The Overwatering Myth Is Killing Your Plants 😱 Here’s Why

Green Happiness
146 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Everyone says don't overwater your plants, but here's the weird thing. This plant gets watered
daily and this one gets watered once a week. It has been watered once in the last week. However,
this is the one that is struggling and might potentially die. The real problem isn't water,
it's actually oxygen. Let's dive into it. Hi, my name is Memo. This is my channel,
Houseplanting Goodness, and essentially it's a place where I like to geek out about my big
passion. You might be able to see somewhere behind me, it's tropical houseplants. So yes,
in today's video we're going to dive into a bit more about the notion of overwatering and actually
why a lot of the times it's actually the oxygen that's the problem. Water has very little to do
with it, or at least not directly, but it's actually the plant's roots suffocating. So in
this video, we'll talk about why these plant roots can actually suffocate, why the soil type
or the growing media is more important than how often you water, why some plants can sit in water
almost forever with things like semi-hydro, and how to design a potting mix, a soil mixture,
a growing media in a way that makes it almost impossible to overwater. But let's start with
one of the biggest houseplant care myths, the fact that overwatering a lot of the times is
misdiagnosed. So for example, I've got a plant here, this is a Syngonium Strawberry Milkshake,
I think I'll add it at the top there, but this is a plant that has been struggling for a while,
this has gone through different bouts of root rot, and it has been used in different bits of
soil media as well. But this myth generally tends to put things like the fact that most plant deaths
are attributed to overwatering. It's always the thing that we always hear, it's just like, oh
you're an overwaterer, you've got much higher risks of actually causing root death through
root rot, because you're an overwaterer. But the thing that people a lot of the times tend to forget
that watering is only part of that equation. But as myself and a lot of other content creators have
said for a very long time now, watering is only part of the equation. Yes, your plants need to be
watered, but their roots also need oxygen. So water and oxygen. And this makes a lot of sense when you
think about how rainforest soils are as well, because a lot of the time things that people
forget is that the rainforest floor, or where a lot of these plants are actually growing, if they
are terrestrial plants, tends to be consisting mainly of debris. It's dead leaves, branches that
have fallen down, all these things which makes it super super airy. I obviously don't need to tell
you this if you're growing an epiphytic plant, because you know that they are growing in not
very much soil, if soil at all for that matter. It tends to be a lot of debris within the nooks and
crannies of trees as they are climbing up to reach the light. So what do roots actually need? And I've
got like a semi, probably has a bit of light dust on it, but basically a clear plastic pot or a cup
in this case, but imagine this was a clear plastic pot with some soil mix inside it, and you can kind
of see a lot of the things that roots will kind of need. So you can see it's very very chunky,
and you can see large air gaps that are happening around that soil structure. This provides a place
where that oxygen can be available to those roots. And the reason why these roots need that oxygen
within those little air pockets, which is why you want it chunky, because if you imagine if everything's
the same size, it just turns into, I think the easiest example I can give you is think of a sandy
beach. So the moment that you dig a hole in like sand, the rest of the sand covers it up and it
becomes a very dense media. I know there's going to still be air between all those different
structures of the sand. If you want to think of it in more kind of gardening terms, if you've got a
very very dense soil, even if you kind of move things around, there's still not going to be a
lot of air available to some of those roots. And this is why boggy conditions means that there's
very little air happening, because there's none of these gaps for the roots to be able to exchange
gases. And gas exchange is something very simple. We see it happening a lot of the time on the leaves
of plants, and this is something that we've all become a bit more accustomed to. We know that when
a plant is exchanging gases, they are releasing oxygen and pulling in carbon dioxide, which is
what they need for photosynthesis. But a lot of people tend to forget that roots also have an
exchange of gases that are happening, so it does mean that they need air to be available around
them basically. And let's just touch on that gas exchange that is happening at the roots, because a
lot of people don't always make that connection. So again, based on the research that I've done,
the photosynthesis that is happening on the leaves is what we're talking about before. They pull in
carbon dioxide and they release oxygen because it is photosynthesizing. With the roots, because the
roots don't photosynthesize, they just need a gas exchange to happen for cellular respiration. And in
simple terms, it means that the roots need oxygen, they pull in oxygen and expel carbon dioxide.
Conversely, the leaves do the opposite. So it is highly important that the roots have got access
to kind of air that is happening around them in order to happen for that gaseous exchange to
happen. But let's talk about the real cause, which is root suffocation. This is the real issue here.
