In this episode we are joined by Geneticist Razib Khan who takes us through the Genetic DNA history of Northern Europe.
We begin in prehistoric Scandinavia as we see the arrivals of the first peoples from various places and we see various migrations some of which are coming from Southern Europe that eventually replace the original Hunter Gatherers. We talk about historiography and archaeology and how their views have changed on the subject of Northern Europeans and their origins.
We eventually leave the prehistoric culture after discussing the Battle Axe culture and the controversy surrounding them and we approach the Nordic Bronze and Iron Age period in Northern Europe and we discuss various migrations and cultures that migrate in, supplant and absorb these preexisting peoples and cultures.
What role did Anatolian migrations have in early Northern Europe? Who were the original hunter gatherers? What impact did the arrival of Indo Europeans have on the original inhabitants?
Eventually we approach the Medieval world and we talk about the medieval populations of Northern Europe and then the Vikings and whether or not these travels and ventures surrounding piracy have an impact on DNA in Northern Europe and in the places they settled such as Ireland, Scotland, England and etc.
Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the Study of Antiquity and the Middle Ages. As always,
I am your host, Nick Barksdale, and today we are joined once again by a channel favorite,
and that is Razib Khan. Mr. Khan, thank you so much for coming on the show today.
My pleasure. I always love it, Nick.
Today's episode naturally involves a subject that you love, and that is DNA combined with
another subject that you love, which is history. And so with that being said, today we are going
to be diving into the origins of the Vikings. But before diving in, I want to remind you,
my subscribers, check out the links in the video description below. It's going to take you to all
of the awesome work that Razib Khan is doing to help people like me and you better understand the
subjects that we all love, and I cannot encourage you enough to become a member of his substack.
I am as well, and seriously, the episodes and articles that he provides are absolutely
fantastic, from hosting the top experts within Indo-European studies to Bronze Age favorites
such as archaeologist Dr. Eric Klein. And so, that's enough of my publicity for today. We're
going to dive in. And so, without further ado, Mr. Khan, when you think of the Vikings, based on your
research or imagination, what comes to your mind?
You know, a lot of the viewers, the listeners, will know what comes to my mind are, you know,
these kind of violent raiders in their longboats, right? And like, we've all watched the TV shows or
read the books, a Viking is a verb, right? To go Viking. So, you know, it's an action. It's not
necessarily a people or ethnicity, though it's obviously associated with a people or ethnicity.
I mean, that would be more properly, like, the Norse, the Danes, the Sverre, the various tribes,
the tribes of Gotland, you know, the Swedes, you're a combination of these various tribes. So,
Viking is kind of like describing an activity that they did for several centuries, more than
several centuries, arguably, kind of around like 800 AD to 1000 AD. And so, that's what I, you
know, they didn't go to battle with helmets with horns, obviously. Those are just kind of like
ritual objects, but, you know, they're pagan people, they're not Christian, they're raiding
Northern Europe, and they tend to come from Scandinavia, ergo, they tend to be Scandinavians.
But it's kind of an interesting term, because, you know, Scandinavians were never Vikings,
because they never went to Viking.
05.01 Before talking about the Vikings and their DNA, I want to backtrack a little bit,
and I want to talk about Northern Europe. When it comes to the populations within Northern Europe,
what has been the traditional viewpoint as to where these peoples originally came from?
The traditional viewpoints have changed multiple times, as some of your viewers and listeners will
know. You know, archaeologists have had various debates on how deeply Indigenous they were,
or not Indigenous. Until about like 20 years ago, I think the dominant view was that the
populations of Northern Europe descend from the populations that were present in Europe,
extend in Europe, at the end of the last ice age 12,000 years ago. Obviously, they're not
native to Northern Europe, because Northern Europe was covered by an ice sheet. Scandinavia
is still bouncing back. The crust is still bouncing back from that. But, you know, the argument is
they come from the South. They're Pleistocene hunter-gatherers. What ancient DNA has done
has transformed our understanding of that, insofar as we now know that most of the ancestry
on the order of – in Northern Europe, on the order of 80%, probably more. In Southern Europe,
on the order of 90%, 95% of that ancestry is actually not Indigenous to Western or Central
Europe as of 12,000 years ago, or as of, frankly, like 8,000, 9,000 years ago. The hunter-gatherers
of the European Pleistocene, the Magallanian culture, the Graevisian culture, the Seleucid
culture, all these cultures, they left very, very little impact on modern European genomes.
