Heritage Steel Cookware Review Eater vs Titanium

Heritage Kitchen
7 followers
1 Video View·Mar 19, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Non-stick pans are skin. And if you're thinking it's time for a new set of cookware but you don't
even know where to start, you landed on the right video. In this Heritage Steel Cookware Review,
I'm about to show you why you should stop using non-stick pans, how this cookware performs,
and if it's actually worth buying. But first, why aren't more people talking about this and
how could ignoring it be putting your health at risk? After tossing out non-stick cookware,
I finally decided to stop messing around and do some research. Turns out, non-stick pans like
Teflon use coatings called PTFE that over time can leach chemicals into your food. This can
cause things like cancer, liver damage, and reproductive issues. So I spent three weeks
diving into cookware forms, Reddit threads, and YouTube videos. And everything just kept pointing
back to stainless steel. It's non-toxic, super durable, and honestly, if you know how to use it,
it actually has better non-stick properties than a non-stick pan. But then I got so overwhelmed and
confused by all the different options out there. Should I go with made in? Should I go with all
clad? Is there even a difference? That's when I stumbled across Heritage Steel Cookware. Now,
most people don't hear about Heritage Steel because it's not some kind of big name brand.
Turns out Heritage Steel and all clad are exactly the same, yet totally different. What the heck
does that even mean? Well, just stay with me and I'll explain. Both brands have five ply clad,
both are made in the US, both come with lifetime warranties, but Heritage Steel
costs less. And their warranty covers warping from regular use where all clad doesn't. Heritage
Steel is made in Clarksville, Tennessee by a family owned company that's been doing this for
over 40 years. Every piece is hand assembled and inspected. All clad, on the other hand,
is a French company that makes cookware in Pennsylvania. On paper, the main difference
between the two is that Heritage Steel is slightly cheaper and you're supporting an
American business. But none of that really matters unless the cookware is high quality.
So how does Heritage Steel cookware hold up and perform? First, you got to look at the options
that Heritage Steel gives you. There's the Eater Series and the Titanium Series. And there's a
link to both of these in the description below. I'll keep it updated with the best discount on
the internet so you can save as much money as possible. If you use the link, I earn a small
commission, but it doesn't cost you a thing. And it helps support the channel. The Eater Series
uses 304 stainless steel. That's also 1810. 1810 stands for 18% cronium and 10% nickel. Cronium is
what makes stainless steel stainless by protecting it from rust and corrosion. Nickel makes the pan
more resistant to stains, pitting, and damage from acidic foods like tomatoes. Now, the Titanium
Series is more expensive because it uses 316Ti steel. The reinforced titanium makes it even more
resistant to corrosion and pitting. If you cook with a lot of acidic foods like tomatoes, wine,
or citrus, the Titanium Series is supposed to handle it better over decades of use. It also
has a mirror-polished finish that looks stunning where the Eater Series is more brushed. The handle
on the Eater Series is flat and the handle on the Titanium Series is round. Both handles are hollow
and they have this bump underneath that prevents you from burning your hand. The Eater Series feels
more comfortable and is less likely to slip versus the Titanium Series, especially when your hands are
wet. Now, both use 5-ply fully clad construction. Clad just means that the pan has layers. Stainless
steel on its own isn't a great conductor, so cookware brands add layers to enhance them. The
top and bottom use stainless steel. The middle has three sets of aluminum cores. When you count them,
that's five layers or 5-ply. Because 5-ply has more cores than 3-ply, it spreads the heat evenly
across the pan and retains it much better. Now, all this technical stuff is great, but how does
it actually work when it comes to pan performance? To put this cookware to the test, I started with
eggs. The number one concern about stainless steel is food sticking. People think that you
need a ton of oil or butter to cook anything and that's just completely wrong. I heated the pan
over medium heat on my induction stove and that was about a seven out of nine. At this point,
there was no oil in the pan. Instead, I waited about two minutes. Then what I did was the water
droplet test. I filled a glass with a few drops of water and poured it onto the pan. At first,
you can see that the droplets slowly evaporate. If the water evaporates and the pan is sizzling
like crazy, that means that the pan is not hot enough. After another 30 seconds, I added some
more water and this time it formed a ball that just kind of glided across the surface. That's
when the pan becomes non-stick. Next, I added a small amount of oil, maybe a tablespoon,
and coated the pan by moving it around side to side. Then I turned the heat down from about seven
to five. There's nothing worse, nothing worse than overcooked eggs. So what I had to do is wait
for the pan to cool down. The trick here is to let the bottom bond with the surface for about 20
seconds. Then when you scrape underneath it, you're going to see that there's no sticking
whatsoever. After flipping it, the underside had a beautiful golden crust and the top was perfectly
cooked with a gooey center. But what about scrambled eggs? Those got to be crazy difficult to
cook on this thing, right? Well, that's what I thought too. I used the same pan and I poured in
the scrambled eggs. And again, zero stick. They came out fluffy and slightly undercooked just the
way that I like them. But this next part is way more important when it comes to cooking with
stainless steel. You want to make sure that you're getting a good sear. So to test this out, I used a
steak, not just any steak, a $20 expensive cut of ribeye, which really wasn't that thick to begin
with. Am I going to absolutely waste my $20 by butchering this steak on this pan? Let's find out.
