The Charles Leclerc lap that's exposed how F1 2026 has ruined qualifying

Formula 1 News
151 followers
59 Video ViewsĀ·Mar 24, 2026
AI GeneratedĀ·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
There has been so much talk about the peculiarities of these 2026 Formula 1 cars and the impact
they're having on the way they are driven, but it's taken a few races and pre-season testing
to really get a handle on some of the more extreme quirks, should we say, and the extent
of the problem. Drivers have used words like odd, counterintuitive and strange to describe
what they're doing. But John Noble, it was really during the Chinese Grand Prix weekend
that we started to get a deeper understanding of how extreme some of these effects are.
Yeah, I think Australia was an eyes wide open moment for everybody. New rules, new cars,
nobody knew what to expect, how it would play out, what the reality was. And that weekend caught a
lot of people by surprise. I think there was a kind of a toe in the water exercise for understanding
energy harvesting, energy deployment and how to get the most out of it. China was a different
picture completely. So a track not as energy starved. We had sprint qualifying and a main
qualifying, so two sessions to understand it. And we finally got, I think, not only a proper
picture of how these cars are, but also the complexities, the madness, as one team boss
described to me, of the rules and how difficult it is for drivers not only to get the best out
of these cars, but to understand what's going on. Exactly. What was clear in Australia was
there were a lot of strange deployment patterns, but trying to connect cause and effect was
extremely difficult for teams as well as for those of us on the outside. But we've got the
perfect case study, a smoking gun, if you like. So we're going to look at some data provided by
the excellent GP Tempo website, which lets you analyse all sorts of data from every single on
track F1 session and race. And so we're going to be looking at Charles Leclerc in sprint
qualifying. He did two quick laps in SQ3 and the difference between the first and the second one
is going to show how a minute difference can have a profound impact. Now, Leclerc's final
flying lap is in white. The first flying lap is the red trace. And it's something we see in the
white trace, the second and final flying lap that set his grid position that really, really does
reveal what we're dealing with. This is a fascinating example because it was something
that confused both Ferrari and Charles himself. During this lap in SQ3, Charles had been up
in the first section of the lap and the time bled away on the back straight. He lost power,
lost deployment, came on the team radio and he went, what the hell is happening? He said,
this deployment, my God, straight after the session, no answer from him, no answer from
the team about what had happened. But you look at the telemetry data and we can see it here.
All that time bleeds away on that back straight. The peak speed doesn't go as high as 320 versus
about 329 and he's up to 15 kilometers an hour slower all the way down the back straight. Now,
our understanding is normally is how your harvest going into a corner basically decides how good
your deployment is coming out of it. But if we look at the previous section, turns 11, 12 and 13,
there's very little difference there. So it doesn't seem to be an obvious
explanation. You need to look much further back in the lap to work out what's happened.
Now, you can look at that straight between turns 10 and turns 11 and you can see there's a lot more
speed in that second lap from Leclerc. Much more power is being deployed and that doesn't
particularly make much sense. And the reason now, and we can see it here on the trace,
is there's a slight throttle lift. Coming out of turn 10, and we can see this from the onboard,
Charles has a slight oversteer moment as the back steps out. He lifts off the throttle
and this bizarrely, due to quirks in the rules, triggers a power boost randomly. And that power
boost burns through more power than he wants and then leaves him without power coming down the back
straight. Yeah, and this comes all down to the arcane rules regarding the change of what you're
doing with the MG UK, whether you're deploying, how much you're deploying, whether you're harvesting,
mode switching, and this is where it starts to get very, very complicated. So,
what exactly happens differently between if he was at, say, 100% throttle when he should have been
and where he was at about 95% throttle? Because this all comes down to all sorts of interesting
phrases like power limited pending and all this kind of thing that starts to get very,
very difficult to get your head around. Yeah, this is a really complicated air of the rules.