And in fact, modern European genomes descend mostly from Anatolian farmers,
so before that, they were hunter-gatherers during the late Pleistocene, and also from people in
Eastern Europe, modern-day Ukraine, that area, and the Transcaucasus region. So, they're kind
of newcomers to the continent within the last 10,000 years. And Northern Europeans, they descend
from the Malong or a mix of these various peoples that occurred kind of in the middle to late Bronze
Age. And so, as we approach leaving the Ice Age, we're approaching the Bronze Age, I want to talk
about a fascinating culture, and that is the Battleaxe culture. Who are they, and how does
this play into this conversation?
Paul Because Northern Europe, because Scandinavia,
the Nordic countries are cold, ancient DNA is well-preserved, as some of the best departments
for studying ancient DNA are in Denmark or Sweden. And this is partly just due to, you know,
their experience and expertise in population genomics, but to a large extent it's because
they have a wealth of materials that they have native access to because they're present in the
nations of concern. So, basically, it turns out that at the beginning of the Holocene,
about 12,000 years ago, the native people in Scandinavia, they are labeled originally,
because population genomics is very original, Scandinavian hunter-gatherers. And they're
genetically kind of equidistant between Eastern European hunter-gatherers and Western European
hunter-gatherers. Probably the most famous example for your listeners or viewers would
be Cheddar Band. They tended to be blue-eyed, dark-skinned. Eastern European hunter-gatherers,
they flourished in Karelia and Western Ukraine. They tended to be more related to Paleo-Siberian
people, and their physical appearance was more mixed. Scandinavian hunter-gatherers look like
to be a mix of these, both Eastern and Western, that came out of a synthesis. There's actually
some archaeological evidence of how it happened. It looks like Eastern European hunter-gatherers
came up over Southern Scandinavia, up through the North, came around, whereas the Western
hunter-gatherers came up through the Baltic, so the two mix. So, that's who the indigenous people
of Scandinavia were. Well, they did not stay dominant forever. And about 5,000 years ago,
you had farmers from the South, descendants of the LBK culture, Linear Pottery people,
and these are descendants of Anatolian farmers. Genetically, their closest relatives are Sardinians.
They show up into Scandinavia. This is the edge of their range. Farming with the Neolithic
cultural toolkit, cultural package, is really, really on the margins of sustainability in
Southern Scandinavia. And so, these are marginal people. They have some hunter-gatherer admixture
by now. And so, these are the people that are flourishing there about 5,000 years ago.
North of them, probably in the northern two-thirds of Sweden, there are different people who are
still indigenous hunter-gatherers. We don't know as much about them today, although a little bit
more about them later. So, what happens is these Neolithic people, eventually around 2,500 BC,
probably a little earlier, they get overwhelmed by people of the Corded Ware horizon, the Corded
Ware is for the pottery. So, the Corded Ware are a mix of people from probably the Caucasus region
with indigenous European hunter-gatherers. They probably descend from Yamnaya or Yamnaya-related
people, Indo-Europeans as such. In Scandinavia, though, they transform culturally somewhat.
They synthesize with the native European farmer substrate, the funnel beaker culture and whatnot.
In Denmark, they're called the single grave culture. They're really creative,
these archaeologists, in terms of how they name them. But in Scandinavia,
they call them the Badlax culture. So, why are they called the Badlax culture?
