Unexpected Views- Iain Forsyth and Jane Pollard on Delaroches Lady Jane Grey - National Gallery

Art Galleries Worldwide
11 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 22, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello, we are Ian Forsyth and Jane Pollard. We're an art collaboration and we're artists,
filmmakers and curators. Right, welcome ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the National Gallery.
My name is Daniel Herman, I'm the curator of modern and contemporary projects here at the
National Gallery and I am delighted to welcome you and thank you for making the time. I'm delighted
to welcome you to our Unexpected Views series of events. Unexpected Views is essentially a
lecture series but what we do is very different from other lectures that we do, what we do is
very different from other events that we do. This is not going to be an art historical
conversation, this is not going to be a background on the established art history of Paul Delaroche's
painting that we see here right before, right behind us, but this is actually an informal
conversation with some of the most interesting and fascinating artists that we have working in
contemporary culture today and the particular interesting thing is that we are actually able
to view works of art from the collection of the National Gallery through the eyes of these
artists. It means it's going to be an informal conversation, it's going to be a very particular
subjective view but hopefully it will give us different ideas about the paintings of the
National Gallery's collection but also about how we can look at art in general and perhaps take
that away to different ways of looking into the world, into the world of culture in general.
Now I'm also very very grateful to our sponsor for these events, in this case of course it is
Hiscox. Without them it would not be possible for us to do these talks together with you and
with our artists so many thanks to Hiscox for which we appreciate very much. Now I'm delighted
that two of the most interesting artists of the current cultural moment are with us tonight.
This is Jane Pollard and Ian Forsythe. Ian and Jane are artists and BAFTA nominated directors
working across film, installation, performance, sound, documentary and TV drama. Ian and Jane have
worked together collaboratively since meeting at Goldsmiths in the mid-90s. Their work has been
exhibited around the world and is really collected by museums and its institutions around the world
including Tate, including the British government art collection and many many others. Their debut
feature film, 20,000 Days on Earth, depicting a 24-hour fictitious period in the life of the
musician Nick Cave, with whom the script was also co-written, won two awards at the Sundance
Festival and won several nominations from BAFTA and the Independent Spirit Awards.
They are currently working on a feature film featuring the work Life of Performer and
performing artist Lee Bowery, which also relates to our current exhibition Lucian Freud, New
Gallery. Bowery was one of the most important sitters for Lucian Freud. But just as excitingly
and very fitting for today's auspicious date of being Friday the 13th, they have recently curated
the exhibition Horror Show, which is currently on display at Somerset House, which I hope all of you
are rushing to see either later today or later in the coming days. The Horror Show is featuring
artworks dealing from the macabre and ranging from the macabre to the terrifying and really
exploring horror as a catalyst to understand the dark underbelly of culture. Apart from that,
there's of course also a Friday the 13th slightly frightening element about the painting that we're
looking at together today, Paul Delaroche's execution of Lady Jane Grey from 1833.
Maybe before we start talking about Delaroche and Lady Jane Grey,
Jane and Ian, can you tell us a little bit about your practice? How would you
describe what you as artists do and how you work and operate?
We have... so hard to do, what do you do? We do projects that really fire us up. So the Horror
Show recently feels like it's a kind of guide to our psyche, to the last 50 years. In fact,
we both turned 50 in the last few months. And it felt like a way of looking at that period
and looking at how artists use horror as a kind of creative force for rebellion. And maybe it's
that, maybe it's creativity that links a lot of our work. Because I'm thinking about the film with
Nick and the film about Lee and Lee Barry and Sue Tilly and a project we're doing with Marianne
Faithfull at the moment. And they're all connected to that idea of why we do what we do. Who makes,
what makes us who we are? How are we shaped? And why do we make those decisions? And, you know,
those kinds of creative decisions. Yeah, I think art for us is a thing that gives you the freedom,
a space in which you can explore ideas. And I think that's what's excited us since we met at
Goldsmiths a billion years ago. It's kind of one of those terms that sort of means everything and
nothing, right? You don't need to put yourself in a little box. And I think for us, it gave us
the space we were looking for as kind of young 20-year-old artists to go out into the world and
just explore the things that we found interesting and then worry about how to put that together in
a way that felt worth sharing with other people. So that's ended up being very, I guess you'd call
it multidisciplinary over the years. I think probably at this point in our life, filmmaking
is a very dominant part of our practice. Throughout your practice, you guys have always
worked much with lens-based media, is that correct? For sure, yeah. Yeah, I don't think
you can grow up in the 70s and 80s and not be shaped by lens-based media. I mean, some of the
most kind of influential pieces for us of work, but of also television and film, but particularly
television. I think things that changed us, Cracker. You remember Cracker on television?
