The UK Constitution - Public Law.

History of Law
11 followers
9 Video Views·Mar 24, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome back everybody to Public Law. As promised this is going to be the lesson where we finally
start to look specifically at the UK constitution. We're going to take an overview of some of the
most important aspects of the UK's constitutional setting, we'll take an overview of the sources of
the UK constitution, the structure of the UK government, as well as the different ways in
which a change slash amendment to the constitution can be made. We'll also be comparing this of
course and contrasting it to other constitutions which have differences in the ways in which they
operate. We'll be talking about the, like I've said, the introduction to the sources of the UK
constitution, changing the constitution and the basic structure of the constitution, imbuing one
of the most interesting principles of the UK constitution, which is this idea of the separation
of powers. Now these are all going to be, this lesson is going to essentially provide as a
precursor to a far more in-depth series of lessons on each of these different topics. So we're going
to talk in far more detail about the sources and the principles and the basic structure of the UK
constitution as we go on throughout the rest of this series on constitutional law. So as a brief
recap, we know the following things about the UK's constitutional framework. We know the following
things to be true. We know that our constitution is one, uncodified. We know that it is a flexible
constitution as a result of the fact that it is uncodified. We know that this is what brings in
with it this idea of flexibility versus rigidity and contrasting that to the idea of codified
constitutions which are not flexible, which are rigid in their nature. We also know that it is
somewhat of a unitary constitution. We note that this is contrasted with the idea of federalism
and federal constitutions where you have the separation of powers not just being horizontal
but also being vertical between different areas and different levels of government. So the United
States, for example, has a federal government which oversees the entire country. They then
also have state governments which oversees the legal, some of the legal issues in those particular
states and then they also have local governments. Now the UK's constitution is far more unitary
in the sense that the supreme source of authority and power, at least when it comes to the creation
of new law, comes from the central government itself. It comes from Parliament through the
principle of parliamentary sovereignty. However, given the fact that we now also have various
different legislatures that exist at state levels, i.e. at country levels, when we have a look at the
Scottish Parliament, the Welsh Assembly, the Northern Ireland Assembly, then there is this
debate to be had about whether or not the UK is truly a unitary constitution or whether it may
be considered to be something of a quasi-federal constitution. It's federal in some senses in that
it looks quite federal, it looks like there are sort of different levels of government,
but at the true heart of the UK's constitution you still have this unitary centralization of power
and we'll get to that in more detail when we look at devolution. So given the fact that the UK
constitution is uncodified, it is not written down in a single place, where is the UK's constitution?
Where can we find it? Well, because it's uncodified, not written down in a single place, it derives from
a number of different sources. Where can we find it? Well, there are various different sources in
which we can look at the UK constitution, the first of which includes parliamentary statutes.
So a piece of legislation that is passed by Parliament would therefore then contribute to
the constitution as a whole. Now, some people argue that it doesn't necessarily make sense to
suggest that all pieces of parliamentary statute contribute to the UK constitution, but only those
pieces of statute that are particularly constitutional in nature. And there is a
non-exhaustive list that we can that we can cite that looks at the types of legislation which may
be considered to be constitutional. Maybe legislation that refers to the structure of
government, the way in which the government operates and proceeds, or maybe
legislation that talks about and expresses the relationship between the government and the people.
So things like the Human Rights Act, for example, is definitely considered to be a constitutional
statute because it refers to the relationship that is had between the government, between the state
and between the people in terms of enshrining their rights in law. You also have things like
the Constitutional Reform Act which essentially moves the, which makes a very significant change
to the role of a Lord Chancellor within the government system, and it also establishes
the Supreme Court. So this is what is considered to be the distinction between constitutional
parliamentary statutes and just general ordinary parliamentary statutes. But at least it is the
case that one of the major sources of the UK Constitution is parliamentary statute in and of
itself. A second major source of the UK Constitution is the Common Law, law that is made by judges,
law that is made through cases and through various principles of precedent and stare decisis. There
are a number of different generalized principles and ideas that are enshrined by the Common Law.
There are also different principles and ideas which the Common Law utilizes to interpret
parliamentary statute. So you will have lots of different examples of judicial review cases where
the interpretation of a particular piece of legislation is put under scrutiny by the Court
of Appeal or the Supreme Court and is examined in this regard. And this also contributes to a further
understanding and a further deepening of the UK's constitutional setting, the result of which means
that it contributes to a major source of the UK Constitution. We also have what are known as
authoritative works, so works of authority. So these are often books, which are often quite old
in fact, which have very much, which have a lot of authority in terms of the ways in which they
explain and enshrine the different details of the UK's constitutional framework. So for example,
A. B. Dicey's Introduction to the Law of the Constitution from the 1800s is considered to be
because it outlines and derives various principles pertaining to the rule of law
and also pertaining to parliamentary sovereignty, all of which contributes to our understanding of
the Constitution. If you want to look a little bit more at the internal workings of specific branches
of the UK government, you might say that Erskine May is a very particularly
authoritative work on the inner workings of Parliament and how parliamentary procedure operates.