These people, they were buried with ceremonial Badlaxes. It's all about ceremony for them.
It's not like axes are multipurpose. I'm only bringing this up because friends of mine are
like, I think we would be much more interested in Northern European prehistory if they were called
the mace pendant people because the Corded Ware were buried with mace pendants. I think in a
previous episode, I mentioned, what do you do with maces? Okay. So, these Badlax people are
buried with sacred Badlaxes because it's sacred, right? And so, they show up here and then this is
the end of the Neolithic farmers. They absorbed the last of the Neolithic farmers and they coexist
in Sweden, in particular, with a group called the Pinned Ware culture and that's based on their
pottery. They're hunter-gatherers, they're fishermen. They probably lived at relatively
high density in these marine environments and so they kind of had a standoff with the last farmers
and also the Badlax people. There is evidence of basically physical conflict between the last of
the farmer peoples as they retreated south due to a climatic change as the hunter-gatherers are
conflicting with them. And so, after about 2500 BC, there was a process of an amalgamation between
the Pinned Ware who seemed to be related in some way to the Scandinavian hunter-gatherers and
perhaps some more Eastern hunter-gatherer ancestry as well and these new Badlax people,
these new Indo-Europeans, right? We go into the Nordic Bronze Age. So, the Nordic Bronze Age,
well, it's the Bronze Age, right? It's between 2000 BC and about 500 BC when the Iron Age hits
Northern Europe. This is basically setting the stage for Northern European genetic background,
as we understand it. They absorbed the last of the hunter-gatherers probably in the far north,
like where the Sami are, that they actually did hold out and were never assimilated until the
Sami showed up, these reindeer herders. And then there are still pockets of Neolithic farmers in
places like, is it the Kattegat? The island where Copenhagen is, right? And so, archaeologists have
actually shown the Badlax people, the Sixth Grave people, these Indo-Europeans, they actually
coexisted for a little while with these Neolithic people. They intermarried eventually to the point
where the latter disappeared. And so, this is how we get the Iron Age cultures that we know
that became the Vikings. And it all goes back to the Bronze Age. Ask Eric Klein.
When it comes to the origins of the Northern Europeans and the advances in DNA, what would
you say the most important aspects are that have been either debunked or confirmed by these results?
There's actually a lot of argument about whether the Finnic people, the Finnic-speaking people,
you know, they speak Finno-Ugric language, Uralic language, whether they are the indigenous
inhabitants of Norden, because Scandinavia only excludes Finland, right, of the Nordic countries,
or whether the Indo-Europeans came first. So, there's arguments about this, right?
Well, so it turns out we have DNA now. 70% of Finnish males carry a Y-chromosome lineage that
you can trace back to the Tamir Peninsula and parts in central Siberia. And ancient DNA is
telling us that this showed up between, say, 1000 BC and 500 BC. So, the Finnic languages are
intrusive, okay? So, I think we don't know what language they spoke, but it's awful suspicious
that 70% of males in Finland have this Y-chromosome and 5% of men in Sweden do.
And they're probably due to gene flow from Finland during the unified political kingdom.
So, now we know that the Finnic people are intrusive. They're not indigenous. Who's
before the modern-day Finnish lineage show up, are recorded where? They were Badlaks. The Badlaks
Y-chromosome was R1a, usually, in Finland. Only 5% of Finnish males are R1a now. So,
maybe they just decided gentlemanly to kind of cede the land to their new Finnic overlords.
I don't know what happened here. I'll leave it to your imagination. So, we know that in terms
of the western part, the Scandinavians were actually probably dominant all the way into
Finland and then something happened during the Iron Age where they kind of lost their sway on
that side of the Gulf of Bothnia. And by the time we have history, we have this ethnic divide
between the Finns and the Swedes and this kind of dynamic, which hopefully we'll talk about a little
going forward, that kind of defines the early medieval period in the great northern world.
And so, when it comes to the origins of the Vikings and their genetic makeup,
what has the traditional viewpoint been on the Vikings?