So complicated, in fact, that I was speaking to a technical director of a leading team in the
paddock on Sunday morning trying to piece this together and get my understanding of the rules
and he didn't know. He shrugged his shoulders, said he wasn't particularly sure, but he would
go and speak to some coding experts in the team to find out and he did find out and we spoke later
and we've pulled the picture together. So, basically what's happening is there are some
straights on a lap where, because the cars are energy starved, you don't want to burn through
as much power. You don't want maximum deployment. You want to limit your deployment as much as
possible, but you've got competing elements in the rules. On one side, you've got to deploy a
minimum of 200 kilowatts coming out of a corner, but on the other side, you can't just switch off
the power. There's a thing called the wrap down rate that limits you and it wasn't China. It was
100 kilowatts per second. So, your perfect corner, say from turns 10 to 11, is you come out of the
corner, you go past 98% throttle, which triggers something in the rules called power limited
pending, which puts you into the minimum of 200 kilowatts for one second and then the power can't
change and then after that one second is complete, you can then go into ramp down rate. So, your
power then can reduce by 100 kilowatts a second and you can end up minimising your power burn
in that section. But this 98% throttle application is really important because Charles came off to
95% according to Ferrari. In the temperature data here, it's 96, but I think we'll go to the Ferrari
version of 95. So, it's at 95%, which effectively resets the entire procedure. So, having been in
power limited pending or in ramp down beforehand, suddenly he's back up to full power. The 200
kilowatts is back in play for a full second. His derating is back in play for later on in that whole
straight and he's burning through more power than he wants. He's unleashing, using up energy in an
area of the track where there's no benefit. You don't want to burn power here, you want to save
it for the back straight and this is effectively what derailed his lap and from something so
innocuous that was a tiny lift, slight oversteer moment coming out of one corner that he then paid
the price for almost 20-30 seconds later. And you can see in the data that it gives him a very small
gain on that run to turn 11, but that's entirely out of whack with the loss he sustains on that
main back straight. That's what it is in terms of the trade-off. You can always gain time by
deploying on a straight, but if you deploy on a straight where it's not very effective and you
can't later, that's a huge threat. You're talking tenths of a second swings. It can make or break
a lap, make the difference between qualifying first or seventh or third or seventh or whatever.
Really, really profound impacts and this is why if you're a driver like Charles Leclerc,
you're complaining that you can't do these crazy qualifying laps when you're a little
bit on the edge. The one that springs to mind for me is Singapore in 2019, a fantastic pole
position lap, but he has a good three moments on that lap where he's right on the limit,
leaning on the rear of the car, using that amazing throttle sensitivity to control what he's doing,
but I think that lap, which is one of the great qualifying laps, the great pole laps of the past
decade, would not be possible with these cars. Do you like what we do and want more? Then you
need your 2026 F1 Paddock Pass with the Race Members Club. Join us around the world for
exclusive updates and expert analysis, bonus podcasts and ad-free videos, and link up with
the thriving community of like-minded fans. Whether we're in the studio, trackside, hearing
from big F1 names or on the road, we're always speaking direct to the fans. This is your last
chance to take up our offer of 90% off your first month with the Race Members Club. Hit the link
below to claim your discount. Now, there's another example from sprint qualifying that we can have a
look at involving Esther Banocon, isn't there, in Turn 13. Yeah, very similar thing. I spoke to
Esther Banocon in the pen on Sunday to ask him about this qualifying oddity, shall we call it.
He said he had the exact same thing. As you can see from the data, going through Turn 13 has a
little moment, lifts off the throttle. Now, Esther Ban says he went to 97%, so we're talking
1% difference that puts him outside of power limited pending and outside of the possibility
to be derating or ramping down, and that's enough. He says that cost him three tenths,
so Ferrari's estimate was that Charles's little moment coming out of Turn 10 cost him between
four and five tenths on the back straight. The consequence of all this is, and from Charles's
perspective, you don't want to push anymore in qualifying. You need to be sure that you come
out of corners very smooth on the throttle, no chance of any oversteer, and I'm not sure we want
qualifying to be like this. As you say, we want drivers to be pushing on the edge. We need them
to be taking risks because qualifying should be a battle of drivers pushing things to the limit,
trying to dig deeper than they've ever done for those final hundreds of seconds,
not I need to play it safe just so I don't get derated four corners later. Yeah, 100%, it's
absolutely not what's needed in qualifying. This goes far beyond trade-offs in terms of how you
drive and trading off entry speed against exit speed and all that kind of thing. It's far beyond
even managing the tyres, the temperature-sensitive Pirelli tyres on qualifying laps because it's just
these tiny things that encourage drivers to keep the cars on rails, and that's the thing that
Formula One has long wanted to reduce, so these live-wire qualifying laps are no longer possible,
and there's all sorts of other tangential effects to this. Oscar Piastri said in China when he was
talking about Australia qualifying, he said, well, I was getting more and more confident,
carrying more and more speed in qualifying. That was actually making me slower on the straights
because it impacts your harvesting. So just globally, this is a huge concern, and you've
also got the fact of if you've got high-speed corners, it's often better to harvest in those
rather than being right at the limit of grip, so you're encouraged to drive inside Turn 9 in
