InFocus featuring MA Taxpayers Foundation President Doug Howgate

Western Massachusetts News, Weather & Sports
497 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 23, 2026
InFocus with Patrick Berry featuring Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation President Doug Howgate.
AI Generated·May contain errors
From the 22 News Plus studio,
this is 22 News In Focus with Patrick Berry.
Hello everyone. And welcome to this edition of In Focus.
I'm your host Patrick Berry.
Today we've got an exciting conversation because we're talking about an
organization that's actually keeping their eyes out to make sure you and I and
all of our tax money and our government is operating the way it should be.
Joining me across the desk today is Doug Haugate.
He is the president of the Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation.
Doug, thank you so very much for joining me.
Thanks so much for having me.
And I apologize because you,
the organization has been in existence for more than 90 years and I have never
heard of it. So, which is why you're in the, you're in the hot seat today.
I do want to learn about it, but before we get into that,
how did you become president?
Have you been with the organization a number of years and kind of got natural
career progression?
Sure. So I've worked for the organization a couple of different times.
So we'll talk about it,
but MassTaxpayers is basically a public policy think tank here in Massachusetts.
And a lot of our work relates to the state budget and state finances.
And so my career,
much of it has been spent in the state house in roles related to the state
budget, the Senate Ways and Means Committee,
and in the Senate president's office. And so when I left the state house,
So you were an elected official at one point?
No, no, no. Always staff.
And went to work at MassTaxpayers as a researcher,
left for a stint to go back, work as a staffer in the state house,
and then came back, uh, about five years ago, uh,
to work as the executive vice president of research at MTF.
And then when the Eileen McEnany, my predecessor left,
I became president about three years ago.
So you must know a lot about the inner
operations of what goes on at Beacon Hill. You, you've,
you've not only worked as a staffer there, but you also do oversight of the,
correct me if I'm oversight the right word.
Yeah. We, we certainly analyze and assess the state budget,
major pieces of legislation.
So you get to see things a lot differently than me,
than probably a lot of our viewers.
It has to be an eyeopening position to do what you do
to better understand how government operates and how the
people are best represented, um, not only in our voice, but in our,
our, our, our tax dollars too.
Sure. Yeah. No,
I think one of the things that we do quite a bit of is we do presentations or
briefings for a variety of groups, right?
So whether it's members of the public select boards, things like that.
And I think a lot of what we do is try to translate stuff.
That's really important to communities, really important to people,
cities and towns, as you say, how their tax dollars are being spent,
the choices we're making collectively about where we're going to invest in the
state and trying to translate what's happening in the state budget or other
legislative vehicles to what's relevant for folks in their communities.
So you just made a passing comment about local communities. Do you,
do you analyze local communities too,
or just state finances and state our focus is
primarily on state finances, though.
We've done reports on local finances as well, but as you might imagine,
some of the major spending areas in the state budget are school aid for cities
and towns or unrestricted local aid. And actually much of my background,
much of the background of our research director relates to public school
finance, which is a huge municipal finance issue.
And so there's a really close interconnection between those local finance
issues and the state budget.
Well, local school,
every community has got to be at least more than 50% of every community's
budget.
It's the largest driver of spending in every community in Massachusetts.
So how many, how many staffers does, does the foundation have?
So we have eight staffers.
We've actually been growing in recent years because there's always more to do.
And there's always more policy areas of interest for us to focus on in recent
years, we've started to do a lot more on housing policy,
early education and care policy, infrastructure policy, demographics.
And so we're looking to try to make sure we've got a staff that can,
they can accommodate that,
but there's always more to look at than there are people.
So you've kind of gone back and forth between your time as a staffer on Beacon
Hill and with the foundation. Have,
have has the staff done similar roles or to have,
because you have an incredible insight because of your, your career path.
Do you, do the, do the staff have similar, like in different varying insights?
It's a mix.
So we definitely do have folks who have similar backgrounds to me in terms of
working in the state house, working on the state budget.