Well, I mean, traditionally, archaeologists and historians, they didn't really think about
folk migrations and genetic changes. They kind of focused on culture, even though
if you read, I don't know, if you read the sagas, like they're migrating to Finland
and all this stuff. There's all these sagas of men going during the Beringian Guard in Byzantium,
going through the Baltic and the Russian rivers and whatnot. And so, yeah, there's a lot of people
moving around, but historians and archaeologists after World War II have kind of been a little
leery of this migration of this folk wandering, which was associated with, let's be frank,
the Nazis and a lot of nationalistic viewpoints. And so, ancient DNA has kind of made people
confront the reality that actually there was a lot of migration, there was a lot of gene flow,
and this was just part of our history. And it's not like Nazi plan and see, this is really based
on the science, it's based on reality. And you started with a really, really deep ancient history
and have progressively moved closer, probably because the technology has gotten cheaper and
which means that you can look at questions which have other avenues of analysis.
So, some of the stuff that I'm going to be talking about, obviously, there are texts,
there's archaeology, there's a lot that we know about these Vikings. So, for example,
economic historians love to talk about how the rise of Islam led to an influx of dinars during
the caliphate into Sweden and the Baltic in general, probably up through the Volga Bulburs
and whatnot. And so, these people are on the edge of history already. And they show up in the,
what is it, early 9th century in Lindisfarne with their sackings and their attacks on the kingdoms
of England at the time, the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms, and then obviously Ireland.
They lay siege to Paris, they extort the king of France, they go at Constantinople as well. I mean,
they're all over the place. They actually show up in southern Spain, they get into the Mediterranean,
Vikings are everywhere, they're everywhere. They didn't leave their genes everywhere though. And so,
this current wave of exploration of this topic is focused on the genes. And I do want listeners,
let's see, Population Genomics of the Viking World. It's a paper, you can find free copies
of it online. It was, I think, originally in Science, if I'm correct, but there are free
copies online. It came out last year, and it used a huge, huge data set of Vikings,
comparing them to modern Scandinavians and other peoples around the world, and trying to come to
some conclusions. And again, like I said, because of preservation conditions, we're talking sample
sizes in dozens and dozens, okay? Not just a couple individuals here and there, but they have
a lot of Viking Age samples that they can compare to modern, medieval, and prehistoric.
And so now I want to approach the question that all of our subscribers are waiting on,
and that is, what has DNA told us about who the Vikings were?
They weren't totally different from what we know, okay? They weren't totally different from what we
know. On the whole, they are the descendants of these people from the Nordic Bronze Age.
On the whole, on average, they are the ancestors of modern Scandinavians, okay,
these Viking samples. But there are differences, okay? So what are the differences? The Vikings
went to England. They went to Ireland. They stayed. Some of them became a Hiberno,
you know, Hiberno-Norse, or Norse-Gaels, whatever you want to call them. Some of them stayed in the
Danelaw. Some of them went to Russia, okay? And they stayed there. And so Kievan Rus is
a Viking state. It was founded by a Swedish man. Now, we have the ancient DNA of the Rurikids,
all the ruling houses in Russia. They actually have a Finnish Y chromosome. This means that
the founder of Kievan Rus was probably a Scandinavianized Finn, if that makes sense.
So he probably had an ancestor in Finland who was probably a local warlord. This is my hypothesis.