Wow. That really opened up kind of how you'd make something. You felt the kind of joy of the
team making that and of the people on screen. And I think that makes a massive difference.
But also I think it was the way that we saw potential or alternative.
Well, we talk about it a lot in the horror shows that a lot of the people who started and kind of
founded punk and were practicing in the 70s and early 80s, it was that 1972 moment of Bowie on
top of the pops when he looks down the camera lens as he's performing Starman and he points at
you as the viewer. And that was like some kind of clarion call, like a rally. We were too. I mean,
that's the year we were born. For us, it was Adamant, the same program, Top of the Pops.
Adamant coming on and Kings of the Wild Frontier and that character and the sort of audacity and
kind of camp and performativeness of it. And it just had that feeling of there's something more
exciting. There's something possible. Well, then, of course, the next question for us is how did
you choose this particular painting? And basically, how do you go about watching a painting like this
with your particular interests in mind and as artists with the practice that you have?
I mean, we chose it because it's the best in the gallery, right?
Yeah. Look at the moment it's suspending. So these walls are full of frozen moments.
But think about the choice the artist is making and which moment to freeze. And you see
moments of revelation or of revolution. You see moments of torture or of chaos, of change,
of violence. But this one, this is so interesting because it's a not quite moment.
It's a just before something. And I find that idea of particularly working a lot with sound
and installation and in the design of the exhibition, you know, the horror show,
thinking about how you connect to a viewer and how you hold them inside a moment. What is that
suspension? And I love here that it's so kind of holds its breath. It's about fear and doubt
more than it is violence. It's a kind of quieter moment than you expect.
But the impact of that means there is, I don't know, there's just more space for you to kind
of be with it. You know, you don't need to avert your eyes. There's nothing that's kind of
shocking, but nor do you really feel like you've kind of missed anything.
You understand the language of what just happened. She's been blindfolded and she's been
lowered. But you see that. Look at that taut dress underneath the knee.
That tells you the story of just the moments before this. And you know what's about to happen.
So it just sits there kind of full of fear and doubt and reluctance. And it's yet really,
really kind of substantial. And I think it's the choice of that very specific, you know,
in a way it almost looks like, you know, if you're watching a film and the old days,
you just pause the videotape and there's just that random moment that's chosen. But of course, it's
far from a random frame in a sequence, but somehow it feels like the whole story is there.
You understand the story. You understand the frames before this frozen moment,
and you understand only too well the frames of the story still to come.
And I think to be able to capture on film an entire story is challenging enough.
To be able to capture all of that within essentially what in my mind feels like a single
frame, a single cell of a story is incredible. There's something about her being blindfolded
that's really key, I think, to the way that you read this work and to the way that the artist
makes room for you as a viewer in the way that you're watching it. If we could see her eyes,
we would know so much more about the kind of emotional content of this. But we can't. We
can't see her eyes, so we have to look at other things. And as humans, we're doing it all the time.
But look at that right hand. I mean, the left hand is looking to steady itself,
but the right hand, that bend in it, those fingers, that's everything. All the reluctance
and fear is in that hand. So you're being made to kind of dive in. You've got to look for other
clues. So you start to read body language and look at things like the taut dress, the tenderness
of his touch, and maybe also her being blindfolded. I mean, we all know what that's like. Just close
your eyes. It's to have your sight taken away. So maybe it makes you, gives you a bit of space,
a bit of scope for kind of to feel empathy as well, to kind of to understand, to be able to put
yourself in that position, even in the smallest of ways. But in that tiny little act, you're making
this something transformative happening between you and it, between you and this moment.