We have folks who have a background get, you know, in academia,
we have an, you know, an economist,
we have folks who worked in other areas of government, but it's, it's a mix.
That's fascinating. So you must love what you do that.
Oh, it's great. It's, it's, you know, I was lucky enough.
I got a job at the state house when I graduated from college.
It wasn't really what I had planned to do. And I got to meet, let me interrupt her.
What'd you plan to do?
So I thought I'd work for a couple of years, go to law school,
do something like that. You know, it didn't really know,
but it was just a place that seemed kind of interesting to work for a couple of
years.
And I think it gives you a really interesting perspective on the state you live
in on your community,
on some of the issues that you hear about or talk about with your friends,
kind of seeing those in action, both for good or for bad.
And so it's really been a great career field.
And then I've I thoroughly enjoyed my time working in the state house and
working directly on policy,
but I've also really enjoyed the role that mass taxpayers plays that as you say,
really is to kind of shine a light on what is happening and what it meant and
what it means to Massachusetts and the people who live here.
So are you a, a, I mean,
Massachusetts is by far a Democrat one state.
So are you a Democrat organization?
Are you a Republican organization?
We're nonpartisan. So we're a 501C3.
And so, and we take that kind of independence very seriously.
We want to make sure, first of all,
we want to make sure we maintain our 501C3 status as a unbiased
research organization, looking at issues that matter to folks.
But we also know that for folks to listen to what we say and to take our
research seriously, I think there,
we have to have credibility in terms of independence.
And so we're nonpartisan you know,
certainly every individual staffer has their own ideological beliefs,
but we work really hard,
I think to try to make sure the research and recommendations we're providing are
in line with our mission and are in line with strong public finances and a
strong economy for the Commonwealth.
What is the feedback you get from those in elected office to your work?
It depends on what we say, but generally speaking, I think what I, I,
I think I come from a tradition of folks who've led mass taxpayers who did a
really good job of building the organization's reputation as a place where you
might not always agree with their position on an issue,
but you're going to know that they take that position for reasons that are
apparent, that are consistent with their mission,
and that they communicate fairly.
Mass taxpayers was led by a guy named Mike Widmer for a number of years,
who was kind of a, and still is kind of a legend up on Beacon Hill,
I think for, for, for doing that role in a really tricky way, right?
Where you are, whatever issue you're going to weigh in on,
there are going to be people who feel on different sides.
How do you communicate what you think is appropriate for the commissions or the
organization's mission?
And also do it in a way where you want to make sure that you're not just seeing
this kind of throwing bombs or trying to embarrass people. Uh,
and then my predecessor, Eileen McEnany, I think did a very good job as well.
So we work really hard to try to make sure that we maintain constructive
relationships with the folks that we work with.
But at the same time, at the end of the day,
we're going to do the analysis and the recommendations that we think make the
most sense.
Fantastic. We've got plenty more to talk about,
but we were up on our first commercial break. Stay, stay with us.
We're back in just a minute.
This is 22 news in focus with Patrick Berry.
Welcome back everyone to this edition of in focus.
I'm your host Patrick Berry sitting across the desk from me from the
Massachusetts taxpayers foundation is their president Doug Howgate. Doug,
thank you for joining me. Fascinating information already.
And I love the fact that you are a middle of the road unbiased
organization. You're basically doing research,
interpreting the data and presenting the data. And as you said,
sometimes one side doesn't like the data. Sometimes they love the data.
Um, what are some of the things that,
that residents really need to know? Like some,
what are some of the research projects and the data and the analysis that you've
done that here in 2026 that residents really need to know about?
I think recently it's,
it's been a lot about the connection of demographics and public policy here in
Massachusetts, right? So when we think about the future success of Massachusetts,
whether it's your local school budget or, uh, in your community,
the fact that Massachusetts has had some challenging demographic trends,
like other Northeastern states for the going back 20 or 30 years,
some of those trends really accelerated during the pandemic.
And we're now seeing this kind of, uh, uh,
intersection of some demographic trends during the pandemic,
some challenges with the state economy and a real reduction in international
immigration really poses some challenges for the future of the Massachusetts
labor force. And that directly ties back to this issue.
