Are There Any Situations Where Whole Life Insurance is a Good Idea?

Finance Shield
6 followers
Mar 24, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
This is an interesting one, Clark. I think I know your answer, but I don't. You know,
we have a lot of young folks who are listening who are starting families and they're buying
their house and stuff. You make yourself sound old when you call them young. He wants everybody
to think he's older than he actually is. And they ask questions around life insurance,
right? And you know, one of the things that we always talk about here is really low cost
term insurance when it makes sense. And so this question came from Restore Sanity. And it says,
hey, are there any situations where whole life might make sense? You know, does it make sense
for me to do that if I'm younger and it's cheaper and it locks in my rate over the long term? What
are your thoughts on that? And I think we're seeing a little bit more of that now. I'm not
sure why, but we seem to be getting that question a lot. Any thoughts on the best way to get
insurance? What type of insurance? And it does like whole life or permanent insurance makes
sense. Yeah. So whole life is really great. If you have a relative who is trying to make it as
an insurance salesperson, they need the sale. I mean, there's almost never a situation that
permanent or whole life insurance is a better choice than buying term because a young family,
they're being pulled a million different directions. And what you're trying to
cover is your kids getting to adulthood, are you getting substantially through your career?
So if you buy typically pretty easily up to 30-year level term, for most of us at the age
that people are having kids now, it will cover both your kids growing up and the core of your
working lifetime because you'll likely be in your 60s at that point. And so you cover that time.
So the whole life thing, let's say you're in a position where your family has a really bad
genetic history of an illness that might later disqualify you to qualify for insurance. And
you're really worried about money much later in life. And you're willing to pay the massive amount,
I don't know, 20 times the premiums or whatever it is for a whole life versus level term.
And you're really, really worried about the genetic time bomb going off and you not being
able to underwrite for insurance in the future. That would be a case where permanent insurance
would make sense. But keep it simple, level term, none of these exotic variable and universal and
index, blah, blah, blah, life insurance things that have massive commissions and not even the
selling it to you has any idea what the policy actually does or how it might blow up on you.
The only thing I would add to that is some term policies,
you would pay a little bit of a premium, but they are convertible to some type of permanent
insurance. So if you are worried about that underwriting time bomb that you might have,
there are ways it will put a premium on that term policy, but it's going to be substantially cheaper
than if you just start from jump street with the whole life, that's got a huge cost
that you don't deal with term insurance. The other thing with whole life is people
don't buy enough coverage because the premiums, the salesman's trying to sell your salesperson,
trying to sell you what they think they'll get you to say yes to in your budget. And you're
not going to have enough death coverage for your loved ones where with term life,
you can buy a benefit easily 10 times what you make in a year and the premiums will be tiny.
Is that your rule of thumb, how much insurance someone should buy 10 times annual income?
So I say that just as a back of the envelope thing, because most people are never going to
run through one of those tools that will take what you owe and what you earn and what your
obligations are and come up with an exact number. So as a default, I just say buy 10 times.
10 times.
The worst thing that happens is your survivor got too much money from you
because you bought 10 times your annual income.
So Clark, I have to ask because one of the things we do is we do TikTok react videos.
You spend a lot of time on TikTok?
See, I knew that, but here's what's funny. So TikTok is out there. I got to tell you,
you would be shocked at how much of the bad TikTok advice, we could do hours of it,
is pushing whole life insurance. And I think it is so interesting you have this
cutting social media tool app, and yet they've gone back to trying to push whole life. It's all
about the money that is to be made, that conflict of interest. I always ask, what do you get paid
for this product? And the other thing, the contrarian in me always says, what do the
insurance companies do with that money? Because what they do, they can give you a guarantee
because they usually restrict your behavior by overcharging on the premiums, or if it's
some other type of permanent type solution, they'll restrict your ability to pull money
out for like a decade. They will invest that money. That's what they're doing with a lot of
those resources. So cut out them making that money and just guaranteeing you just a small,
small amount. You actually, I like the old saying, buy a term, invest the difference,
and it really can be good for you in the long term.
You pointed something out with TikTok, is the marketers at companies are very smart
using influencers, using every form of social media to spread their message about why you
should do something that's going to make the company more money. And somebody will have a
engaging personality, be a great communicator, will have a certain edginess to them, and people
are like, yeah, I really trust that person. And so they get into it, and people don't realize
until much later that person who they believed in so much, that was pay for play. They were
getting paid to sell you down the river, and they're going down the river in a nice boat,
and you got nothing, because they're the ones who made the money and the company they're pitching
for made the money. And I don't want to go on too much of a sidebar, but I've noticed some
consequent, I know you're on tangents. I've noticed content creators that I felt like went into it
with pure heart, they were going to become content creators in personal finance, but then they get a
taste. And I'm not saying this is a bad thing, but crypto is one of those things where I've seen
people who've gotten a taste of the VIG, or the commissions, or the referral fees,
or the affiliate marketing on crypto, and all of a sudden now all their content is pushing
all this stuff. It goes back, we've said it earlier, and I'm not saying anything's
bad about cryptos necessarily. Oh, why not? Why don't we infuriate people and get into talking
about crypto? You're nice, you don't try to upset, but it is one of those things where I think that
people always ask, what is somebody getting paid? Or what do they benefit? That's why I do love the
abundance cycle is because we tell you, come take the free information, reach that level of success,
and then that's when you can come and have the feeling services. And I love how you've always
paid it forward to Clark. You were just so generous with the way you give out information.
And that's why everybody go check out Clark.com. And I think you'll see that there's a reason when
I had families, because I think most people think financial advisors
can tell you how to get out of bankruptcy, or deal with bankruptcy, or to get out of bad debt.
And I always used to say, no, go listen to Clark Howard. He's going to tell you how to,
you know, if you go to Clark.com, he'll tell you how to freeze your credit. He'll tell you how to,
you know, work with the credit card companies on negotiating. You are a great resource for
the people who are struggling with basic discipline too. And that's a powerful tool.
Thank you. And I'm not, thank goodness, I'm not the Lone Ranger. There are several people
that are trying to help people get control of their finances because people accept information
and adapt information differently from different people. And it's great that there are, in addition
to me, there are other people doing this as well. And you find who it is you connect to
and use his or her guidance and advice to get control of your wallet, to be in charge.
You know, I never want you to live an anxious life where you're afraid of what's going on in
your life with money. And so, it really is about you lowering the voltage and getting rid of those
anxious moments. I think about how many people in a couple fight about money. And it's not because
there's too much, it's because there's too little. And it can disintegrate a great, what could be a
great relationship otherwise. So, this is key to your personal happiness and your sense of control
and your relationships to have your money act together. And so, that's why this is so important
to me is that people do, it's basic blocking and tackling, getting your finances under control.
But it all starts here. It all starts in the head and whoever reaches you emotionally, mentally,
that's who you want to get that guidance from to get your spending under control and
get you on a path that feels more freeing than where you are right now.
