My issues with And Just Like That

Sil Curiati - STORY Talk the Walk
19 followers
Mar 18, 2026
This video is for all writers who are involved with the series And Just Like That and also for the wonderful Sarah Jessica Parker, whom I truly admire. I'd love to see some changes in the future.
Subscribe to my channel
http://youtube.com/@storysilcuriati
Hi, I'm Silcreati and this one is for my beloved Sarah Jessica Parker and all the writers and
producers involved in Just Like That, the series that's supposed to be a sequel to
Candace Bushnell's Sex and the City. I'm a huge fan of Sex and the City.
Despite being a feminist and disagreeing with several of the characters' behaviors,
Sex and the City was part of my life when I was 20 or 20 something and Sarah Jessica
Parker's character Carrie was a huge inspiration to my wardrobe. I'm a big fan of fashion and she
was just the best. Her freedom to wear everything she wanted from huge flowers to the nicest shoes
and purple bags on all occasions felt so liberating. So I cannot tell enough how much I
love her. Besides, I do love Sarah Jessica Parker as an actor. Her Broadway play Plaza Suite was
amazing, one of the best things I've seen in theater and she seems to be a very nice person
too. I mean, I met her once here in New York. She was at her store on a Saturday afternoon
and she was just on her knees on the floor helping this old lady to choose the perfect
pair and she greeted me with a smile. She spoke with me and she even told me that I was Cinderella
because it was the last pair. The one I picked was the last pair, my number, so I had to take it,
obviously. So she seems to be a very down-to-earth and nice person too. So I do love her but I need
to talk about what bothers me and just like that. And this is a loving message. I'm a storytelling
expert and a personal branding coach, so I kind of pay attention to those little things that are
off character or don't make any sense to women at our age. I'm specialized in women over 40,
women who are returning to work after maternity leave or after any carer's leave or something,
women who are making transitions at work. These are the women who I coach. So I feel like all we
are seeing at And Just Like That are completely insane. I don't know. I don't know any women
who behave like that. Furthermore, I raised the anti-ageism flag and this series is missing a lot
of opportunity to just make sure we are not promoting ageism everywhere. They should be
empowering the women who, like me, grew old watching Sex and the City. So the last episode
of the third season reminded me of Sex and the City when I saw all these unmarried couples having
sex. I thought it was fun and very Sex and the City-like to show that unmarried women in New York
can have a lot of fun, can have a lot of sex if they just put themselves out there.
But when I see Kristin Davis' Charlotte and her husband Harry just in bed struggling to set up an
iPhone, I cringe. For three main reasons. One, iPhones have a very intuitive setup system.
You just follow the steps. It's pretty easy. Two, you can choose the language. So in their case,
it was in plain English. It was easy to understand. Again, just follow the steps.
And three, they are rich people who have been using iPhones since the first one.
How come they cannot just set up a phone? It cannot be that complicated. It just stereotypes
our generation, the X generation, as people who are not tech-savvy, which is not true. Even
boomers are tech-savvy. Even boomers, they use platforms much more complex. They play games
online. They do that stuff. So a TV series cannot perpetuate the idea that older people cannot use
technology. This is not true. I also come from the tech industry, where I've worked for over
eight years. But what I'm saying here is the actual truth. Older people do use technology
and they're very good at it. This to me is misinformation. And the same goes to Miranda
Hobbes, played by Cynthia Nixon, especially in season one. Miranda has always been this badass
lawyer, a go-getter, a very smart woman who knew what to say, when to say. She has always been this
strong character that was there for the others when they were like all confused with love
situations and all that. She knew what to do. I'm not saying that she should be like that all the
time, but I mean, Miranda Hobbes is a smart woman and a smart woman not knowing how to deal
with the black doctor who's her professor. Oh my goodness. What happened to Miranda? Did she
leave the planet Earth for 20 years and then got back and lost all her skills, interpersonal skills
and not knowing how to interact with a black woman who's as powerful as her, as smart as her?
These two could have a lot of relevant conversations and that's not what happened
in the beginning. They kind of struggled to get together. And just because Miranda's character
was completely off character. I mean, I could go on and on about the little details that bothered me
and annoyed me and frustrated me in all these seasons, but I'm not going to do that instead.
I'll just make a few comments about this last two episodes of this last season,
because to me, the writers missed opportunities to address issues that are really important and
that really matter for women over 45. Things that we talk about with our friends, topics that are
getting the spotlight on social media, things that are relevant to women these days, 2023.
So the first one, Charlotte going back to work. What a great topic. She's not just a wife. She's
not just a mom, as she said, but this could be so much better explored in conversations with her
girlfriends, with her husband, with her kids. Instead, they just put her in unnecessary,
exaggerated positions of a woman getting drunk and getting rid of her phone. So off character.
This is not Charlotte. This has never been Charlotte. Go out and drink with your friends
and celebrate and have fun. But show people that's what you should be doing if you're over 50
and you're going back to work. Yes, you can have fun with your co-workers. Yes, this is your time.
If you want to get wasted, okay. But I mean, if there is only one opportunity to show Charlotte,
don't show her that way. Why? Two, Miranda has a clear self-love issue. And this is something that
so many women go through, especially when their kids are growing up and their marriage is not
that happy. But instead of exploring it, she's just shown as a weak woman who cannot figure out
her sexuality, does not own her power at work, so not Miranda, and cannot afford to live by herself.
Three, Lisa got pregnant. She's probably in premenopause. Can we talk about it? I mean,
can you get pregnant in that situation? Yes, you can. So let's talk about it. What are the risks?
What are the implications? Instead, she was just complaining about it, which, by the way,
is also a great topic and a great opportunity because, yes, she wasn't expecting it. But it
was just a lot of complaint without real conversations. Then she miscarries the baby
and we can barely feel her grief because it could not connect with the story. So not wanting the
baby and then being sad because you lost it, this is a conversation. At her age, this is a conversation.
Four, Professor Nia, what a great character. And she's just facing the fact that her ex-partner
is building a life and a family with a new woman. And we caught a glimpse of what it could cause to
her life as she was barely celebrating a professional achievement. She was suffering
in her personal life with her love, but that impacts her professional life. That's also a story.
That's also real life. But then, oh, there is this nice, good looking chef that comes in or
there is good food here. Let's just forget about that. She's a smart doctor, a professor. And this
is a very important story to tell because on top of all this drama, love and professional, she's a
black woman who struggles more than any white woman to get to the point at her career that she did.
So, yes, that's the conversation. Let's talk about that. No, bummer. And last but not least, my beloved
Carrie. She went through a lot, losing her husband, the love of her life. But then she got Aidan again.
Aidan is a very welcome character. Brilliant. But then when you're 50 or 40 and you have been married
and now you're a widow, Aidan's ask is completely insane. It's childish and it's outrageous.
Life is now. You don't wait five years for anything or anyone. And Carrie should know that.
She went through a marriage and she lost her husband like that. And just like that, she's waiting
five years for someone who's. Oh, my goodness. Plus, the way he's raising his son is wrong.
But this is another thing I'm talking about women here and Carrie should know better.
Just think that women in the series are being stereotyped based on very old models of women
at their 40s or 50s in the 40s. That's not the reality anymore. I have loved to see Charlotte
dealing with her back to work problems in a mature way. Miranda using all her skills to connect with
people in a meaningful manner. Carrie telling Aidan to go F himself. And Liz, Che, Nia bringing
important topics to the table, to the discussion in a smart and real way. If there's a next season,
folks, please consult with real women over 40, over 50, to rewrite these characters,
to put some smart attitude and lines in the action. Really hope to see that soon.