We hear a lot about about migration, right?
Are people moving from Massachusetts to other states more often than they're
moving to Massachusetts?
And that really is about issues of affordability and making sure Massachusetts is
a place that people can afford to live in and want to live in.
And so those have been a lot of the issues we've been focusing on.
So in your research,
have you found that people are leaving Massachusetts in greater numbers than
arriving in Massachusetts?
Yes. And so Massachusetts historically has seen a net negative
outflow of folks in what's called domestic out migration. And we're not alone.
Yeah. So, so that more people move to Massachusetts to others,
more to other states from Massachusetts than the reverse.
And that's been a relatively consistent trend really going back several decades.
But, but we've seen a real downturn in that.
So a real increase in the, in the number of people leaving Massachusetts on a net
basis over the last four or five years. And when you look into the data,
what you see that's a little different from before is usually when you see these
downturns and people leaving, it's directly related to a economic recession.
You know, if people are leaving to find jobs,
that really wasn't what we were seeing during the pandemic.
And what we are seeing though,
is folks on the wealthier side of the income spectrum,
leaving a disproportionate to the share of the population,
but also lower working class families leaving probably due to affordability
issues here.
And the thing that's probably most concerning that we talk about is the one of
the biggest age group that we see leaving is that 25 to 44 year old group.
Really? Yeah. Which is a huge primary earners. Exactly.
And then the folks who are going to have kids who are going to be your later
force in 20 or 30 years. Right.
And so that's a huge public policy concern, I think in Massachusetts,
but all, but in this region as well.
So do you compare the data,
like the migration flow in and out of Massachusetts?
Do you compare that to the 49 other states?
Yes, we do.
And one of the interesting things that we saw during the pandemic is,
so if we were to have had this conversation in 2019,
we'd say Massachusetts has some challenging demographic trends,
but they're pretty consistent with Northeastern states.
And really among those Northeastern states,
Massachusetts was positioned pretty well.
What we saw happen during the pandemic, and this hasn't totally eroded yet,
right? With the pandemic,
you never know what was kind of a blip and what is going to persist. But, um,
Maine, for example,
was really in a really bad place demographically prior to the pandemic,
right? It was the fastest aging state in the Commonwealth.
People were leaving Maine.
And what we saw during the pandemic is Massachusetts started to lose more
people and Maine started to gain more people. Right.
And we've actually seen that in New Hampshire, to some extent, Vermont,
some extent, not tons and tons of people,
but something that might indicate that during the pandemic,
when you had folks who maybe were able to work from home more or be a little
more flexible,
we were all of a sudden kind of had some new competitors for people in
Massachusetts.
Well, you know, it's funny you mentioned New Hampshire and Maine, you know,
prior to the pandemic,
Maine, one of the oldest states, people weren't moving there,
but now remote working exactly in Maine, you probably get property,
cheap, more affordable, New Hampshire,
the tax issue difference between Massachusetts and New Hampshire.
I totally see those two states gaining and being Massachusetts loss.
Yeah. So I think that's,
those are some of the kind of demographic questions that then raise, okay,
so what are the policy treatments? And, and, you know,
you never know exactly what's going on.
You never know what's going to be a consistent trend versus what's going to
change from year to year. And so you don't want to over-correct for something,
but I think one of the, one of the ideas that we,
and I think others have talked about as well is,
could you imagine a scenario where Massachusetts has always been relatively
expensive, but if it, if people became a little less sticky all of a sudden,
right, you're a little, it's a little easier to move to,
especially to a neighboring state,
could that really kind of change the equation of Massachusetts success for
getting people to stay here? And that's something that I think we need to look
at.
And you know, it's funny you mentioned that because as you're telling me this,
I'm thinking that just the ease of working remotely
now, people can work from anywhere. You know, you can,
you might work for Boston Scientific in Boston or MassMutual here in Springfield
and live in Maine or the Bahamas or Pickett.