You then also have Law of the European Union. I've put a little asterisk there because of course
we are no longer members of the European Union, but before we left the European Union, the UK
Constitution was quite heavily influenced by the various laws and principles which derived out of
the EU, whether that be through the treaty law that existed within either the Law on the European
Union or the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, or whether it was the kind of
secondary legislation, whether that be directives and regulations for example, that contributes to
the Constitution. These are considered to be the legal and particularly non-legal sources of the
UK Constitution. A further non-legal source of the UK Constitution is known as a constitutional
convention. Now conventions are seen to be sort of the general rules of thumb which are followed by
pretty much everybody and they're sort of universally accepted as being binding despite
the fact that they are not enforceable and despite the fact that sometimes people may
actually violate various conventions. We will get to the process of how conventions are made
as well as the different principles and the different variations of the different conventions
which exist when we look at that in more detail in future lessons time. So given the fact that
the UK's Constitution at least is made from a number of different sources,
what is the process by which you can make a change to the UK's Constitution?
Well comparing this to the US system for instance, we see that the process of the US
constitutional amendment process is very difficult. We've noted already in previous lessons that it
requires two-thirds majority in Congress and then it requires three-quarter majority
representation within the state legislatures which is a significant amount of support for a
particular amendment to be made to the US Constitution. This is why we say and suggest
that the US Constitution is entrenched and it is very rigid. It is often very difficult to change
hence why there has only ever been 27 amendments and in fact there's only ever been 17 amendments
after the Bill of Rights. Well when it comes to the UK's Constitution making a change is
very very easy. There are three main ways in which you can make a change to the UK's Constitution.
You can change the law which is enacted by Parliament, i.e. Parliament will just be able
to pass a new law which makes a fundamental change to the UK's Constitution. Parliamentary
legislation was important and vital to the process by which the United Kingdom leaves
the European Union and so as such the EU Withdrawal Act for example from 2020 contributes significantly
to a change in the UK's constitutional framework. In addition to this Parliament could just as easily
tomorrow leave the European Convention on Human Rights and revoke the Human Rights Act of 1998.
Again this could be done with a single vote, if there was a majority of course, a single vote
in Parliament which would then remove those particular pieces of constitutional
legislation and the result of which is they change the Constitution by that means. You may
also have the passing of judicial decisions, the handing down of a judicial decision
can make a change to the Constitution either by making a change to specific judicial precedent
or making a change by adding to judicial precedent, by adding to new circumstances and situations
whereby a particular legal case has been brought. Again this is another way in which the Constitution
can change and it can change particularly quickly. There is also the change in the existing practice
of constitutional conventions. Again we will get to this in more detail when we look at conventions
and how new conventions form versus how old conventions sort of wither away over time,
but that's one of the other ways in which we can make a fundamental change to the Constitution.
Finally then let's look at the basic structure of the UK's constitutional framework. We know that
the UK Constitution is structured in the following way. We have the legislature, we have the
legislative branch. The legislature is the institution within government which is responsible
for making and passing new laws, new statutes. These come from Parliament, Westminster
Parliament and Parliament is the supreme authority for the legislature in the United Kingdom.
You then have the executive branch of government which is responsible for the enforcement
of new laws and is found in the UK government. So we often make a delineation between the UK
government, specifically the executive branch being called the UK government, and the UK government
more broadly as in the entire structure of the system itself. So I'll try and be very clear when
I make this delineation, but when we talk about the executive branch and the prime minister
and the various ministers of state and the civil service, this is often also described as the
and the relationship between the government and Parliament for example, even though you can also
describe the UK government as the whole structure of Parliament, the courts, the executive etc etc etc.
So just a quick overview there of that delineation that is made. Then finally you have
the judiciary. The judiciary is responsible for the interpretation and the application of law.
The most senior institution of which we find within the judiciary is the UK Supreme Court.
Now you might think that this is a particularly simple way of understanding the structure of the
UK's constitution. This is a principle known as the separation of powers, the idea that various
different powers are divided among each different branch of government so that no one branch becomes
too powerful. So if you are the legislative branch you shouldn't have the responsibility
of making law, enforcing law and then interpreting that same law that you have made, because then
that can lead to situations of bias and it can lead to situations where that one institution
becomes too powerful. However when we look at the UK's system of separation of powers we will note
that it's a little bit more complicated than as described here. Even though there are three
distinct branches within the UK system, we do have a legislature, we do have an executive and we do
have a judiciary, they're not so separate in the same way as for example the United States system
may be completely separate and we'll get to that when we start looking at the various principles
of the UK constitution.
