.
More specifically, I want to talk about the middle of the market. So the middle ground of the brands
like, um, IWC and others that are in the 3k to 10k price range, kind of like the sweet spot and see
how they're doing. So at first glance, it looks like these mid-level brands, um, are gaining
traction, but once you peel back the layers, the story gets a little bit more complicated. So
in the second quarter of this year, demand for mid-level watches on the secondary market
remained strong, even as retail sales continue to struggle. So we're seeing record highs in both
supply and sales for brands like Omega, IWC, and even Vacheron Constantin, despite its value drop.
It might sound like a resurgence, you know, more listings, more buyers, more turnover,
but here's the twist. Despite all this activity, secondary prices for the same brands continue to
decline. So let's, you know, just look at a few examples from the value retention leaderboard.
You've got Omega trading at negative 35% below retail, IWC sits at negative 37.4%. Like I said,
Vacheron at a painful 41.1% negative, and even Cartier, the best of the bunch, is still down at
28.2% negative. Why, you may ask? Well, in part because retail prices increased across the board,
largely in response to the US tariffs that kicked in on May 1st. So for example, Cartier had an
increase of 2.8% and Omega showed an increase of 4.3%, and Vacheron had an increase of 6.5%.
So now you've got higher retail prices and falling secondary market prices, which is a
perfect formula for eroding value retention. So this growing disconnect between primary and
secondary prices suggests a bigger trend. So buyers are skipping the boutique and going
straight to the resale market. You know, with those hikes, retail prices are starting to feel
prohibitively high, especially for brands that don't have the same prestige cushion as
Rolex or Pate, for example. And that's exactly what the report predicts, that the secondary
market may benefit at the expense of retail sales if this pricing gap continues. So yes,
these mid-level brands are seeing more action, but it's not a comeback just yet. It's more like a
shift in behavior where buyers are looking for better value outside the showroom, and perhaps
that is something you might have already experienced for yourself, that your first thought no longer
goes directly to the boutique and the boutique experience if you think about buying a watch.
You just go online immediately to check prices if you're interested in a watch on the secondary
market. But yeah, if this trend holds, it definitely has the potential to reshape how
those brands that are sitting in this middle ground, middle position themselves in the next
few years and how they intend to gain back those customers. I mean, we have talked about what's
above the surface, pricing, brand performance, and market polarization, but now I would like to
dive into what's really moving the market behind the scenes. We've got two major forces at play
right now, which is tariffs and retail price hikes and changing market health fundamentals. I know
this might be a lot, but stick with me here. It gets very interesting and it's important. So in Q2
of 2025, every single Chinese brand raised its US retail prices. Highly unusual and unified move,
but I mean politics. Patek Philippe lent with a plus 6.9% increase, then we've got Audemars Piguet
with a 6.7% increase, and others like Vacheron with a 6.5%, IWC with 5%, Omega 4.3%, and Rolex
with 3.1%. These price hikes were largely in response to the 10% US import tariff that went
into effect on May 1st. But here's the thing, these higher retail prices are not being matched
by higher resale values. In fact, despite raising prices, brands saw their value retention, that is
how much of the retail price they keep on the secondary market, all across the board. So let's
look at the examples between April and July of this year. For Patek Philippe, the value retention
dropped 7.4% points, Audemars Piguet had a drop of 6.6%, Vacheron is down 5.2%, and even Rolex
dropped at 2.7% points. Only Cartier, woohoo, saw a minor value retention improvement, but that's
hard to do with them. Like I said, discontinuing underperforming models, so not actual resale growth.
So while retail prices are rising, secondary market prices are either flat or falling, and
this widening gap is changing how consumers behave. So pushing more buyers towards the second-hand
market, especially in the US. But that also raises a critical question, how healthy is the market
underneath all of this? So let's dig into that now. So among the big three, Rolex shows the strongest
fundamentals right now. And what I mean by this is that their inventory supply is shrinking,
so lowest levels in five quarters right now. Then we need to look at the absorption rate, so
the rate at which watches are sold is the highest in six quarters. And we have the age of inventory
that is dropping, meaning, you know, just fresher, faster-moving stock. This shows that Rolex is
balancing supply and demand well. I mean, they've always been doing that quite good. And dealers are
pricing inventory more effectively. But the story isn't as bright for Patek Philippe and Audemars
Piguet. The total supply for both is climbing to record highs, and their age of inventory
is consigning. Your average Audemars Piguet watch is 223 days old, and a Patek Philippe watch sits
for an average of about 175 days. That means many listings are six, eight months old, just
sitting on sale, basically. And that's not even the end of it. The age of inventory is more than
double the days on market for both brands. And yeah, secondary prices are still falling for them.