So are we losing workforce too, or are we just losing people?
So in that example, you know, okay, I work for MassMutual,
but I live in New Hampshire.
Yeah. So, so there's a couple of interesting things related to that. One,
one of the things that pandemic taught us is we track workforce in ways that
maybe don't align to the way people work now. So for example,
if you work for a Boston headquarter company or MassMutual in Springfield,
but you only work in the office one day a week and you work from home four days
a week and you live in Maine,
we're probably still counting you for some of our labor force record keeping as
working in Springfield, right? Then we're tied to your, to your employer.
But the other thing that I think we saw that offset for this.
And so we saw this decline in labor force that had been building prior to the
pandemic and then got worse at the start of the pandemic.
One of the interesting things we saw in 2023 and 2024 was
a big increase in international immigration.
That's on Massachusetts post some of its largest labor force gains in about 20
years.
And so you really saw this kind of quick turnaround related to international
immigration,
but we've seen that really fall off the table over the last year or so.
The immigration crackdown.
Exactly. And so that has some real implications for our future labor force as
well.
We are up on our second commercial break, plenty more to talk about with Doug.
So please stay with us. So you'll be interested to hear my next question.
This is 22 news in focus with Patrick Berry.
Welcome back everyone to this edition of in focus.
We're here in the 22 news plus studios sitting across the desk from me,
from the Massachusetts taxpayers foundation is Doug Howgate their president,
Doug. Thank you. Thank you for joining me. I appreciate you coming in.
How do you do your research? Like I know you analyze the state budget. Sure.
That's simple. But how do you do all this other stuff?
Like we were talking about the migration. How do you do that? Yeah.
So I think our team looks at a number of different data sources, right?
Because every data source has its own pluses and minuses. So for example a few
years ago, the state passed an income tax surtax, right.
For income over a million dollars.
And one of the big debates at that time,
that's really still ongoing is what is that going to mean for folks who are
wealthy in terms of leaving the state. And the IRS publishes exhaustive,
you know, exhaustive data, as you can imagine about tax returns,
but they publish it about three years delayed, right?
So in the intervening three years,
you don't want to want to just wait three years to see what happens.
So we use a lot of us census data.
We use a lot of data collected by the state bureau of labor statistics,
the national level. We use a lot of state level data this year for our
competitiveness index. We did do what we did as a poll.
We have actually mass ink polling group, which is related to Commonwealth beacon.
So we did a number of,
we try to use a number of different tools to get a sense of what's going on.
All right. My big question that I teased before we went, went to break,
I think most people in the state think that
government wastes money.
It's our tax dollars that they're wasting. What have you seen? I mean,
is that the case or is it kind of an overblown idea?
So I guess having worked in government and worked outside of government,
I guess I look at it a little differently in that we want to make sure that
government spends its resources efficiently on things that matter.
And like every large organization,
there is always room for improvement on that. But in,
in that room for improvement takes a number of different kind of avenues,
right? One would certainly be fraud, waste and abuse.
And you always want to make sure that you're doing things to make sure with
limited resources,
that the people who are eligible for benefits are eligible for services are
getting services and people who are not are not.
And so certainly that is an element of it. In my experience,
with certain exceptions, I have never seen kind of consistent or, uh,
you know, a rampant waste of money. Yeah. That is,
that is based on some kind of malign motive.
What I think often happens though, is as the state budget grows,
it's easier to add a new program than it is to reassess how effective an existing
program is.
And so one thing that I think the government struggles with time immemorial,
I think any organization struggles with is how do you think about what are we
trying to accomplish?
And then what are the things that we're doing in service to those goals and how
do we repurpose resources?
Cause you're not always going to have additional resources.
You need to make sure that the things you have respect spent most effectively.
What are some of the actions that have taken place in Beacon Hill, uh,
in, in the chambers at the state house from some of the research you guys have
done? Have, have there been massive changes made or tweaks or a little bit of
both?