The Swedish started interacting quite aggressively, and I think he decided that it was
better to become Swedish, okay? So his lineage became Swedish. By the time they show up in
Domgorod the Great, they are worshiping the Norse gods, not Finnish gods. They're speaking in
Swedish. But the Y chromosome lineage is clearly a Finnish lineage. So we know that the Vikings
actually had a synthetic interaction with the Finnic peoples to the east. That's just concrete
proof, right? In terms of how things have changed genetically, in modern Sweden, there's clearly
gene flow from the east when you compare it to the Vikings. In Norway and Denmark,
there's gene flow from the west. Is this surprising? We don't have monks in Norway and
Sweden telling us about the Viking ships coming back. We don't have records of that because they
weren't Christian yet. We don't know what they thought. We only see it from the perspective of
the Christians. We don't know the whole life cycle of the heathen. We see the heathen at the
most violent stage of the heathen life, in a way. So imagine you're a pagan Slav in Eastern Europe
at that period. What is your perception going to be of German Christians? All you're going to see
them is by their sword, right? So Vikings were violent. I don't want to deny that. These are
militaristic people. But let's also remember that we see them in a biased view by the people they
were just spoiling, that they were conquering, that they were marauding. We don't have them in
their own words, except for maybe the prosadas and some of these sagas, right? And that's kind
of garbled and confused, partly because they were recorded by their Christian descendants,
who had their own agendas, let's be honest. So what we see in the Viking world is that
there's been genetic change, genetic change of influence by their European neighbors,
because this is a period where Vikings went out and they came back, okay? It wasn't just a
one-directional gene flow. There's also, this was well-known, but now we can confirm it with
ancient DNA, Viking ancestry in Northern England, Viking ancestry in Ireland, Viking ancestry
elsewhere. It depends on what the population size of the source is and the target in these sorts of
things. But I think this would just be intuitively obvious. What is less intuitively obvious,
I think, is there is some evidence here that the Vikings have changed, the people of Scandinavia
have changed genetically in terms of their characteristics. A higher fraction of modern
Scandinavians can digest milk, okay? So there's been natural selection. There's been adaptation
and evolution. We kind of already knew this as geneticists, I'm going to tell you straight up.
There's already signatures in modern Northern European genomes that are,
the modern Northern Europeans have been selected for digesting milk, even up until the present,
that their skeletal structure has been getting thinner and thinner, and also they've been
becoming lighter. So these Vikings, some of them were already blonde, but I can tell you from other
work I've seen in Estonia, this Nordic phenotype that we think about, it's actually something
that's come about over 3,000 years gradually. The ancestors who descend from the Nordic Bronze Age,
they were somewhat more mixed in appearance. If listeners want to Google,
you know what, I will send you the link so you can post it. But I've looked really closely at
the Estonian data because they have really, really long transects, and they're some of
the palest people in the world. And it's quite clear that Iron Age Estonians were much darker.
I mean, I'm not saying that they were olive skin, but much higher fraction had brown eyes and dark
hair than is the case today. And they have suggestive evidence in this paper that some of
the same was happening after the Viking Age, as natural selection has been changing these northern
people in place. We don't know why, we don't know what's going on. There's only so much we can say,
but we can describe what's happening. And they are changing in terms of characteristics.
Another thing is immune profile. They've been adapting to disease census, which makes sense.
They didn't go through the Black Death yet. They weren't exposed to a lot of the plagues
and pandemics that were going to happen in the last 1,000 years.
And to make this even more complicated, as DNA has continued to mix with history,
we've also found that these Viking raiders were not always one and the same.
And what I mean by that is, occasionally, you see people who are not Northern European,
at least not in the sense that we know them. And Mr. Khan, would you expand a little bit on that?
Yeah. So, they assimilated indigenous, quote, unquote, indigenous European tribe,
European people. I did mention earlier the Norse Gaels. They seem to be a cultural hybrid
of Norse and Irish, probably mostly Norse male with Irish women. This paper actually did find
some evidence of whole families moving, including women. But I think on the whole,
we can assume that in many areas, this was a movement of males. And there are people
who descend from Vikings in these areas. So, where do the women come from? Well,
they're local women. So, William the Conqueror, his mother was probably
of local French heritage background. And his father was, I think his father was the son of
Rollo or the grandson of Rollo the Viking. And so, you have this hybrid hybridity between the
Vikings and the people they conquered and mixed with. And this is also one reason
why there is evidence in Scandinavia itself of Irish or English or Russian type ancestry or
Finnish type ancestry. Because some of these individuals that are born in Ireland or born
in the Danelaw, when the Viking kingdoms fell, they didn't all stay. Some of them went back to
Scandinavia as genetically half Scandinavian, but culturally mostly Scandinavian probably
in their orientation. I mentioned already Rurik, who was the warlord, the Swedish
warlord who shows up in Nagorod the Great and created an empire in Western Russia.