So again, remember we're talking about the gaseous exchanges, you need to think about
potentially what the soil media is in terms of freshness. So this is unused soil media and you
can see all of the little gaps that are happening within the soil. And I'm going to show you my
little, like, believe it or not, this is a plant that's doing something with roots. I was seeing
roots growing on this recently. No, it's still there. This is a phagetii, but this soil and this
is the anthurium soil mix. So this was already quite a chunky one, but you can see that. And I
know it's wet, but that is a lot more dense at the moment than this is. So you need to also remember
that things like the age of the soil is going to be important here because you're going to start
thinking about compaction because over a while, whatever growing media we're using, especially
if it's organic media, because it's constantly going through a wet and dry cycle, at some point
it's going to start degrading or disintegrating, which means that those air, those lovely air gaps
that we've got there are going to be collapsing within themselves. So it's not a case of, oh, I've
repotted my plant now. It's fine. The roots aren't circling. I'm going to leave it there until I see
that it's struggling because it's getting root bound. Because what you might not be paying
attention to is the fact that that soil is slowly compacting. The plant doesn't get a chance to
start becoming root bound to then need the up-pot and the fresher soil because it's starting to rot.
Not because you're necessarily just over-watering, but because you're over-watering is causing that
soil media to become denser and denser and denser. Things are breaking down. The air gaps are
disappearing. Everything is compacting. It's not nice, fresh and fluffy soil anymore. And it means
that that oxygen becomes less and less available to the roots because those big air gaps that were
within the soil media, the fresh soil media, have become smaller and smaller and smaller, almost to
the point that at some point they become practically not there anymore. So that will cause
suffocation in the roots. And it is why people need to start considering not just plants being
root bound as a reason for re-potting, but also what is happening with the growing media. So a lot
of people, I'll give you an example, people that have been growing orchids for a very long period
of time, one of the things that they know, because this is the thing that they have to deal with,
and if they don't it will cause problems, is that because things like orchids, a lot of the orchids,
especially the ones with the chunkier roots, are just growing in something that's very airy. So
this is just an orchid bark with a whole bunch of air holes. This soil media, generally speaking, most
people that are growing these types of orchids would still be re-potting this every couple of
years to introduce new bark within there, get rid of some of that kind of rotting up bark, because
the longer you leave this, the more that bark degrades, decomposes and just becomes dust, and it
becomes denser and denser and denser, and then you start getting rot within orchid roots. So they've
been doing this for a while, it's something that the house plants world as a whole, that maybe isn't
growing orchids, is taking a bit longer to learn. So let's talk about the soil structure, which is
always a bit of a hidden factor with all this. So I want you to kind of imagine, I'll see if I can
get any videos or pictures to kind of put up this section, so you can kind of see it as well. So
imagine something really dense, like a dense peat mixture, and I know most of, at least in the UK,
I'm assuming most of Europe now, is moving away from peat mixes for house plants, and they're
trying to not touch peat as much as possible, not just for house plants, I think this is
generally for like gardening as well. But that tends to be very, very dense at times, very little airflow
that is happening because of the media itself, and the materials that are within the media. Now think
of something like a chunky aroid soil mix, and this is Soil Ninja's Ampharium soil mix. So this is
exceptionally chunky, you can kind of see like nothing is clumping together, and I know it's dry,
but if I was to kind of like drop this all down, you can see that it's all falling down as if it
was just pebbles basically. Then you need to think about bark mixtures, and the important thing to
remember here is how big are your bark chunks as well, or how small. For example, there was a point
where I was trying to get like regular kind of medium to large size orchid bark, and it's
interesting because I went to buy some the other day as well, and I still can find anybody that
had it in stock. So I don't know if there's like a shortage at the moment, but there is a lot more
of the very, very fine orchid bark that is happening. You need to remember that the size of the chunks
is going to matter as well, because if something is small, small particles can fit next to each other
a lot, lot closer, so those air gaps start to become smaller and smaller and smaller. If something
is chunky with something else that's chunky, you get bigger air gaps, which is preferable.
And then think about something like lecca, or any form of semi-hydromix. I'm using lecca because
it's kind of really obvious and really big chunky bits. If you were to see this in a clear pot,
you could see that things don't sit neatly. Yes, these are little kind of balls, but you can see
that big gaps are going to be created amongst those big balls, which means that you're going
to get a lot of airflow that's coming in. That's the slight difference between something like this.
I know there's more nuanced differences as well, but between this and the orchid bark, obviously
orchid bark is organic, this is inorganic, so there is that to remember as well there. But orchid bark
is going to be all different irregular shapes and sizes, so you might get bigger gaps, smaller gaps.