The space for you as a viewer, I think, is what makes it a painting that we keep coming back to.
I mean, it's a painting that I would come to the gallery to literally come through,
look at this piece and, you know, leave. That's enough. That's what I came for. But I think
perhaps it is something to do with what Jane was saying about, you know, nobody's making eye
contact. I mean, being looked at is uncomfortable. You know, you stand in a room and someone looks
at you and you feel it, you sense it. And it's not nice that most people want to leave.
And I think the fact that you're observing the thing with nothing, trying to draw your attention
in that way, it just gives you, it gives you the mental space, but also the physical space,
because the physicality of the work is so, you know, human. I mean, literally life-size. You
literally feel the presence of these figures in a way that's very, very organic and very, very
visceral. And I think the joy has been able to spend time literally in front of the work,
but feeling like it's theatrical. It feels like you're part of an encompassing whole. You're not
looking at a picture on a wall. I think it was quite interesting what you were saying about the
role of the gaze and the role of having, using the gaze of figures on the canvas,
I almost said on the screen, to create a relationship with the viewer, with the
beholder, with us as spectators looking at the canvas. And here we can see that Delaroche is
staging everything to avert that gaze, to avoid that we are making eye contact with anyone.
But even to the point where exactly you're saying that the blindfold in the eyes of the victim,
then Jane Grey, is blinded from us, not just from her. Her sight is being removed,
but also our possibility of making eye contact with her is being shut off and curtailed. And
that's actually quite a dramatic way of intervening between this relationship, between
the viewer and the protagonist in the scene that would otherwise be there. Is this something that
as directors for film works for you in a freeze frame? Or is this also something that works in
moving images? There are both. And I think about the way that very early in our practice,
we made a lot of video art, and we were absolutely obsessed with Bruce Gowman. He was God.
And then later got into Vito Acconci, and really guided by those early pioneers that
had the VHS camera, the cable connected to the monitor, and were able to watch themselves
performing. And so it's like you literally have a camera, and you're able to see yourself.
But one of the things we loved most about that setup was that often it would be comparative
life size to you watching it. So I mean, again, anybody who grew up in the 70s or 80s,
the notion that the newsreader is a head in the box in the corner, you get it. You understand it.
There used to be a man that lived inside our television. And so I think there's something
about that. And there's something about that, that it lessens the distance between you and it.
And I think that's what Dalai Lama does so well here. There are sort of three things at play.
There's no eye contact, but yet you are driven by particularly this character's gaze.
You're driven to kind of look at her. And in a way, you're very similar to this character. You
take a similar stance. And how weird to be the most similar with the executioner. And yet he
seems the most relaxed. He seems the most patient. There's no sense that he's judgmental or kind of
blood hungry. There's a sense of being, of just waiting, of just being with this.
And yet there's the premonition of the axe, which is very, very prominently
waiting and ready to be used. Yeah. But he's almost holding it back.
It's a slight kind of, you know, it's not even held yet.
It's almost the lack of prominence, I think, that makes it so
terrifying. And it's interesting looking at it now, having very recently curated the horror show
at Somerset House, which is all works that are dealing with different forms of horror. And I
think what a lot of them do that really appeals to us, and it kind of relates to this work also,
is that it's horror in a very human psychological way. It's not horror in a kind of
80s slasher movie kind of blood and guts. And, you know, the axe could be the center of the frame.
It could be covered in blood. A head could be rolling in the pristine straw. And it would be
a horrible painting. It would be a terrifying painting. But, you know, I mean, it almost looks
like he's trying to, you know, slip the axe out of the shot. You know, if that was, if this was
the scene you were filming, you'd be quite worried that this guy's going to end up with the axe out
and you're going to lose a vital, you know, story beat. So I think that's something that also is
just always draws us in, is this idea of being able to charge an emotion in a non-obvious way,
to be able to create a kind of psychological relationship with something that isn't about
going, you know, look at this man with his guts pouring out on the floor. Isn't this horrific?