We know now genetically his paternal lineage was Finnish. So, where they were originally,
it is not always where they end. And so, like I said, Viking is not a people. It is a practice.
It is a way of life. Now, you can't deny that that way of life is interactive with
Northern Europe and Scandinavia, but that doesn't mean that it's exclusively Northern European or
Scandinavian in character at that time. Because look, I know some of you guys out there are pretty
barbaric. Some of you probably like Good Church Boys on Sunday. Some of you, not so much. And it
was probably like that back then. And so, some people are probably thinking,
this pillaging and I'm not going to say the other things that they're doing.
Some of these guys are probably like, this is looking pretty good. So,
bye-bye Christ, hello Thor. This clearly happened. This clearly happened in Ireland.
I think there's the best examples of people of Christian women having pagan sons.
And so, this culture flourished for centuries before eventually they were Christianized,
and they became Northern European in a very, very fundamental way, part of Christendom,
part of the world of civilization as they understood it. I have said, this is kind of
like a half joke, but Christianity made the Vikings white. They were no longer heathen.
They were no longer the other. They were no longer aliens, savages, barbarians. All of a sudden,
they become these tall, beautiful, angelic-looking blonde Northern Europeans who people can admire
for their fair skin. Before, they're described as animals. So, I think the Vikings are very complex,
and we have reduced caricatures of who they are. I also think we don't need to be revisionist
and not deny the brutality of their lives and the way they behave. We can create Marxist
narratives of Malthusian conditions and overpopulations, but we know what they did.
And I think the Viking story is related to some of the stories that I've talked about with you in
the past. You mentioned my Substack. I will be talking about it in the future about the early
Indo-European societies, which I think persisted down into the Iron Age in many ways. The Viking
lifestyle is not that different than some of the stuff you see in the Rig Veda. And also,
read the Mahabharata. Read the Ramayana. These are kind of like these nomadic, semi-nomadic peoples
ruled by warlords, ruled by princes, and dominated by magicians wielding mantras,
and all these strange creatures and peoples, whether it be frost giants and elves and all
these things. And perhaps in a future episode, we can talk about my hypotheses and hunches that
these might be contacts between genetically very different people, because that's one of
the things that we're discovering about Europe, that it's actually homogenized a lot, that the
whole world is homogenized a lot in the last 3,000 or 4,000 years with the rise of empire.
Before that, there were people in Europe that looked at each other that were totally physically
different and whose genetic difference was as striking and strong as between Chinese and
modern northern Europeans today that lived in Germany for thousands of years right next to each
other along the same river drainage basin. There was a whole different world that we don't know
about, but that we perhaps have a sense of through our myth. And the Vikings, they've faded from
history and become myths in our popular culture. What DNA is doing is it's kind of put more flesh
into the bones, literally. Instead of just bones, we're actually reconstructing what they look like
in the flesh. And they looked a little bit different than maybe modern northern Europeans,
modern Scandinavians, but you know, the basics are already there.
Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for joining us here today at the Study of Antiquity
and the Middle Ages. Mr. Kahn has done another fantastic job of breaking down large spans of
history and really just dissecting it in a way that everyone can enjoy and understand it as he
makes it even more complicated by combining history with what DNA tells us today to help
us better understand the past. And to our subscribers, don't forget, check out the links
in the video description below. Give him your full support and honestly help him
make history matter. Mr. Kahn, thank you so much for coming on the show today.
I love it, Nick.