With the lecca, you tend to get more uniform gaps while still remaining quite large, and I do know
that you can get lecca in different sizes nowadays. You even think about a couple of years back, you
just had one size of lecca, which is what everybody used. Now you can get small lecca sizes, big lecca
sizes, this medium kind of standard size. So there is a size for everybody, and we need to remember
that pot choice matters as well. So things are going to be very different in the different pots
you're going to be using. So potentially you could have a plastic nursery pot, you might have a clear
pot, you might have a clear plastic pot with drainage holes that's also got big drainage
holes at the bottom, because this is meant for orchids. You could have whatever plastic pot you
have in something like a decorative cash pot, so that means that there's going to be less air.
Or you could have something like a terracotta pot, or, and this obviously terracotta pot I don't need
to tell you, is a lot better at kind of leaching out some of that moisture as well. Now you could
also have something like net pots, which has got a large amount of kind of air holes that are coming
through. This is going to be the most airy solution that you have, unless you are mounting something
directly onto like a cork board with a tiny bit of sphagnum moss, that's going to have the, or even
without the sphagnum moss, just directly onto a cork board, which you might do with some orchids,
that's going to have the maximum amount of air around it. But you can kind of see there's going
to be different options, and there's going to be different ways that certain pots might help,
certain pots might hinder, or decorative pots, and some other pots might sit somewhere in between.
You also, and I'm bringing up the terracotta again, you need to think about things like
evaporation as well, not just from the top of the soil, because that is the problem with a lot of
the plastic pots, even something like this, which is a clear pot with a lot of holes on the side of it,
this is going to allow air to evaporate predominantly around where these holes are,
in not a huge deal as well, but usually just at the top. With something like a terracotta pot,
however, the whole pot itself is going to be leaching out the water as well, which means
that that water and that moisture is not going to be staying near the roots for too, too long,
which means that whatever holes were being filled up with moisture, especially if you may be
over-watering, are going to be released because they are coming through the actual porous material
that is terracotta, even more so with something like a net pot, because at this point you can see
that if I had a plant in here, the soil level up here, yes, you'd get some evaporation that's
happening from the moisture that's within that soil at the top, but also there are so many holes
around this, and if you've got anything like a fan blowing around, forget about it, you're going to
get even more evaporation that is happening from all of these kind of holes that are being created
by the net itself. And I hear all of you, before you even say it, they're just like, but Memo, how does
this work with semi-hydro? With a lot of the times you get the roots actually sitting within water,
so for instance, if this was a plant in semi-hydro, so this has got leca in it, it's a clear pot, just
I'm using it for kind of display example now, and imagine that this saucer was the water reservoir,
if the plant was up here, anybody who's grown in semi-hydro will know that the roots eventually
will go down through the pot, and they'll get, they'll come out from whatever drainage holes you
might have, and end up within that water media that's directly there. That is different, and you're
sitting there going, but how does that not cause issues with watering as well? And how does that
not cause issues with air reaching the roots? But you also need to remember what is happening up
here, let me bring that up again so you can kind of see, can you see those big air gaps that are
happening? So a lot of the roots that are still within that growing pot, and I'm using, this is a bad
example because this is a tiny pot, imagine a much bigger pot with semi-hydro, it doesn't have to be
leca, it could be pond, it could be whatever you're using for your semi-hydro. There's a lot of air
that's happening within that particles that we were talking about before, about the size particles,
that is there and facilitating that exchange of gases. It means that oxygen diffusion will happen
throughout all those little kind of nooks and crannies that the roots can go into that are not
constantly being hugged by soil medias or more dense soil medias. For example, and this is a
good example with leca, some of this is a porous material as well, so that itself doesn't hold that
much water and it's also got little nooks and crannies within the material itself, which can
also help to kind of keep some of that oxygen there available for the actual roots. And then you need
to think about the difference between a water reservoir and saturation, and I do hear you because
a lot of our kind of beloved plants that we can grow, a lot of people will just water propagate
something and just leave it in water and that's absolutely fine, and just like but Memo that is
entirely in water, what is happening there? The difference is that those roots are water roots
there, and a lot of the times what will happen is the roots that are hitting into the reservoir at
the bottom will start to transition into a bit more of a water root, which means that they can still
get the oxygen, because keep in mind the roots up here, they're still more traditional roots and
they're getting the oxygen in the more traditional way, but then the water roots will be able to get
the oxygen from their environment in the way that is easiest for them because they are water roots.