I preheated the pan for about three minutes over medium high heat. One of the advantages of the
thick aluminum core is that heat retention. When you add the room temperature steak to the pan,
if it's a nonstick pan, the temperature is going to drop. But with this type of stainless steel pan,
it doesn't dramatically drop. Do you hear that sizzle? That's exactly what you want. Five ply
construction means heat travels up the sides of the pan too. So you get even browning all around,
not just where it touches the bottom. The entire cooking service of these pans, including the walls,
can conduct and radiate heat. I didn't move it yet. What I wanted to do is just let that crust
develop for about 30 seconds. Now check this out. It released perfectly. Look at that color. That's
the Maillard reaction at work, and it only happens when you maintain consistent high heat. The Maillard
reaction is what gives it that brown, rich flavor and golden crust. After about one minute, I flipped
it. Then I added some butter and some herbs. This is the final result. Cooked pretty much perfectly
in the middle. I would have liked to give the garlic a bit more time, but I'm not going to
complain. As far as the taste goes, this is one of the best tasting steaks I've had in a long time.
The difference in flavor between a nonstick pan and this stainless steel pan is night and day for
steak. But there are some learning curves you're going to have to get used to when it comes to
stainless steel, and I'm about to show you by making some pasta carbonara. First, we boiled
some water. You always want to bring the water to a boil before adding salt. If you add salt to cold
water, it can cause pitting in stainless steel, which ends up looking like this. Once the water
was boiling, the salt dissolved immediately and didn't damage the surface. While the pasta cooked,
we cut up bacon and we fried it up. To all the Italians out there, we know we're not supposed
to use bacon. Our sincerest apologies for butchering your cuisine. Anyways, we started chopping the
cheese. We put three egg yolks in a bowl and added some salt, pepper, and a little bit of that
parmesan. Gave it a nice good mix. Then we drained the pasta, and this is where things got a little
bit tricky for us. Our pan was too hot, so when we mixed everything together with a bit of pasta
water, it dried out fast. Not our best pasta carbonara, which leads me to the first thing you
must know before you buy this cookware. First is temperature. When you're working with the pan,
it's a five ply, so it does an amazing job of retaining heat, but it does take an extra two
minutes for your stainless steel pan to drop in temperature compared to nonstick. So if you're
not patient enough with letting the pan cool, you're going to easily burn your food or dry
out your sauce, kind of like how we did with the carbonara. Second, these pans are not dishwasher
safe, but most stainless steel cookware is not dishwasher safe either. Heritage Steel and many
others use exposed aluminum edges in their cladding, and dishwasher detergent and water
would slowly get in and erode that aluminum core. But there is good news. Cleaning stainless steel
is actually easier than you think. First, wait until the pan cools down. Sticking a hot pan in
cold water causes it to warp. You never want to do that. Once the pan is warm but not scalding hot,
add some water, let it sit for a minute, then scrub with baking soda or a barkeeper's friend
for stubborn spots. This whole process takes about 30 seconds per pan. The third issue I had
was with the rivets. So rivets are these circular metal fasteners that attach the handle to the pan.
Some rivets are flat while others are round and stick out. Heritage Steel rivets are incredibly
strong, which means your handle will never come loose, but they do stick out slightly from the
cooking surface. This creates tiny crevices where food can get stuck. It's not a huge deal,
but you'll need to pay attention when cleaning around the rivets. Soft brush can help get in
those spaces. Now here are three things that surprised me about Heritage Steel cookware.
First is the build quality for the price. When I first picked this up, it was like I was using a
premium restaurant grade cookware at a price that's actually reasonable. The 2.8 millimeter
thickness gives the pan a perfect balance. Heavy enough to feel solid, but not so heavy so that
it's like annoying to move around. The way the handle connects to the pan and the smooth finish
on the rivets with the perfectly flat cooking surface, these are details you'd expect from
cookware twice as much. I threw out a lot of my nonstick pans and I just put a couple into storage
just in case. I thought maybe I'd hate cooking with stainless steel, but after a few meals,
I realized I wasn't going back. When using nonstick, we put them in the dishwasher and
sometimes you can slightly taste the food that you previously cooked in it before,
especially things like fish or even the detergent from the dishwasher. And I don't know how to fully
describe this, but the food on the stainless steel pan just tastes cleaner. Like you don't
get remnants of this stuff. It sounds a little bit silly, but there's a subtle difference and
you also get that browning and that gold crust with the food that makes it taste even better
than if you were to cook it in a nonstick pan. Plus there's no PTFE, there's no PFOA,
no ceramic coatings that can chip off into your food. Just stainless steel and aluminum. These
are materials that have been used safely in kitchens for decades. If you've been concerned
about the health effects of nonstick coatings, heritage steel eliminates those worries completely.
And the third thing is that this might be the last cookware set I'll ever need. It makes sense
to invest in a whole set and it might be a little pricey at first, but because you just buy it once
and you have it for life, it's actually cheaper than just replacing Teflon nonstick pans. And
trust me, once you start cooking with this, you're going to wonder how you ever settled for less.
You don't have to be a pro chef either. I'm just some regular dude who got tired of buying garbage.
If you're worried that it's going to be too complicated, I'm no rockstar in the kitchen.
So if I can do it, you can do it too. After weeks of researching, comparing, and cooking with these
pans daily, I'm super happy with heritage steel cookware. Between you and me, I think the titanium
series is beautiful and the quality is slightly better than the eater, but you're probably better
off just saving a buck and getting the eater series cookware as the performance is pretty
much the same. If you're looking to buy some heritage steel cookware, there are links in
the description below and I'll keep those updated with the best discount on the internet.
