And Just Like That: Miranda Fails

Sil Curiati - STORY Talk the Walk
19 followers
Mar 18, 2026
I keep talking about And Just Like That because there are so many things I find wrong!!
In this video, I show why Miranda is completely off-character and behaving like a non-informed person who's been living on a different planet for the past decade.
To be fair, I made a mistake myself: Miranda referred to someone as a HE, and I said she referred as a SHE. Apologies, these things happen when we're trying to remember scenes from the top of the head.
Subscribe to my channel
youtube.com/@storysilcuriati
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello and welcome back to my channel, I'm Silcuriace and this is a story by Silcuriace.
Here you get tips and tricks to become a great storyteller or to improve your storytelling
skills if you are already one.
You also get some presentation tips and some comments here and there about things that
are maybe bothering me, which is the case of this video.
If you like the content, hit the like button, subscribe to the channel and ring the bell
so you get the notifications.
Today I'm gonna do a follow-up to my previous video about And Just Like That and why I think
it was not the best way to portray older women.
I'm gonna discuss Cynthia Nixon's character, Miranda.
And why is that?
Because when I published that video, I also did the same in Portuguese, which is my native
language, on Instagram and in both cases, I got a few comments about how they do not
necessarily agree with me because they think it's common and actually acceptable for Miranda
not to know how to deal with things.
Well, I agree that not knowing is not the problem.
Not knowing is something that we all should accept and the person who does not know about
something should pause, pay attention and maybe ask some questions instead of assuming
certain things and talking non-stop.
So I'll go back to one of the first scenes, if I'm not mistaken, that Miranda appears
in the first season, first episode of And Just Like That.
She's just joining a class at Columbia University and when she comes in the class, they're sitting
in a circle and she chooses a seat.
Someone next to her mentions that this seat that she chose was assigned to the professor.
She apologizes and moves to another seat.
Then Professor Naya Wallace comes in and as she takes her seat, Miranda points out that
that's the teacher's seat.
Okay, that could be fine if she did not know the professor she's chosen the class from,
which we know it's not true because she mentions Professor Wallace's hair on Columbia website
being different.
So if she pays attention to a person, a black woman coming in the room and taking that seat
and no one said a thing, be quiet.
If it's the case that she doesn't know whatever, she doesn't have enough information, the right
thing to do is, well, I know she is the teacher.
Then as she explains herself, she addresses the person sitting next to Naya, the person
who actually informed her about the seat, as a she.
She never asked if this person should be addressed as a she.
How should I address you?
You can say, this person mentioned that to me.
You don't say she because you don't know.
What matters is how the person wants to be addressed, not how they look.
Then as she explains why she did not think Naya was the teacher, she mentions Naya's
braids.
She did not say a thing about, well, you look different from the picture I saw.
She specifically says, oh, your braids, as she was surprised.
There is no reason for being surprised by braids or any type of hair or being bald or
being gray.
No reason at all.
But as she tries to fix that bad comment, she mentions that the professor being black
is one of the reasons why she signed up for class.
It's important to her.
The white woman saying, well, it's important for me that you're black and you're teaching
me something.
I think it's very aggressive to refer to how someone looks as something important for you.
It shouldn't be.
Why do you care?
You should care about the content the woman will share, not how she looks.
Plus, it's coming from someone who did not have a black friend so far.
I don't remember.
Do you?
From Sex and the City?
No black friends.
So, if it's so important to her, why don't you have black friends?
And then, to wrap it up, she mentions she doesn't care about hair.
She doesn't even dye hers, despite making her look really old.
Oh my God, I cannot stress enough how all these things make me cringe.
As I said in the first video, I just think that Miranda is off character.
Miranda is a smart lawyer, as I said.
It does not make any sense to show her trying to one-up her own excuses and getting completely
messed up as she tries to explain whatever she wants to.
You know what would have been much better?
Well, she made a mistake.
The professor comes in and she mentions the seat is reserved to the professor.
She doesn't know the person is the professor.
When Naya says, I am the professor, she could have said, oh my gosh, I'm sorry.
I did not notice.
You look different from the pictures on the website.
I'm so glad to be here.
This would have been enough.
Oh, so, but then, we wouldn't be addressing all the prejudice and all the discrimination
that was so clear in Miranda's speech.
Yes, we would not have exposed Miranda, the character, to a ridiculous situation.
We would have made her look as the smart lawyer she is.
A smart lawyer, over 50, who's white and privileged and has lived so much and has earned a lot
of money and has studied in the best universities.
This person must be informed.
She cannot talk to people the way she talked in that scene.
And then, how would we address all the other issues?
Well, as her friendship grows with Naya, she could have mentioned something and listened
to Naya.
Or, we could have explored her relationships with her colleagues in the university.
Oh, we would see her having a hard time with the pronouns, for example.
But instead of just assuming things, it would be much nicer if we saw Miranda asking.
She could set up an example for all these women and these people who do not know how
to deal with things.
What's the example we set by having this huge show on HBO?
The example is of someone who does not know how to deal with things because, yes, things
are changing fast and sometimes just because some people do not have the opportunity to
have relationships with people from different backgrounds and cultures and whatever, sometimes
they just don't know how to deal with things.
So they should just ask, how should I address you?
Oh, I really don't care that dyeing my hair makes me look older, which is something that's
really uncomfortable as well because as she comes in the room for the first time, everyone
looks at her like they're not happy to have an older woman there.
That's also bad.
Certain scenes of this series miss the opportunity to make a stand and make a point for all of
us women who are aging, who are struggling with ethnicity issues, race issues, skin color,
culture, background differences, disabilities, whatever.
It's a valuable time on TV and we should learn more.
That's my opinion.
I intend to talk a little bit more about some other scenes and other characters, so if you
have any suggestions and ideas, please leave them in the comments below.
If you like this content, hit the like button, subscribe and come back.
Bye!