That tells us that demand is up, but buyers are price-sensitive, and dealers are discounting to
move volume, not to preserve value. So what's really going on here? Well, retail prices are
rising, mostly due to tariffs, but secondary values aren't keeping up, and that's creating
cracks in the market. Overall, Rolex looks solid, but Patek NAP is oversupplied and aging, and the
mid-level brands are selling, but not gaining ground value. It is a market driven less by hype,
and more by fundamentals, as you can see. And right now, those fundamentals are signaling that sellers
need to be smarter, and buyers are getting pickier. But yeah, before we're going to summarize
everything that we talked about just now, I want to take a quick breather, because I
want to highlight some weird facts that I found within all of this, that I'm sure you'll find as
interesting as I do. So yeah, here are your talking points for the next watch me tab. Let's
start with this fun one. Out of nearly 400 Omega models tracked, only one trades above retail,
and it is the Silver Snoopy Speedmaster. It's a 310, 32, 42, 50, 0, 2, 0, 0, 1. Thank you for those
reference numbers, Omega. All other Omega models are selling at least a negative 9% discount.
So yeah, a big shout out to the Silver Snoopy Speedmaster. Despite rising demand and good
turnover, Omega's average value retention still sits at negative 35%. We talked about this,
and it's planet ocean, and the lines are down more than 50%. And then, before we touch on this,
we have Vacheron Constantin, which just became the first brand Morgan Stanley tracks to drop below
negative 40% in value retention. The worst performer, three quarters in a row. Yay.
And while its overseas collection is the brand's strongest, even that only trades at a negative
12.2% discount, which is one model selling above retail. It's the 4520B210AB128, a blue dial
stainless steel variant of the overseas. So yeah. And a little bit about one of my favorite brands
in the market, where most collections fell. The Panthère from Cartier line defied the trend.
Prices jumped plus 9.8% queue on queue, and plus 9.3% over six months. So good job,
Cartier, for that. It is still a small volume collection, but notable exception. Worth watching
if the trend continues. I love Cartier so much. So yeah. Anyways, just a little side facts that
I think are noteworthy and interesting. Definitely always cool to see some less
in-your-face things, in fact, that still have an impact for the brands. And yeah, let's bring all
of this together now. Let's summarize this. So the Q2 2025 watch market report paints a picture
that's more nuanced than just recovery or decline. It's a market in transition, definitely. Stabilizing
in some areas, but under pressure in others. And so overall, the watch charts price tracker declined
just 0.3%, which was the lowest drop in 13th straight quarters of negative movement.
So that is a good thing that it is all like flattening out and that it's not like steep
decline anymore. But this apparent stability was almost entirely due to just, you know,
four brands. Patek Philippe, Cartier, Omega, and Rolex, and everyone else still sliding pretty
much. 29 out of the 35 attract brands declined in Q2. I've talked about this in the beginning.
In 25, dropped more than 1%. So this means that the market is becoming increasingly bifurcated.
So splitting into two distinct groups with very different performance outcomes. So between these,
they call it blue chip survivors, and everyone else that is struggling to stay relevant pretty
much. Every track brand raised retail prices in Q2, in some cases by nearly 7%, largely to
offset the US import tariffs that happened in May. But unfortunately, and very unsurprising,
backfired and their new value retention dropped across the board, especially for Patek, AP,
and Vacheron, now down to 8%. I keep harping on about this, but it's just so shocking. 41.1%.
Underneath the pricing headlines, market health tells the truth. For Rolex, it means
inventory is fresh, demand steady, and turnover is high. For Patek and AP, the inventory is aging.
Supply is climbing. Models lingering up to eight months without being sold, which is tough. I mean,
mid-level brands show strong demand, but you know, like I said, buyers are still very price
sensitive and discounts are now of the norm, which I mean, as a buyer, it's great, as a seller,
not so much. So where does this leave us? Where are we now? The market isn't crashing,
but it is no longer driven by hype. I want to very cautiously say the kind of froth is gone.
Pricing is more rational, I would say. Buyer behavior is more cautious, and brand performance
is more exposed than ever. I would say things are normalizing somehow. We've had crazy years
to look back on, and now it's just kind of slowly, how do you call this? The pendulum,
like, is not so much swinging out as much. It's kind of in the middle. It makes sense if you're
German. There's a saying. Anyways, if you're collecting, flipping, or investing, whatever you
do, this is the time to understand the difference between desirability and durability in terms of
because only a few brands are proving they still have both, and you need that if you want to make
profit, I guess. And that is all I have for you today. I know this has been a long video.
I hope you enjoyed this. What surprised you the most in this pool? Anything that you did not
expect? What are your thoughts about the future? Let me know what you think in the comments down
below. And as always, if you have enjoyed this video, make sure to give it a thumbs up and
subscribe to my channel to not miss a new video. And thank you so much for watching,
and I hope to see you in my next one. Take care. Bye!