Isn't this a horrible, terrible image? It's more about the suspension, the creating of narrative
that is anticipated by the beholder. Yeah. And the narrowness of depth in here as well. Look at
that. Look at how we're not seeing kind of lines of perspective that are taking us into a world
that exists inside the wall. We're looking at something that has a really fairly solid flat
backdrop and this really substantial kind of architecture to it, but the detail is really
faint and it just sort of sits at the back. And I think that really helps you be close to it as well,
that again, it's not, that it works really subtly with illusion, but that it's not trying to be
overly kind of deceptive with its illusion, like overly kind of, it's not too try hard,
that's what it is. It could have done so much more with the background, but actually it's quite
plain and that lack of kind of, that lack of detail and the sparseness again drives you further in
and it becomes, so those details become poetic and that, I think that does connect to
thinking about the way in which you film, the way in which we film and the way in which we think
about film, whether it's installation art film or whether it's for drama or television. You're
always thinking about like, how do I use the frame for the most amount of impact? And given that,
you know, a scene will be cut relatively short, how do I make sure that you see the things that are
metaphorically or poetically or physically kind of gonna tell you something more or mean something
more? And here I get really obsessed by the velvet. You know it's velvet, there's no,
absolutely no doubt it's velvet and that it's the kind of character with the fur
collar and the women in waiting, but you feel like their sadness is kind of somehow embodied
in the weight of that velvet, in the sort of dragging down of that kind of hugely dense and
heavy fabric that doesn't really, doesn't really catch the light, it doesn't reflect the light
which works beautifully in comparison to her undergarments which are, you know, cold and
crisp and I mean she's essentially already a spectre in the centre of the, in the centre of
the image, you know, the image is already haunted by her death, yeah. Now the painting itself was
painted in 1833 and we are talking about it right now in a way that's very much influenced by the
history and the expectation of photography of a film, where of course invited you also in your
capacity as film makers and producers of visual images in lens-based art.
When you look at the composition of something like this, when you look at the drama and the
narrative that is being developed, are there certain things that strike you as particularly
modern even today or as things that have maybe informed the language of cinema, of lens-based
media in a particular way, or are there also maybe things that are old-fashioned, outdated
that you would consider very different from how we operate today? It's funny, we were talking
about it earlier actually and there's something about the crispness of the straw in the foreground
here and just how sort of perfectly arranged it is that makes it very difficult not to have your
mind taken to the classic nativity scene. There's something about that kind of arrangement that just
takes you there straight away. And that maybe the nativity scene is the kind of ground zero of
sort of tableau vivants, which this kind of, which we know Delaroche was looking at, so these
tableau vivants are still pictures. Living images, living pictures.
And their groups of actors would be frozen in a moment, often costumed, often theatrically late,
so there again you've got that real life-size people in front of you in a shallow depth
platformed kind of entity attempting to communicate a moment, a story, a time, and you get that
with this. For me, the historical kind of story in here is the least important thing
for me. I mean, I'm intrigued by it, you know, the nine-day queen, but it's not what's
leading it at all. You know, for me it's the same as looking at Hamlet or Beckett.
I'm looking at it like that. I'm seeing, and maybe it's because I'm seeing the author's hand
or I'm feeling the author's taste. And I think about the directors that we really like or the
we really like, Jarmusch or Lynch, you see, you know that when one of their films opens,
you get to sink back into the sofa and go, I'm in safe hands. You know that their taste,
their instincts are good. They've really thought about, you can just sense that confidence in the
imaginative crafted constructedness. And I guess that's right at the core of everything we do that
I don't, we're not frightened by that kind of artificiality or that construction. I think if
anything, I'm drawn more to that. So like artists like Tony Ausler or Janet Cardiff love that work.