So let's touch on something that a lot of people say that, oh I've struggled with this plant in soil,
but actually the moment that I moved it into leca, into pond, I saw great success. This is kind of
proving the point there. Whatever oxygen was not available to the plants within that soil media
that you had, even if it was the chunkiest of soil medias, it's probably not going to be as chunky as
something like leca, perlite, all of these different things, which means that the reason why that didn't
do as well in soil, versus something in like a semi-hydro element, is that potentially that plant
is used to having an awful lot of air around its roots. Let me give you the example again of the
orchid that I was showing you a moment ago. This is a type of orchid, and I can't remember that, I
think this is a ringtrevola, if not I'll kind of put the name at the top here, but this it's got
very chunky roots, think of your phalaenopsis orchids, and think for a moment if you didn't
have it in something like orchid bark, and maybe just had it in pure sphagnum moss, or even worse,
in just really dense PT soil, what was likely going to be to happen? Correct, these roots are used to
getting an awful lot of air around them, because actually have a look at some of these orchids when
they're growing out in nature, in their tropical environments, and if I find some videos or pictures
I'll add them here, you can kind of see that a lot of times those roots are just hanging
in mid-air, like almost as if the plant is just surviving on the ambient moisture that is
happening from the air around it. Now imagine putting something that's used to getting that
much air available to it all the time in something really dense that doesn't have an awful lot of air.
That is why a lot of times things might work better in a semi-hydro material versus something
that might be in soil, for example, again I'll bring up the little syngonium that I was showing
you before, which has got again still very kind of airy soil, but this isn't a plastic pot, a clear
plastic pot, it does have drainage holes at the bottom but it doesn't have any drainage on the
side. The last attempt I'm going to make with this plant is I'm going to put in something even more
airy and put it into a net pot and see what happens. I've got a smaller net pot for this,
don't worry. But yeah, that is something that you need to remember a lot of the times, it's the
particle size, it's the availability of oxygen, and it's the plant's preferences or even more
specifically what the plant is used to getting in its natural habitat, especially when it comes to
its roots. But how do you make overwatering practically impossible? I'll give you some of
my top tips and I think most of these will make sense based on what I was talking about
throughout most of this video. So the big big thing is big particle sizes. Remember we were
talking about the particle sizes before, so using something that's exceptionally chunky. There's a
lot of people that will just rely on things, I'll give you a very extreme, two very extreme examples.
So you can have cocopeat, which is something that a lot of people are using for houseplants at the
moment, and do a 50-50 mix of cocopeat and perlite. Perlite's very small particles, you're still
producing those air gaps within there, but perlite is very very small. Try replacing it with something
like lecca, or something like chunky orchid bark, or something that's got a large particle size, or a
large kind of material, because those will create much bigger gaps, and flip it on its side. Instead
of going for something that's a 50-50 mix, go for something that's 60%, 70%, 80% is going to be that
chunky big element, and only 10 to 20% is going to be that moisture retaining element. Yes, before
anybody says this, this will also mean that you might need to potentially water your plants a bit
more frequently, because they're not going to be able to retain some of that moisture. Again, I will
say this time and time again, more over-waterers will kill plants off than under-waterers.
The under-watering can still cause its own set of issues, but less so than over-watering, and what
these larger particles will do is help people that tend to maybe over-water, not cause damage because
of the over-watering. Because again, remember, it's not the over-watering that's causing the problem
necessarily, it's the lack of oxygen that happens because of the over-watering. Because the water
might be retaining in the particles for too long, there's not enough kind of gaps, the oxygen exchange
can't happen, thus leading to root rot. And this is the thing that surprises a lot of people, because
I've mentioned this, and I will mention this time and time again, I've always used it as an example
for Myers-Mellons, which is not looking great at the moment, but again, winter issues, it will be
fine. There's a brand spanking new leaf here that looks particularly healthy, and all the new leaves
are completely fine. These leaves that you're seeing here are probably three or four years old
at the moment, they're fine, they've served their purpose. But these massive plants behind me, pot
size? Maybe a tiny bit bigger than this. Tiny bit bigger than this. Is it telling you something?
So go for slightly smaller pot sizes, yes it might mean you're going to need to water a bit more
often, but sometimes the pot size will mean that you can give a slightly denser soil mix. Please
keep the large particles again, and you'll get the best of both worlds there. Don't forget, we talked
about this earlier on, refresh your substrate every few years, don't let just the orchid growers do it.