Yeah. You know, I, I think that we're,
we're proud of our record and certainly a lot of that goes back to folks before
us, but just over the last few years,
a couple of things I would draw your attention to. So during the, uh, uh,
Biden administration, when the inflation reduction act was passed,
as well as bipartisan, there's a bill called the bipartisan infrastructure law.
These were huge infrastructure bills that provided a lot of resources to states
for major transportation and other infrastructure projects,
but states needed to come up with their own matching funds. Uh,
and our team put together a research report that made some pretty specific
recommendations about how the state,
given our limited resources could pull together some funds to draw down really
meaningful federal support for infrastructure projects that matter in
Massachusetts.
And I think the bill that you ultimately saw get signed into law really was
based a lot on those recommendations.
Another example I would give a recently is transportation finance.
So a couple of years ago, uh,
we wrote a report talking about the need for the state to put together
multi-year funding plans for transportation agencies, the MBTA,
but also other transportation agencies.
And I think we saw that recommendation really get incorporated into some, uh,
legislation that the governor filed.
And we actually saw an example of that and what the house did, um, uh,
house of representatives in a bill they passed earlier this week. Uh,
one more just quick example I would give is in,
in the area of early education and care during the pandemic,
we use some federal resources to launch this, uh,
childcare stabilization grant program to really help childcare providers,
whether the economy during the pandemic, keep their doors open.
And I think the research staff on our team, among others,
recognize that this was,
could be a really important tool to really stabilize the childcare sector,
make sure that there was child care available for whether folks who were
eligible for subsidized childcare services,
but for all families in Massachusetts.
And I think that's been a really important where the only state in the nation
that has kept that program going since the pandemic ended.
And I think our research was helpful there too.
The data that you publish, where can people find that?
Is it on your website? And if it is,
is it in a format that is easily understandable or is it just a data dump?
No. So, so we normally write narrative reports, right?
So I think a big thing that we,
there's always more for us to do as a small organization in terms of making data,
uh, uh, kind of relevant and accessible to folks.
But a lot of what we do right now, so you take the state budget,
the state budget at the end of the day is a 300 page document, but it has,
it spends all of your tax dollars, first of all.
And it also has any number of programs that might matter to you or your family
or your community, but it's not an accessible document. Right.
And so I think our team actually should be Megan Callahan,
our research director does an incredibly good job of taking this incredibly kind
of opaque document and distilling it into something that you can read and you
can understand what's going on.
And then you can kind of figure out working with us or through other resources
where you might want to drill down further.
But it's all oftentimes about writing about things that government is doing in
ways that hopefully are accessible to people who are interested in it.
Can't you just plug that into AI and go give me a 500 word summary? Yeah.
You know, you know, we, we, hopefully not, hopefully not it in, I will say,
it does take mental acuity to really understand the nuances of a budget.
And, and, you know, like everyone else in the world,
we're getting up to speed with AI as well. What,
what I think are one of our principles has been,
as we've talked to folks is a lot of the things related to state legislation,
how the state budget works really do require a little bit of
understanding and a depth,
and you wouldn't want to definitively get it wrong, right?
One of the things you notice if you're using use AI just at home is it can be
very definitive about things that sometimes aren't definitively true.
And I think we take what we would never want to sacrifice is as we're writing
about the state budget, Hey, we're going to get it done much,
much faster. And 18% of the stuff is going to be maybe not so true.
And so at least for now, I think we're, we're, we're, we've, we're,
we're not going to be replaced by AI, at least for the budget research staff.
Fantastic. So I'm going to pull it up again. It, the,
the website is right there. It's mass taxpayers.org.
You can get all the information from that. Doug,
I can't thank you enough for joining for a conversation today. It's fascinating.
Hopefully you'll come back and anytime, you know, actually before,
before I let you go, I got about 10 seconds left. The state budget is released.
When will you guys have your report released?
So the house budget will come out the week before April vacation,
and we will do our report the next day. So actually the day it's released,
we will put out our report. Yeah. Fantastic. Doug, thank you so very much.
Best of success to you and the organization and everybody there.
Thanks so much. Thank you.