I love the sense that, you know, that, that, you know, Jeff Wall, Cindy Sherman, that you're,
you're seeing often these kinds of life-size sets or, or people, and there's a sense of
construction or, or, or of theatricality. And that, that for me kind of permits the potential
for something to happen in front of a piece of work. And I think we're always
looking for that. Maybe that, that moment where you're, you lose yourself, you just like who you
are, what you are, where you are, doesn't matter anymore. And, and whether it's, whether it's
physical or whether it's just momentary and fleeting, I think those are the moments that
define us. You know, they're the moments that change us and kind of, that sort of work the
gears of your heart and make you who you are. And I have that in front of this painting because it,
there's a empathy, there's catharsis, there's doubt. And then he's also used all of these
lovely subtle techniques that close that gap between you and it. It's the same size as you.
It's on a platform. You don't even have to imagine that their legs disappear into the
wall and that they're standing on the same floor as you. You know, it's already, it's,
we, he's thought about that, how to sort of stage it, place it there. Even the kind of
containedness of the sort of architecture, but it's sensed that it's somehow almost continues
the walls on either side. You know, he's thought about that. That's really particular, the, the,
we know this is not how Lady Jane Grey was executed. You know, it wasn't in a building
like this. It wasn't with so few people. But I want to be shown this. I want to experience
a kind of artist's version of things, a world that, you know, that's, I guess that's why I
kind of, yeah, that's why I watch films. That's why I come to art. I think it's what makes work
like this inspirational because there's something that you can, I mean, understanding the,
the authorship of the story you're being told, that it's not about a kind of documenting fact
in a strict sense. And I think what I mean by that is that, you know, our, our degree
was a combined fine art practice and art theory, art history degree. And it kind of trains you into
a very particular way of looking at a work of art. And it's an interesting way, and it's an
informative way, and it's a useful way. There's nothing wrong with it. But it starts to, I think
you start to lose that other muscle. And it takes you a little while to develop that muscle and get
back and to be able to look at something and in a way go, for a moment, let's just not give a toss
what the story is. Let's not care about, you know, Nine Days Queen and all of the stuff of history
that goes around it. You know, let's just look at a composition, a frame, an arrangement of people,
a relationship between different people, a relationship between eye lines and who's kind of
connecting with who. And, you know, I mean, one of my favourite things about the whole thing is
the column here that just is given up on, you know, the downstroke, it's just not there.
And it just immediately makes me think of theatre flats, you know, scenic painting, where, you know,
that grey background could have been painted by a scenic painter at the National this week. It's
totally plausible. Yeah. I think it's maybe it's because when we first met at Goldsmiths,
I mean, you're talking about a degree like it happened recently, 30 years ago.
We were 20 when we met and we got together and then started working together very, very quickly.
My mother said, as did our feminist history teacher, that we kind of found our kind of
collaboration and collective voice quite early on and began by kind of making stuff happen,
publishing and projects and things like that, and then found a kind of desire to make work
together. And I think it came out of going to lots of gigs, really going to music much more.
We were friends with lots of people in bands and Goldsmiths at the time was a desperate place.
It was kind of post YBAs. People thought if you could make big shiny stuff, it was going to sell
straight away and it was superstardom awaited. It's like a sort of Damien Hirst vapour trail
was kind of by the time we got there and everyone was just trying to grab on and kind of get their
own little piece. If I can just sell something to search, there's a career waiting for me.
And of course, that was a once in a lifetime, once in a century probably moment.
And that wasn't the reality. Most of the people that came out of our course
and out of Goldsmiths at the same time as us, we all struggled. It wasn't straight into
gallery representation and museum shows and was for two or three perhaps, but it wasn't
anything like the heyday of the YBAs. So it was kind of a rude awakening for a lot of people.
And I think for us, what we've really realised was the things that we were experiencing in
the culture that were connecting with an audience, that people were feeling
a relationship with and were feeling an emotional response to at that point,
felt like it was much more other aspects of culture than fine art at that point.
You'd go to an opening at a gallery and stand around having a beer, looking bored,
and then go and see a band down the road and have a really great time.
The independent publishing scene was dead exciting at the time. People were doing weird
male art projects and it was just that notion of self-generated activity. It felt exciting.