Australia was a good example of that, and this strikes absolutely at the heart of the driver's
challenge in qualifying, and I think is a huge problem, but it also can impact racing as well
because this effect is still there anytime you're driving the car, and I think if you look, there's
a point where Pierre Gasly is leading the midfield fight, and at the restart, he has a moment coming
out of the last corner, and then Olly Behrmann drives past him, and that decides who wins the
midfield fight, who finishes fifth in the Grand Prix, because Gasly then gets caught up with
battling with Verstappen, etc. He could well have stayed ahead, and he complained of having no
deployment, and most likely, that wasn't an unexpected fault. It was just a consequence of
you have a little moment, you have a lift, and you are in trouble, so this has implications for what's
happening in racing. Again, overall, John, this just underlines why it's way beyond what control
the drivers have. Drivers can't tell the difference of a few percent of throttle travel. The throttle
travel isn't very big on these cars. Isaac Hadjar was talking on Thursday about the impact on lift
and coast in particular, because you have to lift and coast, you have to monitor and manage that on
qualifying laps as well, given the battery capacity and the amount you're allowed to harvest,
so he said, you know, the difference between 30% and 35% throttle if you're lifting off can make
a huge difference to the pace in your qualifying lap, and I can't feel that difference in my
leg. So, this is a great example of the full scale of the problem, and how it's way beyond
what can reasonably be expected of drivers, and also puts them into a position where they have to
be more contained and drive within themselves. Yeah, exactly. When you speak to people in the
paddock, and, you know, you and I are up and down around the Shanghai paddock and pit lane speaking
to people, one of the consistent messages from everybody is these rules are over-complicated,
that there's been many layers of compromises and aims to cure one problem triggers other problems
elsewhere. If we look at formation laps, for example, there is a recharge limit for each
racing lap or each lap a car does. It counts for the formation lap, but that doesn't take into
account that the typical behaviour on a formation lap is very different to how it would be during
a racing lap. You're braking heavily to warm your brakes up, you want to accelerate a lot to get
some heat into your rear tyres, but if you're limited in terms of your rechargeability, then
that hampers you, and in Australia this is what caught out a lot of drivers. Kimi Antonelli's
tyres, for example, when he got off the front of the grid were at 30 degrees centigrade, so they
were very, very cold, because he'd hit his recharge limit, couldn't use up any more battery,
so couldn't do any burnouts, and had this problem. There's other problems like the control line,
where the control line is on the grid, that resets your power for your lap, so cars at the
front of the grid that do their burnouts across this line, all that power they use counts for
that lap. Cars at the back that cross this control line at speed get a reset, so have more power
available, so you can get into a better position for the starts. So a lot of details, I think,
with these regulations that need working through. We know there's a big technical meeting that's
set up for after the Japanese Grand Prix to work through things, and I think one of the aims of
this will be to maybe get rid of some of these complications that have been exposed. I think
the Charles Leclerc example that we've pulled out here and talked about and looked at in detail
is a classic example of a regulation that's been introduced. This 98% limit isn't anything new,
it's been in the regs for almost a decade, I think. It's aimed at improving safety to stop
cars suddenly slowing on the exit of corners. It's been tweaked a little bit alongside other
regulations to stop teams playing around with traction control, to having switches or set
throttle positions that can trigger power reductions to be a form of traction control,
for example. But it's triggered unintended consequences that Oscar Piastri has talked
about. You solve one problem, you cause a few more. So I think there is a case now to, let's
simplify these regulations, let's put more control back in the hands of the drivers,
because if a driver makes a mistake from pushing hard in one corner and suffers five corners later
and the whole lap is derailed, I'm not sure that's a good spectacle for Formula 1. Absolutely not.
In qualifying, I'd go as far as to say it's disastrous for Formula 1. People talk about the
DNA of Formula 1 and that kind of thing, but this is complete and utter anathema to the challenge
of a qualifying lap. Now, you have to keep in mind, this is different to the debate about the
nature of the racing and the battery passes and all that kind of thing. You can make a case
that that's an interesting consequence of the regulations, and I don't think anyone would
deny it's made times the races in Australia and China much more dramatic than they would
have been. There's a separate debate about the nature of that. And it's worth noting that as
this effect has an impact on tactics and racing in terms of how you force a mistake. So,
you could kind of deal with that for Sundays, but for Saturdays or for Fridays as sprint qualifying
is on, given that's where the examples we're talking from, it is terrible for Formula 1 that
this happens. All of these rules and regulations are there for good reasons, but it is a fantastic
example of the law of unintended consequences, that the aggregate of all these measures that
have been introduced for sound reasons, they come together to undo something absolutely
fundamental to Grand Prix racing. You want a driver at the limit, on the limit, you want them
controlling that tyre slip and just with the rear end on the brink of stepping out or just stepping
out at corner exits like that Leclerc qualifying lap at Singapore in 2019, because those are the
moments that fans love, they're the moments that drivers love. And this is absolutely at the heart
of why drivers are complaining about this. For my money, Formula 1 has got to find a way
to sort this element or it risks losing something magical from Grand Prix racing.