We need to be thinking about refreshing our substrate. Do not always, some plants really do
not like their soil being disrupted too much, do your own research on your specific plant, but also
you can refresh that soil media, but actually kind of removing some of it, not all of it, and adding
some new fresher soil media, because then at least the plant roots have got somewhere to go, when
invariably there's going to be some compaction that might happen on the tiny bit of old media
that you've left on there. And then use breathable containers, use something like a net pot, use
something like a terracotta pot, use something like a clear pot with an awful lot of air holes in it,
that will definitely help introduce that oxygen into that root area, even if everything else goes
wrong. Mechanically that means that it's a lot more available because it can go through those holes.
And then finally before I go into some final thoughts, let's talk about a quick diagnostic
guide on how you kind of look at this and how you can kind of quickly go, oh yes this is probably
what's causing this. So first thing is, is the soil compacted? Can you see something that was
at some point very very fluffy and is now very very dense? Refresh the soil media at that point.
Drainage is another one, and I don't know whether or not, no I can't move that at the moment, but
I've got another plant that has been in its pot for so long, and this is what I mean, even I don't
always do this because I don't have the time to do this, but imagine something that has all of these
air pockets here, or kind of holes that are happening. Now imagine a plant that's been
growing for years, it's been moist, dry, moist, dry, you've got some of that compaction happening,
you've got some of that rot that is happening for the substrate, not the roots necessarily,
but then also imagine, and I'm sure I'm not the only one, where you get moss coming out of these
holes. Guess what that moss has done, in a very large sense there, either entirely block those
holes or reduce them to the point where they are no longer functioning to bring in air. So make sure
that the air has a way of still coming into the roots of the plant. Look at your pot size, if
something is really really tiny and will probably be a bit swamped in a pot like this, if you have
it in a pot this size, it's going to also be a problem because there's going to be a whole bunch
of media, it doesn't matter how airy it is at that point, it's still going to remain wet because
there's nothing there to use up that moisture within the media. However, something like a net
pot, you could kind of get away, it's a bit more forgiving, it won't be because you're going to
need to water it more frequently, but it's a bit more forgiving if you've given it a slightly bigger
pot, because even if the roots aren't absorbing all the moisture that's there, because they're
much smaller root mass in a much bigger pot, the fact that there is this much air and evaporation
that's happening from the moisture within these bits of the pot that don't have any roots in them
yet, that will still give you a bit of an insurance policy. Yes, I know the problem with a lot of the
net pots is that they're obscenely expensive for some bizarre reason, but yes, because I know that
they're a lot of times they're just used for ponds, so it's a captive audience, but if enough of us
would buy these, they would come down in price. Yes, they can be messy with soil media, I am not
going to lie to you there. Again, think about the substrate age, how long has the same plant been in
the same substrate? I'm not talking about you needed to repot it or not because a plant hasn't
become root bound yet, but if a plant is a slow-growing plant and it's in exactly the same
soil media, which means it's not going to get root bound within two or three or even five years,
have you upgraded some of that soil a bit as well? Because again, there's some people going, oh but
like the soil wouldn't update within like nature. Think about it, we talked about all the debris
that's happening on the jungle floor, that element, you might get flash flooding happening, you might
get wind, all these things means that some of the older particles are moved away and then you get
more debris, so there is a refreshing that is happening even within nature and it's happening
all the time. And then obviously, ultimately, and this is where it's good to have clear pots or net
pots, have a look at your root health, are there healthy roots in there? Some people might be
looking at this going, well this doesn't look like it's got much going on in there, but yes,
and I'm trying to find some of the other roots but I can show you one there, there is a healthy
root that is happening on the side there and I can see it because I'm using a clear pot, so I'm
visually inspecting the root health. So just to recap really quickly, soil compaction, age of the
soil, pot size and root health, these things are going to be the important things that you're going
to need to be looking at in order to diagnose what the issue might be or how and if it is even
fixable. So I'm really curious from you now in terms of some of my final thoughts and I'd like
to hear your thoughts as well. Have you experienced any of this with your own plants? Have you learned
the hard way, which is how most of us learn actually ironically enough, is by making some
of these mistakes? Do you do any of these adjustments? Has this video been a bit of a
reminder of kind of going, oh no, I haven't done that in a while, I should probably go and do that now.
Let us all know down below if you're just new and you're starting off with the hobby, did any of
this surprise you? Again, let us all know down below and I'll leave you with a final hopefully
positive thought, is you don't kill your plant through watering, you can kill it through suffocation
which sometimes is due to the watering, but as you saw throughout this video there's a whole host
of other issues that you need to be taking into consideration and watering is only part of that
equation. Yes, hopefully you've enjoyed, hopefully I shall see you here soon and I truly, truly hope
that you have a great rest of your day. Thanks, bye!