Which also embraces popular culture as a moment of subversion and thus also allows it to become
political, which I think is interesting. There are two things that I perhaps want to ask you
before we also want to open it up to questions from the audience. First, I know that you also
work together with younger artists, that you have an entire community of artists that you work with
at Somerset House and personally. If you were to work together with young artists at the beginning
of their career now, what would you advise them? How should they look at a painting like this,
the La Roche? What would you give them to look for? I don't know, maybe that freedom,
like you want freedom. But even then, you can look back and I think,
go back to John Berger's ways of seeing and the doors that that opened, the freedom that that
gave you, a language of being able to look without and understand that there's no rules to looking.
There isn't a right way to look at something. You just look. We were saying when we were coming in
that today we cannot look at this without thinking about Marianne Faithfull playing Ophelia
for Tony Richardson's 1968 production of Hamlet at the Roundhouse, because that was then adapted
for film. We've been watching this film obsessively. She does an amazing performance.
Nicole Williamson plays Hamlet. He is by far the best Hamlet I've ever seen.
Antony Hopkins plays Claudius, and there she is in these kind of cold, white, shiny sort of
gown as the fallen maiden, you know, the kind of doomed virgin. She gives a phenomenal kind
of performance. But there's something about this adaptation from kind of, was put on by
the Free Theatre, a radical group of trying to make theatre more accessible.
And they use the Roundhouse. They use the solidity of the building. When they translate it
onto film, it's really sparse, you know. But they also go outside and use bits around the sides,
and they use the underneath the basement of the building. And yeah, I now can't look at this and
not think about that. Like, I feel like this is Tony Richardson's version of Delaroche's kind of,
it's already my way of, but maybe it's that to enjoy that, that whatever it is that drives
your, you know, that's just because we've been writing a script about, you know, Marianne,
and about the character of Ophelia, and how Ophelia kind of seems to symbolize something
else for kind of, you know, the perception of women's role, and how they've been kind of
manhandled by, you know, the media over time. Yeah, I think for me, it also goes back to that
thing about that other muscle that, you know, art school can kind of lose you if you're not
careful where, you know, I mean, I think as a sort of, you know, meaningless soundbite,
piece of advice, I would say, stop looking and start feeling. But as trite as that sounds,
I think it kind of underpins what I feel about, you know, why a work like this is so
appealing to me, why it draws me in, why it inspires me, why there's a kind of constant
desire to return to it, is not because I'm looking, not because of what I can see,
not because of, you know, the details and the brushwork and all of the stuff that we can,
you know, we can talk about and we can read the textbooks about. But I feel something stood in
front of that painting. And I think all great works of art, whether it's a painting, a movie,
a seven-inch pop record, you feel them. First and foremost, that's what matters. How do you feel?
And one of the, well, my second question would be perhaps that considering that Paul Delaroche
was one of the most famous painters from France of the 19th century,
he has also become very famous for a quote. And whereas the execution of Lady Jane Grey
was painted in 1833, in 1840, Delaroche is said to have seen one of the first daguerreotypes that
were ever made, one of the first precursors to the photographs that were developed at the time.
And there's always this anecdote that Delaroche said, from today on, painting is dead.
And of course, we know that, first of all, that's probably not what he actually said.
Secondly, we know that, of course, painting is still persistent, still going strong today.
But in order to tell Delaroche what the medium of photography, what the medium of film,
what lens-based media have perhaps brought to the cultural table in the past 100 years,
what three films, perhaps, would you recommend to Paul Delaroche to watch today?
Wow. I mean, firstly, I can't tell you the number of times in the early 90s at Goldsmith's I heard
the phrase, painting is dead. So it clearly hasn't gone away. But three films.
No, I couldn't. It's too hard.
I would probably throw in Under the Skin, Jonathan Glazer's Under the Skin,
which sort of feels like a very painterly film.
I think it'd be very interesting to hear what he had to say about that.
Yeah. Yeah, I can see that.
What answer have you got?
No, I haven't. I haven't. I've got a mind full of blankness, of panic.
So put me on the spot.
Well, maybe that's a moment of horror that we can end.
But Ian, Jane, thank you so much for coming and joining us tonight. Tell us more about how you
look at this painting. And thank you all very, very much tonight for joining us for this discussion.
Thank you so much.
